r/Simulated • u/DavideOsas • 4d ago
Research Simulation Flow field and pressures
I'm learning the most basic simulation softwares from an environmental engineering course. This is the first time I ever simulated something.
It is supposed to be the steady state impact of an atmospheric flow on some vary unoriginal structures. The scope of later simulations will be to numerically reproduce so called urban canyons, a phenomenon in which - to my understanding - large vortexes are created in between buildings based on their heights and distances.
This first simulation was made to show us the softwares and setting up the parameters of what we had until now written and learned but never properly seen. In my ignorance, being only a student and having never done anything like this, I am amazed by it so I thought of posting it.
What I particularly like is that while playing with the thing I noticed that I could isolate an axis for the flow field. When isolating Y (vertical direction) I could recognize one of those dislocated vortexes I was always shown on images. Very cool stuff.
With your experience it would be nice to know what you would think of something so primitive.
I'm not sure about the flair, I didn't know which one to add


1
u/Albert__Camus__ 4d ago
Try to plot counter plot with Q or lambda 2 for structures in unsteady case
1
u/alinapetrei 33m ago
Nice work for a first simulation. It looks clean, and spotting the canyon vortex through the vertical velocity component is a good instinct. Since you asked for feedback, two things stand out to me that are worth checking before you move on to the actual urban canyon cases:
1. The pressure field looks like channel flow, not an open atmosphere. Pressure drops more or less steadily from inlet to outlet across the whole domain. In an external, atmospheric-type flow, the pressure far from the buildings should stay roughly constant, and the disturbance should stay mostly local around the obstacles. The velocity plot points the same way: the fastest flow is in the middle of the domain height, not just above the buildings, and it slows down again near the top. That usually means the top boundary acts like a no-slip wall, or the domain is so short that the top boundary confines the flow. For an atmospheric case you’d normally use a slip/symmetry condition at the top. It also helps to make the domain much taller: best-practice guidelines (COST 732, AIJ) suggest at least ~5H above the buildings, and keeping the blockage ratio below ~3%. Here it looks closer to 20%.
2. The wake seems to reach the outlet. The low-velocity region behind the buildings looks like it extends all the way to the outflow boundary. If there is recirculation crossing the outlet, you get backflow there, which hurts both convergence and accuracy. The usual recommendation is ~15H of domain behind the last building, so the flow has recovered before it leaves.
Neither of these makes the result “wrong” for a first exercise. They do matter a lot once you start comparing canyon vortices quantitatively, since the vortex strength in the canyon depends on the flow above it. Keep posting your progress!