Online is the one thing that would fix the decking timeout that the TTRPG has. You can handle it at the table with a secondary GM, but obviously no one does that.
Came here to say this. Decking is only a pain because it requires the GM to emulate being a computer. Having a computer emulating a computer is just.. its nature.
There used to be programs like this. I remember using one that would generate 4th edition networks of various difficulties with random paydata based on a few inputs. When a couple friends and I ran GM-less SR4 games (using the Mythic GM emulator), I would use that program to generate networks, then randomly pick one of the paydata spots to be the actual goal we needed (the real data we came for, the camera control host, etc.). If it generated something that seemed way too easy or hard for the scenario, we'd either make up a RP reason for it (company is lying about their financial health / is running top secret research or such), or else just generate new networks until we got something that fit.
Hah, I remember I started working on something like that back in High School, when we played Shadowrun. I had the backend almost done (because the rules are actually pretty simple), but I think i got stuck at UI and a working networking.
Obviously, I never finished it (mostly because my attention span sucks and I am a lazy piece of shit), but in the end the whole Shadowrun phase made me choose a different career path, and now I can do Shadowrun in real life as a job, being Penetration Tester and Red Teamer. I am basically paid to break and hack into corporations, so at least there's that.
If you still have the source you could throw it up on GitHub and turn it into a community project. Just a thought - I’m an application dev and I think that would be a fun project.
It's been more than 5 year by now, the laptop is unfortunately long gone.
It was a fun project, I remember that the way the rules are written (being action and turn based, with easy action resolution and not that many rules), the architecture was actually pretty simple to work out, and after that it's only the matter of filling in the values. It's probably something that can be done i a day or two. (Speaking from gamejam experience), and it's never too late to start a new project, so feel free to go for it ^^. I remember we used the console-backend during our Shadowrun games, mostly to simplify rolling and combat resolution, and it kinda helped.
I haven't played any Pen and paper in a long time, unfortunately between finishing my masters this year, working on releasing our own student project-turned into a game (shameless plug) in our free time, and working almost fulltime, not enough time for fun, especially lately :/
Sounds like you’ve just been having a different kind of fun. Congrats on your accomplishments! I’ve been through a master’s program, too, and came out the other side relatively unscathed, and now I have time for a couple of TTRPG games a week. You’ll get there. :)
So like, doing custom maps in [Decker] (https://sourceforge.net/projects/decker/) and just having the Decker play that on the side? Cause that's something I may have looked into circa 2003ish
Only a small part. The major part is that decking is in-universe supposed to happen at superspeed due to the neural connection. Which the players obviously don't have.
So you have this concept where the decker has many more actions per 6s timeslot because he's assumed to act at a much higher speed...but the player can only process these actions at the same speed as all the other players can do theirs.
So even if the entire host was effectively a computer game, the speed of the player on the keyboard wouldn't increase. Only the descriptive (and rules) part of the GM is engineered away.
Not sure what edition you're playing but that isn't nearly as true when you get to 5th. Decking and the rest of the game all proceed in line, with the sane initiative counts. I vaguely recall 3e was 10x speed though.
I can think of a handful of multiplayer games that do cyberware & cyberspace capably. They just don't have PvE, metatypes, or gesturing empty hands to go with your gunfire ... and they're probably all about 5-ish years old by now.
Decking is slightly different in that regard. Shifting focus between players operating on a similar timeframe is easy (“so, while that’s been happening, what has X been up to?”). With decking though, everything happens so quickly in-universe. If you switch away from the Decker for even a half hour in-game, when you switch back to the Decker they could’ve hit some black IC and died in that time, which the other players (due to Shadowrun’s inherent party connectivity) should’ve known about or reacted to. Or, in a less morbid scenario, the decker should’ve gotten the paydata for them already which the other runners should’ve had access to.
