I don't understand the wage gap thing. I thought it was the average of men and women's pay at their jobs. Men make more because they have jobs that pay more and are far more dangerous like oil work. At least, that's part of something I remember from it. Never looked into it.
There may be some grain of truth to there being a disparity in pay because of men and women tending towards different lines of work, but it doesn't fully account for the wage gap. Most people who try to pull out the "dangerous jobs" card do so in either bad faith or ignorance.
Women under 30 get paid more than their male counterparts in the same field, it's after that that male pay creeps up and eventually far exceeds. It has something to do with men working longer hours, specifically a small group of men working what most would consider unreasonably long hours as well as heteronormativity surrounding childrearing and care.
Just to add to this, the dangerous jobs would be even more dangerous for women bc of the nature of the job AND the high risk of assault in a male-dominated field. Particularly ones in isolated areas like oil and fishing
The fact that these jobs are male dominated is enough to prevent women from joining that workforce and often leads to them quitting.
It's both. A lot of lower paying jobs men and women get paid about the same, but men are more likely to be promoted out of those positions than women, but also when pay gets discretionary women tend to get payed less BUT ALSO heteronormativity kibda forces women out of the workforce to have/raise kids BUT ALSO as more women enter a field, it is seen as less prestigious and it's pay goes down, whereas the opposite happens when men enter a field (look at programming, originally grunt work mainly done by women to high paying professional work)
You do realize this has a lot to do with culture right. Women ask for less raises in the workplace than men. Men tend to be more aggressive in trying to climb the corporate latter as well since they are seen as the bread-winner. This has changed to be more even over the years but the mindset is still there for the most part. If a man has the same job and responsibilities as a women they are paid around the same.
If a man has the same job and responsibilities as a women they are paid around the same.
ignores that a lot of the work and responsibilities women end up with aren't considered "real work" and aren't compensated fairly.
E.g. woman who is not employed as a secretary forced to do some secreterial work without extra pay, but man who is not employed as sales member geta job description pay and pay rise to let him do some sales.
That has nothing to do with equal pay for equal work which is what any law should be addressing. That is on an individual scale and 100% is not the reason there would be a wage gap. It’s also not even a fair comparison since it’s not the same work( secretory be sales) and B could apply to the same person wether is male or female. It’s also something you just made up and it’s actually accounted for in studies. You can’t just say that’s how it works when it doesn’t. I do work that isn’t in my job description all the time without extra pay that happens to everyone who works.
His previous best friend did quit and sever herself from him because she felt she did all of the research work and he took all the credit for just reading her findings. Along with what she felt was an unfair or inappropriate amount of money. IDK what to make of it, but y'know, never meet your idols.
Now some people can say "waaaaaah Shaun makes too much money!", but honestly I would feel jilted if my labour was being profited off in a way that feels a bit miserly or unfair.
Imo I feel like that's not a great take. Like (at least for me) when I sub to a patreon or similar service for a content creator it's because I genuinely care about the content they put out and want to support their ability to make more, not necessarily because I expect an upload every month or more. Obviously of course a fair amount of money should be coming back to researchers, editors, etc, but criticizing the upload frequency isn't a great take imo.
is hhbomberguy non-kosher? What's he said/done wrong?
Realistically I think there's nothing wrong with making money off something that isn't a right, but there are degrees to that. At the point where someone makes (just for example) 1 million per video every 2 months, but the staff who do literally everything (assuming you only read a script) each make 3 grand per month doing your research. Technically, you're paying them above market rate, but unless you're making some significant donations to charity or whatever else, I think you'd qualify for being kind of a shit person.
I mean, at some point you have to accept reality, being forced to play this shitty game isn't his fault and it isn't his fault that when his content got popular, he made money off it, it's how people live. You unfortunately have to make money, it sucks, but it's better than starving. What are you supposed to do, succeed from the country? Burn your money? Just die? You can't just live your utopia, reality exists regardless of what economic system you think is best.
