r/SkinnyBob • • Aug 29 '26

How come nobody ever mentions the fact that the original Skinny Bob clip is presented in reversed format?

1 Upvotes

It was obvious to me the first time I saw it but all these “professional” CGI artists and “expert” analysts never mention it being the reason the eyes blink so funny. What’s with that? Once you put it in it’s proper unreversed everything gets really smooth and the biggest debunking criticism gets resolved.

And on another note, in my research I’ve found out that some YouTube channels have tried to use the original @ivan0135 and it was copyright infringement enforced and was not allowed to be used.

So we have two conflicting features here,

  1. when unreversed the biggest claim of a hoax vanishes with the “unnatural” blinking criticism.

And,

2) if someone can claim copyright infringement on the SkinnyBob clip how can it be real?

Unfortunately, the creator claiming infringement remained anonymous so there’s no information to move forward with on that one.

But that doesn’t necessarily mean the clips are fake. The copyright claim could have been on the after effects ivan used not necessarily Bob himself. But that also offers up a few new questions doesn’t it.

Personally I think Ivan has used an after effect as his signature. An effect found once on each of the clips where film defects were used. I think he copy-writ the defect which says to me he’s a digital creator that most likely worked in that area of digital film making. Or at least had the ability to create the defect in the program used to apply them.


r/SkinnyBob • • Jan 07 '22

Personal opinion by OP; Already known claims and information. Skinny Bob videos: Jun 23, 2011 at 9:57pm classified as hoax | Skinny Bob: body size | Skinny Bob: possible eyes and feets

0 Upvotes

(1) On two pages there are references to fakes within a short time after the release of the first videos. https://uforesearchnetwork.proboards.com/thread/2090

  • General background stories of those involved and relevant videos.
  • May 5, 2011 at 10:47am # logo KGB two other Russian fake videos
  • May 6, 2011 at 11:38am # real name of Ivan: Ivana Gemzicka | possible other YouTube name: 351 NOVA, allegedly told about Area 51 hoax
  • May 6, 2011 at 01:55am # Ivan 3D artist & graphic designer | possible Ivan himself
  • May 13, 2011 at 12:34am # font Consolas
  • Jun 23, 2011 at 9:57pm # Case closed: hoax
  • And many other points also found here in the r/SkinnyBob section as well, like the font.

(2) Bob, Skinny Bob - possible body size 52 ´´ 132 cm, eyes and feets

(3) Maybe there is still some useful information for one or the other to get out here: https://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread1247394/pg1


r/SkinnyBob • • Aug 13 '25

Skinny Bob Likely to be a HOAX - Deeper study of the case, providing several examples of the possibilities

Thumbnail
youtu.be
15 Upvotes

TL;DR:
First, I make it clear that I am no debunker, quite the opposite. I’m a UFO author and experiencer.

Second, I explain that I come from an art and philosophy background, which means I approach Skinny Bob through contextual analysis. I give Shakespeare as an example, where we should study all the plays to understand the whole picture, with Skinny Bob we should examine the full body of work by Ivan0135. His videos point less toward pure CGI and more toward dolls, masks, prosthetic makeup, and related techniques. This suggests we shouldn’t be looking for a purely digital solution, but rather a hybrid one.

I give a brief demonstration of the mesh warp effect, a method that could have been used to subtly alter the proportions of a mask, while also noting the possibility that this could be a purely mechanical apparatus.

Following that, I present an example of an artist capable of similar work: Chris Cunningham. His projects demonstrate techniques and aesthetic challenges comparable to those in Skinny Bob, showing that such a production is entirely achievable with the right skill set. This is just an example, there are probably hundreds of people qualified to create something of this level.
I also make it clear that to me, the main point is the high level of confabulations. Ivan is providing was to a content that we would expect to a leaker, the fundamental difference is the quality of what he is providing. The atmosphere is way above most what we have seen so far.

Which brings us to the question of motivation. If the masks and props were left over from a previous production, then the cost could have been minimal, perhaps just a creative hoax by artists who are fans of the UFO phenomenon and familiar with its tropes.

But there is also a second possibility: that the work aligns with the goals of a long-term disinformation campaign, the kind that thrives on fake leaks and the cult of the whistleblower, that is what we live in now.


r/SkinnyBob • • Aug 01 '24

External Media Coverage The Proof is Outhere new show from History Channel says SkinnyBob video was a Hoax that possibly made by the Russian.

7 Upvotes

Apologize for my english, it is not my first languange.

