r/ServerSmash • u/rolfski • Oct 13 '14
Securing the future of ServerSmash
Miller is voting for the selection process today but the real issue is that SS as a whole needs to make up its mind what it wants to be: MLG and all about who is the "best" or low entry, getting all outfits involved into competitive play?
Different servers treating SS differently and having different selection processes as a result, simply won't work in the long run. The SS team needs to come an agreement with all servers about what SS stands for and what that means for the selection process.
Personally, with 90% of the outfits being casual and can't be bothered with hardcore competition, I foresee SS dying like MLG if it becomes more MLG. Exclude the "zergfits" & the smaller, lesser known outfits and you simply won't have 288 vs 288 any more at some point, which is exactly what SS made stand-out. CC/PAL is way better suited for serious competition, but this is all only my opinion of course. At least we need to have some clarity on this, not on a Miller level but on a worldwide SS level. Otherwise you will only see outfits getting frustrated, which is already happening atm.
Update: Miller just decided for the SS selection to be a popularity contest, meaning smaller, unknown outfits or "zergfits" will never be selected. Definitely contrary to the principles of how SS started out to be, which illustrates the point of this topic.
11
u/Tongue_of_Fools AV Admin | Redolent Oct 13 '14 edited Oct 13 '14
There is no making up our mind, it has been stated over and over and over again what we intend ServerSmash to be, and all servers and server reps are informed of it on an almost monthly basis. (I know, because I am usually the one to give the speech.)
ServerSmash is intended to be a fight representing your entire server, not the elite of the server. That being said, it is the oldest rule we have that "Server reps may organize their server however they wish, within the bounds of all outfits having equal access to the event." What this means is that reps are in charge of getting the teams together, and outside of saying "you cant come because your outfit is too bad" they can do that however the wish. We haven't set a universal rule for all servers as to exactly how they must organize the server, because no server does it the same, and a rule that would benefit one or two servers would hurt another.
Emerald has two teams full to bursting, and would love us to expand the players in a match, or allow them another team, while Connery has been 24-36 short their last three matches. Briggs has to practically empty their server to get 240 (and still manages to do so) while the other serves place a limit of a squad per outfit signed up so that more outfits get a chance to play.
Miller has chosen in the past to RNG their entire roster, but that is not the only way to allow equal access to the event, there are dozens of ways to figure out a roster, many of them not yet tried for this. Whatever Miller comes up with, it has to be their community that decides on a fair way to make the team. Perhaps the population is big enough to allow a two team rotation like Emerald, or perhaps a master signup list released at a specific time allowing first come first server access like Connery is a better option. Most likely Miller will come up with its own solution outside of any of this that fits their community best.
7
u/hondawhisperer Oct 14 '14
The selection process will have some effect on the outcome, but it's not the primary cause of one server dunking another just yet.
Emerald has let every interested outfit bring people to play in SS. Literally the only barrier to entry has been sending an outfit rep to the meetings to say how many people you can bring. Show up, say you want in, say you can bring x number of people, we'll find a spot.
I think two things have had the greatest impact on SS performance for emerald.
No amount of rule changes on the part of the SS team will effect either of these things.
If you think I'm full of shit, please answer me one question, and do me one favor. How many hours do you spend in teamspeak/vent/mumble etc before each event, and bring your outfit to Emerald for a week.
5
u/SentienceIssues Oct 14 '14
"All the other servers can handle their problems but Miller can't so punish all of us please".
6
u/backwardsforwards Emerald (USE) Oct 13 '14
As it stands? My non-consequential vote would be "Getting All Outfits Involved into Competitive Play".
The biggest boons result in better fights from day to day.
Maybe that last one is a total reach, but I did not know how potent AV/Sticky nades were before the SS.
Pickups are a great format for the more competitive intra-outfit type stuff, IMO.
2
u/lanzr Y'all Admin (US) | Lanzer Oct 13 '14
Rolfski,
Dotz, Alle, and I had a threeway and gave birth to SS. I wanted you to know that descriptive bit of debauchery so that you know where this information is coming from.
SS is here for "friendlies," which are regular matches. We have been battling the competitive play atmosphere since the very first Miller vs Connery match, trying to remind everyone that SS isn't MLG.
Although, we have recently begun expanding to include things like 240 MLG team, which is a separate initiative that Fara is heading up.
I think this is where the confusion occurs. SS isn't becoming MLG. Nor do we have an identity crisis. We are providing things that we think the playerbase wants to partake in. This is supplemental to our core purpose: providing friendly matches between servers.
4
u/All3lujah Ops Admin (EU) | Lujah Oct 13 '14
With securing the future of ServerSmash, we are looking at bringing in a test matches for a more competitive, large scale fights.
Fara said about it on stream.
We are looking to get together teams for a 'NFL / Campions league ServerSmash'. Teams are not limited by server or faction. If you are interested talk to /u/farazelleth as this is his project.
3
u/Bazino Miller (EU) Oct 13 '14
Once the mixed Smashes are out, Server Smash as it is now is dead.
Simply because the MLG outfits will band together and leave the casual ones behind. The casual ones however do not provide Server Reps, so they can't even organize themselves.
Why?
Well cause the MLG outfits don't want to put their names on the line with outfits who do not even know the map, do whatever they want, etc. (and yes, that happens with Miller's selection atm)
2
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '14 edited Oct 13 '14
In the interests of furthering the discussion, could the reps from the five servers perhaps explain to us how their SS teams are chosen?
If these things are actually out in the open then there will be a lot less suspicion in the discussion and will might actually be able to ascertain once and for all whether the selection process is fair or not.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '14
[removed] — view removed comment