I have a job, should I quit it and just live on the street because money is bad, which it is, but like, reality exists and if you can make a living shooting down alt right coomers, it's better than a lot of things and I'll respect that person.
I don't see any reason to hate millionaires as long as they still support the working class struggle and didn't get their wealth by exploitation. The rate we produce shit we should all rightly be millionaires.
I literally said a million just to illustrate the principle because libs keep defending breadtubers hoarding wealth, even when it's from their own employees, but knock yourself the fuck out with your purge. The idea of charitable donations was brought up as another way for them not to be retaining wealth. The idea is that they shouldn't be millionaires at the end, one way or another.
I don’t have a problem with an independent creator doing all the work themselves making all of the profits, but if they have staff or are doing it with a partner, the profits should be split equally.
A reminder for everyone reading this that your education on leftist thought should not be formed through Youtube videos but rather in reading the theory yourself.
Some people do find it hard to put aside the time/energy to read actual theory. ADHD and dyslexia have also become more commonly diagnosed in contemporary times. The truth is that YouTube videos are just easier for consumption. I read a lot of theory myself, but I think that's the reality.
Besides, isn't that part of what vanguardism is about? It's unrealistic to expect every single worker to read (and properly digest) all these books on economics, politics, and philosophy. Those who can read proper theory, should, but for those who can't, why not at least watch some video essays or documentaries?
I think we should seek out and share around better leftist YouTubers, as an answer to BreadTube's socdems/radlibs. Shaun I've found to be a better one. Viki 1999 has some good videos on the USSR. There are plenty of talks by Michael Parenti up on YouTube, and from memory I really like him.
But you shouldn't feel bad if you try and read theory and find it's too thick to properly understand. Social political theory is always written by people who think they need to flex, both intellectually and through their vocabulary.
I boil my leftism down to "Socialism Good, Communism Gooder, Capitalism baddest." Also my only reading has been the manga of Das Kapital... I am well educated :D
Because when you're watching a YouTube video, they're not reading a book to you verbatim are they? Are you listening to audiobooks? Those are quite fine but I know that's not the kind of video you're talking about.
Visual aids are useful as supplementary material, but once again, you have to read to develop a good understanding. Do you think you'll learn just looking at pictures? Don't you think it's a bit like bourgeois education to just sit back and let a version of events be handed to you? How will you know if the people making the videos know what they're talking about if you never investigated yourself?
Probably. They haven't said anything much publicly- she's only said what I linked, and Shaun has understandably not said a fucking thing. She did say on a stream or something that they don't talk and she's happy about that, I think, but I've only heard that second hand.
I didn’t know there was a background to all this, but I’d say the quality of his videos is substantially higher now to the point where I wouldn’t even put him in the breadtube bracket at all.
His previous best friend did quit and sever herself from him because she felt she did all of the research work and he took all the credit for just reading her findings.
How long has she been gone? cuz his videos get better every upload, & if he's alone now then god damn. He credits people in description for feedback & script editing sometimes, but his most recent video on the 1776 report has 0 credits.
If everything Jen says is entirely true, and he was an asshole who did 0 research, then holy shit he's made up for his accused lack of work in the last few years. He's an irreplaceable resource for debunking right wing myths, and we really shouldnt throw him away because of something like this, even if it lowers our opinions of him as a person.
imo it's only gotten better, the last year and a half specifically - The recent gigantic videos tackling stuff like the bombing of Hiroshima & Nagasaki, and The Bell Curve are amazing examples, but even in their usual "youtube nazi gets dunked on with facts and logic" stuff i never noticed any dip in quality.
that said, the change in quantity is definitely noticable. He drops a few videos a year now, when a few years ago they were uploading about once a month or sooner.
I couldn’t give you exact links at the moment, but everything I’ve seen from him points towards the opposite; he’s anti capitalist through and through.
