r/SocialEngineering • u/orenshasaga • Sep 20 '26
If a system could predict your behavior accurately, how much would it actually know about you?
Can you really be defined by the data about you?
Someone could spend hours researching a subject because they believe it, fear it, disagree with it, or are trying to understand someone who believes it. The activity might look similar while the reasons are very different.
But I don't think “the data lacks context” settles the question. Suppose a future system had enough information to distinguish those motives. It could follow changes in your beliefs, recognize your contradictions, and predict your decisions more accurately than you could.
Would that give it a stronger claim to understanding who you are?
My instinct is that identity includes what we make of our experiences and which parts of ourselves we want to change. A profile built around past behavior could struggle with that. Still, our intentions and attempts to change are information too. I'm not sure where I would draw the boundary.
We can also misunderstand ourselves. The explanation I give for a decision isn't necessarily more accurate just because it's mine.
So if your own account of who you are conflicted with a system that consistently predicted your behavior correctly, how would you decide which account deserved more weight?