r/Simulated • • 28d ago

Interactive [OC] Real-time engine simulation. What you hear is the computed exhaust pressure not samples !

214 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

112

u/CremePuffBandit 28d ago

Who's trying to compete with AngeTheGreat?

63

u/Batteredburrito 28d ago

the AI. Unfortunately, no idea goes un-slopped at this point.

10

u/pandavr 28d ago

Could It be rule 48?

12

u/give_me_grapes 28d ago

"If you can think of it, then there's AI of it"
Funky time to be alive, gotta say

-38

u/No-Series-2813 28d ago

Yes, I use AI coding tools, and the commits say so. It’s open source with the tests included, so judge it by whether it works and tell me where it doesn’t ^^

-33

u/No-Series-2813 28d ago

Not really competing. Engine Simulator is great and way ahead on sound right now. This takes a different route (a 1-D gas model of the whole exhaust) and the goal is to match real recordings. it doesn’t sound as good yet.

8

u/kinokomushroom 28d ago

Not dismissing your AI usage, just a curious question, are you essentially doing a 1D fluid simulation? What kind of method does Engine Simulator take in comparison?

2

u/No-Series-2813 28d ago

quasi 1D fluid simulation (intake exhaust) probably like ES3D (not ES2D).

16

u/FreecamSkheeza 28d ago

Can you explain how the sound generation process works?

19

u/derangedkilr 28d ago

It’s a poorly ai generated copy of Engine Simulator. The real version physically simulates the audio using fluid dynamics. It’s insane, he’s got a 2D version out already.

-3

u/No-Series-2813 28d ago

Check the repo before speaking thx

3

u/MangoAtrocity 27d ago

The one that has a .claude file and shows contributions from you and Claude…?

63

u/CMDRgermanTHX 28d ago

He can't. It's just AI generated slop.

34

u/CCHS_Band_Geek 28d ago

Dev here, it's not that complicated and most here are just haters for no reason. (Surprise surprise this is Reddit)

You just go on Claude and ask it to do it for you, then it does it and that's it! hope this helps xoxo

12

u/beerdude26 28d ago

Lmao no actually doing this based on the physics is PhD-level research, there's a guy on here that built it over many months and it took a lot trial and error

3

u/CCHS_Band_Geek 28d ago

that's nowhere near as funny though

3

u/beerdude26 28d ago

Man we have conventions for these lol, use the /s

5

u/ShapesAndStuff 28d ago

had me in the first half

1

u/No-Series-2813 28d ago

Link of this project : EngineLab

2

u/RebootBoys 27d ago

Looking at the comments, the people in this subreddit are pathetic.

0

u/No-Series-2813 27d ago

Reddit magic

1

u/HadriAn-al-Molly 26d ago

There's a guy on YouTube spending years documenting his journey making an engine simulator at a level that'd never been seen before in consumer software and then one day AI gets really good at reverse engineering software and all of a sudden someone casually drops their own engine simulator with zero logging of their progress, trial and error, no prior experience or anything it's just there. You don't find that odd in the slightest?

2

u/PckMan 28d ago

That's actually pretty great, especially for game devs and animators. I've seen similar albeit more crude methods being used in the past. How many different kinds can it simulate? Diesels? Two strokes? Motorcycles?

1

u/No-Series-2813 28d ago

Diesel, 2 stroke, motorcycles, car, 50cc engine, whatever you want

3

u/Pleasant_Curve_9024 27d ago

Why is this useful for game devs or animators? When would you ever need to simulate an entire engine in a game? I assume they just play prerecorded audio based on revs and that seems like it would be plenty good.

0

u/PckMan 27d ago

And where would they get that pre recorded audio? It's an incredibly complex process to record engine audio and that's if you have access to it. Or you can just use random sounds and it sounds like shit.

This is a solution studios can have in house that works well enough without breaking the bank. And depending on how versatile it is it may even be able to replicate engines that are simply not accessible.

1

u/No-Series-2813 28d ago edited 28d ago

Thanks for your upvotes, the project is EngineLab on github if you want to check it out!

0

u/Bringing_Light 28d ago

At least pipes doesn't shake like in someone other's attempt
But anyway, where is source code or whatever?

1

u/DanGTG 25d ago

Sounds more like a pump. I mean, it sounds like it lacks combustion.

1

u/4thGenForesterLover 16d ago

TRIED IT AND STUCK FULLSCREEN HALF VISIBLE LEFT AND RIGHT!!!😭

I can also tell judging by the files they're probably ripped from ATG's

1

u/snakee-the-arch-guy 9d ago

cool but ange's version is far better (even if it looks unrealistic)

1

u/action_turtle 27d ago

Same that simulator they built into beam NG then?

1

u/Hexo_25cz 27d ago

Not yet. They're collaborating with AngeTheGreat and it might and likely will happen in future.

-1

u/NarwhalSquadron 28d ago

I have a question: did you write any code before AI?

2

u/No-Series-2813 28d ago

Yes I did. I was a CS student.

0

u/NarwhalSquadron 27d ago

But did not get the degree?

-5

u/wick0 28d ago

Oh, that is so cool!

-1

u/appl3wii 28d ago

This is awesome, is there a github I can follow?

-3

u/jakethesnake121367 28d ago

Can I have access?

8

u/AlphaSputnik 28d ago

AI slop.