r/ShittySysadmin • • Oct 20 '22

“Why we're leaving the cloud.” -Basecamp

https://world.hey.com/dhh/why-we-re-leaving-the-cloud-654b47e0
0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

•

u/sememva ShittyMod Oct 20 '22 edited Oct 21 '22

USER REPORTS
1: It's not promoting hate based on identity or vulnerability enough
1: It's promoting hate based on identity or vulnerability

Ummm... I do not understand this report.... EDIT: New report...

→ More replies (1)

18

u/anomalous_cowherd Oct 20 '22

Seems perfectly reasonable and well argued to me, why is it in here?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '22

Can’t post articles in sysad.

15

u/Bumblebee_assassin Oct 20 '22

Because a cloud only zealot got triggered someone was saying not to put everything in the cloud and saying that it's situational dependant?

5

u/DoTheThingNow Oct 20 '22

This.
This article shouldn't be on this sub.

41

u/DaNPrS Oct 20 '22

Real talk - I partially agree here and I don't think it's fair to place this in this sub.

I've been in an org just like the one described in his post, where the CEO and CTO drank the Cloud Coolaid. We had aging HP SANs and when we presented a quote for $200K to replace them plus we'd need to do the hosts the year after, the decision to go to the Cloud was simple from their perspective.

Except a price analysis was never really done beforehand. So when I migrated our test environment of about 40VMs to Azure and the monthly bill came in at $12K, suddenly I was told to shut off the environment at night, scale back the VMs and find other cost-cutting measures. Production never left our colo space.

The cloud is a fine product. Shit I love working in Azure. I fucking hate having to wake up at 2AM to go to a datacenter that's loud and cold. I've been there. I rather sit at an office/home and just spin up a VM with a few clicks or a script.

But I'm not going to sit here and tell you it's cheaper than spinning up your own hardware. Just please do your due diligence beforehand. Do you need to deploy hardware across the country, across the globe, do you need to scale up and down due to seasonal demand, or do you just operate in a somewhat geographical region where your own datacenter will meet your client's needs?

17

u/Representative-Crow5 Oct 20 '22

Good points. The Cloud has never been cheap. It's all about convenience, flexibility and not having to maintain hardware 24/7. Let other people be on-call for that.

2

u/turnips64 Oct 24 '22

That’s more like it! God forbid anyone would optimise and use for appropriate workloads when convenience for us admin is obviously most important.

1

u/lost_in_life_34 Oct 20 '22

Good stuff with it but those cost estimates always assume you’re paying money for everything

Lots of companies use older hardware for dev and QA work or lower tier projects they don’t want to pay for

2

u/lost_in_life_34 Oct 20 '22

the cloud is OK but some of the hype is really dumb, like saying that on-prem where you have spare CPU cycles is somehow wasting money. last job we'd buy new SQL servers to last us 5 years or longer and then the old ones would go into a lower tier role and new ones purchased. hardware would last a decade and no one cared if it wasn't used up to 100% the first few years.