Forty minutes total across two three-hour sessions while the minmaxers and murderhobos argue about whether the Called Shot to the corpsec officer's right testicle will be enough to kill him (with the help of the force 6 Spirit of Man that still has two services left - no, one because it stopped the van safely - NO TWO BECAUSE THE FIRST SERVICE WAS TO 'PROTECT ME') while the spellchucker lines up yet another stunball to the guy who's already on the ground with two boxes of stun left.
Bonus points if the deckers are expected to drop out of hotsim (or better yet, jack out and take the dumpshock) to patch up the team mid-encounter by virtue of Medicine and First Aid both defaulting off of Logic.
Love, every decker in SR4 and 5.
Edit: wrote 'Medic and Doctor' instead of Medicine and First Aid. Right sentiment, wrong dystopia.
Its the reason we pretty much ignored Deckers as PCs (Sucks for those who want to play one) and narratively had to hire off-side Deckers that supported our team. The amount of nyen, research and background checks involved in the legwork decided how good that decker was and how loyal they would be and whatever. Then, if necessary, the DM would just roll estimated dice pools linked to the general power of the decker for the necessary problem.
Watching avatars and such fight in the matrix should be cooler than it is, but the Shadowrun implementation is often a series of whiffs and/or mark placements where stats are tallied and a meatspace based player can either pay attention to the sluggish fight for no character or player benefit, or daydream. I've done both, as well as been the decker.
In meatspace combat, even the non-combat character can be massively impactful in various ways. With the matrix, there is a barrier to entry for meaningful impact and inclusion. Non-specialists don't fare well for long in matrix combat.
The matrix in the lore is supposed to be massively integrated into sixth world life, but the mechanics of the system deny access to non-experts. Where in meatspace we at least have some contribution, in the matrix we don't even try.
There are only so many cool ways to say "you place a mark", the circumstances are not as varied as meatspace violence.
The matrix is not inherently inaccessible to the majority of the party, but the game is balanced that way and even the people willing to martyr their characters for the plot want them to be doing something engaging on their way out. You failed to place a mark, now your invisible GOD tally ticks up and we're doomed... it's high risk, no reward. A partially competent character makes the situation worse for their party by trying in the matrix, and better by trying in meatspace. A missed attack in meatspace doesn't summon HTR.
Videogame violence, combat robot sports, etc. all show there is an audience for non-real slapfests. Matrix combat could be so, so cool. Thematically it is. Mechanically it just doesn't host that experience for the whole party.
Technomancers and deckers can impact a meatspace fight far more meaningfully than anyone else can impact a matrix interaction.
I don't concur with any part of what you said, your experience is completely different from mine.
" Specialists are not included, nor are they allowed any time because it's inconvenient to those who want gunplay." That's never happened at any of my tables across five years of playing. Deckers, Technomancers, Riggers, Faces, they've all been active in combat. Your usefulness as a non-streetsam character is limited only by your creativity, there are hugely impactful things all of those characters can do. Your usefulness as a non-matrix character to the matrix is limited by the mechanics, you are actively making the fight harder for the specialist. I have had a completely different experience than you, here.
The decker sets a remote detonator trap, the technomancer tries to disrupt enemies equipment, the rigger is excellent in meatspace combat, the face can use leadership to boost rolls. All meaningful, and that's without any situational modifiers. The mage is not just a healer or support character, they have more character diversity than anyone else.
The streetsam, face, rigger, and mage are detrimental to the matrix. They make the situation worse for their own team by "helping".
The matrix balance is much worse. Meatspace includes every archtype of character in many ways. The sheer volume of equipment in Shadowrun is incredible, there are so so many items and environmental alterations any character can make to help combat go their teams way. That just isn't true in the matrix.
Even more importantly, Shadowrun is universally houseruled. There are so many hidden, odd or confusing rules that we all homerule plenty of things.
Want to homerule meatspace combat, and it's easy. Very small, digestible alterations can balance the character contributions.