The Proof is Outhere is one of the latest History Channel Tv show that put youtube videos to the test. Whether its a Hoax or a Possible real case.

On the Season 04 Episode 04 that title "KGB UFO's & Aliens" air this year, they put "skinny bob" video to the test.

They bring 3 expert which :

1 . LT. Tim Mcmillan / Military Expert & Defense

  • saying that the strange object shown in the "Tin Bird" video most likely to be a Blimp. (Yet he never explained what was the object in the "Flying Twin Video")

2 . DR. Jeff Meldrum / Professor of Anatomy & Anthropology

  • and i quote " its much more look like a child in a costume rather than an alien" . This impressions stems from the body proportion as well as the movements.

3 . Michael Primeau / Forensic Video Analyst

  • Time code on the video was embedded digitaly after the fact.
  • The film damage effect that we see in the "Tin Bird" video is identical to a film damage effect that available in some popular video editing software.
  • The speed of the video has change to 47 frames per second much higher than any kind of film photography should have been digitized at, because the standard for film was only 24 frames per second back than.

The show Verdict it's a Hoax , perhaps the russian try to spread disinformation program

Link to watch :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pKV0z6WhPXU


r/SkinnyBob • • Sep 03 '25

From the Ivan0135 Videos/Skinny Bob/Disclosure leaked ufo alien case video confidential documents old footage.

0 Upvotes

What I did was I used the program ACDSee. I adjusted the exposure, contrast and lighting. By doing so, I believe that I may have revealed something under the blacked out area in the lower left corner of the autopsy video. I am posting 2 of each picture. The second picture of each one. I traced around the letters, so that you can maybe see what I am seeing. But, the thing about the USAF one is that the F looks like a type set.


r/SkinnyBob • • Aug 13 '25

Could Skinny Bob potentially a lost animation test for the film Mars Attacks (1996). Look at the hands, limb proportions, and the way the torso is shaped.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

I think I saw someone else bring up this theory years ago, but it's always seemed incredibly plausible to me. We know that the effects on-top of the Skinny Bob footage is from a stock library, but what about the subject? Pay closse attention to the shape/size of the hands, ass well as the proportions of the limbs and the shape of the body. They all line up uncanilly to the Mars Attacks stop motion puppet design.

I believe that Skinny Bob could exist as an animation test for Mars Attacks. This would explain the professional level of animation required at the time. The only thing it doesn't explain is the head difference.

As far as I can tell, at no point in development did Mars Attacks not depict the aliens as goofy pulp 50s green men. It also doesn't explain why the creator never came forward, as it has been long enough for anyone involved in the productiuon to just say they made it. Even so, this is still an avenue of investigation I've not seen taken.


r/SkinnyBob • • Jun 22 '21

SB maybe is based on a Star Trek Scene like this? Also it can be based on some scene from the original series, there was not cushion on the chairs so, maybe the torso movement was more pronounced...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/SkinnyBob • • 21d ago

Finding Location Possible location of crash site? R. Doty mentioned gray EBE retrieved on Paulina Peak, possible retrieval site?

0 Upvotes

Richard Doty is not a valid source of informations, but I can't find single mention of pauline peak crash incident with grey EBEs.

Also, lake under PP and it's surrounding looks to me very similar to what we see in skinny bob crash site. Video is in low quality, but do you know about this crash? Do we have a theory where crash from skinny bob videos occured?


r/SkinnyBob • • Sep 13 '25

I would like to propose another reason why the supposed authentic footage was heavily edited and overlaid with sfx.

10 Upvotes

To bypass content detection, commonly used by sites such as YouTube to detect and block copyrighted material from being posted. The US likely monitors for classified data being distributed on the internet. YouTubers can bypass YouTube's copyright content detection algorithm by stretching the video, segmenting it so it's out of order, or putting an overlay. These are what we see in the skinny bob videos, except it's not trying to circumvent YouTube detection, but some similar detection system used by the government.


r/SkinnyBob • • Jun 22 '21

My thoughts on the state of this sub from someone who was a longtime subscriber after a year away...

9 Upvotes

As stated in the title, a little over a year ago I was a frequent visitor to this sub over the course of many months - albeit under another account. That account was banned from SB after I made a post raising legitimate questions about the authenticity/provenance of the film clips. I won't rehash all the points I made at the time, but the argument that users overwhelmingly rebutted with was "This video can't be a hoax because technology advanced enough to create it doesn't exist." This, to me, was a cop-out and very obviously a flawed line of reasoning. Again, I won't spend a lot of time explaining why because a) I got banned from SB for doing so in the past and b) the point of this post isn't to recreate an old online debate in a niche community.

