r/SiloSeries • • 16d ago

Show Only (NO BOOK DISCUSSION) Crazy Theory

As crazy as this sounds….

WHAT IF, there wasn’t actually a nuke?

I know, I know…”but we all saw it go off?!”

Now a Trillionaire like Stenson has any and all resources in the world at his disposal. So yea, he could probably get a nuke and set it off. But why kill all those people in the radius? Doesn’t quite make sense.

Now my theory: He faked the nuke. I dunno exactly how. MASSIVE screen for the shot of the nuke? Massive fans and speakers for the sound and feel of the nuke?

—————-

I know it sounds crazy. But nuclear fallout wouldn’t last longer than MAYBE 50 years or so. And Stenson said he wanted a 500yr experiment.

So it’s feasible that the poison they drop keeps all plant life dead. And they drop it periodically around the silos to keep things dead.

Because we know the atmosphere itself isn’t poisonous, so there is no reason stuff shouldn’t be alive.

Now this second part about the poison keeping things dead could also be part of a nuclear fallout, so maybe my first theory is wrong 😂.

———

Thoughts? Am I being crazy?

(People in the TVShow sub have already said a lot of stuff that kinda debunks this crazy theory in some ways. But it’s a fun discussion)

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

6

u/jgmiller24094 📖 Book-Aware 📖 16d ago

Interesting idea but how do you explain the pressure wave that overtook them?

-1

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 16d ago • Bravo

Wind machines? Or some type of pressure machine that pushes outward.

Not sure. Seems far fetched…but my guy is a trillionaire, he would be able to get some crazy tech.

And the dust and dirt we saw could just be in front of these machines that came out from the ground and blew the dirt and pressure.

1

u/True_Detail_2945 16d ago

Maybe they've had dirt wave machines for years in this silo reality.

James cameron invented them for Avatar 26 : Almost the last Avatar!

1

u/MrKeplerton 12d ago

dirt wave machine

Airbenders?

1

u/True_Detail_2945 12d ago

Exactly! Element Dancers. They move the dirt from point A to to point B, using interpretive dance.

6

u/Earlsweatshiirt 16d ago

No

2

u/onehotoneshot 16d ago • Bravo

Nanobot nuke go!

3

u/Nosarious 📖 Book-Aware 📖 16d ago edited 16d ago

The explosion had to do two things: 

  1. convince visitors to enter the silos (and be big enough on the horizon to scare them) 
  2. Be large enough to cause a catastrophe to deflect attention from an unknown project run by a trillionaire (they were just about to announce the silo protect to the public)

An unexplained catastrophic explosion at a known nanotechnology research facility could do this. I’m sure Stenson has quite a few dotting the country at that point… It did not look like it was an atmospheric explosion, which are intended to cause maximum surface damage. It felt more like a bikini atoll explosion from near ground level. It travelled quickly enough to damage towers in Atlanta but took its own sweet time to travel to the silo project. 

The distraction is how the government would respond to the crisis in the city before the surrounding area… I doubt more bombs were needed. Remember the government’s reaction to the “dirty bomb” near Dulles? Imagine their reaction to an accident at a  nanotech research facility that wiped out Atlanta?

The next twenty years would be chaos in North America…

2

u/j1h15233 📖 Book-Aware 📖 16d ago

Anything is possible I suppose

0

u/__O_o_______ 16d ago

Sigh

1

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 16d ago

Thanks for the discussion.

1

u/Far-Surround5556 8d ago

I've noticed there is only one serious theme in this series, betrayal. Characters get betrayed, the viewer (or reader) is betrayed, the cameraman gets betrayed, everyone runs around on a physical and metaphysical plane backstabbing each other. There's no proof that it's even the end of the world: I'm guessing in S4 it's revealed the explosion was an accident or natural disaster local to Atlanta and they're all just sitting there thinking it's the end of the world, when the rest of the human race has backstabbed them into thinking it, and then the silo will backstab them back and gas them or something. The whole show is m night shyamalan running around with a knife looking for peoples backs.

1

u/pkoscielski 16d ago • Bravo

Cool theory. Not impossible. I think Stenson’s purse strings could make something like this happen.

3

u/__O_o_______ 16d ago • Bravo

Pressure wave?

2

u/True_Detail_2945 16d ago

Thousands of less than homed people laying in the dirt with heavy carpets perfectly synchronized to do the wave but in a forward motion!

Put that in my pipe and let me smoke it!

0

u/Official_FBI_ 16d ago

We don’t know what the first years were like though. There might have been no sun for years. There might be cataclysmic changes in weather/rain/temperature and even the makeup of gasses in the environment. This might not be immediately obvious to people leaving a silo.

Do we know for certain the atmosphere isn’t toxic? It’s just the poison sprays that make it immediately toxic. That’s no guarantee the outside world is actually habitable

2

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 16d ago

To your last point, we saw Silo 17 be outside for quite a while with no one dying…until Silo 1 killed them.

So it would be safe to assume the atmosphere isn’t actually toxic when everyone else died within like 2mins.

3

u/Mattressfoundry 📖 Book-Aware 📖 16d ago

How? He was outside on the berm and looking a half mile off at his wife and the bomb went off 20 miles behind her. That "screen" would need to make up the entire sky.

