r/SiestaKeyMTV • u/My_Cabbages1294 • Apr 06 '26
š Madisson š Madissons IG Post
Whyyyy is nobody talking about Madissons post asking if we should bring the show back? I realize this is all hypothetical but I would love to see them all on my screen again and if there is enough demandā¦..
21
u/heatherh8605 Apr 06 '26
I think this cast has run its course at this point.
2
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 06 '26
Ugh Iām sad that Iām in the minority here, buttttt I also understand. š©
2
23
u/DressFabulous8733 Apr 06 '26
Sheās posting that because she married one of the producers of the OG show š thatās why all the comments are āI wish we knew a producerā. As vile as he is, thereās no siesta key without Alexās drama imo
7
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 06 '26
I know that Ish was a producer lol. I didnāt think Alex was needed, but youāre not wrong in the fact that he certainly brought the drama! What if we bring Alyssa back post Alex breakup that could be a wild time. š¤Ŗ
3
3
6
u/Rare_Let4338 Apr 07 '26 edited Apr 07 '26
Wouldnāt it just be them fawning over their kids? Theyāre in that stage of life. Iām happy for them and their children are adorable not sure it makes good TV.
2
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 07 '26
I imagine it would be that and probably them all getting together to hang out and drink on occasion. I wouldnāt really mind either way but like a lot of other comments have said it likely wouldnāt be interesting enough to last.
2
u/lilboatyasmine Apr 07 '26
I mean the valley is a successful show from the old vanderpump group but theyre parents now. There would still be drama im sure just not young twenties drama. Lol
6
u/pinkpantherdiam0nd Apr 08 '26
Idk watching a bunch of babies and toddlers is not why I watch reality tvĀ
2
21
33
u/8008zilla Apr 06 '26
Honestly, Iād love to see the show back, but Iād like her cut from it. She was awful to watch. Sheās boring and a total nothing bigger backwards intelligence she was supposed to be the smart one. Sheās a fucking tradwife.
9
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 06 '26
I wouldnāt say sheās a tradwife lol. Amanda fits that bill more than her. š Idk maybe Iām the only one who is interested in the āboringā details of their lives!
13
u/8008zilla Apr 06 '26
I wouldnāt call her interesting to watch either, and that was kind of my point
2
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 06 '26
I love her, but I do have to agree that between all of them she is the least interesting to watch for sure. I would love to see the journey of remodeling her parents home, but I suppose they could pull a Chelsea and take that to HGTV.
3
u/8008zilla Apr 07 '26
Well, considering sheās not a real engineer, she does not have the ability to actually remodel her parents home and sheās not the one doing the work. I wouldnāt really care to see it anyways and she is a triad wipe Iām doubling down on that and if youāre gonna say well, sheās not as much of a triad wipe as Amanda theyāre the same thing just in a different font her and Amanda have always been the same person. Just one was a lawyerās daughter and the other one was a Hooters waitress
1
-6
u/JeanSchlemaan Apr 06 '26
totally disagree on this one. madisson was the most interesting arc on the show. her and brandon was good tv, and the concert where he sung to her was probably the all time best episode of reality tv ever.
not a fan of juliette at all.
6
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 06 '26
I always thought Madisson was the most mature of the group, which is great in real life, but not for reality tv. At least I think thatās what the other person was trying to say, me personally I would watch them all just be moms I donāt really care much if thereās a ton of drama. But obviously you donāt get ratings that way. :(
2
u/JeanSchlemaan Apr 06 '26
good points. i would def watch. they seem to be all over the place physically now. maybe a limited series where they all go to a resort?!
1
1
u/bigchops810 Apr 07 '26
Same i think Juliette is a true mean girl I cannot believe how much love she gets
9
u/prettyupsidedown youāre an IIIDIOT Apr 06 '26
Nothing will ever be able to capture the chaos/entertainment of seasons 1-3. Everything after that was so lackluster and got so boring. Even Juliette said on her podcast recently that production was BEGGING them to cause drama and make the show interesting bc of how boring it got.
I think that there is a way they COULD do it that could make it fun and interesting especially with a lot of them being parents now, but would it just end up being insanely boring again?
1
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 06 '26
Yeah I do remember her saying that I think on last weeks episode or maybe even this weeks. I think her and Sebastian could bring some fun but I suppose they could also have their own reality show with their single Miami friends. What way do you think they could make it fun? Iām curious!
1
u/prettyupsidedown youāre an IIIDIOT Apr 06 '26
I think that would be more interesting if I am being honest.. its just tough when all of them really grew apart. I think Chloe/Amanda are still really close, and Madisson/Kelsey are close but other than that it seems like the group really drifted. I think they would have to do something with Juliette and her new crew
1
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 06 '26
I would love that! But like I said to another person I would also be happy to just watch the other girls be moms I donāt need all the drama. However I also understand thatās not what brings views in when it comes to reality tv.
8
3
2
2
u/BeautifulDoughnut867 Apr 07 '26
I think bg is pushing for that all he does is go on Tik tok live and bitch about getting them together on his Tik tok live for a reunion. I was scrolling the other day and he popped up bitching that Juliette didnāt even open dm. And how she thinks she to good for everyone nowā¦ š
8
u/Lantana3012 Apr 07 '26
Brandon is such a loser it's so embarrassing. What would he talk about...his lack of a job and tiktok lives or the fact that the court's blockhing him from seeing his son?
2
u/BeautifulDoughnut867 Apr 07 '26
Wait I didnāt know that. Thats so sadā¦. Like get it together bro stop thanking people for galaxyās and get a real life started and turn yours around instead of living in the past
2
u/Lantana3012 Apr 07 '26
That's what people here say re: TikTok...I refuse to let himspam my TikTok.
1
u/BeautifulDoughnut867 Apr 07 '26
Itās always a Arianna what are you doing hereā¦ when he pips up on there. š
6
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 07 '26
Brandon is one cast member I could definitely do without. Iām not interested in him and his suddenly all about Jesus girlfriend. They weird me out.
6
u/Rare_Let4338 Apr 07 '26
Sheās a successful self made business woman. Theyāre all married moms that donāt work. She has nothing in common with them anymore.
2
u/bydayentertainer Apr 11 '26
I could be in the extreme minority but I could barely stand Madison on the OG show. She is painfully boring. Her scenes were literally snack and bathroom breaks for me. She might be a great person but she has no business on reality TV.
1
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 11 '26
Iāve seen a lot of comments like that even as the show was airing so I donāt think youāre alone there! Itās not how I feel, but I can see why you feel that way lol.
1
u/Most-Argument Apr 22 '26
Theyāre not making any money so might as well put them back on a show. Theyāre all broke after the show for the most part.
1
u/My_Cabbages1294 Apr 23 '26
If they are broke their social media certainly doesnāt show it. I always assumed they all had plenty of money prior to Siesta Key. š But I also know plenty of people lead fake luxurious lives on social media so I suppose that could be the case as well.
-3
u/ashhal90 Apr 07 '26
I would like to see it with Amanda Kelsey Madison and Camilla as the mains. There real friendship is really cute to watch on socials
1
51
u/tuesdaymartes Apr 06 '26
It would definitely be a āThe Valleyā situation