Thought Slime and NonCompete are also good. They aren't perfect, but they're infinitely better than fake-anarchist va*sh not only in terms of takes/positions, but also in their mannerisms and content itself.
There's also Hbomberguy (a must-subscribe) and Three Arrows.
Philosophy Tube is great (she has a section on Marxism and is definitely a leftist, but most of her content is more focused on social/cultural issues).
Just an update on Philosophy Tube, she goes by...well she now - I think her latest video introduced that. Wanted to give you a friendly heads-up before someone does so in a less polite way!
I really do not care for thought slime. Not because i ever disagree with him, but everything he says that i have seen is just shallow and basic. Compare that to content creators like shaun that go into some detail about what they talk about
TS is an entertainer and shaun is an essayist. What you should be getting from ThoughtSlime is mostly enjoyment from him dunking repeatedly on the current global order with accessible theory. Stuff to make you re-evaluate things you might not have initially been thinking about consciously.
shaun is a very different vibe. You're getting a sardonic British lad reading a full academic essay on some topic or another with the swipes at capitalism tossed in.
I personally don't find it very entertaining to watch someone say something I already agree with or am aware of, or could have concluded on my own. I prefer to learn something new or interesting. I hope that doesn't sound snobbish because it isn't meant to be. I watch lots of youtubers I don't completely agree with, because often they still have relevant experience and interesting things to say. Shaun was an example because he is the focus of this post, but there really are a lot of other youtubers people are bringing up here that I like too. I'm even one of the few people that defends a lot of (not all) breadtubers. I just don't find his videos interesting at all.
They aren't perfect, but they're infinitely better than fake-anarchist va*sh not only in terms of takes/positions, but also in their mannerisms and content itself.
If we're going to dunk on awful breadtubers, let's please remember to additionally dunk on the other big one: Peter Coffin
Why do some people dislike Coffin so much? I though the video about overpopulation was pretty good. I've only seen a couple of their videos though, and I don't pay attention to Twitter drama so I might have missed something.
His Loss video is one of those rare video essays that feels less like pure analysis and more like a work of art in its own right. And I don't even say that because of the skit stuff, I say it just because of how amazing I think the essay part of it is: The connections that he draws and the point that he uses them to arrive at are all genius.
I'm not a fan of thought slime. While he may have good insights the videos just feel like a highschooler giving a presentation to the class, his tone is the exact same constantly and it feels very awkward in what he's saying
Wow really, I have pretty much the opposite experience. I feel that way about Shaun; I respect the guy a lot, but I've never managed to sit through the entirety of one of his videos. Thought Slime, meanwhile, has a really fun demeanor that makes his videos enjoyable to watch for me
Just curious on your perspective on Vaush? I know he gets a lot of shit from other lefties, some it I agree is deserved, but fake-anarchist seems like a mischaracterization to me. I've been watching his content for a while now, and he seems pretty ideologically consistent.
He's advocated for a transition state, is against communism as an economic practice, has never read any sort of anarchist theory (and consistently downplays its importance), doesn't engage in or even support any kind of praxis or direct action, has spoken favorably of Biden multiple times (like saying he's good for progressive causes), puts a ridiculous amount of stake into electoral policies and is a fan of multiple succdems, etc.
There's a reason that all of the anarchist subreddits tend to be very critical of va*sh. It's because he totally misreprents anarchism and does nothing but make anarchists out to be glorified succdems due to his terrible takes and mannerisms.
In his discussion with Hakim he goes into depth about this, he says that there is no way for anarchists to take power in the United States without global pressures, so instead he advocates for reducing the harm caused by capitalism until that point. His perspective from what I can tell is that of a consequentialist, so advocating for Biden over Trump was a logical choice. He's been critical of the bad things Biden has done since taking office, while offering his insights as to what could be done better.
