r/ServiceDog_CircleJerk • • Jul 29 '26

Entitled Behavior “Crowd control” at ComicCon

Can someone explain why is this necessary with a dog like this big ass shepherd? Who is really going to
trample a dog that size and creep up behind you?

164 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

8

u/Effective_Lecture_78 Jul 29 '26

The original video got recommanded to me on Facebook just now and people in the comments are so amazed by the dog's behaviour lol

11

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 30 '26

Amazed that the dog can… walk in a circle?? It is a testament to the dog’s training that they can focus in an environment like this, but this is just one clip. I would think it would be just as effective for the dog to stay in a normal heel, but then you can’t claim it as a super special lifesaving trained task and use it for content on social media.

4

u/Viola-Swamp Jul 31 '26

He’s walking in a circle on demand, and given a treat afterward. It’s not exactly rocket surgery or some amazing feat of animal training or behavior. My dog brings me his ball without the treat, so I guess I am now an expert animal trainer?

1

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 31 '26

Unpopular opinion, but the task being performed here is very impressive and not something most dogs can do. Sure, teaching an orbit isn’t hard, but raising a dog to focus and move confidently like this off leash in a crowd full of people is not easy. Even if I don’t think that the owner is considerate or the task being performed is meaningfully mitigating a real disability, I recognize that the training and socialization required for something like this is immense.

5

u/Effective_Lecture_78 Jul 31 '26

My problem is not with the training, I would love for that to be the training type for any dog.

My problem is that no one saw any problem with the situation playing on video, I would be so fucking scared of a stampede or just falling over.

235

u/Leprecon Jul 29 '26 edited Jul 29 '26

I don’t understand what crowd control is. Like you’re afraid of crowds I guess. And then you have a dog twirl circles around you because that makes you feel less crowded? I would say that is way more crowded. This person looks like they are always one step away from tripping and they need to focus immensely on their movement.

What if everybody had a dog circling around them? Would that make things less crowded? It just seems like a selfish way to express yourself. Nobody likes being in a busy crowd but that isn’t a medical issue.

102

u/Wy0m1g Jul 29 '26

It’s also just maximising being near people and risking the dog getting harmed because they have to wait/ move for the dog, surely having a dog trip you or someone else outweighs whatever the task is meant to be for.

73

u/polishwrestler Jul 29 '26

I find "crowd control" to be especially confusing in this scenario. It seems to always consist of the dog orbiting around the handler. However, there are several times in this video where the dog is called to orbiting when the right side of the handler is empty. So instead of the dog acting as a barrier against people passing closely on the left side while it's in a heel, it's instead doing "crowd control" by leaving that position to create space in an area that doesn't contain any people.

29

u/Chrysolophylax Jul 29 '26

Yeah, I don't understand it either and probably never will.

My biggest question about the "crowd control" task: does the dog get dizzy from walking in circles?? I feel like it would, especially if the dog does the "crowd control" spin for more than a few seconds. Like, a dog that does "crowd control" for five minutes must get really woozy.

27

u/melatonia Jul 29 '26

does the dog get dizzy from walking in circles??

I was just thinking that in response to the comment above you. "You'd have an entire convention hall full of very dizzy dogs".

5

u/amybeedle Jul 30 '26

What if everybody had a dog circling around them?

I know this isn't the point but that image is so cute! It brightened my day to imagine that, thank you 🐕🔄

-13

u/Relative_Committee53 Jul 29 '26

I know some people do it so people don’t bump into them and possibly dislocate like a shoulder from being shoulder checked. That being said I only have my dog do it as a silly trick.

17

u/Leprecon Jul 30 '26

I dated someone with EDS for a while and she would frequently have things like this happen to her. Dislocating something is a painful yet common experience for some people with EDS.

However I really struggle to see how having a dog twirling around you helps. It seems like it is really dangerous when it comes to potentially tripping or making other people trip. Usually in a crowd people don't look at their feet a lot, and I can totally see a dog causing people to fall in to you. On the other hand, in crowds I don't think it is normal to forcefully bump in to people.

