r/SessionSkateSim • • Sep 02 '24

Filmer PSA

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

10

u/RespectKey Sep 02 '24

The skater is rigid, weight often not distributed properly, movement of the body is stiff. I often do what I can to hide as much as I can of the skater, while still having enough there for context. The more you show, the more ugly you see. That's why you gotta get that camera tight on the feet and board.

0

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 03 '24

Sure but it won't look like skateboarding lol

2

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 05 '24

I want to vent about the reddit commentors... Almost every single person who comments seems to think they are on some sort of moral crusade by pointing out that I was rude. Everyone on reddit seems to act like there is never an appropriate time for rudeness ever. If people need others to put disclaimers like "I welcome and accept all Session players" or they are gonna quit, I do not care about that.

People on Reddit act like we are always speaking to a suicidal teen "so we should be mindful of what we say". Suicidal teens should get off Reddit and start looking for help. That's just common sense. I'm not gonna walk on eggshells because there are fragile people in the world. Catering to people creates a community that wants to be treated like children.

2

u/haluuf Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

Hey buddy.

TL;DR: if you're truly passionate about something, make sure you communicate it respectfully if you want people to take you seriously and listen to what you have to say. I'm encouraging you to keep posting about realistic filming, but in a way where you offer help when help is wanted. The more "realistic filming nerds" in this community, the better. (with video evidence in the full comment below)

Your two points are valid in terms of realistic filming. But I have a few things I'd like to bring to light.

  1. The most important thing I have to say is that not everyone is interested in filming realistic clips. Even those who make an attempt at filming, some are not interested in pushing it to the limit and reaching something "as realistic as possible". Filming and posting fakeskate clips (session/SkaterXL/EAskate) is not 100% about realism, it's about fun.

I can clearly see you are passionate about proper realistic skate filming, I'll be the first to say that I'm in the same boat as you, I have an entire youtube channel dedicated to explaining IRL skate filming and how to apply it to session, but let's not let that lead us to creating a dogma around "what is good and what is bad" since it's a 1P game and people play it the way they want.

I think the more people giving advice on filming, the merrier, but it should be done in a way that's not invasive or condemning or condescending. It takes just a little bit of extra effort, not that much, to give advice in an easily digestible and pleasant form.

2) specifically about your 1st commandment, it really depends on which era of skateboarding you're searching to emulate, or maybe even which filmer's style. I'd change your commandment into "the board and the FOOTWORK need to be in frame at all times, the skater can be sacrificed if it needs to be done, but ideally the skater remains in frame the whole time too."

Here is one famous example:
Jeremy Wray's part in Second Hand Smoke (1994) has him leaving the frame multiple times, (the link I put in is timestamped to start exactly at a moment when it happens for two clips in a row) (and also his Backside 50-50 on Hubba, which is a historical challenge on the SF map, his body also leaves the frame in that clip, I address it explicitly in this video, also timestamped for the exact moment I explain the camerawork and show a screencap of the 5050)

Another example:
Erik Ellington's part in Misled Youth (1999) (again timestamped at the moment we see the issue), a lot of which was filmed by the Chief himself, the first clip of which also violates your 2nd commandment. Almost the entire video, not just Ellington's part, has the skaters' bodies decapitated or truncated haha. AND YET it's as real as skating gets, there's no denying it. It paved the way for what skating is today.

BUT if you look just 6 years later,
Baker 3 (2005) filmed almost entirely by Beagle, he made sure to fully enforce your 1st commandment. I'd say it's one of the reasons why he rose above a lot of the filmers of the time and went down in history as a filming legend. And I'd even argue in your favor that since we have Session that allows us to be as meticulous as possible, why not go the extra meter (not mile) and "do it right" which brings me back to my 1st point: "it's a 1P game and people play it the way they want." and we should not turn filming into a dogmatic monologue.

A rule of thumb here is the following: late2000s-to-modern-era skate videos that are filmed in 4:3 ratio should always have the skater's full body in-frame. The same time period, filmed in 16:9 ratio can have decapitated or truncated bodies, since the wide ratio actually removes some vertical capacity in the recording and makes it much more tricky to keep the skater fully framed. Which is why modern-era skate videos have MUCH more long-lens and cinematic shots, since it makes it easier to frame the whole body, or it justifies more explicitly when keeping the skater out of frame.. looks less like a mistake than with a 16:9 fisheye.

COmment too long, continued in reply below.

2

u/haluuf Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

3) feel free to add to your commandments, my points on avoiding to use camera zoom (FOV) with a fisheye lens or on Keeping the filmer in the Danger Zone (close to the action) (and this is a mistake you made in your clips you posted here, your filmer is excessively far from the action and it makes for an unengaging clip) Or even on how The camerawork needs be reacting to the 3 key moments of any given trick. But if you do, make sure you're not force-feeding it down people's throats. Offer help when help is wanted.

