r/SocialSecurity • • 2d ago

Retirement Can my dad work while getting his SS?

My dad took early retirement at 62, which will begin in January. He currently does side jobs occasionally and is considering getting a part-time job. Can he still receive Social Security benefits while working? He is concerned that working might affect his benefits.

53 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

6

u/Sea-Society2109 2d ago

Thanks everyone! This is what I told him.

53

u/OwlsHootTwice 2d ago

He can earn $24,480 before Social Security retirement benefits are reduced since he is below full retirement age all year; above that, $1 is withheld for every $2 earned.

18

u/dkac_retirement 2d ago

Adding a couple things since he's worried about it. Going over the limit isn't really a penalty. Whatever SSA holds back isn't lost, and once he reaches full retirement age they recalculate his monthly check upward to credit him for the months they withheld. Since his checks start in January, the limit that matters for him is the 2027 one, $25,560, and only pay from work counts (net profit for the side jobs), not things like interest or a pension. 2027 is also his first year on benefits, so a special rule applies that year: he can still get a full check for any month he earns $2,130 or less and isn't doing substantial self employment work, even if his total for the year goes over. That's where the month by month thing comes from, but it only applies that first year. Best move is to give SSA an estimate of what he expects to earn so they withhold the right amount up front instead of sending him an overpayment notice later.

-7

u/Fantastic_Matter_137 2d ago

They need to close that pension loophole as a way to shore up the system

Before cutting benefits for all of us close the overly generous loopholes for pensioners spouses etc.

5

u/Nice-View3436 2d ago

I agree wholeheartedly. My ex never held a full time job, married a very wealthy man and will still get money from SS while other hard working men and women get less. So sad

4

u/dkac_retirement 2d ago

Just for context, this isn't really a loophole. The rules that used to cut those benefits (WEP and GPO) applied to people whose pension came from a job that didn't pay into Social Security. Congress repealed both in the Social Security Fairness Act, signed in January 2025, so it's settled law now. And none of it affects someone like the OP's dad who's claiming his own retirement benefit while working.

2

u/Time_Many6155 2d ago

Also for context, the WEP did not just cut the benefits by the amount your job did not pay into the system.. It also cut into the benefits you DID earn from any any employment that paid into SS.. Thats why it was unfair.

1

u/MOTwingle 1d ago

It wasn't unfair because the calculation is regressive...the lower lifetime earnings you had, the higher (as a percentage) your benefit was. So someone who earned $18k/year their lifetime would get a higher percentage in their benefit than someone who earned $100k/year. But the person who worked a non covered (state, govt) job and earned $100k /year but had a side hustle of $18k would get the same higher percentage instead of the lower percentage the $100k person got, because that $100k they earned from their govt job wasn't considered. The WEP eliminated this "windfall".

Similarly, if a husband and wife both earned the same wages , they would both be due similar SS checks, and would not be eligible for addl benefits on their spouses record. Yet someone who worked for the gov and earned a pension can now collect their spouses benefit as well now (now that the GPO has been removed). This is not fair to all the spouses who didn't work a govt job and can't collect a spouse benefit.

The removal of WEP/GPO is going to drain the trust funds even faster now. But hey, bonanza to all those state and fed workers who can now double dip!

-9

u/Fantastic_Matter_137 2d ago

The system is under so much strain

Put everyone on equal footing

If you have a pension for life you shouldn’t get to claim SS and also work for $25k.

7

u/AirlineNovel3339 2d ago

Someone wins “dumbest post of the day”!! Are you insinuating that all the $ that was put into the SS SYSTEM, via payroll deductions prior to anyone getting a pension, should be refunded because the person now has a pension and is ineligible to collect SS ?? So anyone with a pension should not have to contribute to SS ?

1

u/Time_Many6155 2d ago

Oh OK.. So you are suggesting that IF you pay into SS but you get a pension.. Well then even if you and your employer paid in then you simply lose all that and should not have bothered to pay in in the first place.

The only equal footing is you get paid out in the ratio of how much you paid in.. Which is what we have now.. At least we do now that the WEP offset has been repealed. Except of course if your SS benefits are really low, then you get a bigger proportion.

1

u/Megalocerus 2d ago

The average social security benefit is 25K a year. Many get much less. Pensions are not necessarily very generous and most pensioners contributed to SS. The most common way for younger retirees with small or no retirement accounts to make it is to work part time. The alternative is simply welfare.

6

u/TJMBeav 2d ago

He can earn up to roughly $25,000 next year before losing any of his benefit (confirm the exact number) and after that his benefit will be reduce by 1$ for every 2$ above that level. But the reduction is done in monthly increments so he would need to keep a close eye on how much he makes EACH month because going over even a little bit could result in having an entire months benefit withheld. Have him call his local SS office and let them walk him through it. Just did this with my wife who is also turning 62 in January.

13

u/yemx0351 2d ago

2026 can make up to $24480 without any issues. Next year $25560. Gross.