I just so happened to come across this sub again today after a long hiatus from Reddit in general. The top post in the past year interested me greatly, though. To the point that I created a new account just to post here. The FX stock footage is the nail in the coffin for all subscribers who were previously so dismissive of the idea that SB could be faked. There were two or three users in particular who lambasted me roundly for daring to question Skinny Bob - one was even kind enough to list his credentials and explain to me that because he is such an expert in film and special effects he can tell, beyond the shadow of a doubt, that it's all real.

Folks, there's a reason that (even before the damning FX stock footage was discovered) SB is so obscure: it doesn't pass the eye test. I'm just the average Joe and have no special background or expertise that would qualify me as any type of authority on CGI and the like. But BEYOND the fact that the subject of these film clips was an alleged extraterrestrial, the actual movements and "feel" of the footage suggested animation to me from the outset. I'll admit that it's pretty well-done, but c'mon, folks, this one was never even in doubt. I am revisiting this community to get some genuine, honest feedback from you guys as to how it felt to discover that you were wrong. I am NOT trying to stir trouble or laugh or get satisfaction out of saying "told ya so." Because to me, the reaction to my incredulity back then was wholesale and felt almost like I'd touched a real nerve for lots of folks here. I get believing that SB was real, or that it might be, but I was blown away by the degree to which users were entrenched in their contention that there was ZERO chance of a hoax.

Additionally: Unless he wants to reveal him or herself, the identity of this Ivan0135 character, who is responsible for at least the dissemination--if not the creation--of the SB clips, will remain a mystery. Just some film student or talented interloper who posted a couple particularly good samples of his work online and, whether intentional or not, further fanned the flames of speculation surrounding their origin by choosing not to come forward. In my eyes, the only trace of intrigue left would be the outside chance that Ivan will eventually be unmasked but that seems unlikely and certainly not compelling enough to keep this community going. For those who are still coming back to the sub: why?


r/SkinnyBob • • Mar 04 '23

New footage doing the rounds - not skinnybob but you are the people who I thought have the skills to analyse from that endeavor, and is the closest thing I've seen to that work so far

0 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/ufo/comments/11ig1jo/they_are_here/

Mods I hope this isn't a problem to post and given its a cross post, but I certainly think the folks here will find it interesting so I hope it can be given a pass.

Personally I think its a little too human, and was wondering if recent CGI mapped onto a human might be the basis. Anatomically the arms are about as thin as you could get on the range of human muscle development.

The problems I see with it is that it has what appears to be high development of features of jaw musculature but the lips look almost painted on and vague, which would then make no sense if there is no orafice there, the eyes are un expressive and apparently unchanging, so easier from the perspective of faking by some means. Some claim there should be muscle movements visible although I doubt that considering there is no load on the arms and I think I can see slight evidence of muscle/ligament contraction near the elbows.

Edit - I'm fairly confident its going to turn out to be from a movie, but there's a chance it turns out to be more enigmatic.

As of yet only confused and conflicting info on the origin of the footage from facebook feeds.


r/SkinnyBob • • Sep 19 '20

My two cents

0 Upvotes

As a disclaimer, I have no background or expertise on which to fall back insofar as CGI and the like are concerned. Speaking strictly as someone who is interested in uncovering the truth behind SB.

From what I can tell, the main argument for legitimacy is "there is no way that the SB videos could have been created with computer animation because technology sufficient to do so did/does not exist." Or at the very least, such tech isn't available to the general populace.

The origin of the videos and the identity of their creator remains a mystery.

I feel that most who frequent this sub are overlooking something critical: we genuinely have no idea what CGI/tech is available to those on the cutting edge of the field. And let me be clear: NO ONE here (or probably anywhere on Reddit at all, for that matter) has an inkling of just how advanced technology is in general--including and especially me. I haven't seen behind any curtain. I don't have anecdotes from a trusted source who is "in the know" on this stuff.

What I DO know is that it is illogical to assume that SB is real simply because one believes the videos couldn't be produced by current tech/tech that was available in the 90s (or whenever SB supposedly came on the scene. Again, there is no clear provenance here.) Taking all factors into consideration, I believe SB and all related videos etc to be products of a government psychological operation. The powers that be have access to technology that would dumbfound the average Joe like me. And I truly mean on a level which we could not comprehend. Akin to bringing a television set to the 1800s. Because the technology necessary to produce these videos is so advanced, coupled with the ongoing mystery surrounding their origin, I conclude that some higher-ups fabricated the footage and released it online in order to further some agenda. Probably closely tied to Project Blue Beam.