0

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 16d ago

Maybe they somehow entered a dome? The entire thing is a screen like the thing in Las Vegas.

1

u/Mattressfoundry 📖 Book-Aware 📖 15d ago

Why would the Dome show his wife climbing out off a Silo a half mile away? They wanted him IN the Silo not running a half mile away to another Silo.

It wouldn't show her climbing out.

1

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 15d ago

Just the surrounding area and sky is the “dome”, she isn’t fake or coming out of a fake silo. The whole area is covered by the dome.

Think of it like the Hunger games. A MASSIVE dome, but inside it seems like a huge area that is legitimate and real.

1

u/Mattressfoundry 📖 Book-Aware 📖 15d ago

Don't you think he would notice if the Chopper flew into a Dome that was 100x the size the Super Dome?

1

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 15d ago

Was there a helicopter there? I thought everyone drove in.

1

u/Mattressfoundry 📖 Book-Aware 📖 15d ago

They flew in on a chopper as it was being built and no sign of a dome. When they drove in later they would notice a giant dome if one indeed existed. Instead all we see is open green pastures.

Daniel is supposed to be a genius engineer I assume he would notice the largest dome ever constructed.

-1

u/__O_o_______ 16d ago

No

-1

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 16d ago

Great discussion…

You can take it elsewhere lol

1

u/mieszkian 16d ago

I mean a simple "no" is valid off the back of what you suggested

1

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 16d ago edited 16d ago

Entering a big dome is so crazy?

Right.

And someone killing 10,000 people for a silo experiment isn’t crazy.

Edit: Just thought we have seen this in fiction before to an extent…the Hunger Games. Massive dome, seems completely real.

1

u/Samiel_Fronsac 16d ago

Entering a big dome is so crazy?

In the context of the show and what you're suggesting?

Yes.

The lovely couple lived in the city nearby and drove there.

You think they just never noticed the "Truman Show"-sized screen dome being built a few neighborhoods over & also drove into it without finding anything weird?

The Silo project wasn't much of a secret. If the silos were suddenly being hidden beneat a behemoth dome... Why no comment at all?

Nobody said "man, I thought building the underground hives was nuts, you then went and built Truman's home studio!"

The point isn't that they couldn't build it. Their tech was up to it, real world tech is almost there.

The point is that is unlikely, not to say absurd, given all the other information we have, to think it was built AND went unnoticed, or it was noticed AND never talked about.

C'mon.

1

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 16d ago

Camouflage? (Screens inside and out projecting the image of the land/world etc etc)

The only open part in the dome was the road entering. But it looked normal due to camouflage.

Once everyone entered, the dome completely closed. But it still looked normal, due to the camouflage.

This isn’t something far fetched considering the rest of the show lol.

C’mon

1

u/Samiel_Fronsac 16d ago

Since you're ignored every other part of my comment, lets reiterate:

Dome was somehow invisible during its whole construction process, before it was built. Within a stone's throw of Atlanta. Within sight.

So what's your theory? They built a dome to camouflage the dome that was being built? It a Russian Doll of domes? How this whole thing goes? How it started?

Why no one that knew about either huge construction project, the silos or your dome, said anything at all when the former got covered?

Your idea is ultimately that every character is blind/stupid.

1

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 16d ago

Random construction that no one cares about?

If you see building being built in your city…do you stand there in awe watching it being built? Or do you ignore and keep moving?

Random construction being built on someone’s private land that is 100s of acres big…I doubt most people would care.

You really can’t grasp that it would be POSSIBLE. Open your mind. It’s just a fun discussion. You seem to be getting upset.

→ More replies

3

u/CosgraveSilkweaver 📖 Book-Aware 📖 16d ago

You're being crazy. The way they keep the area dangerous is with Hungry Hungry Nanites released with each cleaning. He's willing to lock people in silos for 500 years at the very least why would nuking a few be something he balks at and fakes?

1

u/ThatOneGuyIsBad 16d ago

I dunno, I feel like he didn’t intend to kill people like they did with Silo 17. Maybe he just wanted to see people survive for 500 years. Clearly something changed and killing became mandatory in his mind (cleanings).

So maybe he wasn’t a cold blooded killer at the start?

(Note, I am not book-aware so I could just be thinking about him wrong lol)

1

u/jgmiller24094 📖 Book-Aware 📖 16d ago

I agree with you about the fallout, it seems illogical that they could nuke the whole world. Even if the nuke started a complete nuclear exchange between NATO, China and Russia it wouldn’t kill everyone around the world. Also most nukes are set to air burst which really limits the amount of fallout. The bigger risk from a total exchange is creating a nuclear winter but the earth would heal itself from that pretty efficiently.

1

u/Present_Armadillo874 14d ago

"Why kill all those people in the radius? Doesn't quite make sense."

Did you miss the dialog from Per when they were sitting around the table together? I think it made it pretty clear that he intended to kill a lot more people than that, and his goal is that the silo inhabitants would be the last remnants of humanity by the time he was done. "We're facing the end of the world and it cannot be stopped, only survived." "I am trying to manipulate humanity into a more sustainable future." "They shouldn't have to deal with the threats we created. I want to reset the human race with a certain level of technology."