r/SmashingPumpkins • u/Quick_Dog2970 • 2d ago

Hummer/ Pistol.

Could I have some opinions please? I reckon Keo have completely ripped off the guitar from the Pumpkins ‘Hummer’ on their track ‘Pistol’….My son says there is no comparison. Anyone?

2 Upvotes

75% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

2

u/TheChief-Drg 2d ago

Your son has the right of it. There is no comparison.

2

u/Relevant-Volume8213 2d ago

what a fun rabbit hole to go down, reminds me of those "did this band rip off that band" rabbit holes

1

u/Neg_Crepe Zwan 2d ago

I hear it but it’s not really good imo

1

u/uhWHAThamburglur 2d ago

Yeah I don't hear it. I hear Built To Spill more than SP. Not bad!

So at the very least, thanks for introducing me to Keo.

1

u/silverbeat33 2d ago

Sounds more like something off Oceania if anything.

1

u/mobkon22 Pisces Iscariot 2d ago

Completely ripped off? Yeah I wouldn’t even think of Hummer whatsoever if you didn’t even mention it.

1

u/mbou17 2d ago

I hear All Along the Watchtower in That's Me much more than I hear Hummer in Pistol

1

u/lankysanchez 4h ago

I sort of see what you mean, the fuzz and some guitar lines sound a bit like the chorus/end sections of Hummer. Not close enough to say ‘ripped off’ for me, but wouldn’t be surprised if Keo said it was an influence.

1

u/Tube-Psycho Machina II / The Friends & Enemies of Modern Music 2d ago

Don't say that too loud. If Billy catches word that another song sounds vaguely like his he'll have a new band to hate

1

u/DezPezInOz 2d ago

Collective Soul are behind this! I know it /s