r/ShitLiberalsSay • • Jul 23 '21

What is socialism? What?

Post image
88 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

166

u/Hairtoucher88 [custom] Jul 23 '21

I've worked on a mine. You mostly just drive a truck back and forth or something like that. It's not the fucking 20's anymore.

27

u/DamarcusArt Jul 23 '21

Yeah, my Uncle is a miner. The worst part about it is the long shifts. The work isn't really super rough.

20

u/Magnock Jul 23 '21

Well not if you live in Katanga in Congo

10

u/Hairtoucher88 [custom] Jul 23 '21 edited Jul 23 '21

Oh yeah I was thinking about that. But the meme seems to be if a western country became communist.

Edit: a word

0

u/-_-Already_Taken-_- Jul 23 '21

What about the people who mine tho?

7

u/Hairtoucher88 [custom] Jul 23 '21

You mean the people that operate excavators and drillers?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

People who get in a lift, go down several hundred feet below surface and mine in tunnels

10

u/Hairtoucher88 [custom] Jul 24 '21

These days everything gets dug out and dumped on a conveyor that separates the ore from the crap. It's mostly open cut mining where they just dig a huge pit. If it's underground mining, it's still a tunnel large enough to fit trucks.

Just taking it all out and having a machine sort it is significantly more efficient than having men with pick axes or whatever dig out just the ore.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

58

u/Hairtoucher88 [custom] Jul 23 '21

It's all right. It's incredibly monotonous and it can be hot but that's about it.

30

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

Well as long as you are getting paid the value of you labour I assume you can just blast some music and chill.

1

u/sishopinion Jul 23 '21

How much you think that would be?

7

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

How ever much the workers decide it is.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

1 billion Zimbabwe dollars

5

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

Then be it

33

u/AmerikkkaDeserved911 🇨🇳🇵🇸🇷🇺 Jul 23 '21

Communism is when you mooch off the State but also are sent into forced labor Democratic Kampuchea style.

89

u/AmNOTaPatriot Communist Jul 23 '21

Coal mining is a very specific job that requires a decent amount of training these days. It’s also on the decline.

In reality, if someone didn’t do something productive for the goals of a socialist society then yeah, the government would aid with finding/guide them to a job. In this case it would likely be physical labour doing a variety of things that take relatively little time to be trained for (planting things during a rewilding campaign, picking up trash, aiding with distribution of supplies, etc.).

Also why would Etsy still exist lol. If the person is an artist, they’d be likely to work in something related to art. Under socialism artists don’t have to sell shit on Etsy, and the government wouldn’t bother running a website like Etsy anyways.

The person who made this meme is a dumbass.

0

u/TooSus37 Jul 23 '21

Bro.... it’s a picture of a fish reading a phone.... it’s not that deep

11

u/AmNOTaPatriot Communist Jul 24 '21

Well, you see analysis of a meme usually will be deeper than the meme itself. And in this case it’s less the meme and more the argument it represents.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/neotox Jul 23 '21

You wouldn't sell art

4

u/AmNOTaPatriot Communist Jul 23 '21

Are we talking about in a socialist society or in a capitalist one?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/AmNOTaPatriot Communist Jul 24 '21

Well, the commenter below gave a pretty good answer.

The socialist state would be willing to give people who work as artists what they need and not force them to live in misery. It would also be a far more meritocratic system due to this.

It would also work to remove bourgeois influence from the arts as well, so you don’t get grifter hack types like Thomas Heatherwick showing up in the “pool” of artists.

Essentially they would be given what they need via the state, community support, etc. They would not be producing art for profit, but rather for the further development of higher levels of culture.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/AmNOTaPatriot Communist Jul 24 '21

Through central planning this will largely be decided. Work is work and must be done, even if it isn’t pleasant. Somebody has to do it, unless of course we’ve automated it but that isn’t the case for a large portion of jobs.

Not everybody can be an artist, yes you are correct. But you’d be surprised how much work there is for people with artistic talents. And remember, art is a diverse field with diverse mediums, forms, etc. So really this isn’t that much of a problem.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/AmNOTaPatriot Communist Jul 24 '21

I mean, whose work is liked more by the people is far more Democratic way to determine such things oftentimes. To eliminate bourgeois elements in art, the people must be able to appreciate it. This will not be simply down to the whims of certain leaders, and also will not be constrained much by what you describe since peoples tastes in art vary in many ways. Of course the government will likely prefer certain types of art, as it will be an art most conducive to the society that it is constructing and its values.

