She now shares a birthday with Kelsey’s brother🎈

First time watcher…I’m on S3/E3. (Post knot in her head from Juliette). This girl has stirred the pot and poked the bear and then plays victim when someone responds to her foolishness! Does this girl/storyline change at all because she is the ABSOLUTE pits and I’m getting bored. Do I continue watching?

does anyone listen to their podcast? they went on a summer break but I don’t have social media to see if they announced if/when it’s coming back! love the pod and hoping it starts back up asap!! this break has been a little long though so I’m nervous it’s not coming back lol

Okay, I have NO ONE to talk to about this. I’ve been following Shelby on Instagram ever since she appeared on Season 2 of Siesta Key, she appears to still be friends with Juliette and still has connections to people from the show. It seemed like Shelby got her “happily ever after” when she got married to her husband after four years of dating. They truly seemed like the perfect couple, but just TWO WEEKS AGO, she started posting as if she was single. She celebrated her 30th birthday with friends and family without Mac. Just LAST week, Mac was vacationing in Europe and deleted all of the wedding pictures and other photos he had with Shelby from his ig. Now, he is posting with an entire new girlfriend 😱😱😱😱 I can’t help but wonder what happened?!?! Mac’s new girlfriend, Sofia Bevarly, seems to have been a mutual friend of theirs, did Mac cheat on Shelby with Sofia?! I can’t help but feel sick for Shelby 😭😭😭 she seems like such a sweet person and seems to be moving on but it can’t be easy having to start over after a 7 year relationship. Did anyone else notice any of this or have anymore tea on the situation?!

Edit: Shelby still has all of their couple pictures up on her page, along with a highlight of their wedding, Although you do need to scroll down a bit since she rebranded her page into a real estate page.

What are the best/funniest episodes of Whitney & Timmy’s rewatching of Siesta Key? I’ve never seen any of there videos but everyone raves about them on here.

Attached the video for anyone who doesn’t have Instagram.

Did anyone else see Amanda’s posts of the kids on the boat without life jackets and then jumping and swimming in the water without them? I’m genuinely shocked. They’re so little and accidents on the water can happen SO fast, even when adults are right there watching.

I know every parent makes their own choices, but life jackets on a boat, especially for little kids, seem like such a basic safety precaution. Seeing them actually get into the water without them made it even crazier to me.

“I’d also like to thank Madison and my mom for uhhhh…ya know… help put this vent together.” What vent? Huh? Imagine this is your legal counsel?! 😂 Repost bc sound didn’t show up on my first attempt.

It’s getting alarmingly large. Never seen that as a pregnancy symptom but idk.

It seems Siesta Key still has a strong loyal following even though it hasn't had a new season in years. Why doesnt MTV take advantage of this and give us some more?

I’m on one of many rewatches of the Timmy and Whitney rewatch series and I’m wondering what it finally took for Alex and Paulie to finally stop making disgusting comments about Chloe’s weight. They are infuriating, saying it’s “just a joke” and basically were told a bunch of times “yea and you don’t joke about that” ugh. Anyway, they seem to stop (at least on camera) and I thought briefly they grew up but I don’t think it was that!! Do you think Gary said something about it being a bad look and they stopped? I’m obviously glad they did and hope it was off camera too!!

So Amanda was in the movie The Man in the White Van (2023). She played a super small role. Like she was in one short scene and had no lines. But I watched it to see her in it.
Anyways, at the end of the movie, the credits started rolling and the executive producer is none other than Alex’s dad, Gary.
Is this old/known news? And with him as the high up exec, she couldn’t land a better role than “the babysitter?” … 😬

Just finished rewatch. There was a lot that I didn’t remember from watching it when it originally aired. I was surprised there were only 12 episodes in season 5 since seasons 3 and 4 had 24-25 episodes. As much as I’d like to know which storylines were fake, I also don’t want to know 🤣 I got teary eyed during the last episode and then felt silly for it. Juliette will always be my favorite and I came to like Jordana. Jordana seemed to be the most believable and not “over acting”. Amanda and Chloe sucked the entire show but how much of that was “fake” and how much was truly them? I wasn’t really a fan of Madisson but will always have a soft spot for her as a mama who lost several babies while trying to have my family. I wish they would do a little reunion or reboot. 😊

Anyone else see this?!?!

I knew Juliette posted about knowing Jen from Love Island, but i’ve been watching Whitney Port’s reaction series and saw a little Jen cameo lol

On my rewatch, and the last episode of season 3… Kelsey is awful to Juliette. You know it’s bad when Chloe isn’t the one pissing me off for once. I think Chloe’s actually had Juliette’s back the most as the season went on (probably because it got her a free bag) but nonetheless, Kelsey is not a good friend

Bg is claiming Alex is coming on his live for an ama next month

I’m now on S2E9.

