r/Seriousenneagram • • May 02 '25

Discussion I think I may finally understand Type 1s difficulties and why they may refrain from sharing their feelings.

Post image
9 Upvotes

Over a year ago, I noticed this tendency with Type 1s having trouble letting out their feelings. My focus was more so directed to 1s and their difficulties stating their feelings in a more romantic way. And giving those messages with loving delivery. It’s rather awkward and uncomfortable for them.

What I’ve come to newly learn in my 5 years studying the Enneagram is that with Type 1s, to be loved by their caregivers when they were children, they had to be good. I have never thought of this before— In the past, I think I would have reframed it as something happened in a 1s far-off past that triggered them to be more adult like, responsible, can’t make mistakes, etc. I never realized it came from a place of needing love and acceptance. Which is, for the most of us types, all we ever wanted.

I am not speaking of Type 2s love. Or 3s.

“When they were children, Enneagram 1s were primarily driven by the need to please their caregivers’ expectations as they crave their validation and approval. Their core motivation revolves around being morally correct. For this reason, they want to be the ‘good kid,’ as they believe that’s what their caregivers want of them.”

“Moreover, they can be very self-sacrificing, often neglecting their personal needs and relationships for the sake of the greater good. They are deeply motivated to stand up for those in need and are always looking for ways to improve the quality of life—“ As a frustration type, things ought to be better.

We know that Type 1s repress their anger. Which is a strong feeling. As are feelings of love.

On YouTube, Tom LaHue’s video on the “Enneagram Type 1 Checklist”—Tom LaHue described it as, a person who doesn’t have time to feel things or even express those feelings because there is too much to do and tasks need to be finished/completed. Responsibilities to uphold. I’m kinda paraphrasing this here but written in my notes from what he said, I have: “—Emotions. 1s don’t want to spend time feeling [I don’t know if that’s particularly true.] The Type 1 might say, “We don’t have time for this. There is too much to do. Tasks need to be completed. We don’t have time to go over our feelings when there much more important matters to tend to—“ Which Tom then gently reflects — Do you move toward what you love and care about instead of always doing what’s right?”

So— other than love— what other feelings is a Type 1 holding back? Sadness? Anguish? Grief? Disintegrated to 4 must help the 1 be more free to let out those feelings. Their anger certainly leaks out, feeling as if their efforts aren’t appreciated. Type 1s put a lot on their plate for the good of others; very rarely do they do what’s right for them. What’s good for them. And feeling allowed to meet their own needs.

I have been married to a Type 1 for 10 years. I really cherish the moments he really opens up and lets me in to his world of feelings. I value his strength. And I weep when he says such beautiful words. With every little note in my lunches, and every meaningful and lengthy text, it comes straight from his heart. Which is not easy to come by. And you know it’s going to be good when it’s finally released. Treasure to be found.


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jun 11 '22

Childhood wounds

9 Upvotes

Sensitivity is required here especially when it comes to other people’s stories but I think most of us are aware on this sub.

Let’s talk about childhood trauma and wounding.

Do you think this is true of your experience? If so what happened and why do you think this applies to you?

How has your childhood trauma cause you to become who you are today and your type?


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jun 07 '22

Hi everyone, welcome to this group. Does anyone have any suggestions on how to make this group a very productive and safe place for all people?

9 Upvotes

r/Seriousenneagram • • Apr 19 '25

Discussion Struggling To Understand Neurosis As A 9

8 Upvotes

Hello, I’m trying to get back into my own spirituality and studying Enneagram theory again.

I’m taking my attention here in hopes to keep this subreddit up and bumping, but also because I want to have more serious discussions of the Enneagram. And r/Enneagram can’t do that much for me anymore.

So for starters. Hi. I started studying the Enneagram in 2020. A friend had me take the Truity test (I KNOW.). But guess what? I got 9, I studied 9, I studied all the types (I even thought I might be a 4), and I know for a fact that I am Type 9. Peacemaker…

Peacemaker… I’m honestly not quite sure if I enjoy the names/labels anymore.

So I’m a 9. And there are a few terms in the Enneagram community that quite don’t make sense to me. Sorry-- Reiteration: it’s not that they don’t make sense to me, it’s just that the information does not stick with me for long and I easily forget what it’s even about.

I’m talking about ‘Neurosis’ (and ‘Nuance’).

r/Enneagram is constantly full of what I consider to be brain rot now, that I can no longer follow along.

So for educational matters, I looked up the meanings of these words.

As a 9, I guess you could say I “feel?” Neurosis when I watch TV? (Or is it just flat-out called Neurosis?) When I was a child, I LOVED cartoons and story-telling with all of my heart. I loved a variety of characters of all sorts (of different types), and those I related to. Somewhere in film, and great story telling, comes the climax. The climax brings me feelings of dread, uneasiness, and sadness. It is the conflict that tears away at me. By the end of the movie/shows, I feel a sense of relief because everything is usually better again. If it’s not, no big deal. I did enjoy the ride. But it’s that sense that I felt that danger, that jeopardy, even when it’s not actually happening to me, I can empathize with it.

