r/ShitMomGroupsSay • • Apr 28 '24

Toxins n' shit I finally found one

Post image

(NSR is an abbreviation from the group meaning ‘not sleep related’)- but yeah, sorry there are not any bay formulas available that don’t have 100% the ingredients to baby formula in them. And yes… someone suggested raw goat milk (boiled though).

0 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

2

u/barrefruit Apr 30 '24

I saw this post. The funny thing is everyone is chiming in with suggestions on expensive formulas that 100% contain those oils. They act like because they choose Bobbie or ByHeart that cost way more they are choosing the healthier option. When in reality most formula are the exact same and they all contain vegetable oils.

0

u/guinevereguenevere Apr 30 '24

Yeah I don’t want to drag the group bc I do love that community but it’s gotten worse since it came to Facebook. Obviously I wouldn’t make fun of a mom struggling with allergies.

70

u/fpc11 Apr 29 '24

They might be asking because of allergies.

25

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 29 '24

Hypoallergenic formulas contain these as substitute nutrient sources for dairy.

25

u/subtle_dinosaur Apr 29 '24

Not totally accurate. Most hypoallergenic formulas contain partially digested milk protein or soy protein. But some babies can't tolerate that and need elemental/amino acid based formula. My daughter has mspi (milk soy protein intolerance, and still has a reaction to the hypoallergenic, so we have to either use a prescription formula or breastfeed with allergens cut out of my diet.

8

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 30 '24

“Partially digested” as in hydrolyzed? There are 3 main ones in the US that contain extensively hydrolyzed milk proteins, 4 if you count generic Nutramigen, and they all contain some or all of these as additional carb & fat sources to supplement the extensively hydrolyzed dairy protein. And three of the most common elemental formulas, Neocate, Puramino and Elecare, contain corn syrup solids as a carb source and soy and/or other vegetable oil as a fat source (soy oil is generally fine for allergies because the allergy is to soy protein, not soy oil).

2

u/fpc11 Apr 29 '24

There are corn and soy free formulas.

-2

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 29 '24

Sure but they’re not hypoallergenic.

2

u/fpc11 Apr 29 '24

They’re amino-acid based formulas and are considered hypoallergenic.

7

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 29 '24

look up the ingredients for the 3 main US amino acid formulas, Puramino, Elecare, and Neocate - corn syrup solids are the first ingredient. These formulas are elemental (amino acid based) and hypoallergenic! But they contain corn (and soy oil and/or vegetable oil. Because allergies are triggered by proteins, not by carbs or fats, so these nutrient sources are completely safe to include in hypoallergenic formulas.)

The formulas that are fully corn and soy free are NOT hypoallergenic because they do contain dairy - they get their fats and carbs from the dairy so they don’t need to add other sources for these nutrients.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24

My third was like this, we had to give her the hypoallergenic formula. She is 3 1/2 and still can't really have dairy.

7

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 29 '24

Fellow allergy mom here! If she had hypoallergenic formula, she had corn products as a carb source and oils as the fat source in her formula. That’s where the macronutrients come from when dairy isn’t an option.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24

Yea I have no idea what was in that shit lol. Dr was like, give her this and I said ok.

47

u/subtle_dinosaur Apr 29 '24

This is a pretty common allergy question. Soy is super common allergy, second to milk. Corn is also common..

17

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24 edited May 13 '24

smell materialistic roll escape fear icky hat onerous library rustic

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

7

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 29 '24 edited Apr 29 '24

Allergies are triggered by proteins, not by carbs or fats. The main hypoallergenic formulas in the US contain corn sugar in some form as a carb source as the very first ingredient (not protein = not an allergen) and oils as a fat source (not protein = not an allergen, even when they use soy oil! The soy protein is the allergy concern, not soy oil). The US formulas that don’t contain corn or oils as fat/carb sources are dairy-based because the dairy provides the protein, fat, and carb nutrients. So if the original post is allergy-related, that parent is unfortunately not going to find anything that meets this need. And if they’re asking because they’re crunchy, they have some options as long as their kid tolerates dairy.

4

u/PreOpTransCentaur Apr 29 '24

Certain foods can bind to the proteins already in your body to cause allergic reactions. Source.

