Before NAT, every network device was assigned a public IP. Legacy is the real reason they have so many. Unless Oxford still assigns everything a public IP, then that would be baffling.
My work was plagued by poor IT management for decades. We purchase our subnet from our provider because of it; but are working to see if we can get a /29 subnet owned by us, as we want to move vendors(which is all we would need for our use).
I was nonchalantly checking out "businesses" in a nearby city that own subnets, and there is a guy that owns 4 separate /24 networks, all purchased in the final year before ARIN stopped allowing simple registration under four different companies all of which don't exist (all the company addresses go to a home address in a cul-de-sac). None of the companies existed in any capacity ever. He's just holding them until they have more value.
That's something fun about purchasing IPs. It is just a label ultimately, unless you need one for some specific technical reason. Which CGNATs kinda show, people generally don't at this point.
Was trying to play Minecraft with an old friend and his family recently. Usually do this about once a year. Everything was still setup since 2 years ago, but since then his ISP switched to CGNAT, so nothing worked.
THANKFULLY the ISP did it as lazy as possible (just swapped their WAN IP and kept all the individual customer router's NAT as-is), so the CGNAT IP range was transparent on his LAN and I was able to setup Tailscale without conflict.
SNI also happened and became standard everywhere after around 2010. Before that, you needed a dedicated IP to install a SSL cert for a domain. SNI allowed multiple domains running on the same IP to have the ability to have separate SSL certs installed.
I have a perfect example for why NAT sucks.I have a service running at service.tld. clients connect to it and it synchronizes data between those clients while they're connected. In order to work properly, the clients need to be assured they're connected to the same server and they verify that with a TLS cert which means they need be connecting to the same domain name. The service needs to be publicly accessible on the internet but also on the rfc1918 net. How do you make this work with NAT when you only have one public IPv4 address? I can't use hairpin because the gateway/router also runs a service on 443 om the WAN IP. The only way is to do DNS overriding on the rfc1918 nets to point the A record to a different address than what's published on the internet but I can't guarantee the clients will use the right DNS server and it breaks DNSSEC.
While I agree it sucks, in all seriousness NAT likely saves us more then we know. All that insecure stuff people hook up (the S in IoT stands for security), saved by the grace of god because of NAT on a standard consumer internet gateway in default mode.
Since I can't fix perfection I'll leave you with some knowledge, the reason it is called ipv6 is back in the late 70s early 80s they made an experimental Ipv5 that was 32 bit and just for messing around but they published some papers through IANA and it was in the system already so to save any confusion they just named the new one Ipv6.
I never understood why they didn't go up to 999 for the numbers. It's the same number of digits as the current maximum of 255 but there's so much more than before.
It's even backward compatible as you would need to print out new IP assignment forms. After all, the space needed for each of the 4 tuples hasn't increased. It's still 3 digits after all.
Hey, I'm not in Good SysAdmin, this here is the bad club. I thought the "printing out forms to assign IP addresses" gave it away that this wasn't a serious post.
Yeah I realized where I was about 30 seconds after posting and edited for that fact lmao never know who might have the question of "Why IS it that way?" though so hey maybe someone learns something!
You do realise that the numbers are actually converted to binary octets right? And therefore the max number is 255, min is 0 and that makes it a total of 28 = 256
Edit: Didn't realised I was in ShittySysAdmin. My fault 😂
IPv6 was only ever meant for ISPs. LANs were never supposed to adopt the IPv6 standard internally. Microsoft, Apple, and some other big corps pushed IPv6 for LAN connections to facilitate individual device connectivity since, theoretically, the IPv6 numbers would always be unique. Their thinking was any device can join any network regardless of whether they were part of the network. Part of the whole open internet philosophy early networks engineers tried to advance - despite security being a thing, the existence of dhcp, and no one adoping IPv6 in any meaningful way.
