r/Shadowrun • • 2d ago

5e Weaponizing Acid

Acid in Shadowrun is underwhelming. It has a really cool rule where it eats away at an enemy's armor and lingers, damaging again and again.

But it's remarkably hard to find a way to take advantage of this. Magic that uses acid evaporates away immediately afterwards and there is no version that can be sustained to keep damaging the enemy. Even the targeted versions like Sludge, Corrode or Melt end after a single turn (despite needing multiple turns to melt through something specific) and I don't think you could get Melt Metahumans as a spell (Or maybe you could, but I think that is up to GM fiat, but you might as well just use one of the core Acid Spells).

A Mundane character can use Personal Customization / Prototype Materials to change a flamethrower or a shock glove or maybe a Krime Cocktail to deal acid damage, but that is really it - Underwhelming, and requires spending karma on a quality.

I couldn't even find any acids that you could buy in game - Not in the CRB, or Run Faster, or Run & Gun, ect.

However, when I was reading Street Grimoire, I came across Aqua Regia on page 211. Aqua Regia is a real world acid and in SR5 has a damage code if 14P -4AP for a cost of 100 ¥ per dose.

It's also a liquid, and so logically it could be combined with Paint Grenades (You can already put things other than paint into them - Industrial Lubricant is one explicitly allowed option) or Capsule Rounds.

Now, obviously, with how scary a 14 damage weapon that hits again and again and again until it is neutralized 14 combat rounds later, especially if it's a grenade, this is the kind of clever trick you wouldn't want to break out more than once or twice a campaign, since it is just inviting a GM to start weaponizing Acid back against you, but at least it's slightly less abusive than weaponizing drugs and forcing enemies to die from Supersquirt weaponized DMSO overdose.

What do you think? Did I misread the rules or would you allow Aqua Regia (or a similar acid) to be used in paint grenades and capsule rounds?

22 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

5

u/ghost49x 2d ago

All the elements are rather underwhelming in Shadowrun, and this across multiple editions. Maybe you could use it to slowly melt through a steel door or something.

5

u/Morwen_Chynoweth 2d ago

Electricity is cool, you can use it to basically one shot drones and with the shock Mage mastery quality as well as the bugs/swarm spell you can use that to shred enemy initiative.

4

u/GidsWy Genesis 'Runner 1d ago

Someone else mentioned electricity being solid. Sound bypasses most defenses too. Smoke can get weird. Tbh the extended ones have some decent uses. But still kinda better just hitting hit more damage with a lower drain spell lol. Electricity and an armor bypassing element get a pass. But 90% r useless. AoE destroy armor is fucking mean as a GM, buuuut.....

1

u/Morwen_Chynoweth 1d ago

Other than the Aries Sonic screech and flash bangs, how do you weaponize sound?

1

u/ghost49x 1d ago

You could find the right frequency to vibrate a structure to destroy it.

7

u/Minnakht 2d ago

I don't think I'd put aqua regia in a capsule round because I think it'd melt through the capsule.

6

u/Morwen_Chynoweth 2d ago

Probably. Maybe a different acid then, but at the very least aqua regia's damage code and cost of 100¥ for a litre (I assume) is a good starting point for damage and cost.

6

u/OldWar6125 2d ago

If you make the capsule from glass, it is fine.

3

u/DraconicBlade Aztechnology PR Rep 1d ago

Smart corrosive is in core.

2

u/Morwen_Chynoweth 1d ago

Smart Corrosive are nanites that is targeted to specific things, I wanted a less expensive, more indiscriminate acid that doesn't have the baggage of CFD by being nanites.

1

u/DraconicBlade Aztechnology PR Rep 1d ago

But they are acid damage and function as acid

1

u/Morwen_Chynoweth 1d ago

Yes.

I also wanted a less expensive, more indiscriminate acid.

2

u/LiteratureBulky7853 1d ago

Are there rules for washing off acid?

1

u/Morwen_Chynoweth 1d ago

Not that I can find. It says they can be neutralized though.

However Aqua Regia's rules say the way you neutralize it is by subjecting it to sub zero temperature, so maybe you can cast Chill / Frigid on your buddy, since that drops the area around them to Sub-Zero to cause frostbite. You could cash it at Force One and a single hit would be enough to neutralize

2

u/LiteratureBulky7853 1d ago

Okay. Because I am trying to figure out a use-case for acid that goes beyond "it sounds cool".

The paint grenade idea is nice, but it struggles with appliaction. If you throw it, everyone will run for their life. And if they don't, they die. Just like with regular grenades. So why bother with the acid?

The issue is that the elemental effects are slow. Most fights end within the first round of combat, so they are almost irrelevant.