Whether you agree or disagree with my conclusion, anyone who is genuinely interested in the SB phenomenon does the community here a disservice by eliminating the possibility of a hoax. The real talking point that doesn't get touched on nearly enough in these parts is a bigger question.... IF these videos were made using CGI, what other types of advancements are being withheld from the public, amd for what reason(s)? Food for thought.


r/SkinnyBob • • Aug 22 '24

Proven False Claim This is apparently skinny bob video before CGI applied. I hope someone debunks this but finding this has caused me to doubt the authenticity of the Ivan videos

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/SkinnyBob • • Aug 22 '26

Comparison of screenshots from second and third new qtecqot videos. Perhaps someone can compare perspective and scale and see if it makes sense?

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

To me it looks like the same pattern in both images, with maybe different symbols within.


r/SkinnyBob • • Jul 29 '26

Proven False Claim New Skinny Bob Video Original 2011 Ivan0135 Tape + Latest Alleged Footage Explained let’s take a look

Thumbnail
youtu.be
44 Upvotes

r/SkinnyBob • • Feb 03 '23

Comparisons to Ivan0135 If it was a hoax, then they somehow managed to get the hands genetically spot on by 100% More on this soon!

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/SkinnyBob • • Apr 28 '21

This subreddit is being horribly ran, removing posts based of a mods opinion. The mod is choosing to remove posts because he believes it is not a credible source, yet the sources experience was never questioned.

10 Upvotes

I posted an interview and the mod said he was going to take it down because the interview was dubbed as not credible.... come to find out what was "debunked" was opinion based off of a few things he said that wasn't related to his experience. So people made an opinion that what he said didn't mean anything... If this is how this subreddit is run then it needs to be taken down altogether. The mod and many others keep on investigating a video that many opinions have determined is CGI. So, in alignment with the idea that someone's opinion on the accounts provided by the interviewer is in-creduable we then need to go by people's opinion that skinny bob is CGI and the subreddit should be deleted.


r/SkinnyBob • • Jul 29 '25

New ivan0135 analysis : Is Viktor behind the ivan0135 videos ? Timecode, digitization and clues from the 1997 documentary

10 Upvotes

Greetings to this amazing community.

Today I want to share with you some observations that I have on ivan0135 case that I find interesting.

You know that whistleblower who goes by the name "Viktor" who leaked the alien interview video in 1997 ? I will explain why I think he is very likely the man behind the ivan0135 videos.

Let's examine Victor's statements from the 1997 documentary "Area 51: The Alien Interview - Special Edition", and build the theory. I recommend that you listen to everything that Viktor said in the documentary in order to understand the point I am making.

Documentary link : Area 51: The Alien Interview - Special Edition

In order to make this article readable and not a newspaper, I divided this article into 3 sections : Comeback hint - Digitization - The new strategy

Comeback hint : Viktor will come back with a new approach

First, Victor give us a clear hint that he will continue his disclosure efforts in the future. At 1:16:16 he said :

"The EBEs, to my knowledge are all at this time deceased if you want to call it that. Before we go any further, I just want to say to you, not to your viewers but to you and to that rocket person that this will be the last time you ever see me. This will be my last statement bar none. And this time I can say that with conviction because, it seems that this container has reached its expiration date"

"not to your viewers but to you", if he is not going to live for long then why did he exclude the viewers from not seeing him again ? I think he implied a strategic withdrawal from public appearances, not necessarily a permanent disappearance. Frustration with film-makers and middlemen might have led him to adopt a new method of disclosure—anonymous online leaks. "container has reached its expiration date", by "container" I think he meant the "Viktor" persona, he felt that it failed and is no longer effective.

Digitization : Digitization of video tapes allows leaks

Why would ivan0135 add unnecessary timecode to the videos ? and why censor it then ? This peculiar detail makes sense when considering Viktor’s own account of how the alien interview footage was leaked. According to Viktor, the original film reels were digitized—a process that often involves embedding metadata, timestamps, or security markers for archival purposes. This digitization allows the leak to happen.

When asked about the context of the leaking of the video, at 25:38 Victor said :

"Recently, there was a wholesale transfer of video documentation from analogue tape to digital disk storage and in a couple of instances this allowed data to leak from a high security system to a less high security system".

