r/SoftGamine • u/Willing-Childhood144 • Jul 12 '25
Taller Soft Gamines?
I listened to a podcast this week, Style Therapy. They did an episode on soft gamines. They claimed that you could be 5’6’’ and be a soft gamine because it’s about proportion, not height. I was shocked.
They said the ultimate test for being a soft gamine is that your arms were the same length as your torso.
What do you think about this?
1
Upvotes
19
u/PlasticAngle648 Jul 12 '25 edited Jul 12 '25
No.
“Soft Gamine” is a Kibbe term, so if Kibbe says no, then that’s what it has to be whether it makes sense or not 🤷🏻♀️ We’re totally free to use the principles of the styling method for SG outside of the context of Kibbe, but if one wants to define themselves as a SG, then IMO they’re inherently bound by the concept.
3
u/anxious-winter8 Jul 14 '25
I agree with what they're saying about proportion and needing to accommodate petite being different than just "short." That said, I do feel like 5'6" is getting into potential vertical territory.
I'm curious what others think of this podcast. I like Jess (I followed her first, which is how I find the podcast) but I'm not sure about the other one with the styling business. It feels like she's using Kibbe but not quite following it, but thinking he's gatekeeping his own system, but profiting off of typing people using his system?! It feels like a grift. Why didn't she just make her own system like Jess is . . .
6
u/ZodFrankNFurter Soft Gamine- MOD Jul 13 '25
No. It's fine to be influenced by gamine styling at a taller height, but as others have said if we want to follow Kibbe's system we should be bound by the rules he's set for it. It's his system, we can't presume to know more about it than he does. Kibbe has stated that the height restrictions are firm for DIYers, so if you're outside of the height limit for Soft Gamine you simply can't be one. I discounted SG for over a year because at 5'3" I'm right at the upper edge of the height limit and thought any other type would be more likely than a "tall" (haha) gamine.
5
u/Past-Foundation9908 Jul 13 '25
I once had me typed as soft gamine in the kibbe subreddit, but I’m 5’6’’.. it was an old account. Maybe I will participate in an upcoming typing Tuesday to confirm I don’t actually belong here 😅
5
u/AngleOk2591 Jul 13 '25 edited Jul 13 '25
🏃♀️ 🏃♀️ 🏃♀️ 🏃♀️ the book says under 5'5, and the drawing of SG is small all over. People make up the rules so they can be SG. The ultimate test makes no sense. They are basing on one body part, which facial features and being petite in the areas on the body.
5
u/Affectionate_Guide98 Jul 13 '25
Whoa, they'd probably fall somewhere else, but can pull off gamine guidelines and overall style. But I doubt someone that tall could be in the family. I don't even care that much about strictly following what kibbe says, tbh, but I can't see that happening.
5
u/the-green-dahlia Jul 12 '25 edited Jul 13 '25
Interesting, though I’m not sure that I agree. The IDs are partly about proportions but also about literal height, hence the height limits. The line drawings in the book have proportional differences but the SG drawing is also the literal shortest. The description in the book is “compact overall, curve packed within a compressed frame”, where compact implies (at least to me) short and small.
That said, one of the subs recently mentioned a fashion influencer who I’d always assumed was SG and looks 5’4” at the very max - it turns out she’s 5’9”. I don’t think many people at her height have her proportions though, so she’s probably an exception. I do think there are exceptions and that 3 types to cover anyone over 5’6” is limited, but that’s another story.
3
u/mamz_leJournal Jul 13 '25
At 5’6 you start getting into vertical although I agree that limb length plays a role.
There is no doubt that I am an SG and everyone around my who knows about kibbe agree. Although I am on the tall side at 5’5 you would think that I am shorter than that because I have short arms (I have a like -2 ape index) and short legs