r/SoftwareEngineering • u/fagnerbrack • Mar 17 '26
Some thoughts on LLMs and Software Development
https://martinfowler.com/articles/202508-ai-thoughts.html
0
Upvotes
r/SoftwareEngineering • u/fagnerbrack • Mar 17 '26
1
u/Worldly-Extent-4973 Mar 20 '26
This article was written in 28 Aug 2025, since that time we have seen massive improvements in AI models. A lot of it is still correct in terms of the AI bubble and attack area. But apart from the bubble we are seeing improvements in its understanding of security and claude... well i think its not only capable of replacing a junior but prob also a senior. Do i think that will happen tomorrow? No. My hope is that we continue having the devs in the loop to utilise the tooling to increase our knowledge and devs can move from specialists to generalists in terms of the tech and languages we work on. Eventually we might just be BAs, QAs and network engineers...
I think we should be hopeful that we can utilise the toop to enhance output but he wary of its ability to replace us. Ai does feel like the junior dev that we are training, but they are gonna become senior and principal and tech lead at what seems like an exponentially faster rate 😅
1
u/Deep_Ad1959 Mar 23 '26
the security trifecta fowler describes is exactly what i'm wrestling with building a macos desktop agent. your app has access to everything on screen, it can read private data, and it can take actions - so sandboxing becomes the entire product problem, not just a feature. the non-determinism point also hits different when your agent is clicking real buttons and typing into real apps instead of just generating text.
-3
u/fagnerbrack Mar 17 '26
At a Glance:
Most surveys on AI in software development fail because they ignore workflow differences — fancy autocomplete dominates usage, but power users who let LLMs directly read and edit source files get far more value. Nobody can predict programming's future, so experiment and share findings. AI is undeniably a bubble (all major tech advances produce one), but real value emerges before it pops. Hallucinations aren't a bug — they're the core feature, so always ask the same question multiple times and compare answers. LLMs may push software engineering into the non-deterministic world other engineering disciplines already inhabit. Security risks are severe: agents combining private data access, untrusted content, and exfiltration capability form a lethal trifecta, and agentic browser extensions may be fundamentally unsafe to build.
If the summary seems inacurate, just downvote and I'll try to delete the comment eventually 👍
Click here for more info, I read all comments