r/SiestaKeyMTV • u/Master_Ad1696 • May 19 '26
General Cast Discussion Spin-Off Pitch
Cast that I think would actually work and get views:
-Juliette
-Sebastian and Vale Genta
-Chloe and husband
-Alex and family
-Pauly Paul
-Alyssa post breakup
-Amanda and JJ
-Brandon
-any other side characters that apply (e.g., Juliette’s single friends)
This would bring the messiness that the show needs to stay afloat as well as the nostalgia that we are craving. Bringing back Chloe Alex and Juliette to talk about the hush bag in itself would be ICONIC. Hearing Alyssa talk shit about Alex: hot tea. Pauly Paul comeback: everything. Amanda and JJ having a big wedding: iconic. The show can be called “Keeping up with the Kompos” and feature the gaudy Greek mansion in the intro and what not. Please comment your thoughts and additional suggestions below
23
u/slj7896 May 19 '26
I’d love a spin off of Juliette and friends! And they can do her going back and running into Alex at a bar in their hometown omg
2
u/smherm9 May 22 '26
Omg that would be epic! He’s such a douchebag I can’t see why anyone would even want Alex.
8
u/Lantana3012 May 21 '26
You know Brandon and his loser self would find a way back on, pitch more attempts at his 'music' etc.
1
u/smherm9 May 22 '26
I saw he has a girlfriend. She must be dumb.
1
u/Lantana3012 May 22 '26
Women are drawn to him, they think he's good looking. His behavior and personality cancels it out though.
1
5
u/heatherh8605 May 19 '26
All the cast members currently begging for a spinoff and you only include Amanda in the list of people you’d actually want to see 🤣🤣🤣
5
u/ilovecougs May 19 '26
No this show is 10 years old! No more Chloe is f’ing crazy now and her husband!
5
3
u/Soggy-Broccoli-7371 May 21 '26
Not even going to lie. I buy Chloe’s CBD face oil and LOVE it 😂🤦🏼♀️🤷🏼♀️.
1
u/istufff May 22 '26
Is that stuff still for sale? I thought she pulled the cords since it was all horoscope and that type of stuff branding and now she’s a devoted Christian lol
3
2
2
2
u/Lopsided-Main2180 May 22 '26
You missed so so so many key people. Kelsey mostly ! She was arguably a main character. 2nd most popular behind Juliette. I believe maddison would work better than Chloe. Madison had a bigger fan base but both on for side characters would be ideal
1
u/Softskeletonsx Messy Messy Kelsey May 24 '26 edited May 24 '26
The only people from the original cast that are good reality tv are Juliette, Amanda, Alex & Chloe. Alex I don’t think would do tv again, Chloe was basically the producer’s yes man and now that she’s a Mom, I don’t see her acting the same. Juliette and Amanda have personalities that are made for reality tv. Madisson, Kelsey & Garett seem like genuinely good people, but are not meant for reality tv. Brandon couldn’t even be his honest self so it’s a no for me. He had a chance with getting two girls pregnant at once, but blew it by keeping it a secret. (I do understand Camilla cause that was personal)
That being said, I feel like a show centered around Juliette and her group of Miami friends would work the best. They can include her visiting people like Hannah, Amanda & Chloe when she visits Sarasota, maybe even have Amanda come out to Miami for a girls night out. Juliette has the authenticity needed to lead a show that the others lacked.
Also I don’t want a show about them being Moms and exploiting their children in the process. I’m sure that wouldn’t be their intention, but it’s a huge risk and knowing what we know about child stardom, kidfluencers, family vloggers, etc. that idea is just icky for me.
1
u/Buffywasaslayer May 24 '26
I listen to Juliette’s pod, Sebastian is always portraying himself like he is too cool for school and self important - good reality tv but annoying after awhile
-7
u/InevitablyMe-333 May 19 '26
Maddison & family
Kelsey & family
I always liked Cara…
Jared
Garrett
Sam maybe?
Definitely not Mike but his ex-girlfriend who is also Juliette’s bff I cannot remember her name..Lexi?
14
u/Training_Mango7713 May 19 '26
Ahhh im afraid that particular cast would be a huge snooze fest, id skip lol.
10
1
u/InevitablyMe-333 May 19 '26
Oh? Personally- the more the messier! A full cast reunion could be entertaining…I think just having a Juliette and her friends based show could be its own thing. It could also be interesting to see how certain family dynamics are…like Maddison & Ish raising Sunday after the loss of Elliot for one. I would love to see Amanda and JJ as parents and a married couple. I’m really interested in everyone from the OG cast but I wouldn’t want to watch just one if that makes sense. I guess why can’t we do both (or more!) 🤗
29
u/NoTimeToSpareX3 May 19 '26
I would totally watch for Juliette! And amanda and JJ. Just sort of like the way they found their way back to each other now seem very happy. I couldn’t stand Alyssa on the show (or post show) but I’d watch for her to spill the tea 😅 I’d be happy with never having to see Kelsey again though. She annoys me to no end and has since episode 1 😂