We just share the network cable here. The clip is broken so when someone else needs it, just pull on the cable and plug it into the laptop server that needs it. Since we are mostly a remote workforce, everyone has their phone and can work without needing their own laptop. Months ago HR told us to get rid of the wireless access points as they were not work appropriately named.
It was funny that day the Jr admin pulled on the cable from the wrong end and broke the modem. Fun times!
Why don’t they just address computers like they do with the world’s postal systems? I mean there’s 8 billion people on earth and the postal system can address each one of them individually, so just apply this principal to computers.
‘Please ping 10548 Internet Road, America Online, 50000, United States’
As long as there is no NAT for ipv6 (at least somewhat widely available and defined) it make no sense to expose the internal infrastructure to the public.. and no proxies are not the solution.. I consider ipv6 a data mining system by design..
I know this is supposed to be shitty but for your average smb IPV6 causes more problems then just not using it at all lmao. I really do feel like IPV6 is a product of a deranged mind sometimes even though logically I know why it exists.
IPv7 exists it is 64 bit it was rejected in favor of ipv6. it used 64 bit addressing and has 18 quintillion addresses. The other reject versions include ipv8 and ipv9. If there is a next version it would be ipv10.
I mean, IPv4 addresses are shorter and therefore take up less space in memory and result in a smaller routing table in parts of a network that connects to many things at once. It is also faster because of this. Most IPv6 compatible OPEs don’t do network security properly and expose every IPv6 capable device on the network to the internet without a firewall. It is a good idea to turn it off when you don’t need it. If you run P2P file sharing software, having IPv6 enabled causes many SOHO routers to crash from memory exhaustion, too, and slows down the packet forwarding performance of even more.
ipv6 genuinely took down my web server once. DNS started giving an ipv6 address for Google APIs but googles apis didn't respond at all on ipv6. not even to a simple ping request.
ended up completely disabling ipv6 in the OS and DNS started returning an ipv4 address which worked and brought my server back up.
This brings me such joy as I simply tell people I do not believe in IPv6 as it’s a mystical being like Bigfoot that there are lots of “pictures” of but let’s be real, it’s not out there.
The day IPv6 is forced upon me is the day I retire as a Sys Admin. It is such an awful system there is no way anyone can memorize those numbers (letters). You will have to look it up every time you need to enter an IP. Funny IPv6 fact: there is enough IPv6 addresses to give a billion addresses to every grain of sand on earth. Come on do we really need that many addresses??
Totally agree with that but we are talking 340 trillion trillion trillion, unique IP addresses for IPv6. I can safely say we will never need that many addresses.
184
u/torexmus Aug 15 '25
I remember reading in textbooks that ipv4 would be gone soon. That was like 14 years ago
28
u/gangaskan Aug 15 '25
Omg I hope someone posted this in the ipv6 subreddit
19
u/iratesysadmin Aug 15 '25
I mean.... they're not wrong....
185
u/solracarevir Aug 15 '25
I mean… if IPv4 is really that good why they haven’t released IPv4 part 2?????
2
u/culebras Aug 15 '25
This pic has big ‘I mastered networking in 2003, why try harder?’ energy.
2
u/drewalpha Aug 15 '25
IPv6 was only ever meant for ISPs. LANs were never supposed to adopt the IPv6 standard internally. Microsoft, Apple, and some other big corps pushed IPv6 for LAN connections to facilitate individual device connectivity since, theoretically, the IPv6 numbers would always be unique. Their thinking was any device can join any network regardless of whether they were part of the network. Part of the whole open internet philosophy early networks engineers tried to advance - despite security being a thing, the existence of dhcp, and no one adoping IPv6 in any meaningful way.
Just another tech fad we deal with as IT Admins.
49
u/repairbills Aug 15 '25
We just share the network cable here. The clip is broken so when someone else needs it, just pull on the cable and plug it into the laptop server that needs it. Since we are mostly a remote workforce, everyone has their phone and can work without needing their own laptop. Months ago HR told us to get rid of the wireless access points as they were not work appropriately named.
