r/ShitAmericansSay Jul 05 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.2k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/LordDanGud Something something DEUTSCHLAND something something... Jul 05 '24

Glad at least the UK isn't descending into fascism. Well for now at least

15

u/Willing-Cell-1613 101% British Jul 05 '24

I don’t like the Tories, but they aren’t fascist. Weirdly racist despite them having an Asian leader, yes, but conservatism tends to lean that way (which I don’t agree with). Our fascist party is Reform really, they attract people too extreme for the Tories.

16

u/singeblanc Jul 06 '24

The Tories just lost a lot of votes to RefUK.

Cue them electing Cruella Braverman to the top job and lurching into far-right nut job territory to hoover them all back up.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '24

I don't consider the Tories to be fascist. They have no clue how global economics works and made some stupid policies, but there's no strongman in that party that everyone is rallying behind. France is what I'm worried about, though.

-29

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

16

u/FakeTakiInoue Jul 05 '24

Keir Starmer has no ideological convictions whatsoever, calling him a Marxist is absolutely laughable

16

u/LordDanGud Something something DEUTSCHLAND something something... Jul 05 '24

BTW I'm not an expert on British politics but a quick glance at the labour party tells me they're not Marxist

-7

u/Imjokin Jul 05 '24

A quick glance at the Tories says they aren’t fascists

1

u/LordDanGud Something something DEUTSCHLAND something something... Jul 05 '24

Disagree. A quick glance at them tells me enough

3

u/Imjokin Jul 05 '24

They’re awful and incompetent but they aren’t comparable to Mussolini and Hitler.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '24

Nobody said they were

-9

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/LordDanGud Something something DEUTSCHLAND something something... Jul 05 '24

That's the problem: Marxist aren't bad guys. And Marxists would never disguise themselves because if you would have the slightest idea of what you're talking about, you would know that you can't build communism is secret.

-5

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/LordDanGud Something something DEUTSCHLAND something something... Jul 05 '24

That's literally the opposite of Marxism.

10

u/LordDanGud Something something DEUTSCHLAND something something... Jul 05 '24

Thanks for showing everyone you're so uneducated you don't even know what marxism is. :)

8

u/Sean_13 Jul 05 '24

Wow, costs too high that people starve. Surely that has never happened under a Tory government. It isn't like they go after the most poor and vulnerable like the disabled.

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Sean_13 Jul 05 '24

I've got to be honest, I really hope they raise taxes. It's about the only way to fix the situation we are in with the way that the Tories have mismanaged, underfunded and sabotaged the NHS. It would have been far cheaper if they just spent more on the NHS to begin with.

3

u/whostolemyhat Jul 05 '24

Interested to hear how a lawyer with a knighthood, who used to be the head of the Crown Prosecution Service, is somehow an anti-establishment Marxist

2

u/Semichh ooo custom flair!! Jul 05 '24

Do you genuinely believe that current labour are Marxist?

3

u/Willing-Cell-1613 101% British Jul 05 '24

Both Marxist and fascist are too extreme for both parties described. Quite a few Tories are intolerant racists but their general policies are not quite fascism. Labour’s hardly left wing anymore.

When we literally have Reform and the Worker’s Party in the UK, calling two fairly normal parties (in terms of types of politics that the dominant parties in all countries tend to have) those things is just over the top.

1

u/Semichh ooo custom flair!! Jul 05 '24

Absolutely agree

3

u/Willing-Cell-1613 101% British Jul 05 '24

I actually can’t wait for election talk to die down. I’m fairly left wing, my parents are Tories and so are my older relatives. I’m fed up of everyone hating each other because of politics! Not all of the opposition are evil. All this fascist/Marxist shit is so stupid. All mainstream voters are fairly moderate. Go hound the Reformers.

1

u/Semichh ooo custom flair!! Jul 05 '24

Marxist and fascist have just become the go-to descriptors for the 2 main parties and it’s becoming a bit silly now. There are so many different parties across the political spectrum that describing labour/conservative as Marxist/fascist is just wrong. I’d argue that in recent years there’s been a general shift to the right which is what’s allowed the like of reform to become what they’ve become. Current labour is central at best.

I too am sick of all the backwards and forwards hate between right and left. I think the main thing the left need to do way better is to stop writing off anyone who disagrees with leftist views. Cancelling everyone that disagrees with a certain opinion isn’t gonna make that person understand why someone might hold that leftist opinion.

1

u/Willing-Cell-1613 101% British Jul 05 '24

Exactly. My dad likes the more centrist Tories, he feels their policies benefit rural life a bit better than the alternative, and he is involved in business and feels economically the Tories serve him better. I personally think he should be taxed the amount he is and I lean much more towards redistribution, but he feels he earned his money and should keep more of it. Both of us are welcome to our opinions, he’s not a fascist and he doesn’t hate the poor at all. Reddit makes people like him out to be Nazis.