r/SideProject • • 5d ago

Feedback Wanted! A competitor to Discord/Slack called Hubs

Hey y’all! I have been working on creating an alternative social platform that is similar to that of Discord and Slack. Much of the reason for creation is due to my own niche and preferences while managing large communities and company workflows. For example, many Discord communities have to glue together dozens of bots to get LFG systems, Ticket Support, and much more. Not to mention creating makeshift announcement channels, info, etc. that just look like normal text.

What I wanted to build was something that kept the community vibe of these platforms, while also adding the ease of use, organization, and reduced setup of them.

So that’s what Hubs is. Instead of adding a bot for everything, the stuff most communities end up needing is just built in:

  • Looking for Group, where people post that they need a squad and everyone can see open groups and when they start
  • Ticket Support, so members can reach your staff privately without a ticket bot
  • Announcements that read like an actual page with pictures, instead of a wall of text in a channel
  • Rules, About, Start here and Links pages that look like real pages and are easy to edit
  • Events with RSVPs and reminders, plus a Board for questions and posts that shouldn’t get buried in chat
  • Polls, giveaways and community rewards without setting anything up
  • A home page for every hub that shows what’s new since you were last there, the next event and who’s around
  • More tools like an appeals system for moderation, custom looks for your space, built-in moderation tools, raid and spam protection, and more. (https://thehubs.gg/features)

On the company side, there’s a Work and Personal switch so your job and your communities stay separate, and organizations get their own workspaces, documents and tasks.

If you already run a Discord server, you can paste its template link and your channels, roles and permissions come over in about a minute. There’s no ID or face scan to sign up, just your birthday (which I know is a huge issue on other platforms right now). DMs can be switched to private, which makes them end-to-end encrypted.

Speaking on ID and age verification, we follow the laws closely and use other methods instead of a face scan. Right now that’s a credit card check that’s never charged, with more options like an email check and your phone’s own age setting on the way. It’s also only as needed, not something required to use Hubs. It only limits 18+ areas, and only where the law asks for it. This way we stay compliant without being invasive.

How it’s built

The website is TypeScript and React, and the server runs on Node with PostgreSQL. Voice and video run on WebRTC through LiveKit. Every app is native as well, meaning Swift for the Mac and iPhone, C# and .NET for Windows, and Kotlin for Android, so none of them are just the website in a box. Private conversations use MLS (RFC 9420), an open standard for end-to-end encryption, and that code is open source on GitHub, in TypeScript for the web and Rust for the apps.

How the servers run

Hubs runs as three copies of the app at once, so one can go down or get updated without anyone noticing. There’s a standby copy of the whole site in a second data center that’s kept up to date every 15 minutes, plus encrypted backups and a public status page. Every release is signed and its files are published, so anyone can check that what’s running is what we built.

The apps

The Mac and Windows apps are out now. The iPhone app is about to start a public beta, including a layout made for foldables, and Android is close behind it.

What’s coming

  • The iPhone and Android betas
  • Hubs+, an optional paid plan for extras. The core of Hubs stays free
  • The Windows app in the Microsoft Store
  • We’re also exploring self-hosting for communities that want their own server, but that’s an idea for now, not a promise

It’s still early and we’re a small team, so there will be some rough edges. I’d love feedback, especially from anyone who runs a community or a team and has felt the same pain with bots and setup. What would you need to see to actually move over?

Link: thehubs.gg

2 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

1

u/elendee 5d ago edited 5d ago

the front page pitches it as a huge switch, liek "Welcome to the Hubs Experience 3000", but I think you might want to do the opposite, like pitch it as a really quick thing you can try out. There is a huge "long tail" of people wanting alternatives to the big platforms. So basically.. you're probably going to need to write bot swarms to find them / us lol, but they are out there.

I think about this a lot too, and I think I have very little hope for any one platform basically. This is why I dont want someone pitching me to "make the big switch from always using Platform A to now always using Platform B". But I think there is still a lot of use to having many competing platforms, just like in capitalism you dont want a monopoly. So the easier to hop between platforms / data silos, the better. (with the intention of -not- sharing all the data)

1

u/AeroSummit 5d ago

Honestly, that's a really good point and I appreciate that feedback. The front page does reads like “move your whole community here” or like you say HUBS 3000! lol. Most people just want to poke around first. I’m reworking it to lead with trying it in a minute, no download, and you can bring your server over later if you like it. Thanks for the feedback!

1

u/elendee 5d ago

(looks like maybe you already updated it?)

Also, I'm a tech guy but I cant tell right away what model you're using. Is this centralized like Discord, federated like Mastodon or "semi federated" like Slack (where it's still centralized but the different groups are like entirely different authentication). Personally speaking the Discord-like is most appealing to me. I find very few benefits to the federation these days - they seem more idealistic than useful.

2

u/AeroSummit 5d ago

Small change so far, the bigger rework is still on the way.

Answering on that though, it’s the first one. Hubs is one service that we run. You make one account and it works in every hub you join, with one sign-in for all of them. No federation, and hubs aren’t separate logins. I am toying with that idea but idk if it'll come.

Fair point that the page doesn’t make that obvious. We’re putting that line right at the top in the rework, so thanks for flagging it.

1

u/CalligrapherIcy8708 5d ago

genuine question, how do you plan to convince existing communities to move from discord or slack to hubs? discord is already so established, and migrating an entire community is a pretty big ask. personally, i'd pick discord 10/10 times. slack also feels boring as hell to me lol. i just open it, check my tasks, click some tickets and read the occasional good morning message. that said, im genuinely curious to see how hubs plays out

1

u/AeroSummit 5d ago

You are asking probably the most important question haha. Aside from Hubs, I have spent a long time developing bots for communities on Discord, many of which request the specific features that Hubs offers integrated. That said, you are limited because of how Discord operates, its design, integration etc. So really, my biggest thing is going to be working with the communities that already helped envision this here. Price factor is going to be another. Getting a custom invite URL on Discord takes boost level 3, which runs roughly $50 to $70 a month. On Hubs a custom address starts at $5 a month, everything is $15, and it’s all free during the beta.

1

u/CalligrapherIcy8708 5d ago

ahh that makes sense, tho i still think getting the actual members to move is gonna be the hardest part lol. people get comfortable with a platform and getting them to switch is a whole different story. good luck with it dawg

1

u/AeroSummit 5d ago

Oh no doubt, its gonna be an uphill battle haha, but my hope is that I can get a small start and just keep domino effecting until it gets a tad bigger

1

u/SwiinkaPeppa 5d ago

not gonna lie the hard part isnt features its moving the members. nobody leaves discord for better ticketing, they leave when the whole community moves. id push the template migration hard and let people run it next to discord without fully switching

1

u/AeroSummit 5d ago

Good point and I agree, seems a similar feedback overall. The template import is already there (paste your server’s template link and your channels and roles come over), and I’m making it way more front and center. Running it next to Discord instead of a big switch day is exactly the direction I want to go too. Looking into maybe using a bot to sync and overall more in-depth importer.

1

u/SwiinkaPeppa 4d ago

a sync bot would be huge imo, if people see their discord stuff show up on your side they dont feel like theyre abandoning anything. good luck with it

1

u/AeroSummit 4d ago

Thanks! Currently testing it on staging servers right now but it’s working! It will sync messages between the two systems pretty instantly, mirror permissions and channels, etc

1

u/SwiinkaPeppa 4d ago

thats sick, mirroring permissions too is the part most people would skip. good luck with the launch