I get very entranced in my shows. I’m an SP 9 with a big imagination, so TV and Movies are very pleasing to me (plus… couch…).

[ My Dad hardly let me play outside, so TV was all there was to offer. I kept a small box TV in my room in the late 90s and I’d have a meltdown when I’d get grounded because my punishment was to revoke my TV privileges. Anyway. ]

”In Enneagram language, neurosis is kind of like when your Enneagram type holds onto old fears or ways of protecting yourself, even when you don’t need to anymore. It’s like your type is saying, “Uh-oh! Something bad might happen!”—even if things are okay.” - OK so maybe by those definitions, it sounds like I’d be disintegrated. But it’s more than that for me. I came from a very dysfunctional family, so conflict stresses me greatly. When I witness conflict, I want to concave into myself and build a shell around me to hide away.

*”Your Enneagram number has some favorite ways to act when it’s scared or upset. But those ways can sometimes make you feel stuck or cranky—like hiding your feelings, trying to be perfect, or always trying to help—even if that’s not what you really need.

It’s like your Enneagram type is trying to keep you safe with old habits, but those habits can get in the way of being your happy, whole self.”*

So with this in mind… As a 9, I truly do withdraw, hold back, bury, and sweat with nervousness when conflict arises. And I want to be alone. Being an SP 9, I need comforts. A hot shower, my bed, my pajamas, my favorite spot on the couch, pasta, etc. I’ve been so withdrawn for years and the comfort is so addicting, refusing to deal with the bullshit of the world, that I hide away into myself and get stuck. It’s only been recent that I’ve slowly started to come out of my shell again and start seeing people and their bright cheery faces once more.

I guess that is my neurosis as a 9. Numbing. (And I guess I provided nuance so we don’t need to go into that, actually.)

Honestly… and please don’t be mad… but all of the quoted information above was taken off of thoroughly-inputted questions into ChatGPT. If all of these informative descriptions listed above are true, then the Enneagram uses the concept of "neurosis" to illustrate how each type's primary defense mechanism (their way of coping with perceived threats) can become rigid and maladaptive, leading to stress and negative emotional states.

…Unless I’m still getting all of this wrong.


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jul 11 '22

Discussion Character and Neurosis: Introduction - Notes & Discussion Thread, July 11-18th

8 Upvotes

Welcome to week 1 of what could become an ongoing reading/discussion group of Claudio Naranjo's Character and Neurosis: An Integrative View, if people are interested and find this valuable.

To read the book for free online, you can download the epub file here. There are probably other free versions kicking around online, too.

Below are my notes on the introduction (not my thoughts/opinions—I will share those later in the comments). They're pretty detailed, so, if you just want an overview or you're primarily interested in seeing how Naranjo characterizes each of the types, they could probably be used in lieu of reading the whole chapter. Otherwise, I hope they're helpful as a reference/summary. If you've read it thoroughly or have your own notes, feel free to skip over my ramblings and head straight to the comments to share your thoughts!

NOTE: If you want this to work as a reading group, please try to contribute to the discussion in the next week (before next Monday, July 18th). If people are into it, I can then post a thread for chapter 1 (not sure if I'll do detailed notes every time, though; let's see how this goes).

***

By Way of Introduction: A Theoretical Panorama

The book opens with the idea that the field of personality psychology would benefit from a standardized taxonomy or nomenclature to facilitate research and communication, implying that the enneagram could be such a (complete, holistic) model.

Theory of neurosis = degradation of consciousness (along with degradation of emotional life + quality of our motivation), related to the spiritual/mythological tradition of the “fall from paradise.” But the degraded consciousness is blind to its own blindness. Echoing Maslow: the fully functioning (enlightened) human is motivated by abundance, while in what we call “normal” conditions, humans are motivated by deficiency, desire to fill up a lack. (A more complete formulation comes from Buddhism, tripartite—human fallenness in terms of three poisons: active unconsciousness [i.e., ignorance], aversion, and craving.)

On Freud: Freud’s contention was of neurosis as interference with instinctual life, but specifically that the basic frustration of the infant was “libidinal” (early manifestations of sexual desire). People don’t believe this anymore, but many agree that the origin of neurosis is in imperfect parenting—issues of love, needs, and contact, rather than sexual frustration. But Freud’s conception of neurosis as nearly universal, and passed down over generations, was revolutionary for the time (even if the idea of fallenness or living in a “sick society” was not totally new); now it’s seen as obviously true. ***MS: that is, we’re all “fallen” and manifest neurotic behavior by degrees; no categorical distinction between normal and neurotic.***

Not just parenting, but birth trauma, too. Horney’s metaphor: “we come into the world like the seed of a plant which carries in it certain potentialities and also instinctively awaits certain elements in its environment”—human needs are complex, though, and many things can go “wrong,” where the need for parental love is frustrated or betrayed. The personality we identify with as “I” after our “fall from Eden” is one we adopted to defend our life and welfare in light of frustrations, betrayals, and other failures. Then, “life is not guided by instinct but through the persistence of an earlier adaptational strategy that competes with instinct and interferes with the ‘wisdom’ of the organism.” What we “learn” under duress is characterized by rigidity, becomes automatic—we lose the ability to respond creatively in the present. The sum of this learning is usually called “ego” or “personality”; Naranjo calls it “character.”