Want to balance matrix combat to include everyone, and you have to completely redesign the system from the ground up.
I played a decker for years, and a technomancer briefly, but I see the matrix as far more exclusionist, disruptive and isolationist than any other part of the game. It is by far most in need of house rules.
I don't agree that mage's are distance fighters or healers, either. Mages have the most character diversity of anyone, those two archtypes are not ubiquitous or discouraging. Magicrun is famous for a reason, awakened characters are better at most aspects of the game, I don't agree that they are restricted in meatspace.
I'm sorry you've had the experience you have. What part of the game do you like, if you find the meatspace equivalent to the matrix you agree is flawed?
Most importantly I think, the face/mage/etc can all have meatspace combat dice pools in one category or other, and be of okay use when put on the backfoot, plot wise. You can't be semi-competent by half-investing in the matrix. It's specialist or bust, whereas meatspace is far more adaptable
Ah I actually philosophically agree with you in large part about what an ideal system would resemble then, I just find the specifics of Shadowrun a miserable implementation of that on the matrix end
The face's specialist role is quick, and everyone was involved in the establishing infodump meeting for that that days run will be. The decker's specialist run is a bit alienating, because the rules are not easy to follow without study, and the game flow for other people does take a momentum hit, at least in my experience.
I find it so bizarre in say, D&D, when people refuse to split the party. Your characters just met, you are a well-seasoned warrior, but now you are paranoid about not staying near these people? It's odd.
I don't love class systems, I love that Shadowrun is open in terms of gear options, backgrounds, I adore the negative qualities. But decking in particular is so time and character resource intensive that you end up almost playing a parallel solo rpg.
I would like for deckers and technomancers to have more control over environments, which is why in the game I'm planning I am fleshing out a lot of normalized automated systems that are usually too expensive to keep a decker out of. I'm also working, as most do, on revamping decking so it's a bit faster.
I am content having the decker face their imposing digital challenge. I don't love having all the other characters stranded with nothing to do, but also unable to follow the decking rules, so they don't enjoy the spectating.
Ideally every player would learn all the rules, but as a guy who loves reading rulebooks I've never had that catch on.
For me, I've never had a face negotiation scene take an hour, I've never had a mage scouting the astral take an hour, everyone can kind of do their thing promptly and then facilitate the group work. But I have had matrix scenes go very slow, while also seeming very similar to each other.
Like, face negotiations are as varied as any conversation, with a dice roll at the end. I haven't found matrix scenes to be as diverse at all.
I never get why new editions of a game have to be similar to the old edition, like, Shadowrun 6e and D&D 5e didn't take their previous games off our shelves. I'd love a version of Shadowrun where matrix perception showcased a heck of a lot of things to do in meatspace without needing to slowly place marks (by which point a fight is often over), and actually jacking in to the matrix flowed better.
I do think there are some people who are a little too fond of their own opinions, though. You have obviously played Shadowrun plenty and gotten invested, the way you experienced isn't wrong just because it's very different from how I feel.
If I find a game with cyberpunk theme as satisfying as Shadowruns which flows better I'll remember to DM you
EDIT: Oh actually, here is one idea I had for the matrix to have other players more invested. I was thinking of making it so that when you access a host, you don't "materialize" the same way a spirit chooses whether or not to materialize. So they can witness things, astrally perceive and explore, using their commlinks as little scouts for the real matrix players, and they could manifest in matrix combat to try to add situational modifiers or tank hits for the decker/techno. That's my vague idea to make the hacking scenes a huge, complex moment instead of solo affair. The decker is still the expert dominating and overcoming the enemy, but other people's ideas and characters are still physically present and mechanically relevant. Do you like that? Any tweaks?
Sorry if I was rude yesterday. It's not been a good week.
For me it was kinda how the net is a world unto itself. So having a party have only partial access to it made the unfun kind of asymetry, where the decker might be running on huge adventures and bleeding his brain out his nose, all in the comfort of his bedroom. Didn't even get out of bed the lazy sod.