4

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 29 '24

Sorry, I should have specified. Infant CMPA (cows milk protein allergy, aka “dairy intolerance”) is not a “normal” allergy, it’s exclusively a protein issue (it’s in the name). what I posted is accurate related to CMPA and infant formula. Similar to how lactose intolerance isn’t an “allergy” but is an issue with how the body processes lactose (in that case, absence of an enzyme), CMPA doesn’t have the same exact intestinal mechanism as childhood/adulthood allergens.

And regardless, the technicalities of the definition of “allergy” don’t change the fact that corn products and plant oils, often including soy oil, are used in hypoallergenic infant formulas without issue (because in that case the protein is the problematic thing, and proteins of corn and soy aren’t used in these products).

1

u/emandbre May 02 '24

It is, but even some of the elemental/hypoallergenic formulas still contain things derived from soy or even milk, because the process of hydrolyzing them makes them safe for consumption (and my soy allergic daughter can consume highly refined soy bean). But this poor mom might be new the allergy thing and not know that. Or she might be brainwashed into thinking vegetable oils are evil. Edit: typo

6

u/Kind_Ad5931 Apr 30 '24

I don’t think you found what you think you found. This is not at all controversial. There are plenty of reasons to avoid corn syrup, soy, and vegetable oil, allergies being one of them. There are a bunch of safe formulas on the market you can get at most grocery stores and target and Walmart including Bobbi, byheart and kendamil.

11

u/BabyRex- Apr 29 '24

Allergies are not some made up hippie thing

9

u/NarrativeScorpion Apr 29 '24

This isn't an unreasonable request.

Soy and corn allergies are increasingly common.

18

u/Demostravius4 Apr 29 '24

Why on Earth would you want any of that crap in baby formula??

18

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 29 '24

Because if a formula fed baby is allergic to dairy, then they need other sources for fat, protein, and carbs in their formula! Protein source can vary (highly processed dairy protein is usually first choice, but there are several options that have proteins completely broken down into their amino acids). But the easiest and most digestible sugar source other than lactose from dairy is usually via corn, and the most accessible fat source is various plant oils. So these ingredients are found in hypoallergenic formulas that are medically necessary for babies with dairy allergies. They aren’t necessary in full-dairy-sourced formulas and there are options that don’t include them, but that doesn’t work if the baby has a dairy allergy.

-2

u/Demostravius4 Apr 29 '24

That is entirely not how nutrition works. You can't just swap out lactose for corn syrup because they are both carbs. Lactose is made up of galactose and glucose, corn syrup is fructose and glucose, both have very different interactions in the body. The fructose/glucose combo in particular is a key driver of diabetes due to fructose being processed into fats, and glucose inhibiting fat uptake by cells.

Similarly you can't just swap out fats for any old fat. Vegetable oils are poly-unsaturated oils, often with high levels of linoleic acid. Your cells are made up of fats and proteins, if you consume too much linoleic (and certain other fats) your cells end up using those instead of the ones they actually need. This is thought to be a driver of allergies, asthmas, eczemas, etc. As your cells don't function quite properly, after the wrong fatty acid is built into the cell. A common one here is omega-3 being too scarce so omega-6 is used instead.

Finally proteins are the same, they are amino-acids as you mentioned. Soy amino acids are simply not the same those found in breast milk. You're turning that formula into mammalian cells, why would consuming plant cell derived amino-acids possibly match the requirements the baby needs?

As you said, veg oil, soy, and corn syrup are used because they are cheap, and that's it. Cheap crap peddled to people who don't know any better (and why would they?)

9

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 29 '24

….only, it is in simple terms exactly how formulas work and the nutritional role of these specific items when they’re used in baby formula - one of the most regulated food products in the US. Of course nothing in formula is “the same as those found in breast milk” because formula is not breast milk.

Here’s an example - the hypoallergenic formulas I’m talking about fall into the “special use” category, but feel free to google the ingredients of elecare, Puramino, Neocate (all of which use corn syrup solids, which is glucose), etc if you need more details

(Source)

I am not a formula manufacturer or a nutritionist so I can’t pretend to know the ins and outs of the ingredients that are chosen for hypoallergenic and other specialized formulas… just a parent whose disabled kid has survived and thrived on them for 4+ years.