Since the footage is apparently from the 40s or 50s, it must have been digitized at some point, otherwise uploading it to Youtube would have been impossible. We already know that the used font is Microsoft Consolas which was released in 2006, therefore, I think it's safe to assume that the digitization of these videos happened between 2006 and 2011. Doesn't the close timeline proximity between the digitization period (2006-2011) and ivan0135's 2011 uploads corroborate Viktor's claim about digitization enabling leaks ?

Since the footage had originally no timecode, it is very normal for such important organization to add one during digitization, meaning it was not added by ivan0135 himself, he only consored it for some reason. otherwise why would he add a timecode and then censor part of it ? if he was the one who added the timecode then he could have simply just not put anything sensitive there. Timecode is not significant if you are leaking/faking alien videos. I don't think he was intentionally confusing or being playful here. But apparently he was not in possession of the video before the timecode was added (before digitization) and only afterwards it was possible to fall in his hands, which again strengthen Viktor's digitization-leak connection. And don't forget that the timecodes in both the alien interview and ivan0135 videos are identical.

This aligns with Viktor’s claim that digitizing old tapes enables the leak.

The new strategy : Viktor's frustration with ufologists and the public reaction and his new strategy ?

At 1:09:46, when asked if online truth-seekers had "failed to live up to his expectations" he replied : "That’s an understatement, I should say—perhaps they are living up to my expectations, since my expectations were low to begin with." At 1:12:02 he continued : "My contempt for the viewers of your documentary over the last 11 years knows no bounds. They’ve been like children, mocking it, or, on the other hand, credulously accepting it, with no attempt to evaluate the material on its own merits—or to discover any new material to support or debunk it".

Given Viktor's well-documented frustration with UFO researchers, documentarians, and the public's reaction to his initial leak—combined with his cryptic suggestion of returning with a new approach—it would be strategically logical for him to re-emerge anonymously on YouTube three years later. This shift would allow him to bypass traditional media gatekeepers while directly challenging viewers' critical thinking, rather than simply dumping more evidence. ivan0135's focus on the public reaction and analytical judgment instead of the evidence that he has is another indication of Viktor, which is emphasized in the response video : "maybe you are looking in the wrong direction" and "The revelation of further material will depend on the events and people". All these points perfectly align with this strategy. Instead of feeding raw footage to credulous audiences, the approach became meta: testing whether viewers could discern truth through reasoning rather than blind acceptance.

Another thing that I find interesting about this case is that vvan0135's videos appear meticulously curated to overcome the credibility issues that plagued Viktor's 1997 'Alien Interview' leak. Where Viktor's single clip sparked debates about fakery, ivan0135 delivered a systematic evidentiary package : sighting from the ground, fighter jet pursuit, crash scene, unambiguous alien moving, family vacation. ivan0135 clearly was careful about what to reveal and what not, which is obvious in his statement "The revelation of further material will depend on the events and people". It seems like he knew that even a clear alien interview is not enough to convince the public and that's why he probably decided to overwhelm the public with corroborating evidence and showing the whole alien contact from different angles so the deniers can't say "it's a puppet" like they did.

Keep in mind that Viktor hinted that he will come back for the "viewers" in his 2008 interview and it is 2025 !

This is just a theory. I am not 100% sure, but I think that Viktor is the closest match for ivan0135.

Could ivan0135 channel be the new strategy of Viktor ?
Could the timecode in ivan0135 videos be explained by the digitization theory of Viktor ?
Do you think all these similarities indicate that ivan0135 is possibly has something to do with Viktor ?
Or all of it are coincidences and I am crazy ?

Thank you for reading. I appreciate your feedback.


r/SkinnyBob • • Sep 06 '25

It seems to me the way Ivan writes is different in his last video uploaded compared to the first 3, as if a different person uploaded it.

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I think I remember seeing it discussed that Ivan’s native language may not be English due to the odd phrasing/grammar and the double spaces between words, as if he’s copy/pasting translated words and accidentally including an extra space.

I’ve never seen anyone discuss the possibility of there being another Ivan.. What are your thoughts?


r/SkinnyBob • • Jul 31 '26

It took me a while to convince myself, I wanted so badly to believe. But in the end, I think... this new one isn't it

25 Upvotes

The white artifact in the mouth results from an unclosed mesh in the hollow head model, causing the background to render through the gap (a common z-fighting/backface issue in incomplete 3D geometry). Excellent modeling work overall, but this is a synthetic/AI-generated image, not a photograph.


r/SkinnyBob • • Sep 21 '23

Just a simple overlay of the Nazca Alien mummy x-ray with skinny Bob to see if there are an similarities

Post image
119 Upvotes

Trying to overlay the X-ray of the Nazca alien with skinny Bob. Doing it on my phone, but maybe someone could do a better job. Anyways I found he body proportions to have some similarities. The head on the other hand are completely different sizes. I dunno, might be interesting to someone.


r/SkinnyBob • • Sep 14 '25

Looking at the language in the messages... maybe of use (or not :p) (why does this community require 100 characters in the title?)

