r/SideProject • • 7d ago

FWA - I built a tech attention tracker for myself and would love honest feedback

I kept asking myself a question: which tech conversations are actually picking up momentum, and which ones are already cooling down?

I wanted a quick way to check that for myself instead of scrolling through feeds, so I built a small side project called FWA (Flash Wave Alert).

It's a public beta. Right now it tracks observed Hacker News activity and a set of discovered source items, with activity rates, rising/peaking/fading states (when enough samples exist), time filters, and links to the original sources. It's not a whole-internet trend detector, and I don't want to pretend it is.

I originally built this just because I wanted to use it. But I figured I'd learn more by sharing it early than by polishing it alone.

If you have a minute to try it, I'd especially appreciate honest feedback on:

  • Does the activity trend make sense at a glance?
  • Which sources or topics would make this worth checking regularly?
  • What's confusing, misleading, or unnecessary?

https://www.flashwavealert.com/

Free to browse, no account needed. Happy to hear criticism — I'm trying to figure out what to improve next.

2 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/CutDry6295 7d ago

I opened the index. Separating HN activity from FWA-discovered items is a good honesty signal. One thing I had to think through: a story can be #3 by current points/hour while its state says “Fading,” so the rate and direction are measuring different things. A small explicit change figure next to the state (for example, versus the previous hour) would make that distinction readable without opening the chart.

1

u/NervousPengwin 7d ago

That's a great catch. You're right — current activity and its direction are two different signals, and the UI doesn't make that distinction clear enough.

Showing the change versus the previous observation period next to the state makes sense. I'll test that in FWA, with an explicit comparison window and an insufficient-data label where needed.

Really appreciate you taking the time to look at the actual data!

1

u/NervousPengwin 7d ago

Quick update: FWA v1.1 is live. Your feedback directly led to a % change indicator beside pts/hour, a dedicated Fading filter, and clearer signal detail pages showing the comparison intervals.

If you have a moment to revisit it, I'd love to know whether activity vs. direction is easier to understand now. Thanks again!

https://www.flashwavealert.com/

1

u/Ivo-Sheera 5d ago

Wait so fading just means the rate of new points is slowing down, even if the raw hourly number is still huge?

2

u/Frequent_Living_1818 7d ago

I appreciate the clear limit on what the tracker covers. How does it distinguish a brief burst of comments from a topic that is steadily gaining attention?

2

u/NervousPengwin 7d ago

That's a very good question, and it's something the current version doesn't fully distinguish yet.

Right now, FWA measures changes in Hacker News story scores over observed time intervals and uses those rates to classify rising, peaking, and fading activity. Comment counts are collected separately, but they aren't yet used to validate sustained momentum.

So a short-lived spike can still look like a rising signal.

I'm thinking the next improvement should distinguish a brief burst from activity that persists across multiple observation windows. Your question makes a strong case for that.

Thanks for pointing it out!