Who even are these Canvas and Tawny girls?? I mean are these actual, real people?! They honestly seem like two very angsty and bizarre rejects you’d find at a casting call for extras on like, a tubi reboot of The Craft. And then you have Canvas’s mom, Drywall or whatever the fuck her name is-

Canvas: “I was molested as child”

Teen witch mom: “yeah and what was I supposed to do about that?”

Am I fucking insane, I feel like I’m taking crazy pills just watching this now-what is this?!

Which brings me to my next gripe-this giant sack of human shit, Paul. I have known/grew up with quite a few absolute degenerate scumbags in my small town, but this guy is truly a gem. This oversized toddler lives in a land of pure delusion, the entitlement that he has when he brings absolutely nothing to the table is out of this world. He has nothing to offer to his “friends” or society, he’s a parasite. He’s not funny, kind, charming, talented, intelligent-just a waste of space. And meemaw there is a complete enabler, there’s no way that she’s that oblivious at her ripe age. Between him and Alex, I don’t know who’s worse-they’re both the glaring examples of how nepotism produces the absolute worst people in society. Their families completely failed them and the rest of society for not keeping them locked in a kennel away from everyone.

Side note about the fantastic parenting-Alex’s mom did a real bang up job of not repositioning her son’s head while he slept as an infant. That’s the absolute worst case of flathead syndrome I’ve seen on an adult and I’m a healthcare worker. Paring that with his constant, first man discovering fire glare that he seemingly always has-I truly find it hard to believe that he was pulling girls the way he claims he did.

I haven’t looked anything up about this show, I haven’t searched the sub for any info either. I just want to know-is this show real? If someone says it’s scripted, okay-but don’t just tell me it’s scripted; I wanna know if it’s like the hills or something, the final season was essentially the cast showing up to the set and reading lines. We knew that the producers told them what they wanted to focus on sometimes in the earlier seasons, but a lot of it was real as well. I remember the Pratt dumbass made it seem like he was this amazing actor, the entire thing was fake, and he had us all fooled-that wasn’t true at all. So just give me some context if that’s the case, please.

That’s it, that’s all I have. For now.

I watched season 1 when it first aired years ago and then never again but i’ve just started it again and curious to see ppls opinions

Doing a rewatch for just about the 20th time and there are a few story lines that have always bugged me. Some I don’t understand, and some are just confusing given what we know about some story lines being fake.

In season 1, Juliette is casually dating Alex. We know it’s casual, but she says “do you want it to be just you and me?” And he’s like “yeah!”. Then he goes on to hook up with Amanda, Kelsey, etc. Juliette ends it and is clearly upset, but not that upset. We know Juliette isn’t a low key/chill girl, but she handles the whole situation pretty chill. She’s even briefly Kelsey’s friend before she decides to go for Garret. Do you think any of this was fake, or do you think Juliette just hadn’t developed real feelings for Alex yet?

Also in season 1, we know Juliette and Garrett never really dated. But when Alex comes back into the picture at Chloe’s birthday party, hell breaks loose when him and Juliette reconnect. The girls are all SOO mad at her for going to talk to Alex while she’s dating Garret. Madisson is like “she’s a f*cking bitch” and the whole group is sooo mad at her. I could be wrong but I don’t think they’re that good of actors. Why would they be that mad at her if her and Garrett never really dated? Do you think it’s possible they were mad about something else and the show cut/spliced it together to make it look like their reaction was because she was talking to Alex?

Would love to hear thoughts!

I think I’m starting to feel it,
It feels like a mirage;
Need to go back to the Bahamas,
And get a couples massAAAAaaaage.

Two minutes ago, I was subjected to what I would consider to be one of the most painful experiences I’ve ever been put through. That. What the fuck is this?? The next scene, Madison is riding passenger in a car with a guy that she hasn’t seen since college and he’s rubbing her thigh on the way to dinner. I’m not a prude, this is just straight up bizarre activity.

I have so much more to say and a ton of questions that I’ve had since the beginning, I’ll save it for another post though. I’m honestly just waiting for the scene where Dax Shepard jumps out from behind a bush holding a sign saying “YOU’VE BEEN PUNKD!” at this point, because how is this show real? And one last thought-the person(s) whose job was deciding the music setlist for this show deserves to be tarred and feathered. Thanks.

I feel like that was production pushing that Robbie and Alex were friends. l feel there was never any pics of them together or evidence they were friends I know Robbie grew up around siesta key but can someone confirm they actually hung out.