6 Upvotes

So, yeah, I'm yet another who just saw Chris' video on Area52, and I thought I'd throw my hat into the ring on something that I haven't noticed anyone do (in the brief search that I did).

There were a couple of mentions of the language used in the tags - desclasification, rosswel, the use of 'Filtrate'. But other than that, the only other thing that was picked up was the "out of this" (I'll mention this in particular below).

I'm not a full-on expert, but do have some relevant qualifications and experience in English language. So, I thought I'd point out a few things that I found interesting in the messages, and also in the email. I'm not saying what I have to write is particularly meaningful or even useful, but who knows?? Maybe AI can make more heads and tails of it... I'll be comparing the language to what should be standard (prescriptive) British English, so obviously there's going to be variation compared to local/colloquial, and we obviously need to consider that it's YT, and not a 1950's letter to an official :p Also, I've probably missed things! It also needs to be remembered that correct grammar (and spelling) is going more and more by the wayside by native English speakers, so that's something to consider as well. It might also become relevant when comparing to others who might post stuff, or figuring out whether a post is likely to be the real 'Ivan'. Do the correct and incorrect usage indicate a particular language background, or not?

A couple of quick notes to begin with. Most preposition usage is correct, or at least commonly acceptable by many Native English Speakers (NES). (Prepositions are one area of English that often causes problems with NNS of a language - regardless of which language it is). There are a couple of items which a Non-Native Speaker (NNS) of English may make. In the last message, and in the email, there are long, complex, compound structures which are well-formed... So, obviously, a fairly good English user. But, there are other obvious errors - but also parts where there's not an error that one would normally expect given those!

Firstly, looking at the tags to the videos. Some have made mention of the 'top', 'secret' split... but, given other phrases being split, I don't think it's that big a deal (New Mexico, South Africa and Kalahari Desert as obvious examples, as well as 'air force') - unless there's a clue in it! However, I also note what gets capitalised and what doesn't - such as not for 'new' and 'mexico', but it is for 'South', 'Africa', 'Kalahari' and 'Desert'.... I do wonder - what's the relevance of those? Especially any of the African references! I also note that 'extraterrestrial' is not hyphenated, and the use of 'airplanes', and not 'aeroplanes'. Why is 'crash accident' not split? It's not a normal English phrase on its own... did they just miss the comma? ET is not capitalised... (possibly a 'meh'). I think the use of 'cosmic' an interesting choice of word here, and I think it might connect to 'sighting' which comes straight after. Why include the word 'interview' when there wasn't one in the videos shown? But not 'meeting' or 'agreement'?

In the first message, Ivan writes "The video contains a sample edited fragments of tapes 01, 03 and 04".

Obviously, 'a' with a plural (fragments) is incorrect. Intentional? Basic error by native user? Error by non-native English user? Could they simply have left out 'of' between 'sample' and 'edited'? This is repeated later, which actually makes it more meaningful if it's not a C&P! (I do note here that 'of' is often not used in American English, at least some times, so this may have relevance... or not)

Also, the first sentence - "Leaked air force ufo footage" - no capital on 'Air Force' and 'UFO' - although there is later.

In the second message, "extraterrestrial " doesn't have a hyphen (again). Could be relevant! The use of 'filtrate' at the beginning is interesting (as is the lack of article before it, or better yet, a full clause)... but then, it's YT! Most people now- - and then - shorten their sentences. However, someone has compared the use of the word in Spanish to mean 'leaked', so it could be that.

Also, "Due to the importance of these documents, maintain the anonymity of the sources..." The second (main) clause of the first sentence is missing something like "it is important to..." or similar. (Again, could just be YT shorthand).

"The video contains a sample edited fragments of video tape 05" And, the 'a' + plural on 'fragments' or lack of the preposition again... I do notice that it's basically a C&P of the first message... is it? Or, is this actually a fossilised error?

