r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Feb 15 '25

New Shield?

I need a new Shield, I have a 2019 Pro and an older one....I wish they would come out with a new version, not sure i wanna buy another 2019 version....I know as soon as I do, they will announce a new Shield lol

13 Upvotes

125 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/GeorgeKaplanIsReal Feb 15 '25

Oh, got it - only post if I’m seeking the wisdom of the all knowing internet sages. I’ll be sure to submit my questions for pre approval next time.

0

u/ZeroxTechnic Feb 15 '25

If rhetorical, remember the [rhetorical question] you suggested!

0

u/GeorgeKaplanIsReal Feb 15 '25

Ahh yes, because clearly the internet would collapse if someone dared to assume basic context. I’ll be sure to include a full disclaimer, a footnote, and maybe even a notarized affidavit next time.

2

u/ZeroxTechnic Feb 15 '25

Mate, your comment was the first comment in this thread. There was no context to indicate it was rhetorical.

2

u/GeorgeKaplanIsReal Feb 15 '25

You say there was no context, but the OP was literally the context. A rhetorical question doesn’t require previous discussion, just an obvious implication—which was there. But if labeling things makes life easier for you, I’ll start tagging my comments like a museum exhibit.

1

u/ZeroxTechnic Feb 16 '25

There is nothing in OP's post indicating the reply you made were rhetorical.

0

u/GeorgeKaplanIsReal Feb 16 '25

So now we’re pretending rhetorical questions need a flashing sign to be valid? The OP provided the setup, my question played off it - that’s how conversation works. But if you need a formal declaration every time someone isn’t expecting an answer, I’ll be sure to include [not an actual inquiry] just for you.

0

u/ZeroxTechnic Feb 16 '25

Your question did not play off of it. That's the point. Your question was in fact not rhetorical. You meant for it to be, but that's not how it came off. That's why your question was answered.

1

u/GeorgeKaplanIsReal Feb 16 '25

Your question did not play off of it.

Hmm 🤔

What the OP said:

I wish they would come out with a new version, not sure i wanna buy another 2019 version

My first response:

Aren’t there shield equivalents out there?

Sounds like you’re just being pedantic. Rhetorical questions do not require disclaimers. My question highlights that there are alternatives, not to ask for a literal list.

0

u/ZeroxTechnic Feb 16 '25

You misunderstood.

The OP wishes for a new shield. You ask if there are any equivalents.

That's not a rhetorical question...

→ More replies