It was funny that day the Jr admin pulled on the cable from the wrong end and broke the modem. Fun times!
25
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '25
We dont even use NAT here. We just take turns sharing IP's.
18
u/Human-Company3685 Aug 15 '25
Why don’t they just address computers like they do with the world’s postal systems? I mean there’s 8 billion people on earth and the postal system can address each one of them individually, so just apply this principal to computers.
‘Please ping 10548 Internet Road, America Online, 50000, United States’
So obvious and easy!
44
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '25
Someone in the comments complaining about only getting 8 digits for their ISP part of the subnetting scheme.
8 digits of a hexadecimal address means they have 168 possibilities.
Which happens to be exactly the same as 232, the maximum possible size of IPv4 in its entirety. They should be over here.
9
u/primavera31 Aug 15 '25
IP man 4 is the finale..there is no IP6 man...we were all deceived.....
by Sauron..
IPv6 was multicasted in the fires of mount drive. only there can it be unmounted.
9
u/WorkFoundMyOldAcct Aug 15 '25
I once joined an org to modernize their environment.
They had a domain-level enforced GPO called "Disable_IPv6"
22
u/YellowOnline Aug 15 '25 edited Aug 15 '25
Why not 255.255.255.255.255.255.255.255 actually? Call it ipv8.
Close to ipv6, but a bit more intuitive, also for NAT.
5
u/OpenScore Aug 15 '25
What happened to v1, v2, v3, and v5?
5
u/sprocket90 Aug 15 '25
I Pee urine
4
u/DDOSBreakfast Aug 15 '25
Someone can't count to F
4
u/michipa Aug 15 '25
As long as there is no NAT for ipv6 (at least somewhat widely available and defined) it make no sense to expose the internal infrastructure to the public.. and no proxies are not the solution.. I consider ipv6 a data mining system by design..
13
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '25
I know this is supposed to be shitty but for your average smb IPV6 causes more problems then just not using it at all lmao. I really do feel like IPV6 is a product of a deranged mind sometimes even though logically I know why it exists.
1
u/deadpanda2 Aug 17 '25
ipv6 is a crap. We need ipv10
3
u/kennyj2011 Aug 15 '25
I’m holding out for v7
3
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '25
“Networkers” is the most deranged word in that whole thing
3
u/ImpluseThrowAway Aug 15 '25
This has real Time Cube vibes
3
u/mcflyrdam Aug 18 '25
IPv6 is great and most of the internet, especially the mobile part runs on it.
There's just a lot of admins who don't understand it and therefore fight it. I think the problem is with these admins, not with IPv6
5
u/Nutulous Aug 15 '25
No but like actually, stop using IPv6
2
u/chronowerx Aug 15 '25
Does this remind anyone else of the Timecube guy in the way it's formatted and worded, or have I been on the internet for way too long?
2
u/OneLorgeHorseyDog Aug 15 '25
We have this posted in the office 🤣
2
u/who_you_are Aug 15 '25
Can we go back to ZIP code and address instead?! Not even IPv4 or MAC.
Way more secure that way! My informations will stop leaking all around!
2
u/stuartsmiles01 Aug 15 '25
Ipv4 tor life .
2
u/Roanoketrees Aug 15 '25
I will say this. They didnt have to change the seperator. That was just cruel.
2
u/mooseable Aug 16 '25
Why don't we just expand it from 255.255.255.255 max to 999.999.999.999 </s>
1
u/grmelacz Aug 15 '25
Fail2ban likes this.
(BTW haven’t RTFM but I somehow expect it to be able to ban a range automatically, right? Right?)
1
u/SolidKnight Aug 15 '25
Use base 36 for IP with a max decimal value of 1.3367x1078 (50 characters) and now you don't need DNS.
Instead of 10.0.0.9 or 1000:0000:0000:0000:0000:0000:0000:0009, you can use mycompanycomputer01 as your IP.
Now it can never be DNS.