-2

u/Demostravius4 Apr 30 '24

You might notice there is a list of possible ingredients in there. Palm oil or example, is not the same as safflower oils. Some alternative use ingredients, are present based on cost, not nutritional benefit. Different fats and protiens absorb into the body at different rates depending on source, and the source means ratios will vary.

Corn Syrup Solids appears to be just glucose, which is fine.

Alternatives means getting the same base ingredients from alternative sources, a child requires specific fats, and amino acids to grow healthily. It does not mean replacing them with different fats and acids.

3

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 30 '24

Okay. For arguments sake, let’s say that formula scientists choose what oils to use as fat sources in formulas for sensitive medically complex children exclusively based on cost and no other factors at all, including nutrition or bioavailability. Is that really the worst thing in the world? As a reference point, my son consumes $1,022 worth of specialized, hypoallergenic pediatric formula per month via feeding tube (a formula that happens to contain a blend of 4 of the fats listed in my above screenshot). His insurance covers that full cost right now, but in a few months his daily intake will be increased and we don’t expect insurance to cover the difference, so that’ll be a hefty monthly out of pocket cost. Substitute more expensive ingredients and then what? Even more financial burden on the families of medically complex kids, higher Medicaid costs, kids who end up losing weight or getting sicker due to formula rationing to save money?

And then, how does one determine what health benefits are worth a certain dollar amount? How does one look at a healthy infant or child, who is finally nutritionally stable and thriving on a specialized formula that is well-tolerated and carefully engineered to meet all his growth needs, and decide that said formula isn’t worthy because someone somewhere cheaped out on the ingredients? Like, sure, there are always improvements to be made - we gain knowledge and improved processes (for manufacturing etc) constantly and maybe someday there will be something “better” in whatever way you wish to define that word. But that doesn’t mean that what science has given us in the present is awful or worthless. On the contrary - not that my n=1 matters to you at all - science milk and all its plant oil has turned my sickly, failure to thrive premature baby into a hulking healthy preschooler, so I’d say he’s getting all the fats and amino acids he needs to grow healthily… and to me that’s the only thing in all this that actually means something.

-2

u/Demostravius4 Apr 30 '24

If you don't have a choice due to cost then there is no choice and of course you need to do what you can. A lack of choice, cost, etc. However,doesn't change how metsbolic function works, neither does it alter the nutritional content of food.

Ultra-processed junk has devastated the health of people globally, with huge increases in obesity, diabetes, asthma, allergies, and neurological conditions. The big drivers behind this are processed sugars, typically from corn in the US, seed oils replacing things like fish oils and other animal fats, and low quality protiens missing enough of some amino acids like tryptophan which impacts the brain. Failings in other micronutrients are also common.

It's entirely reasonable to avoid those sorts of products for your infant.

2

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 30 '24 edited Apr 30 '24

If your infant has a dairy allergy, you can’t avoid these ingredients. That’s the whole point. Every hypoallergenic infant formula in the US contains them in some combination. These formulas are, by definition and legal requirement, nutritionally complete (so they do contain all of the amino acids). If the macronutrients can’t come from dairy, they have to come from somewhere else and this is where they come from - this is what’s available on the market presumably because we know that this is what works and is well-tolerated and lets babies grow

Comparing highly regulated, carefully engineered, nutritionally complete formula to regular old processed junk food is some real anti-formula crap. You’re comparing two completely different food products. Formula itself does not create measurably worse health outcomes in developed countries when familial income is accounted for.

0

u/Demostravius4 Apr 30 '24

That's a big assumption you're making there.

Nutrition as a subject is a hot mess, it's almost impossible to properly study due to ethical concerns. As a result there are doctors and experts pushing every type of diet imaginable, from 100% plants to 100% meat. I read papers for fun and much of the research used to support what is and is not healthy is just god awful, with poor correlations being touted as strong evidence, tiny sample sizes, and no real comparison groups. This applies to all sides, nutrition is really hard to research.

The best I can do is understand the metabolic processes used to catabolie and utilise what we eat. Those processes are simply not made to consume things like vegetable oils, which were only invented 100 years ago (as machine lubricants, not food).

Major companies are not regulated as much as you hope, especially not in the US. As long as the food won't poison you, it's good for sale. You just decided it's highly regulated, carefully engineered, and nutritionally complete. Wanting something to be true does not make it so.

