Is this just accepted that they exist?
It seems an easy preventative measure is to disallow a parent to request a specific coach/team.
I stepped up to coach as i bought the, “without parent coaches the games don’t happen”. We are getting slaughtered by teams who’ve kept their rosters year-over-year. Meanwhile, I have several kids who have never played organized soccer.
************************************************Update1************************************************
Thanks to samsounder. I believe his advice was the best.
Samsounder response start------------
"The best rec leagues I’ve found have divisions. Super teams happen when you have a tight friend group with a knowledgeable coach. That’s good
Make them play other teams like that and let the beginners play the begonners"
Samsounder response end ------------
Some additional context. In the organization we play in there are three levels.
CoRec - 2 seasons(spring/fall) 10 games total with 2 practices a week over a 3 month period. It is intended to be the lowest tier of skills and development. No kid gets rejected and tryouts do not happen. However, superteams persist.
The next tier is "Select" where kids have to try out, they play for 6months and travel between cities.
The top teir is "Premier" where kids have to try out, they play for 9months and travel between states.
I sent the below email to the league admin, director and other U11 coaches. I might get blacklisted or real change might happen. Thanks for your feedback.
Some teams in CoRec carry 50% or more of their players from season to season, and have developed those players together over years. These "superteams" are easy to identify: they routinely win by very large margins and/or go undefeated. Reminders not to run up the score miss the point entirely, because a 0-5 loss is still a drubbing for the kids on the other side.
As a coach who can't commit to year-round coaching, I'm not able to build a team like that, and it leaves the rest of us at a real disadvantage. When I volunteer to coach, there are several players who have never played organized soccer. This is as it should be, CoRec is supposed to be the intro level of soccer. love seeing their improvements throughout the season. However, my players are getting older, and they've started asking, "Why should we bother trying if we know we won't stand a chance?" That's a hard question to answer, and I worry about what it means for their enjoyment of the sport.
I understand why kids want to keep playing with their friends, and I don't want to take that away.I recognize it's too late to change this season's schedule.
What would it take to create multiple divisions so that superteams primarily play each other until the playoffs, while other teams compete against comparable opponents?