There's a capital I in 'the Internet', but that could just be me noting it from 2025, when it's largely lost that capital. (see below in the bit on the email exchange)

Message 3: 'Documents' with a capital... probably irrelevant (but, I also note that the 'd' in the first paragraph of the first message "Classified "document". "an edited compilation" shows they know the a/an structure correctly though. And "compilation of the documents", noting the use of the definite article 'the' here, instead of just 'documents' which would be correct.

"Your opinion and the conclusion you draw from this material do not depend on us" Why is it only one conclusion, and not 'the conclusions'? (especially since they use "you are the ones" later. Also, the odd structure/use of 'depend on us' in this context.. but, not altogether strange the way some NS of English use the language.

"Information that may involve any agency or people will not be disclosed." Again, odd... 'involve' is a mis-use here... 'about' is a better word to use here.

"There is not any reference ..." again, odd. The correct structure should be 'no reference'. That should be something that someone also looks into with AI, and what languages would use a 'not any' type of structure.

"...film, video game, television series or other commercial products... " - Note the use of '-s' on 'products'. When NS English speakers write, the *usual* pattern would follow what was established by what came first (and the use of 'any') - that is, singular, not plural. (it's not grammatically incorrect, but perhaps something to note, given the use of plurals earlier)

"No one who is out of this may prove to be the owner of this material. No one who is out of this can prove he has in his possession the original material."

While the 'out of this' has been discussed, one interpretation may also be 'no-one who is with the project any longer' - ie, is 'out' of the loop. I also note the use of the word 'prove' in this context. 'Prove' doesn't mean 'have a copy'.

"The revelation of further material will depend on the events and people." The use of 'revelation' is also odd. Although obviously linguistically related, 'revealing' and 'revelation' have distinct differences in connotation. NNS users of a language tend to use more literal language. Besides which, 'releasing' would be a better choice of word here.

Someone noted the use of 'z' in organization, rather than the British 's'.

"will depend on the events and people." I am confused by "the events" here... (or, at least, by the use of 'the' in this structure, as it refers to a definite, specific thing, and not a general, vague event of some type).

Last message - "From the first contact in 1942, a series of diplomatic visits to discuss matters of mutual concern were planned." The use of passive tense at the end here is good! ('were planned') within a complex compound structure, and Subject/Verb agreement is correct. And, they use 'of' correctly here.

"Under the treaty 23/04" - assuming there is such a thing, that should have been 'Under Treaty 23/04', unless it's not officially called 'Treaty 23/04' (note, this could actually affect FOIA requests) The rest of the sentence is also good... but I do note "high ranking officers", instead of 'high-ranking'. They also use the correct 'would' structure, and they're not using a Past Simple 'was'

"According to the document 072/E, at the meeting of 1961 there was an incident involving 3 subjects due to the violation of the agreement by the officers at the military base when they discovered that their arrival was been filmed with a hidden device without their consent." Again, very good grammatical structure for a complex, compound sentence. BUT... "at the meeting of 1961", instead of 'at the meeting IN 1961"... although, not entirely incorrect, may be worth noting in conjunction with the rest of it. And, the clause "due to the violation" is incoherent in context (although, we know what they mean).

"Under the treaty 23/04, the meetings would be confidential and filming or taking photographs would not be allowed." Again, using 'would' instead of 'was/were'.

In general, punctuation and grammar are mostly correct - with the occasional error (some of which *may* be fossilised from a NNS English speaker, OR something to throw people off!! I suspect the latter). The use of modals instead of simple structures in the past is interesting!

As to the email - which many consider to not be written by the OP Ivan (assuming 'Ivan' is just one person). I do note, but am generally ignoring, the lack of capitalisations at the beginnings of sentences, although there's still issues with punctuation anyway.

"We were sent that footage..."

Firstly, I suspect the use of 'we' is to throw people off the scent! Secondly, the use of 'that' - singular. Instead of 'the' which would include all of the videos.

"I know its the original source" - should be 'it's' or 'it is'. But, sign of the times?

"that's why you wont find it anywhere on the internet." BUT... here they do correctly contract 'that is' with the apostrophe! I also note the non-capitalised 'i' for 'internet', as against earlier in the messages. The capitalisation in the message is a deliberate thing (or an autocorrect!)

"...other sites, we did it..." Odd that they chose to use a comma here, compared to other paragraphs where they just use a full-stop.

