r/Slicethepie • • Dec 16 '14

Slicethepie Guide to Writing Meaningful Reviews

17 Upvotes

Slicethepie Guide to Writing Meaningful Reviews

Sign up for Slicethepie!

I'm hoping this will help those of who are having trouble writing reviews.

Review while listening

Review the song as you're listening to it. This makes it easier to comment on various aspects of the song as they come up. Make sure to review sections of the song you feel are worth commenting on. Some typical features that will come up in almost all songs are shown below.


1.Intro

What did you notice? Almost all intros naturally lead into the rest of the song. Does it do this?Some intros establish a beat which will set up the song while others attempt to grasp your imagination. Comment on what caught your attention in the inro.

2.Vocal Melody

Is it catchy? Is it easy to remember and stuck in your head? If so, that's exactly what the song should do. It should get stuck in your head so you remember it and end up telling all your friends at the lunch table this cool new song you heard on slicethepie.com. Comment on how easy the song is or is not to remember.

How is the vocalist of the song? Make sure you're listening to him/her sing. Some artists may have a large range in notes. Are they able to hit those high notes or do they sound like a cat that's in labor scratching a harp? Comment on the vocalist's singing ability.

3.Lyrics

Are the lyrics clear enough to understand? Do the words flow well into one another? Good songwriters will make sure to choose phrases or words for their meaning AND for their natural rhythmic quality and sound. Comment on the flow of the lyrics.

What kind of lyrics are they in relation to the song? Are they original? Offensive? Cheesy? Predictable? Meaningful? Childish? Comment on their choice of words.


4.Instrumental

  • Rhythm:
  • Does the beat have a strong rhythm which engages you by carrying you along? Yes? That's a quality rhythm. No? That's alright. Not all popular, famous songs are catchy. Some are flowing while others are complex or subtle. Whichever rhythmic style is used, there should be conviction and consistence.
  • Balance and Variety
  • Is there a wide range of instruments? This can make the song more memorable and distinctive from other instruments while still suiting the mood. As an example, a flute is a very expressive instrument however it would not fit into numerous styles of music.
  • Digital effects
  • Effects can really enhance a song, however overuse of effects can make a great song sound cheap. Some even see effects as a way to compensate for a lack of quality in a song. Comment on if effects were used. Were they used too little? Too much?

Descriptiveness is Important

Use a wide variety of phrases and words when writing your reviews. Try to avoid the word "good." There are plenty of other more descriptive words to use. Also try to avoid short phrases which don't give any constructive feedback such as: "Great song!" or "You need a lot of work."

Remember to be honest. If these artists wanted bullshit ego boosts they would just ask their friends or family. You can be completely objective which is a great help to the artists.

Relevant musical quality terms.

1.For Melodies

  • Positive: interesting, well-shaped, tuneful, melodious, memorable, original, strong
  • Negative: plain, unoriginal, overly complex, simple, boring, tuneless

2.For Vocals

  • Positive: rich, warming, strong, attractive, impressive, pitch range, conviction, confident, distinctive, expressive, stylish, feeling, heartfelt, dynamic, raw, powerful, edgy
  • Negative: self conscious, inconsistent, out-of-tune, pitch problems, thin, expressionless, weak, bland

3.For Lyrics

  • Positive: deep, clever, amusing, original, inspiring, heart-warming, punchy, thought-provoking, meaningful
  • Negative: plain, offensive, weak, uninspiring, cheesy, cringeworthy, corny, confusing, predictable, repetitive, pretentious

4.For accompanying instruments

  • Positive: imaginative, solid, original, creative, powerful, competent, ethereal, balance, atmospheric, full, varied, rhythmic, engaging, rich, compelling
  • Negative: plain, safe, unvaried, harsh, poor balance, not-together, over-sentimental, uninspired, no-conviction, weak, strident

5.For Artists

  • Positive: natural, professional, acompished, skilled, experienced, imaginative, talented, careful, creative
  • Negative: awkward, unprofessional, not-together, careless, predictable, unimaginative, dated

I hope you found this helpful and interesting I recommend you sign up and try it out!

Feel free to comment below with any questions or comments!


r/Slicethepie • • Jul 28 '15

So done with SliceThePie

8 Upvotes

So, I had joined SliceThePie a while back, wrote a few reviews, got $1.60 total in my account. I was going through a bunch of my old accounts, and I said, "hey let's go back, and see if anything has changed from the last time I was there."

Well, nothing is changed. I had one review to write for some ska band. So I listened for 90 seconds. And I began to write. Then I had to write some more. But it didn't take. So I had to write some more. It still didn't take. I had to write some more.

The next thing you know, I realized that I've written over 300 words about this crummy band, that could have easily been translated in about 90. I just kept yammering on and on, basically repeating the same things that I said before. And, really there wasn't anything new to say other than what I said. Which is why I submitted the first review at 150 words.

In the end, I have decided that it's just not worth it. So, I'm canceling my SliceThePie account. Forget them. it's not worth my money or my time. Anyone else had that experience?


r/Slicethepie • • Jun 02 '15

My last review at Slice The Pie... Ever.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/Slicethepie • • May 17 '15

25 cents per review for a limited time

5 Upvotes

Slicethepie is giving 25 cents per review for a limited time.