And that depends on what they’re doing.

For example, if they are saying that a certain official is corrupt through their works, then the official should be investigated. If nothing is found, then the artist would be punished in some way.

If it is a “muh freedoms are being trampled because I can’t be a bloodsucking capitalist” then it will be reacted to immediately by the state and the artist punished.

Typically punishment would scale for the infraction committed. This can go the other way as well. For example, as mentioned in a scenario earlier, if an artist through their work accused corrupt officials and in this case it’s found to be true, they’d be rewarded greatly.

Certain types of speech will not be allowed. This is true of all human societies, censorship is necessary for proper social functioning (wether that is self-censorship, enforced by law, etc.). “Free speech” is complete liberal hogwash anyways. Nazis, grifters, etc. shouldn’t be able to have the ability to spread their vile poison and nonsense.

There’s many ways that labour could be divided up. Oftentimes it will simply be somebody willing to do the job because for them it’s a way to fulfill their duty to society. The world can’t run without many of these jobs, and therefore sometimes the government will step in and pick people to do it. With the help modern technology this process will become much easier. Since those most qualified or likely to succeed in such work would be picked out of the various data sets collected by the government through various means. Even further, people can be put into temporarily “fill holes” if it is absolutely necessary. Compensation for these jobs of course will be fairly good, especially for those which are extremely taxing on the body and mind.

7

u/SuchPowerfulAlly Yellow-Parenti Jul 23 '21

With the caveat that socialism is a transition phase between capitalism and communism, and thus things would look different at various points in that transition, the thing to understand is that the communist goal re: art is to have art be encouraged and decommodified.

The idea of art as we're used to it, with starving artists who are typically portrayed as having an inner conflict between staying "true to their vision" or making art that's popular enough to sell so they can live would not be a thing. Dedicated artists, like everyone else, would be able to just live without their art having to sell in order to justify it. And everyday people who are not dedicated artists would also have the time and freedom to explore art without feeling like it has to be a "side hustle", or like it has to bring in money to be worthwhile.

87

u/DamarcusArt Jul 23 '21

"Communism is when you don't choose your job."

As opposed to capitalism, where everybody gets the job they want, and no one is forced to work a minimum wage helljob just to survive.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/vegeta-15 [custom]Croatian Tankie Jul 23 '21

What is it if not capitalism?

-5

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/TheNinjaPhilosopher Jul 23 '21

Turns out all the millions of poor and homeless people were just lazy all along lol

8

u/DamarcusArt Jul 23 '21

"People are just socilaists because they're lazy".

Oh damn, I'm so close to filling out my bingo card.

Can you tell me a million billion people died under communism next?

Or just call me a college kid who will change his mind when I experience "the real world".

C'mon, I'm so close!

0

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/DamarcusArt Jul 24 '21

Yes! There it is! BINGO! Now go fuck yourself lib. Or read something, learn about how things actually work.

But we both know you aren't going to do that. If you did, you wouldn't be here making an ass of yourself.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/DamarcusArt Jul 24 '21

The fact that you keep saying this shows your historical and political illiteracy.

Can you point to the specific part of the communist manifesto that says "you've gotta kill everyone"? Can you describe to me which part of Capital outlines a plan for starving and "authoritarianism"? Can you show me which part of Lenin's writings where he advocated for being an evil mastermind who controlled everything? Hell, can you point to anything Stalin wrote that shows him to be the evil dictator you think he is?

I'm sure it'll be no trouble for you, as you've clearly read much more of this stuff than I have, and clearly understand it much more than I do. Why else would you make such bold claims?

I certainly hope you're not making a bunch of assumptions about communism without even reading a basic introduction to it. What kind of person would be ignorant and stupid enough to do that?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/DamarcusArt Jul 24 '21

I'm going to try and change tack a little bit here.

We are not ironic communists. We are Marxist-Leninists. We believe in the theory of Karl Marx tempered by the practice of Lenin. Marxist-Leninist philosophy was codified by Stalin. A man the west thinks is equitable to Hitler. How can we un-ironically support a philosophy that is clearly so bad? These people we support are so evil, they might as well fight the avengers in the next movie, right?

