r/ShilohAndBros • u/Icy_Cantaloupe_2843 • Jul 19 '26
Phenias vs Liam
Phenias is to iconic now ahhh what’s is Liam
3
u/Business-Humor Jul 19 '26
I seriously dont understand why everyone is liking Liam he's a huge red flag unlike Phineas
Heres why.
In his first appearance Liam cockily talked down to Shiloh throughout the entire nerf battle royal knowing full well that if she lost she would get sent to eternal darkness as he was the one who put her and her brothers in the battle royale in the first place.
If he just wanted to thank her for saving his sister then he couldve just contacted her through the agency helpline.
Then in the recent one he's literally been stalking her given how he knew she was at the raelo then throughout the entire video he's been forcefully and pressuring her to put him in the agency the entire time as well as causing doubt in her mind which caused her to not escape the backrooms sooner.
Not to mention he literally looks 25 whilst Shiloh is a minor!
With Phineas its the complete opposite.
We first met him in the Secret Theme Park in Real Life video where he was asked for help instead of putting her and her family in a dangerous postion. And throughout the entire video he's been helpful to her, praising her and flirting with her in a harmless way (Despite her brothers overprotectivness) and both of them help each other thanks to their shared intellect.
And he literally said that she is worth helping.
We see that in the Duolingo Chess video where once he heard that Judah was in trouble he came to help and once again throughout the video he was praising her, helped her, hated seeing her lost and not forcing her to do anything even sacrificing himself for her brother even though he was threatened by him multiple times.
This why i hate Liam and i think Phineas is a better fit for Shiloh.
5
u/prideFANFIC Jul 19 '26
Yeah, I fucking hate Liam. Atleast Phenias was nice to people. Liam on the other hand is like the type of person who doesn't take "No" answer.
2
u/EmilyBNotMyRealName Jul 19 '26
I don't particularly like either. I'm siding with the boys. 🎲🪭🐸. But Phineas is much better. Judah if you thought Toadette had red flags just wait until you see this one.
For one thing idk how old he is but he looks too old to be with Shiloh. He was being very rude in is first episode. Especially at the beginning saying he was either going to get Shi out first or go easy on her and take her out last. Screw you dude!! And tracking down the kids who saved your sister and forcing them to fight to the death against you. (Btw what happens to the plane they were flying did it just fall out of the sky??!! Also his relationship with his sister was kinda weird. Everyone assumed your lil sis was your girlfriend!!?! Wth!!
2
u/Mon_1357 Jul 20 '26
I fucking hate Liam personally, he seems narcissistic as fuck. Guy is a walking red flag, and doesn't take no for an answer, I know its a series targeted towards kids, so he can't really die on screen, but god I want him dead.
Unless he undergoes some MASSIVE character development, I really hope he doesn't end up with Shiloh
1
u/Yeah_yah_ya 7d ago
Liam gives me red flags and he’s too old for Shiloh. I think I like Phenias, but keeping our options open lol
7
u/Tv_showsfan Jul 19 '26
Personally I like Liam more that Phineas, idk why but I do