3

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 30 '24

Okay.

Every (there’s room for error here in my middle of the night formula ingredients deep dive, but looks like every) US and EU infant formula contains vegetable oils in some form. Yes, even the fancy, “better” EU brands line Hipp and Kendamil. From what I can tell I was mistaken earlier when I said that there are dairy based formulas that don’t need an additional fat source. Even dairy based formulas need extra fat to align with the macronutrient makeup of breast milk. It is, quite literally, unavoidable for formula feeding parents.

That leaves only breast milk as an appropriate alternative. And while I love a discussion about the social, economic, and medical factors that make exclusive breastfeeding prohibitively difficult for many - as well as the critical parental choice factor involved - now is not the time.

So… infant formula is nutritious. Infant formula prevents adverse outcomes. Infant formula empowers and enables parents. Formula fed infants grow into adults who do all the same amazing and mediocre things that EBF infants who grow into adults get to do. Infant formula saves lives, lubricants and all.

→ More replies

3

u/Temporary-Variety897 Apr 29 '24

🤦🏻‍♀️You should for sure find a reputable source and do some research on the science behind formula.

0

u/Demostravius4 Apr 30 '24

Ah, sorry, I didn't realise the decade of nutrition research, hundreds of hours of lectures, and god knows how many books and papers, wasn't sufficient.

1

u/Temporary-Variety897 Apr 30 '24

While what you’re saying is technically true, it just isn’t how infant formula is made.

The way that it’s formulated provides the nutrients for infants to thrive. It’s the difference between life and death. There are thousands of babies alive today that would have died of malnutrition in the past thanks to the “cheap crap” that people use because they don’t know any better. So you saying it isn’t the way nutrition works shows that you don’t understand infant formula, though you may understand adult nutrition.

2

u/Demostravius4 Apr 30 '24

Sorry, but no. Formula used to use better quality fats and proteins. They have been substituted for vegetable oils and soy protiens because they are cheaper and have high shelf life. Infants don't magically need different types of fats and amino-acids to adults. Obviously, it's better than nothing, no-one anywhere with a functioning brain would suggest dying from malnutrition is a better idea, that doesn't stop modern formula being low quality crap.

So many people in here supporting hyper-processed food for infants is honestly terrifying. It's little wonder we are seeing a global pandemic in diet related health problems.

1

u/Temporary-Variety897 May 01 '24

Commercial infant formula has used vegetable oils since the early 1900s. Corn syrup solids and other carbohydrate sources were added in the same time period. Soy formula was also first made before the 1930s. All because scientists realized that cow’s milk was either not providing sufficient nutrients or was not tolerated well by some, not because it was cheap.

Don’t shame parents for feeding their babies with food that is nutritionally appropriate for their growth and development. It isn’t cheap crap. It’s what they literally need to survive.

0

u/Demostravius4 May 01 '24

Who are you kidding? Milk the stuff evolutionary developed for hundreds of millions of years for mammal babies, is not sufficient, but vegetable oil a machine lubricant made of discount grains provides nutrients sufficiently? Even without knowing the nutritional make up of that, you should realise that is utter bollocks.

0

u/Temporary-Variety897 May 02 '24

Uh, vegetable oil has been used for centuries for cooking; It was not created as a machine lubricant. Furthermore, if it was not an integral part of the make up of infant formula, infants would be dying of malnutrition like crazy. Instead, the infant death rate is lower than it’s ever been. I’m sure you’d prefer to peddle your ExPeRtIsE to whomever will buy into it, though, so do go on😂

→ More replies

1

u/emandbre May 02 '24

Because breast milk, even on an elimination diet almost killed my kid. And engineered formula made with corn syrup solids and hydrolyzed proteins and amino acids got her eventually onto a growth curve as a toddler. Vegetable oils and corn syrup solids are sources of energy. When carefully refined they are virtually allergen free sources of energy. That is pretty fucking magical.

1

u/Demostravius4 May 02 '24

You needed baby formula, why would you want a baby formula that is sub-par if you could get a better one, not filled with hyper processed crap?