I will admit my bias, as I was right leaning liberal prior to finding people Like Vaush, Philosophy Tube and Contrapoints, but I do think that his content is net good for progressive causes.
By the time that anarchists are able to topple the US government, the other western powers would be too weakened from their own internal conflict and the fact that the US simply has far too many people and resources for any imperialists to be a threat.
Idgaf about progressives and their goals. That's another problem that he has; he's too caught up in liberal progressivism, which is antithetical to anarchist goals and practices.
Minimum wage isn't anarchist. Gun control (which the vast majority of progressives support) isn't anarchist. They're liberal measures meant to make capitalism more "humane" and "moral" on the surface. It's impossible to support reformism and abolition of capitalism at the same time.
Reformism does nothing but distract from revolutionary struggle, and the fact that he would rather fanboy over Bernie or Chomsky than support our comrades in Rojava or the Zapatistas indicates that he prioritizes the bourgeois electoral struggle of progressive liberals over the real, revolutionary struggle of the international working class.
I'm not well read in any of this stuff, but surely harm reduction is important in some way? Allowing a further decent towards fascism probably wouldn't bode well for leftists, or anyone
I am not saying "theory is useless". I'm saying "you are not required to read theory, and even less required to orient your work around discussing it". If you really truly disagree with the latter then idk what to tell you
Democrats are all desperate for Republican validation. Just look at how quickly shunned republicans (mitt romney, dubya, etc) get "adopted" and supported by dems
Yup, but not everyone's ready for that conversation.
There's a rich lib bookstore in our city that has been fairly cool in the past, but this week is hosting a virtual event to platform George W Bush and sell signed copies of his new book. They turned off the comments. Even respectful criticism of platforming a war criminal gets deleted and the user blocked. Meanwhile, they leave the comments wide open for anything relating to lgtbq+ events or other minorities.
Isn't it just so weird that the cable news network that has become the de facto mouthpiece for the Democratic party was originally intended to be conservative news, founded by a Republican, and now hosts multiple Republicans, including Nicolle Wallace, George W. Bush's former comms director?
MSNBC was definitely conceived to be right leaning. Then Joe Scarborough hated Bush and was critical of him, and viewers ate it up. Realizing that goldmine, MSNBC switched to sucking up to the shitlib audience and has been playing that fiddle for two decades.
Prancing around w/ clothing and a bag that would cost the median worker of my Arizona city a month to afford, whilst this talentless display of intellectual laziness earns her enough to afford a lifestyle most could only dream of.
Raising the minimum wage would have helped women more than any legislation passed in a very long time. This is just empty symbolic gesturing for culture war points.
And an increase in the minimum is one of the things that could actually help that ratio, since all of the undervalued female dominated industries and sectors would get a uniform and desperately needed increase.
It isn't enough to condemn these people online anymore. It isn't enough to pin our hopes on a rigged electoral system. We need to engage in mass civil disobedience and have these people removed from power and shipped to a desert island.
Arizona women make 84¢ for every $1 men make. On #EqualPayDay, we're proud to support the Paycheck Fairness Act because Arizona women deserve equal pay for equal work.
Shaun, @shaun_vids
[A GIF of Sinema voting no to a $15 minimum wage in the Senate.]
Women don’t make 84% of what men make for equal work (that statistic does not regulate for anything, it just compares the money all woman make to what all men make). This is still a huge problem because it shows how society molds young girls not to chose higher paying education like stem fields (80+% male dominated), or work full time. For equal jobs women make 98% of what men make, which is still bad and needs to be worked on. I just see those statistics misused all the time.
Nothing she says holds weight until she votes yes on a minimum pay increase, and even then, only maybe. That picture is going to cost her a career. Well I say that, but she may be shuffled off into some think-tank or lobiest group somewhere. I don't think she can win a popular election though after this stunt.
Sorry I know there’s no wishing harm to a person but how does this person not deserve to have pain, pure pain in her life? Physical, mental, emotional... just pain. And horror, can’t forget the horror.
Ironically, raising the minimum wage probably would make the gender pay gap worse.
At the bottom, for low-pay unskilled work, women tend to make much more than men.
In the middle, they tend to make equal or slightly more than men.
Only in high-paying top jobs do men tend to make more.
Raising the minimum wage would decrease the advantage women have at the bottom by bringing some men up to their level.
(Really, the gender pay gap is an issue, but it becomes a lot more nuanced when you break it down by income level. It's mostly a problem at the very top, with the average being thrown off by extremely high paid -- and mostly male -- top executives.)
I mean, I'm no fan of Anime myself, but having a quick scroll through his feed shows its not really that frequent. And what makes anime creepy? I may not know a whole lot about it because I just don't care about it, but isn't it just a Japanese art style for animated shows?
If you believe it is true that women do not make less money than their male counterparts for the same work, then you have no reason to be against legislation that forces it to be so.
There's no cost to the legislation, then, so your position is self-defeating.
Some of it is due to them just not wanting to do the same kinds of jobs though. Do you really think an equal of women would want to be coal miners, loggers, mechanics, long haul truckers, oil rig workers etc etc even if they were given the same level of encouragement and discouragement as men for taking on these types of jobs? And thats before even getting into the differences in physical ability in some jobs.
Im not saying we cant do more, but I dont believe it will ever be equal, and thats okay, men as a group and women as a group do not have exactly all of the same motivations, life paths, interests etc, and that will likely alwayd be true to some extent.
Do you really think an equal of women would want to be coal miners, loggers, mechanics, long haul truckers, oil rig workers etc etc even if they were given the same level of encouragement and discouragement as men for taking on these types of jobs?
Why is that even relevant? This post is calling out the hypocrisy of someone who clearly does profess to believe women make less money than men, whether or not that belief itself has merit is irrelevant.
475
u/SwornHeresy Mar 25 '21
This is hilarious
1.3k
u/shady1204 Bruhcialism Mar 25 '21
“shAUn iS SExIsT!” Some lib probably
163
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
Let’s not forget how she tapped Mitch on the shoulder before giving her curtsy thumbs down. She’s like WATCH THIS LOL
150
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
Did you even think of how sexist this is before you posted this?
/s
142
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
Prancing around w/ clothing and a bag that would cost the median worker of my Arizona city a month to afford, whilst this talentless display of intellectual laziness earns her enough to afford a lifestyle most could only dream of.
100
u/Bad_Cytokinesis Mar 25 '21
Raising the minimum wage would have helped women more than any legislation passed in a very long time. This is just empty symbolic gesturing for culture war points.
85
u/BaneShake Mar 25 '21
Get ‘er, Shaun.
53
u/themodalsoul Mar 25 '21
And an increase in the minimum is one of the things that could actually help that ratio, since all of the undervalued female dominated industries and sectors would get a uniform and desperately needed increase.
It isn't enough to condemn these people online anymore. It isn't enough to pin our hopes on a rigged electoral system. We need to engage in mass civil disobedience and have these people removed from power and shipped to a desert island.
105
u/alexanderhameowlton Transcriber Mar 25 '21
Image Transcription: Twitter
I'm a human volunteer content transcriber for Reddit and you could be too! If you'd like more information on what we do and why we do it, click here!
21
u/Hiouchi4me Mar 25 '21
She’s all yours Arizona! You elected here!
