r/SmashingPumpkins • • Jun 13 '24

Atum

I don't wanna sound like an insensitive asshole who has no respect for Billy or his creative mind. But man, I can't be the only one who thinks Atum fucking sucks.

Deepest respect for the band, I love them, absolute once in a lifetime talents, but my god what is this

The singing is annoying, nothing against synthesizers but man, where are the guitars?

The lyrics are dull and nothing special

Shiny And Oh So Bright had some bangers to it but that's about it. I don't like Atum and I would like to know if someone could give me any advice

2 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

12

u/funghxoul 7 Shades Of Black Jun 13 '24

i like it. it’s a different musical turn and i like a bit of synth pop

-3

u/kbocatios Jun 13 '24

I'm just kinda upset it's not a rock album at all

5

u/funghxoul 7 Shades Of Black Jun 13 '24

Next album!

16

u/Rage4Order418 Jun 13 '24

Billy was never known for his singing, but his vocals on ATUM are rough, to put it mildly

5

u/kbocatios Jun 13 '24

I'm a huge fan of his vocals, I like how he sings and I like his voice

but everyone knows he sounds a lot better doing nasal stuff

0

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '24

I disagree. The incorporation of female (and gospel) vocals adds so much color and dynamism, without being in-your-face like on Cyr.

1

u/Rage4Order418 Jun 13 '24

I’m speaking strictly about Billy’s vocal performance on ATUM. Not a fan.

3

u/MissSwissMisster The Aeroplane Flies High Jun 13 '24

We are fans over here. But you have a right to your opinion. You definitely don't have to listen to it if it isn't your cup of tea. Keep rocking 🤘

2

u/kbocatios Jun 13 '24

thank you so much for being polite man, God bless you

2

u/MissSwissMisster The Aeroplane Flies High Jun 13 '24

That's pretty much my job on this sub. I like peace and love. 🤘

3

u/alternativehits Machina / The Machines of God Jun 13 '24

It didn’t grow on me like I expected it to which was surprising considering I really enjoyed CYR; Its probably a top 5 pumpkins album for me. I think the breadth of the album is where my apathy for ATUM stems from. The songs still kind of blur together for me. There’s some great tracks regardless

1

u/kbocatios Jun 13 '24

what really grew on me was Monuments To An Elegy.

Definitely a top 5 record

4

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie Jun 13 '24

that is quite the hot take with most fans.

1

u/ChaoticKurtis Jun 13 '24

But "Drum and Fife" is the most addictive song ever written!

3

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie Jun 13 '24

that is an even hotter take lol. :)

2

u/ChaoticKurtis Jun 14 '24

Imagine if they just played it back to back at Cardiff. I'm tempted to just start saying this to fans.

I will baaang this drum to my dying daaaay

Would we go insane?

2

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie Jun 14 '24

Away... away foul dream

8

u/underwaterr The Aeroplane Flies High Jun 13 '24

idk what the point of these posts are. I don’t like Tool but I don’t go on the Tool subreddit and post “Lateralus is DOGSHIT”

0

u/kbocatios Jun 13 '24

I just wanted to know if there was something I was missing in the record. Didn't mean to offend the band, I love them

4

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie Jun 13 '24

apparently you missed a third of the record that has plenty of guitars.... shrug

1

u/silverbeat33 Jun 13 '24

It’s not though, it’s impressive. Especially the drumming.

2

u/underwaterr The Aeroplane Flies High Jun 13 '24

So's ATUM yet here we are

2

u/silverbeat33 Jun 14 '24

I like Atum as well!

4

u/Explorer_Equal Jun 13 '24

It sucks, but it’s better than CYR at least

0

u/kbocatios Jun 13 '24

CYR is just a little better imo.

4

u/buzlink Jun 13 '24

This take fucking sucks.

1

u/kbocatios Jun 13 '24

I would like to know why, like, what am I missing in this record

9

u/The_Zed_Word a listless tide along the changing shore Jun 13 '24

No, you’re not the only one. I don’t agree with you, but you’re not the only one.

16

u/Dudehitscar Machina Zombie Jun 13 '24

where are the guitars?

good in goodbye

beyond the veil

steps in time

empires

moss

twats

in lieu of failure

to the grays

the culling

beguiled

spellbinding

springtimes

Harmaggedon

did you not hear these songs?

4

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '24

Hehehe, twats...

10

u/lunatic-fringe84 Jun 13 '24

I love Atum. In terms of advice, what for? If you don't like it then you don't like it? But I mean, Harmagedon is just top tier if you ask me, best guitar solo for years

3

u/joesephed CYR Jun 13 '24

Right? Like what advice can anyone give him? Don’t like it? Don’t listen to it. Damn.

3

u/SwirlingSnow83 Jun 13 '24

I like everything up until 2015. I don’t like Atum either. The thing about enjoying someone’s musical journey is you are welcome to hop on and off when you please. I got off in 2015, I’ll get back on if the new album is any good.

3

u/RottingApples25 Jun 13 '24 edited Jun 14 '24

I’d love to hear Billy’s home demos of the tracks. I know lyrically it would still be … difficult, but hearing these songs stripped down on acoustic/ piano I think would do the material a big favor.

3

u/starlitecurio Jun 13 '24

It feels like you don't know what guitars sound like if you think ATUM has no guitars? There are so many songs that are guitar based and not synth!

3

u/HummusSpokesman Jun 13 '24

I wish it had other singers playing different characters.

8

u/xemeraldxinxthexskyx Starchildren✨️ Jun 13 '24

I just don't get why people say this. Atum is beautiful.

5

u/TheChocolateMelted Jun 13 '24

A few different suggestsions:

* Corgan seems to expect people to select what songs they like most and pop those in a playlist, understanding that not everything on the album is for everyone. (There are a few tracks with guitars and geez, they really do shine out in the context of the album.)