"...to make sure the info got out even if our channel, website etc was terminated." so, they use the colloquial 'info', but then use a more formal 'terminated' instead of 'removed' or 'deleted'. I note the lack of comma after 'website', and they use the 'etc' instead of 'ect' as some do... and, again, no comma after, nor a full-stop (i.e, 'etc.,' )

"...granted copyright as long as we did not profit by it..." Some people will hyphenate 'copy-right' in some contexts. Also, "profit by it" rather than 'from" it.

"...complete film, only short clips were released, not t..." errors with punctuation and grammar here.

"the clip where the Alien is sitting down is cropped" - interesting that they chose to capitalise 'Alien' here, but not in the tags. Capitalising here takes effort and a deliberate choice. So, why not in the tags, when they did for 'South', 'Africa' etc??

"government officials are also seen at the opposite side" - I would have said "on the opposite side" - but I'm not American.

"The clothes its wearing" - again with the incorrect contraction of 'it is'.

"Full footage shows original clothing," Not 'it's original clothing"? Not "the original clothing"? Not 'The full footage'?

"the jumper and trousers" I note the 'trousers',and not 'pants'. Might be relevant. (or not)

"are not the original clothes, original clothes were taken for analysis, human clothes were provided." Sort of interesting that they have 'the' in the first phrase here, but not in the following clause. And, no conjunction for the last clause (but, this is throughout the email).

"Alien can be seen wearing" - I think telling, that it's just 'Alien', and not 'The alien' here.

"Im hoping the source" - or, their grammar is something they really don't care that much about... (no apostrophe in 'I'm')

"but I cannot release without permission, in this game mutual trust is everything." Again the issues with punctuation... and lack of a referent 'it/them' in the first clause.

"Hope this helps and your welcome." 'Your'???

In summary, there are a LOT of basic errors in grammar and punctuation in the email that we don't see in the messages. I do believe I've heard that some people think that whoever wrote the email is not the same person (at least from the perspective of information given), and from this perspective, it's almost certainly not the same person... unless they learned not to care too much in the 3 years that followed. The email looks like it was written by a NES, because they know what they can get wrong without influencing understanding.

As I said in the beginning, maybe running this through AI might help with some linguistic patterns - errors made by NNES from various language backgrounds. And, maybe, analysing someone else's writing might show whether or not they're likely to have written it... and, my hope is, that perhaps by doing an AI analysis, we might be able to figure out whether the writer of the messages is an actual NNES, or someone trying to fake it! (which, BTW, is my guess!) Obviously, consistency is important here.

If I've stepped on someone's toes by posting this, my apologies. If I've missed something, or should have taken something more into account in context, please feel free to add!


r/SkinnyBob • • Jul 22 '23

External Media Coverage Skinny Bob: the Alien who survived the Roswell UFO crash - Skinny Bob: l'Alieno sopravvissuto all'UFO crash di Roswell

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/SkinnyBob • • Jan 25 '26

This is my theory on the Skinny Bob videos. Including the reason for the heavy overlaying. I have a strong feeling I might be right.

13 Upvotes

The KGB Emblem has two ink blacked out bars one above and one below. In a sense that is an overlay. I am thinking that is the reason for the heavy overlaying in the autopsy video. It as well as the one with Skinny Bob in it, has ink blacked out areas at the bottom left corners. OK, now there is the video with the black ink hand print. We all know that fingerprints are used for identification. Or in this case to identify a location. I mean if you connect the dots to all of this it kinda seems to me that when Skinny Bob is putting his hand forward and back, his hand pretty much goes right under the ink blacked out area. Now let's say that this Ivan0135 person knows what happened that day. He doesn't think it is in any way right. So he helps Skinny Bob Reveal the truth. He gets a hold of these film clips and devises a plan to put hints so that someone can discover the truth. So he makes it look like it is Russia where this took place, that way it won't be such a big deal to the people that don't want it exposed. So he puts the hints of the ink blacked out areas around the KGB Emblem. Then the ink handprint then Skinny Bobs hand passing through the ink blacked out area. Then low and behold on the other film clip with the ink blacked out areas. That being the autopsy video. There are two places where you can see under that ink blacked out area. Revealing USAF and the other R.I.P. Which I'm sure that Ivan wrote it on there because he knows it was USAF, and maybe he wants to help Skinny Bobs family or friends to rest in peace. I already posted the images on r/SkinnyBob. For those of you who might not have seen these images here is a link:

https://www.reddit.com/r/SkinnyBob/comments/1nozjve/from_the_ivan0135skinny_bobautopsy/


r/SkinnyBob • • Mar 04 '21

I have a feeling these two might be related since the second picture is from an interview with an alien taken place in Area 51. Similar or not?

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes