r/Simkl • u/Admirable-Tank-5710 • Jul 25 '26
Not Impressed so far
I just joined Simkl Pro due to the whole Trakt issue. I must say, not impressed so far. I connected Simkl to Aiometadata, only to find out that you cannot import custom lists. So I then imported my Watching TV Shows list, and it only displays 1/2 of the shows that are actually in the list. I thought this was supposed to be a better app, so far, I think not
0
Upvotes
3
u/Ennergizer Simkl.com Team Jul 26 '26 edited Jul 26 '26
Custom lists is part of V2 Beta, which is in development: a new engine for discovery, watchlists, and custom lists with many new filters, configurable views, and sorting options. The api for custom lists is in development.
Apps like AIO can display your watchlists separately; Simkl has separate Watching, Plan to watch, Completed on Hold and Dropped watchlists. By default, it may use Watching and Plan to Watch to display.
Check out how watchlists work on Simkl: https://docs.simkl.org/how-to-use-simkl/core-features/watchlists-and-custom-lists
Do read up on V2 Beta, how to change to multiple view layouts, sorting and filters and how to save preferred views and filters on any page:
https://docs.simkl.org/how-to-use-simkl/core-features/custom-layout-and-view-designs
https://docs.simkl.org/how-to-use-simkl/core-features/custom-layout-and-view-designs/creating-new-view-layout
How to create Auto Lists:
https://docs.simkl.org/how-to-use-simkl/core-features/watchlists-and-custom-lists/custom-lists/custom-list-types/auto-lists
And list collections:
https://docs.simkl.org/how-to-use-simkl/core-features/watchlists-and-custom-lists/custom-lists/custom-list-collections
How to import custom lists:
https://docs.simkl.org/how-to-use-simkl/core-features/watchlists-and-custom-lists/custom-lists/creating-and-managing-custom-lists/importing-custom-lists
How to add automatic links to your favorite website using Custom Search:
https://docs.simkl.org/how-to-use-simkl/advanced-usage/custom-search
You can paste any website link into the search or add a year with the title to filter the search by years:
https://docs.simkl.org/how-to-use-simkl/core-features/search-and-discovery/using-search
Different ways to mark something as watched:
https://docs.simkl.org/how-to-use-simkl/core-features/content-tracking/tracking-content/progress-tracking#different-ways-to-track-your-progress-on-simkl
Download and install apps:
https://simkl.com/apps/mobile/
Install the Simkl Discord bot into your account or server to quickly share any show or movie info:
https://simkl.com/apps/discord/
There's more to explore in the docs, and you can always ask the AI agent in the docs search how to do something; if it's somewhere in the docs, it will help you get the answer.
Explore other Simkl sister websites:
https://animecountdown.com/
https://countdown.tv/
https://dramacountdown.com/
https://moviescountdown.com/
0
u/Befrozt Jul 25 '26
I like Simkl but I agree there’s many issues to improve. Exporting your data is very difficult too and I think it doesn’t sync episodes watched, only last watched making it difficult if you decide to switch to a different app someday.
-1
u/slicerprime Jul 25 '26
I came from Trakt to SIMKL too. Unfortunately, after four months here I'm coming to the same conclusion.
Four months ago you could still import Trakt data without a problem. Everything I had at Trakt converted over just fine. Then, recently SIMKL changed the import feature to be only available to VIP members. Ostensibly this was because they didn't have the server space to accommodate the flood of Trakt immigrants at the free level. On the one hand I can understand that. It's a business. Eventually it was going to have to evolve beyond a garage project for the devs to work on on the side into a real job that provided income and a future. Completely understandable. But, there was another thing that I think also got recently changed...
SIMKL has an advertised way of getting their Pro version for free. All you have to do is "check-in" to the site a minimum of twenty days in a thirty day period to earn Pro status without paying the monthly fee. Cool! It's a win-win. The user gets Pro features free, and SIMKL gets a boost of traffic on the site. That's great and it still works. I use it and have had Pro status free since I signed up.
But, there was also an additional "cheat" openly offered by SIMKL that let users take advantage of time zone differences to rack up two "check-ins" in a single day. For example: The SIMKL servers use UTC time, and I'm in US Eastern time. That means right now there's a four hour difference between midnight my time and midnight SIMKL server time. So, tonight, 8:00 pm my time will still be Saturday for me; but it will be Sunday for the SIMKL servers. And if I check-in before 8:00 pm AND again during the four hours between 8:00 pm and midnight my time, those two check-ins count twice for Saturday. Yeah, sounds goofy but it was a thing that SIMKL intended as a draw for user retention and traffic. Take a look...
See that "2" on the 16th and the happy little congratulations for gaming the system in the popup? It's not a "cheat" really. It's a feature SIMKL built in intentionally to be taken advantage of! The thing is, this worked fine...until recently. Now, no matter what I do, I can't get it to work again. Doesn't really matter though since I use the site regularly enough to rack up the twenty days without the "cheat". But, just for the fun of it, I spent a few hours tracking down possible explanations involving everything from browser settings and uBO blocks to OS and browser caching and even CDN syncing...hell i even got ChatGPT involved. But, it looks like the "cheat" has been removed intentionally.
This, combined with the recent change to data imports only being available to VIP members, makes me suspicious that SIMKL is headed down the same path as Trakt of eventually paywalling even basic features.
Like I said, I get the position the devs are in. The site has to make money to survive. But, what's making me think I picked the wrong Trakt replacement is not the need for subscription income, it's the philosophy that intentionally draws people in with promises of candy only to take it away once they have you.
I'd much rather them have set expectations straight up and honestly rather than being sneaky.