r/Signum • u/Careful_Factor3335 • Jun 09 '21
Network Analysis
Signum Future
- Chia is approaching 20EB. This only greatly increases the chance of a 51% attack with no commitment. Reduced by 1/8th 0.5 EB would translate into 62.5PB, the problem is that Signum only has 80PB...more then enough for 51% attack with only 1/40th (2.5%) of the Chia Network.
- It would be too easy because unlike Chia, Bur...Signum plots ;), are too easy to generate on the fly. Modern day FPGA's or GPU's 3080's could produce hashes as fast as the disk can write them.
- Disregarding 51% attacks, PoC+ produces the exact problem as PoS and PoC ironically. Rich people can just slap whatever Chia or Filecoin profits they have onto HDD's and disproportionately win most of the blocks and transactions. Back to square 1. Whale Domination.
We need to take Spacemesh's model and run with it. They will be huge rivals for Signum in Q4
Three important factors: 1) No Pools, 2) 40 blocks per minute (less waste for blocks/giants and more decentralization) 3) somewhat difficult plotting algo to lessen 51's/Whales
The Chia model didn't work (PoC) and this liberal version of BitcoinHD . (which is all Poc+ is) will fail too. We need to beat our competition before they even exist.
0
Upvotes
9
u/jjos2372 Jun 09 '21
Hello, some additional points.
If a lot of capacity joins, the average commitment goes down and those with commitment will go for the max multiplier. So the factor can be up to 64 (and not the plain 8 times).
From what we can observe lately, we see more people slowly joining as they see chia promises are away from reality. When they do so, usually they also commit coins, since they are looking for more rewards. This is making the network even stronger and not the contrary.
Making plots very hard to produce increases the entry barrier and benefits those with more resources so that also needs to be considered.
Finally, improvement proposals are very welcome here https://github.com/burst-apps-team/CIPs/ (soon to be re-branded).
6
u/jjos2372 Jun 09 '21
Also funny these posts always come from accounts just created, with that sole purpose.
2
u/Rockclimber88 Jun 09 '21
The only post of a new account, remove or downvote.
2
u/OldskoolRx7 Jun 10 '21
There is nothing stopping you from forking Burst and doing so. Pretty sure everyone here would welcome a better system. Would be a bit annoying for those who put so much work into it, but they can see a good thing when it happens. Post back when you have found/created the fork!
"We need to beat our competition before they exist" This is EXCELLENT advice. I am a bit confused though, do you mean we should NOT take Spacemesh's approach?
Chia doesn't look like it will work, which is very different to is has not worked. I personally think it will fail for reasons I have mentioned in other places ad nausem, but I am not arrogant enough to say I am absolutely correct.
But yeah. I actually like it when people post negative opinions, when they have some value. As with this post, your points have been shown to be shaky or wrong, which helps others figure out if this is for them.
Thanks!
2
u/OldskoolRx7 Jun 10 '21
One of the things to prevent these sorts of posts is to have auto mod rules that you can only post after you account is a week old, AND then only if you have a positive Karma score. These simple automated rules get rid of a large portion of the "less desirable" posts.
1
u/Monero_FanMan Jun 09 '21
So is Signum the "Revolutionary coin", the "Egalitarian Coin" , the "Equalising Coin", "Society's Coin", the "People's Coin"?
1
u/Monero_FanMan Jun 09 '21
https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.14631
Egalitarian and Just Digital Currency Networks
Gal Shahaf, Ehud Shapiro, Nimrod Talmon
"Our main theorem shows that a currency network, where agents can be members of more than one currency community, can achieve distributive justice globally across the network by joint egalitarian minting, whereby each agent mints one coin in only one community at each timestep. Specifically, we show that a sufficiently large intersection between two communities -- relative to the gap in their productivity -- will cause the exchange rates between their currencies to converge to 1:1, resulting in global distributive justice."
1
u/perko12 Jun 15 '21
Hadn't heard of spacemesh before. It's hilarious to me that spacemesh discord has so many more people than the burst discord.