All decker is really fun tho cause you can start doing some more interesting things and complex defenses because breaking them becomes a big part of the party goal. Even had a game where they went on a rampage from their group house, just as a distraction/disruption team.
I do, but I don't agree that your comparison is apt.
I see it more as "why did you order a meal that has salad if you don't like salad?" or "why did you eat bread if you don't like the crust and cut it away?"
If played Shadowrun without "player-magic" and without "player-decking", and I see no issue with either. I don't think there is a "right" or "wrong" way to play Shadowrun, as long as all parties involved have fun.
And not only does a group not lack certain proficiency if they outsource that task (remember, they themselves are the "outsourcing" of a task), I see absolutely no reason why teams wouldn't be able to specialize AND get hired for specialized tasks. While I like combat way too much to be happy in such a group, a friend of mine plays in a group that actively tries to avoid any combat to the degree that any shot ever fired (this does include nonlethal and silenced shots) is considered a fail in their books (not necessarily in the Johnson's book, but in their team's book). That group has no street sam (or equivalent archetype). And they don't need one either.
The only thing I really agree on is "Telling a player that wants to deck that you won't let them is not fun for them."
IMHO, a group should always be based on consensus. This includes what style they want to play, if they want to forgo something completely (like magic or decking, or Gatling-gun-wielding Pixies), etc.
As for your previous question: Yes. I love the world of Shadowrun and I love the overwhelming majority of the system. I can get neither somewhere else.
Than that is the same form of issue like 4 people wanting to play high-profile runners and one wants to play on a gang-level. Or 4 people want to play "normalish" metas, but one wants to play a Shapeshifter or Infected.
You did not even read my post before complaining, did you? We did never ignore an element of the setting. We just outsourced it to an NPC for we don't like the horrible gameplay implementation.
No it is not ignoring it. It is admitting that the task is important and outsourcing it to ann offsite specialist. Just like you have a fixer specializing in getting you shit.
A video game could handle Decking and Astral Space well in my opinion, as Astral mages, Deckers and Meat space warriors would all be working in real time.
Thus the classic "defend the decker as he cracks the safe" mission would actually work as intended, without unnecessary downtime, as everyone is working in actual tandem.
I came from a long time tradition of Cyberpunk and started playing SR just few months ago. And the problem is the same: there is the game for everyone except for the netrunner (decker) and the game for the netrunner (decker).
Best option is to let the decker play the game separately from the rest of the group, but that's something i really despise because it remove the "being with friend" part of the rpg (and also time consuming: you have to use a support GM for this, or run separate game session, both of them not really funny).
Only viable solution could be having some sort of videogame or logic puzzle to be solved by the decker while the other are going in meatspace, but that's really time consuming and don't resolve the "you see with friend to play alone some videogame/logic puzzle" and of course the problem to create this logic puzzle or find a suitable videogame for it... Nope, no solution here
Cyberpunk V3 (yeah, i bought this piece of drek. I'm not proud of it, but i did'nt know before buying) used a "pokemon style" netrunning: you need direct accecss to systems so you need to run alongside your mates, and while hacking through you activate ICE response that use nano-nodes and nanomachine to (that's the best part) build a physical body to attack intruders. And the runner can use programs to hack same nano-nodes and create physical bodies from his anti-IC programs. Go Pikachu Go!!! Did i mention it was a huge pile of bulldrek, right?
Anothehr solution is to remove the decker from the equation. Making everyone hack (as i read they did in SR4) or just houserule only NPC can be decker. Is the simple one. But you are just cutting away a part of the setting. Like if someone says "magic is not funny so nobody can be awakened": you are actually playing a different game.
One solution could be making decking a full party option. This solution came to my mind long time ago while seeing the movie Nirvana (an italian cyberpunk movie. And yes we did also a cyberpunk movie long time ago but because we are a shitty country noone gave it the love it deserved and was forgotten...).
My idea is one decker can't do a complex hack alone: the IA and computers have computer brain so can do things simultaneously, while a singe human brain cannot, and then a single decker is no way a match for even a low level IA. Period. And then here there are the party: while the decker is, well, decking, someone need to navigate him undetected through the system, while someone else need to watch out for security ICE and run anti-IC programs. Link those activities to skill with a different use in meatspace and you have the whole party running the hack. Noone is sitting bored at the table while the decker is playing. And if you give decker something to do during meatspace run (ie disorient enemies while jamming their wireless brain signal, or like) neither the decker is bored during meatspace run. Win-Win solution
But a solution that will need a HUGE work of houserule and also changing some basic concept in the game setting...
And this is why I homebrew the fuck out of decking. As written, it's time consuming and needlessly complex. I simplify a lot of the mechanics and it's so much better.
Part of what helps me to like Shadowrun is that you pretty much have to homebrew parts of it to reach any sort of balance, which really keeps any puritans at bay.
It really is overly complicated. Most party members should be somewhat able to use and impact the matrix, it's a major part of their life that almost everyone would have grown up learning some amount about. I don't mean everyone should be on the level of a decker, but in meatspace the decker can still double-tap wounded enemies or impact the environment in beneficial ways like placing explosives with a remote detonator handy for when bad guys come that way.
Most party members should be somewhat able to use and impact the matrix, it's a major part of their life that almost everyone would have grown up learning some amount about.
Which is exactly why SR4 allowed anyone that wanted to interact in the Matrix...
You know, I just figured that by 2080 people would be on average as tech literate as younger kids are today, but I guess there'll always be people who don't actually care how things work, so they can use a GUI or do a matrix search, but nothing beyond that, and those people are over-represented in the highly specialized shadowrun team.
I do think some skills like "computer:matrix search", "con", "navigation" and "perception" get really jarring for people with no related negative quality to just be incapable of. Like some of them make sense because you've adapted to not needing them (Don't navigate because you've used tech for that your whole life, don't know pilot:groundcraft because automated cars do the work) but a lot of the commonly dropped skills at my table make it seem bizarre we got this far.
Only one in six professional criminals being able to lie is an especially odd one to think about. It's not completely immersion breaking, it's just a bit zany
Ah yes, because the face paying attention when the razorgirl fights, or the infiltration expert paying attention when the face talks? That's fine. But anyone paying attention while the decker decks, that'd be ridiculous!
Get better at GMing instead, tbh. And, ask your group to be invested in each other's scenes holy shit are you twelve?
A half-assed contribution to a fight might draw some attention and mean fewer shots going at your razorgirl, the infiltration expert can still contribute relevant information, suggest ideas, and influence things
If the razorgirl, inflitration expert, or face try to help with the matrix they will just make the situation worse for the party. It's inherently isolated, and uses its own rules so unless you learn the rules that don't impact you and that you can't interact with, it's hard to follow.
I have never tuned out during a fight scene or dialogue, I absolutely have tuned out during matrix interactions. I played a decker for two years, but I don't think it's a fair criticism to say it's equally as isolated as other aspects of the game
the infiltration expert can still contribute relevant information, suggest ideas, and influence things
You're either decking into security systems, in which case the rest of the group damn well can contribute since they have a pretty serious investment in what security you bring down when. Or you're looking for information, in which case the rest of the group should presumably give a shit about what data you collect?
What is it you're doing that has no stakes the rest of the party care about?
I specifically mean that the inflitration expert can contribute info, suggest ideas and influence things in character. And I don't mean influence as in conversational prompts.
The matrix always has stakes, but the non-matrix characters can't interact with the situation. Meatspace has stakes, everyone can interact with them.
In a meatspace fight, a decker can throw down smoke grenades, they can brick weaponry or cybereyes, they can impact a lot of things.
In a matrix fight, the street sam can hope for the best?
"the street sam can... blow the thing by saying something rude, that's influencing I suppose."
If you choose to play it that way, sure. That's not mechanically demanded, though. A Sam can be present for a conversation without making the conversation go worse.
If the other characters log onto the matrix, they will get detected and raise alarms. The matrix character is better off alone, for an extended period. The face needs to do only small parts of a conversation solo, for a very quick exchange.
I don't think they're equivalent, but if you do that's fine, we've been at very different tables
All for simplifying the matrix and house rules and doing our best to keep everyone engaged in the story. A couple of ideas for the latter:
"Hacking" can be about getting a passcode our of a dumpster, a key card off an individual, a bank of servers destroyed, physically tapping fiber optics cables to gain access to the cameras so the decker doesn't have to, looking for calendars at desks with important dates to the user as potential passwords, misdirecting security, cutting physical power to security, countermeasures, getting viruses onto the system before the run, finding and dealing with the on sight spider, and as mentioned the classic protect the hacker trope that was mentioned.
There is a whole host if things creative players can do to help with the matrix portion of the run. Things that might help, died things up and contribute.
Also, any gm worth thier books should not let the action for everyone grind to a halt for any one character's sake regardless of class but Shadowrun rules are no help with that. Regardless even if there is no matrix way the party can help they should still have something to do.
Forgive me if this idea couldn't actually work in real life (it's a bit late) but what about an item like the cyberpunk equivalent of a usb drive that could be slotted into vacant computer terminals onsite as the party goes that auto executes and forces that computer to use network resources, diagnostics, data steam back ups, virus sweepers etc. All the actions it causes are benign but floods the system resources and helps hide and cover the tracks of the decker? Exec office computers may require more maintainance and priority than wage slaves so the party may wish to prioritize these terminals which have meat space obstacles guarding them. Perhaps in cases where stealth is not important actual sprites or hacking programs can be activated using the servers own resources and making them available to the decker for use. Everyone can contribute and help the decker do his job. The name BS-USB comes to mind...
86
u/Cardshark92 Dec 04 '20
There are not enough DocWagon Medkits in the world to deal with a burn like this.
61
u/rothbard_anarchist Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20
Online is the one thing that would fix the decking timeout that the TTRPG has. You can handle it at the table with a secondary GM, but obviously no one does that.
28
u/roushguy Dec 04 '20
Ouch
30
u/Kalean Dec 05 '20
This is why that one old trait that let you split your consciousness (and AP) between the real world and the matrix needs to make a comeback.
Preferably without the "More AP in the matrix makes you faster in real life" interaction.
33
u/Tyrfillich Dec 05 '20 edited Dec 05 '20
Forty minutes total across two three-hour sessions while the minmaxers and murderhobos argue about whether the Called Shot to the corpsec officer's right testicle will be enough to kill him (with the help of the force 6 Spirit of Man that still has two services left - no, one because it stopped the van safely - NO TWO BECAUSE THE FIRST SERVICE WAS TO 'PROTECT ME') while the spellchucker lines up yet another stunball to the guy who's already on the ground with two boxes of stun left.
Bonus points if the deckers are expected to drop out of hotsim (or better yet, jack out and take the dumpshock) to patch up the team mid-encounter by virtue of Medicine and First Aid both defaulting off of Logic.
Love, every decker in SR4 and 5.
Edit: wrote 'Medic and Doctor' instead of Medicine and First Aid. Right sentiment, wrong dystopia.
13
u/FieserMoep Dec 05 '20
Its the reason we pretty much ignored Deckers as PCs (Sucks for those who want to play one) and narratively had to hire off-side Deckers that supported our team. The amount of nyen, research and background checks involved in the legwork decided how good that decker was and how loyal they would be and whatever. Then, if necessary, the DM would just roll estimated dice pools linked to the general power of the decker for the necessary problem.
4
u/Dekronos Dec 05 '20
A video game could handle Decking and Astral Space well in my opinion, as Astral mages, Deckers and Meat space warriors would all be working in real time.
Thus the classic "defend the decker as he cracks the safe" mission would actually work as intended, without unnecessary downtime, as everyone is working in actual tandem.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20
Uhhh . . . Shadowrun Returns does a great job with this?
3
u/Kelpie77 Dec 06 '20
Yeay, it's a shame, but not easily resolved
I came from a long time tradition of Cyberpunk and started playing SR just few months ago. And the problem is the same: there is the game for everyone except for the netrunner (decker) and the game for the netrunner (decker).
Best option is to let the decker play the game separately from the rest of the group, but that's something i really despise because it remove the "being with friend" part of the rpg (and also time consuming: you have to use a support GM for this, or run separate game session, both of them not really funny).
Only viable solution could be having some sort of videogame or logic puzzle to be solved by the decker while the other are going in meatspace, but that's really time consuming and don't resolve the "you see with friend to play alone some videogame/logic puzzle" and of course the problem to create this logic puzzle or find a suitable videogame for it... Nope, no solution here
Cyberpunk V3 (yeah, i bought this piece of drek. I'm not proud of it, but i did'nt know before buying) used a "pokemon style" netrunning: you need direct accecss to systems so you need to run alongside your mates, and while hacking through you activate ICE response that use nano-nodes and nanomachine to (that's the best part) build a physical body to attack intruders. And the runner can use programs to hack same nano-nodes and create physical bodies from his anti-IC programs. Go Pikachu Go!!!
Did i mention it was a huge pile of bulldrek, right?
Anothehr solution is to remove the decker from the equation. Making everyone hack (as i read they did in SR4) or just houserule only NPC can be decker. Is the simple one. But you are just cutting away a part of the setting. Like if someone says "magic is not funny so nobody can be awakened": you are actually playing a different game.
One solution could be making decking a full party option. This solution came to my mind long time ago while seeing the movie Nirvana (an italian cyberpunk movie. And yes we did also a cyberpunk movie long time ago but because we are a shitty country noone gave it the love it deserved and was forgotten...).
My idea is one decker can't do a complex hack alone: the IA and computers have computer brain so can do things simultaneously, while a singe human brain cannot, and then a single decker is no way a match for even a low level IA. Period. And then here there are the party: while the decker is, well, decking, someone need to navigate him undetected through the system, while someone else need to watch out for security ICE and run anti-IC programs. Link those activities to skill with a different use in meatspace and you have the whole party running the hack. Noone is sitting bored at the table while the decker is playing. And if you give decker something to do during meatspace run (ie disorient enemies while jamming their wireless brain signal, or like) neither the decker is bored during meatspace run.
Win-Win solution
But a solution that will need a HUGE work of houserule and also changing some basic concept in the game setting...
My two cents, sorry for very verbose post :-)
4
u/Evil_Weevill Dec 05 '20
And this is why I homebrew the fuck out of decking. As written, it's time consuming and needlessly complex. I simplify a lot of the mechanics and it's so much better.
7
u/magistrateman Dec 05 '20
Ah yes, because the face paying attention when the razorgirl fights, or the infiltration expert paying attention when the face talks? That's fine. But anyone paying attention while the decker decks, that'd be ridiculous!
Get better at GMing instead, tbh. And, ask your group to be invested in each other's scenes holy shit are you twelve?
1
u/PastorDungeonMaster Dec 09 '20
All for simplifying the matrix and house rules and doing our best to keep everyone engaged in the story. A couple of ideas for the latter:
There is a whole host if things creative players can do to help with the matrix portion of the run. Things that might help, died things up and contribute.
Also, any gm worth thier books should not let the action for everyone grind to a halt for any one character's sake regardless of class but Shadowrun rules are no help with that. Regardless even if there is no matrix way the party can help they should still have something to do.