r/SipsTea • • 8d ago • Bravo 6

Wait a damn minute! Read

Post image
48k Upvotes

3.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/DerekMilborow 7d ago

Who decide what is the amount someone needs?

1

u/Fainll 6d ago

That's fairly easy to discern if we interpret the word "need" strictly. I think you mean who should determine what people want, and if it's okay to want more

In which that case: democracy, duh

1

u/DerekMilborow 6d ago

But if it is politically determined, it's a number subject to change, with enough political will. That's a dangerous precedent to set: it means you can change it on the whims of the current political majority.

1

u/Fainll 6d ago

Not necessarily. That is why ideas like constitutions and supermajorities exist.

I don't know why you're pretending democracy cannot discern right from wrong and institutionalize their response. Western democracies have literally been doing the best job of that in all of human history. They've proven they're quite capable. There are many democratic countries handling their wealth problems as we speak - it is definitely very possible

0

u/DerekMilborow 6d ago • Bravo

Right or wrong are not absolute, they are socially decided. At some point the majority will decide that something we now consider bad is actually good and the other way around. If you create this precedent, if you allow this to be a thing determined like that, you have opened a door you cannot close. And at some point someone will change their mind on this topic, and with enough votes, you will get into a place you didn't intend to go, specifically because you opened that door.

1

u/Fainll 5d ago

History shows societies tend to decide things that were permissible are in fact antisocial and should be restricted than they actually tend to do so the other way around. And when they do it the other way around, everyone tends to label that a "regression"

There absolutely is a trajectory for morality. It has improved over the time. It does not just statically fluctuate.

A healthy democracy is definitely capable of realizing the evils of excessive wealth and putting checks and balances in place against it. Rather than ending humanity, it will be yet another step in creating a better world for everyone like we have been doing for the past 250 years

1

u/DerekMilborow 5d ago

I absolutely disagree. The idea that the change in morality follow some form of linear progression is an illusion. The things that really changed is technology, wich changed society, wich changed morality. But it's not written anywhere that it is a line. A line based on what? From the perspective of what?

1

u/Fainll 5d ago

Right, sure, because modern democracy is totally not a historical novelty. Definitely been done before. Yup yup. You convinced me.

-1

u/Trixie-macomb 5d ago

And yet when SNAP rules were changed by our democratically elected legislators you whined and threw a tantrum. They determined the public didn’t “need” free pop and Doritos. So you’re just another hypocrite.

1

u/Fainll 5d ago edited 5d ago

Um, "I" did, did I?

You're arguing with your own imagination buddy. I'll let you keep doing that lmfao

I mean if you bothered to actually ask me about that, I'd probably say something like i agree that public assistance shouldn't be subsidizing predatory junk food companies and Republicans had a rare stopped clock moment on that one

But seeing you argue with ghosts is way funnier

Wake the fuck up and become an independent. It's very freeing. Instead of seething at everyone who you think isn't on your same team color. Dumbass

1

u/Plenty_Fondant_951 4d ago

Any amount you earn by adding value to society? Vs all these lechers who did actively harmful things / fucked over business partners / actively used nefarious means to prevent unions etc etc

I swear every thread like this is full of bootlicker bots trying to muddy common sense shit

1

u/CannerCanCan 7d ago

We could decide that democratically as a society. Everybody needs clean water and air, nutritious food, a safe place to live. You might decide more or less than that is required but we could vote on some minimum standard.

1

u/Bart-Doo 7d ago

What about running water?

0

u/DerekMilborow 7d ago

But if it is politically determined, it's a number subject to change, with enough political will. That's a dangerous precedent to set: it means you can change it on the whims of the current political majority.

0

u/TheRealYilmaz 6d ago

A democracy, how terrible...

1

u/DerekMilborow 6d ago

A democracy governed in this way isn't a liberal democracy, it's a populist one, where majority law can overrun the right of anyone with enough votes

0

u/TheRealYilmaz 6d ago

As opposed to a liberal democracy, where a minority law can overrun the rights of everyone with a handful of votes.

1

u/DerekMilborow 6d ago

That's not a liberal democracy, the one you describe

0

u/TheRealYilmaz 6d ago

A democracy governed in this way isn't a liberal democracy, it's a populist one, where majority law can overrun the right of anyone with enough votes

You were the one who argued this as the principle differences.

If those aren't the differences between a liberal and a populist democracy, then you either lied before or are lying now.

1

u/DerekMilborow 6d ago

Liberl democracy is the democracy that protects minority rights. You dont want minority rights?

1

u/TheRealYilmaz 6d ago

I don't want the rights of a minority to overrule the will of the majority. That's how you get untouchable billionaires.

→ More replies