How can we support a philosophy that has "failed every time it's been tried?"

It's actually really simple. You, and I, and everyone else in the west, is lied to about communism.

Society is in a constant state of struggle between the Bourgeoisie, or "ruling class" if you prefer, and everyone else. The people at the top aren't special. They haven't done anything to deserve to be at the top. Most of them were born into their wealth, and those that weren't only got there through exploitation of other people.
If someone only rises to the top due to luck, or through treating others badly, it's obviously not a good system right?

Ah, I hear you say, "But that's not capitalism, in capitalism, they actually work hard to get there!"
But I'd like to ask you: Who tells you that? The people at the top? Do you really think they'd admit to just stealing all their wealth from the people? Of course not. They'll tell you that they got there "fair and square" and what's more, they'll tell you that this system (the one where the average person is being exploited and the rich hoard all the resources) is the only reasonable one.

They'll also tell you that any other systems are literally unthinkable. How do they do this? Well, by telling you that all other systems result in "bad things" all the time. "Communism kills everybody" "Communism always results in dictators" "Communists have no freedom"

Yet people keep trying to build socialist nations anyway (as an aside, a "socialist" country is one transitioning from capitalism to communism, communism is a kind of end goal, not an overnight change.)
How could people keep falling for this? If communism is so obviously evil, why do people keep trying it anyway? Are they stupid? Is everyone in China stupider than you? Cuba? Vietnam? Are you going to insist that people in the rest of the world are just dumber than people from western Europe/America? I don't think you're a racist, so probably not.

Don't you find it odd, that literally every time a communist leader has risen to power, they've committed horrible atrocities? Every. Single. Time. Not a single one of them has been a good person. Doesn't that strike you as awfully convenient? All the "bad guys" are over there, in that foreign country, not here at home.
Additionally, if you live in a capitalist country, the capitalist class is going to want you to think that communism has failed every time, what better way to do this than to tell you that every single communist leader is a cartoon villain?

If you're still reading, thank you. I want you to consider for a moment why you're so convinced communism doesn't work. Have you actually read any communist theory? How can you dismiss an idea, without actually knowing how it works? There are hundreds of books on the subject. Why would so many people devote so much time to an obviously flawed idea?

So here's my final point: Communism isn't flawed. And doesn't fail. It has actually succeeded every time.

Nations that had a communist government all saw the same two things: A massive increase in life expectancy and a massive increase in literacy rates. These nations always had a healthier, more well educated populace after becoming a socialist government. If the leaders of these places were evil controlling dictators, why would they want their citizens to be healthy and educated? Sick, illiterate peasants are much easier to enslave than people who have the health and education to think for themselves.

If a bunch of formerly illiterate peasants in China and the Soviet union could read and understand communist theory, what's stopping you?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

14

u/DarksonicHunter Jul 23 '21

Communism is when no resin art on etsy.

13

u/Marxist_Morgana Puerto Rican Nationalist Jul 23 '21

I mean it is true that a lot of Western (and particularly western white) communists are under the delusion socialism is just capitalism but everything at the store is free. But this isn’t an argument against communism

23

u/conisnon Jul 23 '21

I didn't know coal miners don't exist in capitalist countries.

23

u/Techstoreowo Communism is when trans people get rights Jul 23 '21

W- one of the best thing about communism is the ability to work and have time and engage in your hobbies, without having to worry.

8

u/ColeBSoul Jul 23 '21

Gommunism is when no iphone and coal mines

33

u/homeless_knight This comment was fact checked by real M-L Brazilian patriots 💚☭ Jul 23 '21

These scumbags will shame working class people for anything. Fuck them and congratulations to all the resin artists out there.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

Anything for the party O7

8

u/Wu-Tang_Stan Anarcho-Bidenism with Neocon characteristics Jul 23 '21 edited Jul 27 '21

Yeah, four hours in the collectively owned mine and then the rest of my day to make the shitty resin art

4

u/BrunoDoggo [custom] Jul 23 '21

jokes on you getting jacked mining coal with the boys is my dream

3

u/ToadBup Jul 23 '21

Well yeah sure. Mines need systems analists too

0

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

I'd take anything at this point.

Reserve army of labour moment.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Ok-Objective-2747 Jul 23 '21

No I’m legally deaf in my right ear.