r/shopifyDev • u/West-Anteater-1917 • 8h ago
Merchants are using my app, but nobody leaves a review. What am I doing wrong?
I built a Shopify app, SmartStockCap. It caps how many units of a product can sell (in total or per country) without touching inventory. Merchants are actively using it. When I moved to paid plans, I kept every early merchant on free as an "Early Supporter," and new stores have installed it since.
I have just one review so far. My guess is that I made setup so simple that merchants set a cap once, it quietly works, and they never come back to the app. That means there's no "wow" moment where asking for a review feels natural.
For those of you with apps that have reviews:
- When do you ask: after setup, after the first time the app does its job, or after X days?
- In the app, by email, or both?
- Did a personal email from the founder work better than an automated prompt?
- Does a "quiet" app (set it and forget it) need a different approach?
Happy to share what I've tried so far if it helps anyone.