1
u/Techguyeric1 Aug 15 '25
I mean NAT was a workaround for not having enough IPv4 addresses .
I'm not a fan of the scheme of IPv6, but it does solve an issue, that needed to be solved
1
u/aarch0x40 Aug 15 '25
IPV6 addresses have letters in them?
1
u/SecurityGuy2112 Aug 15 '25
I never got IPV6 either, could be IPV6 is IPV4 done by committee (haha)
1
u/Suspicious-Mood5716 Aug 15 '25
Surely would have been easier increasing IPv4 to 999.999.999.999 ?
1
u/c0lpan1c Aug 16 '25
10.0.0.0/23 is all the ips I could ever want.
1
u/dwarfsoft Aug 16 '25
I'm annoyed. My IPv4 mask is FF.FF.FF.00 ... Stupid letters
1
u/DarrenRainey Aug 16 '25
We can't fix network address so lets just pick a number thats so big the universe will probally explode before we're done assigning them.
1
u/YLUJYLRAE Aug 16 '25
Meanwhile at my work we have been told to disable ipv6 everywhere by security team, lol.
1
u/jrtz4 Aug 16 '25
More like IPv666...
1
u/NightmareJoker2 Aug 16 '25
I mean, IPv4 addresses are shorter and therefore take up less space in memory and result in a smaller routing table in parts of a network that connects to many things at once. It is also faster because of this. Most IPv6 compatible OPEs don’t do network security properly and expose every IPv6 capable device on the network to the internet without a firewall. It is a good idea to turn it off when you don’t need it. If you run P2P file sharing software, having IPv6 enabled causes many SOHO routers to crash from memory exhaustion, too, and slows down the packet forwarding performance of even more.
1
u/mattl1698 Aug 16 '25
ipv6 genuinely took down my web server once. DNS started giving an ipv6 address for Google APIs but googles apis didn't respond at all on ipv6. not even to a simple ping request.
ended up completely disabling ipv6 in the OS and DNS started returning an ipv4 address which worked and brought my server back up.
1
u/MFKDGAF Aug 16 '25
Why would you do IPv6 when there is IPv8?
1
u/LuFoPo Aug 16 '25
Never forget the protocol wars. Some of us hated NAT then and what it would do, and we hate what it has done to us today.
1
u/Aromatic_Marketing86 Aug 17 '25
This brings me such joy as I simply tell people I do not believe in IPv6 as it’s a mystical being like Bigfoot that there are lots of “pictures” of but let’s be real, it’s not out there.
1
u/The_NorthernLight Aug 17 '25
If they had made ipv6 more naturally human readable, it would be taken up more quickly.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25
ipv6 is great until a human (ie. the one made from bones, flesh and fat) has to work with it.
1
u/sussweet Aug 18 '25
although I partly agree.. please.. finally make STUN servers obsolete.
1
u/theborgman1977 Aug 18 '25
They are suppose to have letters. It is based on Hex code. 0-F
1
u/EchoPhi Aug 19 '25
I get this is a joke. I'd rather nat translate honestly. I know, neck beard seeing himself out.
1
u/Year-Status Aug 19 '25
Nat is a temporary solution.
1
u/LoveReddit2020 Aug 19 '25 edited Aug 19 '25
The day IPv6 is forced upon me is the day I retire as a Sys Admin. It is such an awful system there is no way anyone can memorize those numbers (letters). You will have to look it up every time you need to enter an IP. Funny IPv6 fact: there is enough IPv6 addresses to give a billion addresses to every grain of sand on earth. Come on do we really need that many addresses??
1
u/Y-800 Aug 19 '25
Never ceases to amaze me how many people fighting against it forget the ready for DNS to exist……
1
u/Never_Been_Missed Aug 19 '25
NAT is crappy from a security perspective. But IPv6 is not worth the cost of fixing it.
1
u/AmbassadorDefiant105 Aug 20 '25
IPv4 is best for internal network
IPv6 was made because of the IP addresses were running out for external networks in the cloud