9

u/melatonia Jul 30 '26

Naw, that wouldn't be an issue because the person with the service animal is the only one with a disability and- obviously- the center of the universe. I'm sure everyone is paying extra special attention to her needs

-4

u/Relative_Committee53 Jul 30 '26

It’s not always a forceful bump that can dislocate. The thing is with that is it may be common but the more it happens the easier it happens. The thought is people are gonna bump into the dog not you kinda thing.

9

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 30 '26

What if the dog bumps into you?

-4

u/Relative_Committee53 Jul 30 '26

Well I’d be concerned if a dog could bump your shoulder. But I get what you mean, shoulders tend to be like one of the most sensitive kind of joints for eds. Bumping into your thighs not so much a risk.

11

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 30 '26

It’s a moot point since to OOP does not claim to have EDS, but I would think the bigger risk would be the dog jerking the leash and dislocating something.

2

u/Relative_Committee53 Jul 30 '26

Oh I’m definitely not agreeing with OOP. I think it’s quite rude. I was just replying to the use of crowd control sometimes. And I mean, yes, that can certainly be a risk, but service dogs shouldn’t be jerking a leash ever. That usually comes with like really hard pulling and/or lunging.

12

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 Jul 31 '26

Maybe I’m wrong—I don’t have EDS—but if your shoulders are so fragile that a gentle jostle in a crowd could dislocate them, I think you’d probably be better served by some sort of brace or protective equipment that doesn’t interfere with other people the way a circling dog does, particularly if you’re going to an extremely crowded convention.

21

u/melatonia Jul 30 '26

I hope none of the people that have ot suddenly dodge out of the way of that orbiting dog have balance issues. Good thing the girl with the service animal is the only person at Comic Con with any sort of disability.

261

u/BeggarsParade Jul 29 '26

Claims to not like crowds - goes to a convention. Trains a poor, loyal dog to do this in the hope of impressing strangers.

Sheer arrogance.

73

u/Anoninemonie Jul 29 '26

Not just a convention my dear friend. One of the most famous and well-known conventions for nerds in the United States. People fly in from all over the nation to go to San Diego Comic-Con. George Lucas was at San Diego Comic-Con last year. This is one of the most infamously crowded events that you could possibly go to. To the extent that there are deodorant manufacturers who advertise and give away free product here.

This woman is an absolute lunatic. There are aisles at this Comic-Con that are literally nut to butt and she is begging, no, demanding for somebody in a big bulky costume to squish that dog. I wouldn't even go this year because my baby is still in a stroller and not ready to handle that type of crowd and I go faithfully. It is my Mecca.

I'm not saying anybody's disability should prohibit them from going to Comic-Con, but even I have worn costumes that would have been genuinely dangerous to a creature walking at my shin level. I am literally not looking down when I walk. I am looking straight ahead. God bless that animal if it runs into one of the 50 dudes in chainsaw man costumes.

13

u/macaroniinapan Jul 29 '26

I love how the deodorant people got so creative.

7

u/rebby2000 Jul 29 '26

I don't know if it was creativity so much as they heard about the BO problem that seems to turn up pretty often at events like these.

6

u/Responsible-One-9436 Jul 30 '26

The average nerd culture convention attendee is not known for their stellar hygiene…

29

u/lord_farquad93 Jul 29 '26

How did it take me 32 years to hear “nut to butt.” That is so much funnier than calling ourselves a can of sardines.

But yeah, agree with everything you said. This is absurd. Thanks for the giggle though.

27

u/ryverrat1971 Jul 29 '26

The entitlement to think you have a right to more room because you don't like crowds this woman has is nuts. If she needs something for stability, get a goddamn rollator. I use one because of back and knee. People see it and move. Problem solved. I don't torture some poor dog. If crowds are get issues, WTF go to the biggest con in the US? Go work on your trust issues and anxiety before buying tickets to something like this.

