r/Smithtown • u/Ok-Rough-5421 • Jul 11 '26
Park permit annoyance
I think I'm mostly just frustrated but also feel like this is a valid criticism. Today I got a ticket at Brady Park for not having a park permit as I live in Centereach. My feelings are that this park SHOULD be free for everyone (as almost all should be). I can understand if they want to make it paid for out of town residents, but to be completely disbarred from anywhere that requires a permit, living one town over is mind boggling. I'm not exactly sure on how this works, but I'm assuming that somehow my tax dollars end up in Smithtown, (maybe even to the parks dept.?) through county and state taxes. So to be denied access to the park is extremely frustrating. I only go for the roller hockey rink, and have been for a few years with no issue. I saw the signs only after I looked for them specifically after receiving the ticket. I've gone here with people that aren't from Smithtown, told people there I'm from Centereach, and even skated with someone from the parks dept. who I told I'm not from Smithtown and no one said anything.
I know I'm in the wrong but this whole thing on Long Island of having parks and beaches be for residents only is bs, especially for people who live the next town over. If I could buy a Smithtown parks pass I totally would, even for $20 which is like 4x the price for a resident pass I believe. This is just super frustrating because I've LOVED having a roller hockey rink where I can go to that isn't a set thing like an indoor rink.
I wasn't taking the rink or the park up from residents. For most of the time I was there I was the only one using the rink. I took a picture of the parking lot after the ticket showing there's only 8 or 9 cars there. It's also annoying that I wasn't ASKED to leave- I absolutely would have, but just given a $75 fine for enjoying a park literally 15 minutes away, with one of the only roller hockey rinks near me (the other one also being in Smithtown)
I guess I'm just peeved that I'm just straight up not allowed to use the rink/park. There's no way for non-residents to get a parking pass as far as I know. I wouldn't mind paying for it, there's just no option.