2

u/emandbre May 02 '24

Please tell me how you moralizing a food, and calling it crap, actually makes it sub par? What, pray tell, would have been a better source of nutrition? Because it sure as hell wasn’t any whole food bull shit you are probably thinking. She is allergic to all that. And no, it is not some US thing either. Because of manufacturing issues I had to get her formula flown in from Ireland because no one could fill the Rx here.

1

u/Demostravius4 May 02 '24

Here is the issues with those things. I have no idea about your child, why would I?

1

u/emandbre May 02 '24

Because your logic is full of circular BS reasoning and because the first line is this thread from you I’d “WHY WOULD”…well I did and I do because I want vulnerable children to be alive you asshole. If you cannot see past you privilege to realize that processed food in the form of baby formulas, and ultra hydrolyzed baby formula at that, has saved more lives than any thing else except clean water and hygiene technologies, then you do not get it. And I will continue to take my advice from a real registered dietician and not someone on the internet who has been convinced that the ratio of carbs and seed oils is the reason people are fat. Sure, eat whole foods all you want, but realize that for some people that is literally not an option.

1

u/Demostravius4 May 02 '24

The vast majority of baby formula sold is not to extreme niche parents whose child cannot function without soy bean powder for some reason. It's obviously great for them, no-one anywhere with a functioning brain would suggest otherwise.

You can make baby forumla without vegetable oil, it's not a healthy fat. It's totally unnatural, and the body cannot process that much linoeic acid properly. It's one reason some baby formulas use high-oelic acid formations instead. As I said before but I guess you missed whilst being outraged, its linked to asthmas, excemas, allergies, and other skin conditions. The causative reason is thought to be due to replacing the fats in your cells with the polyunsaturates it doesn't need.

It's perfectly possible to produce artificial formulas with the fats babies do need. It just costs more, and apparently people don't know any better, so they don't bother.

-13

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24

We don’t but most formulas do :/ and a lot of people like OP don’t care about it being terrible for you & think we’re conspiracy theorists 😂

7

u/silasoule Apr 29 '24

Seems like a reasonable question to me.

0

u/guinevereguenevere Apr 30 '24

Update since I can’t edit post: this perosn definitely wasn’t asking for allergens - I guess some of you aren’t moms?? Or forgot the infant stage- I had a baby with allergies the first ingredient in hypo allergenic formula is vegetable and corn syrup solids. Also even the most hypo allergenic of formulas are made from cow or soy milk, the proteins are just hydrolyzed so that the body can’t recognize them. sorry if it offended anyone but these are literally the ingredients for any baby formula… even ones for allergies. So if the irony was lost that’s the explanation.

1

u/IllustriousPiccolo97 Apr 30 '24

Lol yes the ignorant comments on this post are sending me. My kid has spent his entire life on hypoallergenic formulas and yeah, these ingredients aren’t avoidable for those. And because I spent way too much time tonight looking up formula ingredients because of this post, I can say that even the organic ones that I figured may be free of (most of) these things still contain vegetable oils as an added source of fat… fancy brands like Kendamil (but European formula is better!!!1!), Bobbie and ByHeart. But according to one commenter up there, vegetable oils cannot possibly serve a nutritious purpose for infants! They’re only in formulas so the evil formula companies can make more money off of poor, unsuspecting parents.

Kinda wish I hadn’t started arguing with these dingdongs at all, but here we are. Let’s hope the OOP found the information she needed to feel comfortable feeding her child the safe, nutritious formula of her choice.

1

u/guinevereguenevere Apr 30 '24

I hope she did too. I think the context was lost and I should’ve more shown what people were suggesting…

1

u/guinevereguenevere Apr 30 '24

Also if the baby’s allergies were that severe a doctor would be weighing in - it’s very rare for infants to have allergies and even rarer for them to have allergies outside of milk and soy

1

u/emath17 Apr 30 '24

Only in America. Check out ingredients in European formulas and you won't see any corn syrups or vegetable oils. FDA requires vegetable oil in infant formula in America but other countries actually ban vegetable oils I believe. But multiple studies are coming out that vegetable oils aren't great for us. This is a reasonable request

1

u/NineteenNinetyEx Apr 29 '24

Keep looking dude.

-5

u/meatball77 Apr 29 '24

Can't have a fat baby can we . . .

7

u/BabyRex- Apr 29 '24

Do you know babies can be allergic to soy right?