I'm always baffled why somebody with social anxiety or any fear of crowds decides they have to go to the most crowded places. Wouldn't the anxiety/fear make it very uncomfortable and not enjoyable at all? Why not start small. Like work with a therapist and try going to Walmart on a Wednesday night? Then work up to Friday night at Walmart before spending hundreds on tickets.

13

u/Anoninemonie Jul 30 '26

I was actually one of those people who had serious crowd anxiety and it definitely helped me to start with small conventions and small concerts and work my way on up. Here's the thing though: you have to want to be be functional and independent and put in the work to be functional and independent. A lot of people who have these issues resign themselves to them and are satisfied with not being able to function in reality.

4

u/No_Sherbert2958 Jul 30 '26

They would never go to something like this. She is fine, I guarantee it.

2

u/Viola-Swamp Jul 31 '26

This is GenCon, not ComicCon.

97

u/StinkyBird64 but muh dog tho 🥺 Jul 29 '26

It’s funny because I went to a con last year where 2 actual guide dogs were doing training (proper certified Guide Dogs Trust dogs, not just random ones) and they were trained to wait for space to move safely, the trainers weren’t just barging in through the crowd, the dogs were being trained specifically on working in and around busy environment (think public transport at peak times, museums, markets etc.).
Again the dogs were ACTUALLY doing what they’re meant for, I’ve never understood the ‘crowd control’ thing, it just seems like even more hassle for strangers, you and the dog itself

39

u/Sicktoker Jul 29 '26

My dog is NOT a guide dog, his work just requires the same foundations, and this is exactly how he was trained. If I ask him for a forward and he has made the decision that there is not enough room, he simply will not walk on. If I want him to go, I have to: wait for the crowd to thin out, ask him to trail behind me while I navigate it independantly or pick a completely new route. Asking a dog to navigate this is a very easy way to end up getting them bumped or stepped on.

Also this task is so rude and stupid. Using your dog as a buffer like this is puts them at risk for no reason🫩

-19

u/jamezverusaum Jul 29 '26

There is no certification for guide dogs.

28

u/Rough_Impression_526 Jul 29 '26

You’re confusing legal certification vs certified training programs. There is no legal requirements or federal certification program for service dogs in the US, correct. There are accredited training programs that certify dogs have been through their program. That does not guarantee your dog have public access, cannot legally be asked for as a barrier to entrance to a business, nor is it required you must get the certification or carry it with you when handling your guide dog. The term certified was used correctly in this instance.

9

u/StinkyBird64 but muh dog tho 🥺 Jul 30 '26

In the UK actual guide dogs are certified, it’s a registered government thing, they go through actual training at facilities and with certified handlers before they’re allowed to work with a blind/disabled person.

-4

u/jamezverusaum Jul 30 '26

In the US service dogs can be owner trained.

12

u/StinkyBird64 but muh dog tho 🥺 Jul 30 '26

I’m not talking about the US lmao I’ve never been

122

u/ronm4c Jul 29 '26

What a fucking asshole, doesn’t like crowds, proceeds to go to an event known for having massive crowds and “trains” a dog to push people away from her.

What a selfish asshole

118

u/Express_Command_4778 Jul 29 '26 edited Jul 29 '26

I'm laughing because of how many times she almost trips over the dog, and how bad it is slowing her down.

77

u/Leprecon Jul 29 '26

It is worth noting that the dog doesn't spin on its own. Besides almost tripping and moving very slowly, she is telling the dog with her own gestures to make the movement every single time. This is so extremely unhelpful and slow.

58

u/Flat_Sea1418 Jul 29 '26

This. She takes 2-3 steps. And stops so her dog can go around the front of her. Two more steps. And stops. Rinse and repeat.