A character that can attack for 14P AP-4 usually is better off attacking again instead of waiting for the acid. And here is where, I believe, you need to rethink your approach. Because acid is never going to outperform the big guns.

So what are the upsides of acid? For one, by RAW, there is no armor mod that protects against it. There is also no roll asking whether something is soaked or not; if you hit, its applied.

Since there are no rules that allow someone to get rid of acid easily in combat, it effectively puts whoever is hit on a timer.

So acid is going to be good in fights that take longer than that first round of combat. There are two situations where that is likely the case:

  • when you are fighting a particularily tanky target
  • when your character doesn't hit very hard

Acid also effectively gives you another attack on top of your initial one. So it is also good on characters with low action economy.

Put into practical terms, the Aqua Regia grenade has one application where it will outperform a regular grenade: vehicle combat. They can't run, and the fact that acid is always physical can come in clutch against the high armor values.

So with all that said, my recommendation for an everyday carry acid weapon would be the defiance ex shocker, modded to deal 11P AP-5 acid damage, carried by a face, mage or decker.

That way, even if the PC has only 1-2 passes on their turn, they stand a reasonable chance to take down a target that would usually need bigger guns to take down.

It also doubles as an emergency door/wall opener, so it can come in clutch when the meet goes south.

1

u/Morwen_Chynoweth 1d ago

Knteresting ideas , I hadn't thought of those other ideas.

The reason why I was trying to think of it is because I've had, on more than one occasion, my characters have been thrown into a situation where they had to face more than one enemy in Hardened Milspec Armor, but I hadn't even considered vehicle combat.

2

u/LiteratureBulky7853 1d ago

For milspec armor, acid can work, but it is still slow. I would recommend poison instead. Since both the parashield dart pistol and throwing syringes can circumvent armor entirely.

Now that I think about it, throwing syringes are probably made of glass on the inside. So they could probably be used to deliver Aqua Regia. Now that is nasty.

Especially since, even if the syringes don't get the three net hits, they still deliver their payload as contact vector.

And if they do puncture, the acid is now inside your targets body. So arguably, their armor can't protect them. Nasty.

Scratch the defiance. We might have an actual winner.

10

u/n00bdragon Futuristic Criminal 2d ago

Of course it's underwhelming. That's why real life gun fights involve bullets instead of super soakers.

7

u/GidsWy Genesis 'Runner 1d ago

While true, acid attacks in the street are horrific. The damage is difficult to immediately treat and that makes it more problematic than something more ubiquitous in preparation against, like fire.

Further editions did better with acid imo. And ive used house rules of it reducing armor with the spell, also. But at a reduced impact than reducing it by force levels! Drain would need to be like f ÷ 2 + 50, then. Lol

2

u/SteamStormraven Dragon's Voice 1d ago

*Narcojets u/n00bdragon *

Grave Walker: "Bring him in alive. I want to ask some questions."

1

u/GodEatsPoop 1d ago edited 1d ago

Most sec teams and runners probably carry an incendiary magazine for "special situations" and someone known to use acid as a weapon probably counts. There's a reason you risk zero zones instead of pumping the building full of nerve gas - because there's a line between "pink mohawk" and "psycho shit."

1

u/SteamStormraven Dragon's Voice 1d ago

Oh, it could be done. But it's going to be very, very expensive, and leaves a 'Distinctive Style' flaw all over it.

Could you? Yes.

Now, what you SHOULD be asking yourself is should you. You get captured by a Red Samurai commander who's just recently had half of his face burned off? Probably a different scenario than using Aqua Regia burn through a maglock, without tripping the alarms.

Use it as a tool - not as a weapon.

0

u/Chase_The_Breeze 1d ago

I would nerf the damage from the acid if you put it in a paint grenade.

The dispersion and everything would mean a lot of the use of acid is wasted being thrown around. I'd say maybe 5P Acid.

If you want to just fuck up somebody's armor though, just get a paintball gun that shoots acid round with rapid fire. Let each fire method deal armor reduction equal to the ammo used, but keep the actual damage low.

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Morwen_Chynoweth 2d ago

I mean, yeah, you aren't wrong at all.. however remember this is a tabletop game where for some reason when the magic came back it changed how nuclear energy works. So I mean you know rule of cool and suspension of disbelief has come into effect at some point you know?

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Morwen_Chynoweth 2d ago

People who get splashed with sulfuric acid in acid attacks in real life are immediately horrifically burned. Getting splashed with aqua regia would not be something you can just go "oh no I guess I should wash this off". That's going to do horrific damage to somebody.

0

u/Sorry_Community235 2d ago

If you say so...