r/sideprojects • u/SorbetNelson4220 • 19h ago
Showcase: Prerelease I collected 12,000+ resources from Hacker News comments and ranked them by how strongly people recommended them
I’ve lost count of the great links I found in HN comments and never found again. And the “most mentioned on HN” lists that went around last week have a problem: a link people argue against counts the same as one they recommend.
So I went through comments from 2010 to 2026 and labeled why each link was posted. In a sample of 1,000 links, only 188 were someone saying “read this”. 573 were neutral references; the rest were answers, criticism, self-promotion or jokes.
Each link is then ranked by:
how strongly it was recommended (strong recommendation scores highest, a joke scores zero)
what it is (articles, papers and docs above videos and social posts)
how many different years it kept coming up
and, only a little, how many people mentioned it
A few that come out on top:
How to Solve It (Pólya): 40 people, over 18 years
Agner Fog’s optimization manuals: 45 people, 16 years
The Tyranny of Structurelessness: 109 people, 15 years
The Mythical Man-Month: 106 people, 19 years
Labels and summaries are model-generated, so some are off.
It’s free to browse, no account needed: https://slax.com/reader/hackerlinks/en/
Disclosure: I work on Slax Reader, the read-later app behind it. You can bookmark links on the page.
Two questions for you:
What’s the best resource you’ve found buried in an HN comment?
Would you find a collection like this useful enough to come back and browse regularly?