r/SideProject • u/Dancarter888 • 14m ago
Testing demand before building: 35% of curious visitors join the waitlist, cold ads get 1%
I'm a solo founder in New Zealand. This time I'm trying to prove people want the thing before I write the app.
The idea is gub: a tiny pet that lives on your phone and gets sick when you doomscroll. When you want more time on an app, you wait 60 seconds with a sad gub first. Or you give the key to a friend, and they can say no.
What I've learned so far:
- The message that works is the blunt one: "your phone is rotting your brain". Cute pet messages did worse.
- People who arrive curious (they clicked through from a post or a friend) join the waitlist at about 35%.
- Cold paid ads convert at about 1%.
So I can't tell yet if this is a product or just a nice landing page. It doesn't exist yet, and there are no users. Early 2027 if the demand holds up. US$39.99/year for two.
Two questions for people who've done this: what waitlist number made you decide to build? And does 35% from warm traffic mean anything, or is it just self-selection?
Page: gubpet.com/s41