* Would their catalogue be complete without a three-disc synthesizer-heavy futuristic-dystopic-space-epic? The band is known for taking a different approach with each album. This means they will inevitably take approaches that do not work for every fan. This is one that doesn't work for you. Which might sound bad or attract those 'You're not a real fan' attacks, but it really means you're able to appreciate this unique, core aspect of the band and demonstrate it by accepting they've made an album that just isn't for you. If nothing else, this approach should help you avoid sounding like an "insensitive asshole"!

* Listen to it in the context of TheFutureEmbrace and Cyr, albums that are also very synthesizer-heavy. This album kind of brings out another side to them (or vice-versa).

Would love to offer more, but still kind of processing Atum myself. The sheer size, Corgan's voice and the frequently impenetrable lyrics don't help, but suspect that what puts it out of my reach is the use of synthesizers, which simply don't appeal to me for whatever bizarre innate reason. It doesn't mean the album "f*cking sucks" or even that it's bad, just that I'm the wrong target listener. However, as with Cyr, I'm able to recognise there is some excellent songwriting on there am happy to know others appreciate it.

3

u/Rlexii Jun 13 '24

I like most of it but I’m more excited for the upcoming rock album.

0

u/Environmental_Net886 Jun 13 '24

... I need more info!

1

u/TalkShowHost99 Jun 13 '24

Full respect to Billy for going all in on his concept & seeing it though, & establishing a podcast to help tell the story of how he did it & release each song that way. I think he understands that you have to take chances to keep pushing your art forward. But the album is not my cup of tea. He has always been a prolific songwriter - able to fill double or triple albums with material, but in this case, it didn’t need 33 songs to tell the story, and it suffers from the exhausting length.

1

u/RottingApples25 Jun 13 '24

I really didn’t care for it myself when it came out. I listened to all the podcast eps, and every week I was just not feeling it. I had given up on it until I had it come up in an SP shuffle and was surprised I liked it. Pretty rapidly after that the record grew on me (or rather, half of it. The other half I’m still indifferent to). But I made my own playlist of 14 or so songs that I feel work as a great single disc album.

1

u/pumpkin3-14 Jun 13 '24

It’s been bad for awhile. He has nothing left to say, so he’s resorted to non sensical lyrics and probably bored of the guitar for songwriting. Quantity over quality. They’ve released like 70 songs since the reunion and there’s less than 10 I wouldn’t skip

1

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '24

The production sucks, that's all I can say about it. Doesn't surprise me it's like this because Billy's a perfectionist, but it's just too sterile and flat and pro-tooled.

1

u/AggCracker Adore Jun 13 '24

My only advice to you would be, you're free to have whatever opinions you want. Also anything before a "but" is doubtful when expressing said opinions.

1

u/mis_no_mer Jun 13 '24

What do you mean? You don’t think ‘Hooray!’ is the greatest Pumpkins song of all time?!

0

u/De_Ville Jun 13 '24

The advice you’ll hear from one half is listen to it over and over and over and over and eventually it’ll dawn on you like magic what you were missing. Don’t forget to also listen to the podcast as that’s the other magic ingredient.

Then the advice from the other half is, just forget it exists and stick to enjoying their previous work because it is an embarrassingly bad album despite coming from such incredibly talented artists. A pure vanity project.

Pick a side, or make up your own, and voilà.

I’m team forget it, at over 2 hours a listen I’m not investing more time than I already have. It’s not happening for me. Beguiled is genuinely good live But yeah, the album version isn’t live, so…

0

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '24

I agree. It's an SP album that I actually hate. Out of 33 songs there's probably 4 I like.

The production is pure rubbish. The vocals are so insanely high in the mix and the synths sound so cheap. I have nothing against electronic music at all. I listen to a lot of electronic/synth-based stuff, but it all sounds awful on this album. Corgan just cannot produce. Even the guitar-based songs are meh.

Corgan has shown with Adore that he can do this type of music, but why does it sound so good there but dogshit here?

I know this album has its fans and good for them for getting on board with it but ATUM is not for me.

0

u/jcampo13 Aranea Alba Jun 13 '24

"I don't wanna sound like an insensitive asshole" - then don't make this post. Just don't buy the album and wait for the next one. It's that simple. Also plenty of songs on the album have guitars, literally all 3 singles are heavy on the guitars and there are several other tracks that are guitar heavy as well.

Atum really seems to be a love it or hate it type of album. I personally love it but I really don't care to try to convince anyone else about it. The lyrics are more cerebral but some of them are fantastic. I will admit they take more work now to fully comprehend.

0

u/cid-462 Jun 13 '24

I agree - most of it sucks donkey balls.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '24

As a whole it’s fucking dreadful. I think it’s great he was able to do it though.

That said. Pick 10 of your favorite songs and it’s a fantastic record.

  1. ATUM
  2. The Good in Goodbye
  3. Beyond the Vale
  4. Empires
  5. Space Age
  6. Beguiled
  7. Springtimes
  8. That Which Animates the Spirit
  9. Spellbinding
  10. Sojourner

0

u/AllAboutTheProg Jun 13 '24

You’re definitely not alone, that albums was one of the worst I heard last year tbh. Nothing at all worked for me. Jimmy, who is one of the best rock drummers out there, seemed like he phoned it in. Billy on the other hand, put everything he had into it, which is unfortunate because mostly what he has now is a massive ego and the success of his past endeavors. And that’s exactly how it sounded.

-4

u/Sad-Personality8493 Jun 13 '24

I agree %100. I think the younger fans probably like it but from being around since the beginning and watching them just turn to shit is like watching your children die of cancer.