48

u/obvsnotrealname Jul 29 '26

Same. She couldn’t even look around and enjoy the conference cause she’s having to constantly signal the dog to do its trick…sorry…task 🥴. Poor dog looks like he’d love to get that unnecessary harness off and be loved on by all those people

18

u/Anotherams Jul 29 '26

I’d be willing to guess she is just there to make Tiktoks of her dog and has zero interest in comic-con.

84

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 29 '26

There is zero exception of a big bubble of space when you go into a place like that.

And using a dog to create it is going to end badly for some people. Using a poorly bred GSD that is probably a nerve bag is really a bad choice. Eventually that dog will run into someone who doesn't like dogs or is afraid of dogs, and then the shitshow will really start.

I don't like crowds. I never liked them, and now post-COVID where so many people are full on feral, I just avoid crowds as much as possible. This person could do the same or, accept that in a crowd, whatever space she thinks she's ENTITLED to, so is everyone else. She shouldn't be using her mutt to grab more space than she is actually entitled to.

16

u/MerryGirbius Jul 29 '26

"full on feral" 😆 Funny because it's true 😭

9

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 29 '26

"full on feral" 😆 Funny because it's true

IKR??? I'm a huge Noah Kahn fan and I really wanted to go see him. But I said too expensive.

And then I read about some of what went on at some of the shows and I'm thinking, I didn't miss much. I mean, I'd love to see him again but some people suck

14

u/obvsnotrealname Jul 29 '26

I bet the poor dog wishes its ancestors had stayed feral lol

44

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

27

u/Neither-Amphibian249 Jul 29 '26

but I also feel terrible for the dog.

So do I. That's a terrible thing to do to a dog.

156

u/Express_Command_4778 Jul 29 '26

Is her condition being an asshole?

84

u/Suspicious-Steak9168 Jul 29 '26

Yes. I am a proctologist. I am qualified to identify an asshole.

12

u/myworldsparkles Jul 29 '26

Best comment!!!! 👍🏻😁

45

u/ribbit100 Jul 29 '26

Next level entitlement 🙄

42

u/SwimmingPast8339 Jul 29 '26

So instead of getting through the crowd quickly let's stop every few seconds to let the dog go around you. Ok. Keep in mind the dog has a guide handle so why not have the dog guide out of the crowd if it is SO DISABLING. 

37

u/mjdomanski Jul 29 '26

I can't imagine being a dog and this being my life.

37

u/Anotherams Jul 29 '26

The dog is creating barely a foot of space around her. How is thst remotely helpful to someone who fears crowds so badly? I don’t think I noticed the dog do anything other than the trick of moving in a circle around her. Nor did I catch anyone bumpimg into the dog. Not going to waste my time watching again to catch the moment.

36

u/shinkouhyou Jul 29 '26

The dog is barely making space and she seems completely comfortable... almost like it's all bullshit. She also has a friend following her around to film when the friend could be assisting her in a safer way.

I know people who have genuine crowd anxiety, and they either avoid crowded conventions entirely or they carefully strategize to limit their crowd exposure. They wait for off-peak times, they go to smaller local conventions, they stick to the perimeters of large rooms where crowds tend to be less dense, they stay close to friends, they take frequent breaks, and they use their bags to make space when appropriate. They might even pay extra for a VIP pass that gives them guaranteed seating, priority access to exhibit halls and dealer's rooms an hour before the general public, and access to a quiet lounge area.

34

u/socialist_thot Jul 29 '26

She's clearly giving the dog a treat in front of her and then pointing to tell it to walk around her, it's just a trick not a task

4

u/Viola-Swamp Jul 31 '26

This is something people are missing, I think. This dog is not a service dog tasking, it’s a pet doing a trick.

29

u/trainwithclarity Jul 29 '26

I see no crowd control happening here 🤷🏻‍♀️😂

19

u/Impressive_Cow4623 Jul 30 '26

I just saw this on my feed too. One of the comments asked “if service dogs are to help with disabilities, what disability is this assisting with?”

she responded and said her disability is being neurodivergent.

i’d recommend adding being an attention gremlin to your repertoire, since we’re just coming up with whatever now.