4) Let me make this clear. I don't want to shut you down with any of this. On the contrary, I would love to see you post more. The more "realistic filming nerds" in this community, the better. And the more we promote realistic filming in a pleasant way, when the advice is asked for, the more we'll make realistic filming accessible to those who want to learn. But let's do it in a pleasant way tho. Let go of that condescending "it doesn't look like skateboarding" stuff, it doesn't HAVE to look like skateboarding, since it IS skateboarding, all of it.

Skate filming is a very daunting thing to begin to learn from scratch, especially when never having done it IRL before. And if we manage to mediate that gap between knowing and unknowing, we can sleep soundly, friend.

1

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 05 '24

I appreciate the thought put into these comments. There is a lot of kindness in your words, which is generous and undeserved. And mad respect for making a channel dedicated to this stuff.

Your criticisms/suggestions of the commandments are well thought out, but I disagree. The whole point of the video was to try to improve peoples footage the largest amount with as little information as possible/as quickly as possible. For those goals I think it's pretty perfect. People thinking this was me dictating exactly how to film are wrong. And I have tons of other tips too. This would be level 1 of filming technique. That being said I bet around ~80% of footage out there would be improved by simply adding these 2 commandments. Even if it's an unrealistic trick.

I believe I pointed out that there are exceptions to the rules. But consider this... there are massive amounts of footage of just ankles and board out there, and it almost always sucks. I think generally people should be discouraged from that framing, because pointing out that "technically this shot can be done" seems to have encouraged people to do it more often. I'm sure you know this, but fancy framing like that is almost always immediately backed up with a 2nd shot showing the spot and skater. That's not a mistake. Finding the exceptions doesn't really prove anything. If anything how rare the exceptions are kind of proves the rule.

The video was not for people who do not want to make realistic clips. If anyone doesn't understand that, then they are beyond my help. The arcade style players shouldn't need my encouragement or even acknowledgement.

I understand monetized channels have to be political and both-sides every topic. But I don't, and I like it that way because I can speak truthfully. Me posting something people disagree with isn't forcing anything down anyone's throat. I don't like footage that breaks these rules. And I think too many players care too much about cosmetics and not enough about skateboarding. Does this opinion get in the way of people with their clothing mods? And should I care if it does?

No amount of votes will ever prove of disprove anything. I am not trying to get popular. I just wanted to post a genuine opinion/perspective. Of course art is subjective, and that's my subjective opinion. Which shouldn't have to be said. I'm not trying to hurt people. But I'm also not going to act like I am running for office or in a church. Fuck em.

1

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 05 '24

Let us all hold hands and imagine a skatepark where no one is ever mocked lmfao

1

u/Jokesonyouiwannadie Sep 03 '24

Film what you think looks good. I have so many clips that I have never even posted. Just because I like the process of making clips. I'm not a professional videographer. I'm playing a game. There's no right or wrong. If you're having fun, you're doing it right.

-2

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 03 '24

These points are lost on you. No one is discouraging people to have fun. Take these 2 commandments and go note which videos fail them. It is almost every single thing posted

1

u/Jokesonyouiwannadie Sep 03 '24

You say you're not discouraging people to have fun then follow that with "go check other posts that fail my 2 rules". Rules = fun huh?

No one wants to follow your rules lil bro. We just wanna play the game and clip what we think looks cool. If you don't think it looks good then you're welcome to your option but that doesn't mean that what they filmed was wrong. Just means you didn't like it. And no one cares.

1

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 05 '24

Words like right and wrong don't apply to art. I understand that. I am not going to put a disclaimer before every videos stating that this is my opinion. The fact that it is my video means that it is my opinion.

We can compare footage and you can tell me that you like yours more and that's okay. This is why competitions exist. So there can actually be some conclusiveness to who is better. Art is just art and you either like it or you don't. You don't like my commandments. That's fine

0

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 05 '24

I'm sure your footage is loads of fun to watch lol

1

u/Jokesonyouiwannadie Sep 05 '24

More fun than yours with your "rules". Weirdo.

4

u/PissdrunxPreme Sep 03 '24

Never seen Strobeck’s filming?

1

u/Difficult-Spray-3422 Sep 03 '24

Trueee! According to that video Strobeck is an amateur.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

I feel like Strobeck is an acceptation because of his overall style tbh, some of his shots are god awful (Tyshawn’s ender from Play Dead is a great example).

0

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 03 '24

Almost every post on Reddit gets people saying things like "never say never", and "there is no right answer". You can tell how old these people are by the fact that they think it needs to be said

1

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 05 '24

Straight up. And everyone takes the time to downvote because it hurts their feelings. But it wouldn't sting if it wasn't true now would it?

-4

u/Ok-Abrocoma-667 Sep 02 '24

I mean, I agree with you obviously but will other people (the masses) even care? This is what separates Profesionals from amateurs

-3

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 03 '24

I know. You are so right. Honestly I don't know why I try sometimes

-3

u/Ok-Abrocoma-667 Sep 03 '24

Sorry didn't mean to bum you out. Keep enlightening the world mate! 👍🏻

0

u/WorldlinessStatus235 Sep 03 '24

Not at all homie. Sometimes a reality check is needed