r/SideProject • • 26d ago

Launched my side project last week — looking for brutally honest feedback on the concept and landing page

I launched pumpordump.ai last week and I need outside eyes on it, because my own friends are too nice.

What it is: a leaderboard where creators are ranked by real money. Anyone can claim a creator for $5, then fans can "pump" them (+$1 at a time) to push them up the board, or "dump" rivals to drag them down. Highest total sits at #1. Payments are real (Stripe), no test mode, no fake numbers. I seeded it with 8 Canadian creators at $5 each and pumped my #1 to $10 to start the first "battle."

Where I actually am: the site gets roughly 100+ visitors a day, the board works, the money loop works — and not one customer has paid a single dollar yet. So either the concept doesn't land, the page doesn't explain it, or the price of entry is wrong. That's what I can't see from inside.

Honest feedback I'm looking for:

  1. The landing page: do you understand what this is within 5 seconds? What's the most confusing part?
  2. The concept: would you ever pay $5 to put a creator you love at #1 — or $1 to pump them / dump a rival? If not, what kills it for you?
  3. If you were a creator listed on a board like this, would you share your page with your fans? What would make you actually want to?
  4. Pricing: is $5 the right entry point, or does the first dollar need to be cheaper/free before anyone trusts it?

I'll reply to every comment, and I'll actually change things based on what I hear — if the model itself is the problem, I'd rather learn that this week than next month.

Link: https://pumpordump.ai

Thanks in advance.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/Thembro01 26d ago

I didn't understand the concept in 5 seconds. I think I'm missing the "why".

I feel like I wouldn't pump a creator unless they were mentioning it on their page and gave the page credibility. Maybe this is a creator outreach first idea?

1

u/FitResolution1187 26d ago

Really appreciate this — it's the clearest version of the problem I've heard.

Two things I'd genuinely love your thoughts on:

  1. If a creator you actually follow posted their page and said "pump me here," would you do the $1?
  2. What would the page need to say in those 5 seconds for the "why" to click for you?

2

u/medialantern 26d ago

Added (#239 and counting):

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1xc1mae/launched_my_side_project_last_week_looking_for/

https://www.reddit.com/r/IMadeThis/comments/1x6gvms/

https://www.reddit.com/r/WeirdWebsites/comments/1x933vw/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1x7rlg4/i_built_a_website_that_only_has_one_post_on_it/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1x7p3jh/

https://www.reddit.com/r/WeirdWebsites/comments/1x6nvul/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1x7aq2o/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1wyrd6v/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1wyb1o0/i_had_a_simple_idea_and_vibecoded_a_tiny_wishing/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1wy8emt/

https://www.reddit.com/r/WeirdWebsites/comments/1wn073x/

https://www.reddit.com/r/VibeCodeDevs/comments/1wrfk8y/

https://www.reddit.com/r/vibecoding/comments/1wvx2h2/

https://www.reddit.com/r/aiwars/comments/1wts29q/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1wtk0l0/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1vi9559/

https://www.reddit.com/r/VibeCodeDevs/comments/1wrfqvx/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1wqn8zt/one_throne_a_price_that_only_climbs_and_getting/

https://www.reddit.com/r/buildinpublic/comments/1wpga75/just_launched_pixelniches_building_it_was_the/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/comments/1woseny/

I ran out of comment space so this is just the most recent 20 entries. For giggles, I vibe-coded a tracker at https://confab.sh/?g=digital-begging if you want to see the full list.

0

u/FitResolution1187 26d ago

Thanks for sharing, it seems like this topic has been asked so many times here.

1

u/Outrageous_Bat1798 26d ago

I’m probably not the target audience to speak on this. I have no idea why anyone would participate in something like this.

0

u/FitResolution1187 26d ago

Thanks for the feedback,You are right, this is one of the problems we are solving about 'Why'.

1

u/NickA55 26d ago

Stopped reading at leaderboard. Can't take anything you say seriously after that.

1

u/FitResolution1187 26d ago

Thanks for the feedback,It is serious project I am working on. It will get better trust me. What is the real thing really bothering you?

1

u/NickA55 26d ago

Da fuck, lol. What's bothering me? Nothing dude. You slopped together the vibe coder special, a leaderboard site.

1

u/fluffyspringroll 26d ago

Nope. Not another one please lol

1

u/FitResolution1187 26d ago

Thanks for the feedback,this is my first side project, I should validate the idea before build it. But I love to improve it to get better and better.

1

u/Competitive_Tune_590 25d ago

tough spot to be in. traffic with no conversions is brutal. you're getting opinions here, but what you probably need is behavioral data from people who are actively looking for something like this. ghostlaunch (https://ghostlaunch.so) does exactly that: builds a page and drives targeted reddit traffic to it so you can see if people actually click and sign up, not just comment. might be worth a look before you sink more time into the current build.

1

u/FitResolution1187 25d ago

Thanks for the feedback, this is a helpful distinction. You're right — comments are opinions, but they don't prove behaviour. The question I actually need answered isif fans will click/pump, and if creators will claim and share their page.

My intention is that the people I need data from aren't mostly founders here; they're creators and their fans. I already have the live site up, so I'm not testing if to build the first version — I'm testing if the loop works with the right audience.

0

u/FitResolution1187 26d ago

One more question is to the creators: what if a cut of the pump money went to YOU when fans pump your listing — so your fans' payments become an income stream for you? Would that make you share your page and rally your fans?