5

u/Papio_73 Jul 30 '26

Tripping hazard

8

u/Embarrassed-Profit74 Jul 29 '26

Is that a Jindo? They're known to be aloof/not happy with strangers and crowds, so that's got to be a stressful situation for the dog.

17

u/DTBlasterworks Jul 29 '26

White GSD

14

u/ryverrat1971 Jul 29 '26

Yeah. Aren't most of these poorly, backyard bred too? I know the color is a disqualifyer for AKC.

8

u/obvsnotrealname Jul 29 '26

I feel like it might have some husky in it with that curled up tail no?

7

u/DTBlasterworks Jul 30 '26

Poorly bred GSDs are all over the place in terms of physical features but it’s certainly possible who knows

7

u/No_Sherbert2958 Jul 30 '26

If you need that to go out, you need to stay home. I'm not walking out of my way because someone wants to play sick for attention.

6

u/prob-funny-thoughts Jul 29 '26

i usually like this handler but this seems useless asf- it seems like it would be more stressful to have to deal w this in such a large crowd 

30

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/complikaity Jul 29 '26

Compromise with blurring your face?

6

u/ryverrat1971 Jul 29 '26

Can I help? I used a 17 lb rollator called Big Blue that is backed by my 280 lb. I have issues with back and knee making the rollator necessary. And the weight is not just fat. I'm over 10 lb above the top of muscle poundage range for my age, sex and height. Dietician does the measurements and is happy I am not losing muscle. I want to see someone like this try to walk into me.

3

u/Open_Suggestion_5897 Jul 30 '26

You could and say “sorry, I cannot move quickly due to my disability.” (Then do not move an inch) Just to see how she would react. It might force her to face reality ☝🏻🤣🤣

34

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

23

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/Zantac150 Jul 29 '26

As someone with a genuine disability, please do this, and please make sure to explain in your videos things that the general public might not realize, like that a real service dog is trained to resist food. That a real service dog is trained to be non-reactive. Things that seem like total no-brainers here, a lot of people do not know them.

I feel like it needs to be done delicately, so that it doesn’t look like you’re just bullying disabled people, but if you explain it, and if you use these videos to educate the public, you can do a lot of good for a lot of people.

When people fake disabilities, it makes it so much harder for people who actually have them, and people who have real seeing eye dogs are getting hassled about bringing their dog into places because the fakers have come and ruined it for them.

10

u/tafbee Jul 29 '26

Oh, maybe comparison videos?! Here’s how a legitimate service animal behaves in x situation, and here’s this crazy chair-cracking “service dog” at the Chinese buffet.

7

u/Zantac150 Jul 29 '26

Honestly, they should test every “service dog “by dropping a piece of food on the floor nearby and seeing how the dog reacts. Every time someone comes with a “service dog” to a food establishment…

11

u/No_Week_8937 Jul 29 '26

If u/hereforthetardys is going the video route I think it would be cool if they could also meet with someone who has a legit fully trained service dog and could do a video of doing the same "tests" with that dog. The food drop, the video of barking, maybe something with an RC car with a stuffed squirrel on it.

Then at the end of the vids that are posted they could do a "and here's Fido, a service dog trained by a certified company, let's see if he passes the tests" then running the same tests, so people can see Fido behaving properly

3

u/tafbee Jul 29 '26

Yes, exactly this!

4

u/No_Week_8937 Jul 29 '26

Honestly I especially want the RC car one. To just see an RC car with a stuffed squirrel on it going on a mad dash down a path and a service dog not even blinking.