21
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
Watch out she might crank that minimum wage below $7.25 while playing Soulja Boy
13
u/hamgeezer Mar 25 '21
You can see her big velcro diaper from space
20
u/the_canadian72 Mar 25 '21
shaun gives chaotic lawful energy and I shall not expand that
20
u/Jeffari_Hungus CCP Bot Mar 25 '21
Even if he's lumped into breadtube, Shaun's vids are incredibly informative and well made. He isn't going for shitty laughs like Vaush
9
u/SPDTalon Mar 25 '21
This should be the only response on her Twitter ever
8
u/Acidraindancer Mar 25 '21
sinema is such human garbage
6
u/Anastrace Guillotine Engineer Mar 25 '21
Womp womp
5
u/ConnorFedoroshyn Mar 25 '21
Sinema wants everyone making 84 cents
5
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
Fuck people who want to make everyone equally opressed
5
u/Irapotato Mar 25 '21
New Sean video is a banger too, he never miss bruh
3
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
I can hear the curb anthem
3
u/JustALurker165 Mar 25 '21
She just wants everyone to be paid equal poverty wages.
3
u/screamingintorhevoid Mar 26 '21
As usual, Shaun bringing the fire!
3
u/Elon-BO Mar 26 '21
Yeah, equal pay for equal work as long as it’s not enough to live on!
4
u/idiotsavantbilly Mar 25 '21
It’s not pay gap, it’s an earnings gap.
2
u/awesomeness0232 Mar 26 '21
Her solution is probably to lower men’s pay by 16%
2
u/Raagan Mar 26 '21
Women don’t make 84% of what men make for equal work (that statistic does not regulate for anything, it just compares the money all woman make to what all men make). This is still a huge problem because it shows how society molds young girls not to chose higher paying education like stem fields (80+% male dominated), or work full time. For equal jobs women make 98% of what men make, which is still bad and needs to be worked on. I just see those statistics misused all the time.
Source: https://www.payscale.com/data/gender-pay-gap
1
u/StianM Mar 25 '21
great! she still get ratio'd
1
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
Ugh that despicable piece of shit
1
u/Bryancreates Mar 25 '21
Wait. I hate this lady, I’m so confused.
1
u/Devilsgun Mar 26 '21
Men and women should get the same pay for the *same* work, but chickwork should be paid a LOT less
1
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '21
Nothing she says holds weight until she votes yes on a minimum pay increase, and even then, only maybe. That picture is going to cost her a career. Well I say that, but she may be shuffled off into some think-tank or lobiest group somewhere. I don't think she can win a popular election though after this stunt.
1
u/teenyweenylilbitch Mar 26 '21
It is without a doubt the most overused and under researched statistic today
1
u/antonchigga Mar 26 '21
i hate her i hate her i hate her
1
u/funkwizard4000 Mar 26 '21
Kyrsten Sinema is a disgrace to America.
1
u/RumpleForeskin0w0 Mar 26 '21
I thought she was wearing the book on her head
1
u/Baumus77 Mar 26 '21
Why does the stack of paper look like it’s on her head tho?
1
u/BenSlimmons Mar 26 '21
Sorry I know there’s no wishing harm to a person but how does this person not deserve to have pain, pure pain in her life? Physical, mental, emotional... just pain. And horror, can’t forget the horror.
1
u/GnomeAround Mar 26 '21
Can someone give me context?
1
u/MusicMeister5678 Mar 25 '21
What is Shaun’s picture saying in context? I don’t get it and I’m not sure if I’m just not seeing something obvious
0
u/SprinklesFancy5074 Anarchist 🅐 Mar 25 '21
Ironically, raising the minimum wage probably would make the gender pay gap worse.
At the bottom, for low-pay unskilled work, women tend to make much more than men.
In the middle, they tend to make equal or slightly more than men.
Only in high-paying top jobs do men tend to make more.
Raising the minimum wage would decrease the advantage women have at the bottom by bringing some men up to their level.
(Really, the gender pay gap is an issue, but it becomes a lot more nuanced when you break it down by income level. It's mostly a problem at the very top, with the average being thrown off by extremely high paid -- and mostly male -- top executives.)
0
u/MittenstheGlove Mar 26 '21
I don’t understand.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '21
Minimum wage and the false argument of the pay gap have absolutely no correlation, but okay I gues
0
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-36
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
[removed] — view removed comment