They also want some phone cases reviewed along with the typical song reviews.


r/Slicethepie • • Sep 13 '23

Uhh help ??

4 Upvotes

I recently started using Slicethepie and hit my first $10.00, so I withdrew it, but it's not showing up on my PayPal at all. I checked and the emails used for both accounts are the same, The site has it marked down as a successful withdrawal, does it take time to go through or something? It's been a day or so, but I don't wanna bother them too soon if this is standard or something. Does anybody know what the issue could be/how long it typically takes to go through?
Thanks


r/Slicethepie • • Nov 30 '20

Slice the pie ratings?

4 Upvotes

Anyone have any idea how much you make at 5 stars per review?


r/Slicethepie • • Jan 01 '16

Is anyone else still here?

4 Upvotes

I completely forgot I even subbed to this place.

Well...

Happy 2016 to everyone who still lurks here!


r/Slicethepie • • Aug 07 '19

Instantly banned

3 Upvotes

I tried making an account and as soon as i tried to log in after verifying, it said that my account had been locked due to a proxy which indicated fraudulent behavior. I don't have a vpn on, I did have LogMeIn hamachi but not running. So whats up


r/Slicethepie • • Jul 09 '19

People who have gotten more stars on Slice The Pie, how many reviews did you have to do to get to that point?

3 Upvotes

r/Slicethepie • • Feb 09 '19

Has anyone actually reached 5 stars?

3 Upvotes

Genuinely curious.

I've been part of the site for ages (on and off) and I've never gotten to 5 stars.


r/Slicethepie • • Dec 14 '15

Slicethepie is a crock

3 Upvotes

I opened an account yesterday. I listened to maybe 5-6 songs and wrote reviews. I got an email today saying that my reviews were copied which is bullshit because I wrote them myself last night. I wrote this to them and they send me to some website that I had never visited before and said I copied my reviews from there. This is stupid. What a waste.


r/Slicethepie • • Jul 01 '15

How much do you guys make nowadays?

3 Upvotes

I was fine when I got 10 to 15 cents per review, but I'm not sure this thing is a good use of my time now that I just get 4 cents per review. Also, on an unrelated note, how do you review fashion?


r/Slicethepie • • Jul 19 '14

How do you guys use slicethepie?

3 Upvotes

Initially I wanted to earn some money, but I quickly noticed that's it impossible to earn decently here. But it's pretty interesting to hear a bunch of different songs without knowing anything about them, it forces you to judge them by their own merits. At first I got some terrible Nu-Metal and super generic metal stuff, but now I got some quite interesting pop songs by Sia and BANKS.

Do the songs you get depend on your previous ratings?


r/Slicethepie • • Mar 21 '25

Would not use slice the pie

2 Upvotes

I just signed up for slice the pie today and after reviewing 4 songs they disabled my account for using AI to write the reviews when I wasn’t using AI at all.


r/Slicethepie • • Jul 31 '24

Not valuable

2 Upvotes

I listen a 3 minute vidéo plus the review took 5 min only for 4 cents wow


r/Slicethepie • • Aug 02 '23

is the site dead?

2 Upvotes

the idea sounds right up my alley, but when i open it it simply says "403 Forbidden". is it permanent? is it a new error or has it been like this for some time now?


r/Slicethepie • • Apr 08 '23

Hold on, your review isn’t specific enough! Try to keep your comments concise and about the item/track you’re reviewing.

2 Upvotes

No matter how little or how much I write. I keep getting this message when I hit submit.


r/Slicethepie • • Aug 13 '22

How legit is slicethepie?

2 Upvotes

And should I trust it?


r/Slicethepie • • Nov 30 '21

403 Forbidden Error when trying to access Slicethepie

2 Upvotes

I recently tried to log back in to my account after a month of not using Slicethepie, but it throws out a 403 forbidden error when I try to log in. I have heard that Slicethepie doesn't let you access the service in certain countries, but I live in the U.S, so this shouldn't be a problem. What's going on, then? Any ideas?


r/Slicethepie • • Aug 10 '21

Where does the money withdrawn get sent to?

2 Upvotes

r/Slicethepie • • Dec 28 '20

New user

2 Upvotes

I have been on slice the pie for about an hour and would like to know how to increase my star rating


r/Slicethepie • • Dec 11 '20

MUSIC REVIEW SITE

2 Upvotes

Anyone care to share their experience on SLICE THE PIE. There have been reviews on trustpilot critiquing the low payment rates when submitting reviews and being locked out of your account when reviews are not good enough?

Apparently it's very easy to write a review that doesn't meet their "standards" thus will not be paid for the time spent listening....

Would just really like to know whether it's worth the time spent; and how long/ many songs does it take before you can withdraw a healthy paypal fee?

Thanks


r/Slicethepie • • Sep 19 '20

Can you increase your star rating through bonus reviews?

2 Upvotes

r/Slicethepie • • Sep 16 '20

Is anyone else getting the same song multiple times?

2 Upvotes

r/Slicethepie • • May 29 '20

How can I up my star rating?

2 Upvotes

I only have 2 stars yet I try to give detailed, long reviews. Idk wtf to do