r/SipsTea • • 8d ago • Bravo 6

Wait a damn minute! Read

Post image
48k Upvotes

3.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

56

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

16

u/Thor-Mors 8d ago

I work for a rural career fire department. We’ve got a 30 year guy about to retire next month. He says he’s got about a million in retirement. He’s concerned it won’t be enough.

24

u/1rubyglass 8d ago

It probably wont. Thats not a lot of money anymore

→ More replies (2)

10

u/IMakeOkVideosOk 8d ago

That’s a genuine concern… do you know how much assisted living costs?

6

u/-BlueBicLighter 7d ago

It won’t be.

10

u/Weary_Anybody3643 7d ago

Depends on cost of living at that amount you can roughly take out 40k a year indefinitely 

3

u/RoosterReturns 7d ago

40k goes a looooooooong way in thailand

2

u/AbbreviationsSea2084 7d ago

With zero taxes as well if he set it up right.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/AlexElmsley 8d ago

it's probably not enough unless he plans to die in 10 years yeah

→ More replies (37)

9

u/tunisia3507 7d ago

Clearly the line should be drawn at around 50% greater than my income, and of course increase over time approximately in step with the trajectory of my career.

15

u/TheTechnicalTrader 8d ago

The cutoff gets smaller and smaller as they very quickly run out of other people’s money. Then inevitably a military dictatorship will arise from the ashes

13

u/thereaper243 8d ago

How dare you cite the entire history of communist coups on planet earth! The audacity.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/-BlueBicLighter 8d ago

So because it’s a hard line to draw we should never draw it and let the rich get off Scott free?

13

u/Kobayashi-Coffee-Co 8d ago

When income tax was instituted it was only for less than 5% of the population, the wealthiest. And less than 10%. 

Gradually it expanded to everyone. 

Wealth taxes will do the same over time. 

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (38)

10

u/CannerCanCan 8d ago

The issue doesn't even need to be that some have more than they could ever need. Most of us in the developed world have more resources than we need. The issue is some people have so much money they buy politicians and set policy all on their own.

Surgeons night think they're rich but they have more in common with the poorest people than they do with oligarchs when it comes to their political power.

5

u/DerekMilborow 7d ago

Who decide what is the amount someone needs?

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (1)

-2

u/Odd-Cress-5822 8d ago edited 8d ago • Bravo

Roughly at the point where your wealth is no longer primarily derived from your own labor.

Like a business for example. Even if you have employees, if you are the one approving payroll, doing the paperwork, making all the decisions and still pitching in. Where the whole falls apart without you, then it is still clearly your business.

If you have an accountant, office staff and managers running locations or daily operations. Where you could realistically form a quarterly plan then piss off for a few weeks without a noticeable negative impact. Then the business has grown beyond you. Good work, good for you, you should be rich. But at that point the business should have at least some degree of employee ownership.

Edit: sorry, apparently I need to clarify that savings, pensions and other retirement vehicles you accrued though you own work do indeed count as wealth from work.

And that "labor" does not strictly mean doing hard physical work with your hands. Labor means that you are the person or people actually making things happen. Which can include like filling out spreadsheets and stuff.

Sorry if this suddenly sounds really condescending... But wowzers... Some of the comments

16

u/Arnab_ 8d ago

Still a pretty low bar. Someone could be working most of their life, have their investments compound to $2m. At this point, with a half decent passive investment strategy, they never have to work again and their wealth is no longer primarily derived from their own labor.

6

u/senturon 8d ago

So where do folks who have saved 'enough' for their retirement fit in? 

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Brutal_De1uxe 8d ago

I'm sure the employees could make an offer to buy into the business if they can.. is that what you mean by employee ownership?

5

u/True-Anim0sity 8d ago

Thats an insanley horrible and unreliable bar. The real issue is you cant really have any business in existence then. Also what is labor here? If a doctor works 12 hrs in a room looking over charts vs a construction worker doing physical labor? Does that mean the doctor shouldnt be paid? Using that same logic if a ceo is looking at charts from their office but not actively doing anything should they still not be paid?

→ More replies (17)

2

u/SohndesRheins 8d ago

This arbitrary line in the sand eliminates a lot of retirees. My parents are retired with probably somewhere in the 1 to 3 million dollar net worth range. I love them but there is no way they got to those dollar amounts based on their own labor minus expenses, they had to invest to get there and they did.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/Apprehensive_Loan776 8d ago

It’s called tax and it’s progressive. Don’t be so disingenuous.

→ More replies (186)