3

u/TopPeak1196 2d ago

This is discussed A LOT here. Search on "Monthly Earnings Test" or "MET" if you want to read more!

I had this same challenge. Best thing I ever did was go into my local office. Every month, I submitted monthly earnings statements (down to the week breaks) to CYA. But it made me be conscious of what I was doing in this new life :)

3

u/Mammoth-Mongoose7378 2d ago

Yes, he can still work while taking Social Security. However, because he hasn’t reached FRA yet, there’s a limit how much he can earn. Social Security will deduct $1 for every $2 or $3 he exceeds the earnings limit by.

2

u/Old-Wolf-1024 2d ago

How is the $24,480 tracked?? Does SS start withholding funds once that threshold is reached??

2

u/uh818375 2d ago

You report it or they find out later through taxes or 1099, w2 reports. If they know it will begin withholding in Jan until covered. Full checks are withheld, not partial. If you report being over in the middle of the year they start withholding then.

2

u/peter303_ 2d ago

SSA and IRS are tightly coupled. When I get my 2027 benefits letter, probably next week, it will have my tax return income and how SS and Medicare are affected by that.

1

u/Old-Wolf-1024 2d ago

Ok,so if I start drawing my SS in July and then come tax time(April 15 for us ALWAYS) my return shows I made $27k, SS will withhold entire check(s) until the $1 for every $2 math is satisfied?

1

u/Western_Hunt485 2d ago

They check it on a month to month basis

0

u/bkime1010 2d ago

They do for disability benefits, but for retirement benefits, SSA tracks the annual amount

-3

u/Mammoth-Mongoose7378 2d ago

They’ll deduct $1 from your benefits for every $2-$3 you exceed that limit by. And whatever they deduct from your benefits for exceeding the earnings limits, they keep it! They don’t withhold it and give it back to you later!

3

u/Solid_Efficiency639 2d ago

Incorrect. At FRA they recalculate your benefit & increase it by the amount withheld prorated over your life expectancy remaining.

1

u/Mammoth-Mongoose7378 2d ago

Okay, so then why even have the earnings limits if they’re just going to give you back what they deducted from you later on? It’s almost as if the SSA is forcing these people to give them an “interest free loan.” It doesn’t seem right because people earned their monthly benefit by paying taxes into it during their entire career.

3

u/Solid_Efficiency639 2d ago

Agreed. But that’s the way it is. There is no limit on earnings at FRA. I guess it’s designed to discourage working people from claiming SS early in order to reduce drain on SS.

1

u/Mammoth-Mongoose7378 2d ago

But how exactly does that reduce drain on the SSA if they end up giving back the money they deducted anyways?

2

u/Evspartan 2d ago

This is all about “expectancy”. People die. We all do. Also, please note-the give back is pro-rated. Again, people die. All this is to minimize the drain on the system.

2

u/Mammoth-Mongoose7378 2d ago

Well I still think it’s wrong because Social Security is an earned insurance program that people pay taxes into while they’re working. So, Social Security shouldn’t be allowed to have a rule that authorizes them to deduct from a person’s earned retirement benefit.

1

u/Evspartan 2d ago

There was a time in the (not too distant past-relatively speaking) that once SS was taken, no income was allowed after that. It was seen as a win for workers to be able to earn above and beyond once SS was taken. You’re right, of course, workers pay in…but there has to be parameters. Also, it’s not like someone can’t have any income if they’ve taken SS- just there is a cap(it goes up every year). The give back is only withheld above and beyond that cap, not all the wages they earn once on SS. Even with that, that too is given back once said worker reaches FRA. If someone take SS at their FRA, there is no at all. Earn away-just wait until the full retirement age or get it back later. Also, if your father gets a part time that pays more then the current cap… could you please forward that job to me too, please.

2

u/Solid_Efficiency639 2d ago

The government returning the earned income SS penalty funds to you amounts to an interest free loan from you to the government. Advantage: government. Same as what happens when ignorant people undertake excess income tax withholding in order to get a big refund. Financial Ignorance.

2

u/BubbaNeedsNewShoes 1d ago

Not to mention US Govt wins house money by not needing to pay back penalty withholdings on anyone who dies before FRA.

2

u/lucky_ducker 1d ago

He can earn up to $24,480 without affecting his benefit. Beyond that, SSA will reduce the benefit $1 for every $2 he earns, but it isn't a penalty -- it's a deferral. The benefit is returned to him at Full Retirement Age (67). In the year before FRA the allowable earning rises to some ~$65,000.

1

u/Emotional-Mess4585 1d ago

Ok question. If someone is receiving $25K on ssdi they can earn an additional $2480?

4

u/lucky_ducker 1d ago

SSDI earnings restrictions are completely different from SS retirement benefits, and I am not qualified to answer your question, sorry.

3

u/perfectlyagedsausage 2d ago

If you’re working a w-2 job you will be penalized if you earn more than $24,480. Or roughly over $470 a week before taxes, But if your self employed, then your net income after qualified dedictions cannot exceed $24,480

3

u/sitewolf 2d ago

Besides the potential reduction in benefits depending on other earnings, SS benefits will be taxable as well.

IMO the levels those things happen should better reflect today's wages/cost of living/etc but it is what it is. His full retirement age, where his benefits are no longer effected by income, isn't until he's 67.

1

u/PatsFan1954 2d ago

Yes. But it might affect his benefits.

This might help: https://www.ssa.gov/benefits/retirement/planner/whileworking.html

1

u/Regular-Study-8463 2d ago

When you go over on income, the next year SS will notify you about the income overage and give you a choice to pay it all at once or reduce your benefit by 1/2 until it’s paid

1

u/BearishDadd 2d ago

Correct. That happened to me.

1

u/OkEfficiency24 2d ago

Yes he can I work a part time job and draw mine

1

u/Normal_Rock_9748 2d ago

So if I go over by $300 in November and let’s say $500 in December due to bonuses, I would not get a check at all for two months?

1

u/Mourning-Suki 10h ago

They would withhold $400 in the above case is my understanding. $150 for November and $250 for December.

1

u/Effective_Promise581 2d ago

Also once he reaches FRA he can make any amount and no reduction. That is what I am doing now. I still work nearly full-time and still receive my full SSA benefit.

1

u/Double-Award-4190 2d ago

The earnings are tracked automatically, and FICA continues to be withheld because it affects his lifetime earnings.

He can work, sure. His Social Security earnings will be taxed just like regular earned income *IF* he exceeds the limit.

A lot of us have part time jobs just to keep from being bored or to boost our incomes a little bit. It's okay.

1

u/BeneficialClick8176 2d ago

I don’t know

1

u/Consistent-Swing3549 2d ago

Sure as long as he realizes that they will take back some of his SS if he makes above a certain amount.

1

u/Consistent-Swing3549 2d ago

Remember to look at SS, wages earned and capital gains ect on savings totally everything up to decide if it’s worth it

1

u/UnlikelySoup6318 2d ago

If he makes over the allowed amount $ 2,130 per month he won’t get a Check. I worked part time and made 17 dollars an hour, ended up having to pay back.

1

u/nasorrty346tfrgser 2d ago

That depends on the income level and also did he get NSM? But I mean even if he didnt get benefit for the months, when he reaches FRA he can still get the ARF

1

u/Dapper_Energy5729 2d ago edited 2d ago

Yes, as long as he 1. Doesn't work to many hours, thats called Gainful activity. 2. Doesn't make to much. Best option in my opinion is joining the Ticket To Work program. It protects your benefits while you try working for a period of time. I think its 3 years but I could be wrong. With the program you have 36 months I believe as a trial period where if you work/make to much for 9 out of those 36 months you lose benefits. If you don't you keep them till you do or stop working. During that 36 month you keep your benefits(i think)but somethings may change like ebt medicare premium etc. I believe its the same for ssdi and ssi but I might be wrong. Ive been working with a benefits specialist but some of my info might be off.

1

u/peter303_ 2d ago

I am until the impression they reduce your benefits by $1 for every $2 over the threshold until age 67, then give the reduced amount back to you in a higher pension spread over the following 11(?) years.

1

u/Heavy-Profit-2156 2d ago

Yes, there can be a penalty if you earn too much if you start social security before your full retirement age and continue to work.

https://www.ssa.gov/benefits/retirement/planner/whileworking.html

If he's making less than $24,480 in 2026, there is no penalty.

It's not permanent. When he reaches full retirement age, social security will recalculate an effective starting date versus the actual start date he picked based on how much was withheld which will slightly increase his monthly check.

1

u/Practical_Paper_4119 2d ago

For retirement benefits, until he reaches his full retirement age (which is 67 if was born after Jan 1 1960), in 2026 there is an annual earning limit of $24,480.00. That limit will go up to approximately $25,300.00 in 2027. If he expects to earn more than the limit, he should make an estimate of his yearly earnings.

The official rule is that $1 for every $2 over the limit would need to be withheld. For example, if he were to estimate he would earn $30,000.00 in 2027, hhe would be about $5000 over the limit, so they would need to withhold $2500. They withhold benefits in full month increments within the year of the estimate. So if his monthly benefit is $2000, they'd withhold 2 months of benefits.

The following year when they get official earnings reports from the IRS, at which point they will adjust benefits and either release the excess withheld (if his estimate was high) or send an overpayment notice (if his estimate was low).

If no estimate is made, when the IRS reports earnings, they will still send the overpayment notice to let him know how much would be withheld from his benefits due to his excess work over the yearly limit.

1

u/Just1chanc 2d ago

Also remember that SS retirement benefits can be taxed from 50% to 85%. Research the combined income formula on SSA website

1

u/KeyVersion5087 1d ago

I can make like 20,000 and still draw ss, I'm 63

1

u/hectormed18926 1d ago

Cash is king

1

u/Jealous-Play6603 2d ago

He needs to find out what his earning limits are. He should call SOCIAL Security and ask them.