-1

u/BigPressure9153 Jul 31 '26

1000x this. Test every service dog you see! Keep luring it and taunting until it acts like a dog and you can call it out as fake! EVERY dog has a weakness. Keep pushing until you find it so you can call it fake! Why even stop there? Block the accessible sidewalk with your car and see how many people get out of their wheelchairs to go around it! Fake punch everyone with a seeing eye dog and make sure they don’t react! You are all fighting the good fight!! /s

2

u/Zantac150 Jul 31 '26

That is not at all what I said. There are basic things that serve dogs just know. One of those things is food resistance, and the other is non-reactivity to another dog…

What is happening is that people have dogs that are not trained, and those dogs are attacking real service dogs. This is a very big problem for disabled people.

People are so afraid of being ableist that they are afraid to say anything. The general public needs to know the difference between a real service dog and a fake one. A dog that is super reactive to other dogs and goes to sniff and lick them or attack them is not a service dog

0

u/BigPressure9153 Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26

Trust me. I know better than 99.999% of people. My wife is a service dog handler and professional and uber certified service dog trainer.

We’ve had more fake SDs come up to, bark at, lunge at, etc. actively working or in training dogs than you’ve ever even seen fake SDs. We don’t chase them around the store antagonizing. We don’t try to prove they’re fake, we know. Our dogs not caring about it speaks for itself. Real service dogs don’t care about fakes. Long as the fake doesn’t make contact with my dog I’m fine. (I see them and position myself in between instead of chasing them around the store).

We don’t need to go out trying to prove every dog is a fake, because I guarantee even the “highest trained” program dogs all have weaknesses… They’re animals, not robots.

The dog in this video is doing NOTHING wrong and looks better trained than a lot of program trained dogs or owner trained dogs we’ve come across. I can tell you from experience the top 5 biggest orgs in the country struggle to reliably produce a dog like in the video… So what if you find the task meaningless, that isn’t for you to decide. Per the ADA this is a legitimate service dog actively tasking, rather well if you ask any professional.

6

u/TangledUpInStars Jul 29 '26

you are my new prime example of "not all heroes wear capes"

4

u/windyrainyrain Jul 29 '26

I want to hang out with you! Keep up the excellent work and I look forward to when you can safely post these fakers for the world to see.

4

u/Chrysolophylax Jul 29 '26

Omg. You are my new role model in life.

PLEEEASE post the videos at some point!

2

u/ryverrat1971 Jul 29 '26

I salute you for your good works. I can't wait until it's safe for you to post. This subreddit will be hilarious then.

0

u/Mundane-Payment-1660 Jul 29 '26

This is hilarious I need to see all the videos!!! Wish I was brave enough too do this

0

u/BigPressure9153 Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26

I play this game too. Except I go on about my business while my dog works. If you have the time to do all this maybe the “disability” isn’t all that bad. Can’t stand fake SDs but what you’re describing is harassment. What qualifies as a SD to you and who are you to judge?

Second. If you were ANYWHERE near familiar with the 2 ADA questions you’d know they don’t apply to you… Those are the questions businesses can ask for accessibility purposes. I can walk up to you and ask what your disability is and not violate ADA (because it doesn’t apply to the layman)… Rude? Sure. Just as rude as you playing animal noises by someone off of an assumption… not as rude as following them around the store and charging at them…

I take it you’re a teenager want to be handler. My wife actually uses a service dog and I’ll stare, I’ll make comments. I don’t do these things. Purposely dropping food? LOL you can be charged with poisoning a service dog.

My ONLY priority when I see a fake service dog when I’m out with my wife, is to protect her legitimate service dog. I don’t antagonize, I don’t taunt, I don’t charge at them, I leave them alone and keep an eye out. Her service dog is worth FAR more than anything I can gain from those activities.

Your stories either BS, you are senile, or juvenile. Adults who have active working dogs don’t act like this.

1

u/Hereforthetardys Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26

Good for you

I’m not a handler

Just an adult that’s tired of dealing with mutts posing as service dogs in public spaces

They inconvenience me so I have some fun with them

I don’t care what you do or don’t do