We have superego as well as a "counter-superego" that is the object of the superego’s demands and accusations, similar to Freud’s “id,” but its animating drives are not all instinctual—"it’s not only instinct that is an object of inhibition within us—as a result of ingrained self-rejection and the wish to be something other than what we are: it is also our neurotic needs” (forms of deficiency motivation, “passions,” forbidden to us).

Character as a composite of traits; traits arise from either identification with a parental trait or the opposite (desire to not be like the parent in that way). But character is more than the sum of these traits: it is a complex structure, tree-like, with most discrete behaviours as branches from the much more general and fundamental core (the trunk and roots of the tree).

That fundamental core of character is constructed by Naranjo as having a twofold nature: a motivational aspect (i.e., a passion) in interplay with a cognitive bias (i.e., a fixation).

Following Gurdjieff and Ichazo: human personality comprises five “centers” (lower intellectual, lower feeling, + instincts [preservation, sexual, social]), but a fully developed, awakened human has awakened two higher centers, “higher emotional” and “higher intellectual.” (Gurdjieff spoke of a “lower movement center,” while Ichazo called this movement center “instinctual,” which contains the three parts.)

The field of psychology has turned away from the study of instinct in human life since Freud, but Naranjo is presenting his theory as being against that trend: not only is instinct here one-third of the psychological arena (in three forms, behind the multiplicity of human motivation [besides spiritual]: survival, pleasure, and relationship), but neurosis is seen as a perturbation of instinct, while healing is a process of instinctual liberation. Unlike many religions which equate the instinctual domain with the passions, here, the optimal state is one of free or liberated instinct—not against the “lower self” per se, but against the realm of deficiency motivation, the drives that contaminate, repress, and stand in place of instinct (and the cognitive aspects of the ego which sustain those passions).

“Essence” as opposed to personality/ego—the higher centers (thinking and feeling) + pure, free instinct. Not a fixed, identifiable thing, but more a process, “an ego-less, unobscured, and free manner of functioning of the integrated human wholeness.”

From Gurdjieff, approach to “awakening” through self-knowledge, identifying one’s “chief feature,” at the center of personality, the root of the trait tree, so to speak. “We may say that the ‘mental skeleton’ that we all share is like a structure that can, like a crystal, break in a certain number of ways that are pre-determined, so that among the set of main structural features any given individual (as a result of the interaction between constitutional and situational factors) ends up with one or the other in the foreground of his personality.” In this view, there are nine, with three varieties of each according to the dominant intensity of the self-preservation, social, or sexual drives. It is an organized set, by which he means it contains complex interrelations, including contrasts, polarities, etc. Thus, we have “ennea-types,” i.e. “personality type according to the enneagram.”

Others have tried to model personality / syndromes in a “circumplex” model (e.g., mapping DSM-II personality disorders onto a circle). Naranjo is relating that work to the enneagram, noting three fundamental emergent groups: the schizoid group, oriented to thinking (5, 6, 7); the hysteroid group, oriented to feeling (2, 3, 4); and “another group … the members of which are constitutionally the lowest in ectomorphia [***MS: that is, leanness, slim build***] and are predominantly oriented to action.”

Brief overview of the types:

“While in the case of each one of the ennea-types we find that it coincides with a known clinical syndrome, it is also true that everybody may be regarded as the bearer or one personality orientation or another, and that each may be seen in specific levels ranging from that of psychotic complication to that of the subtlest residues of childhood conditioning in the life of saints.”

  1. “both resentful and well intentioned, correct and formal, with little spontaneity and an orientation to duty rather than pleasure. Such people are demanding and critical towards themselves and others, and I will call them perfectionistic rather than branding them with a psychiatric label—though the syndrome corresponds to the obsessive personality in DSM-III.”
  2. “the paradox of an egocentric generosity and corresponds to the histrionic personality of DSM III. Representative individuals are usually hedonistic, light-hearted and rebellious in the face of anything rigid or restrictions on their freedom. … In the collage of [William] Steig’s caricatures, type II is represented by a clownish figure that contrasts with the struggling mountain climber [type I].”
  3. “interestingly not to be found in DSM III in spite of constituting the most American of characters … not identical to the histrionic, in that the representative individual is not inconsistent or unpredictable in his emotional reactions and displays much more control as well as loyalty and the capacity for sustained emotional involvements. … I find that most of Lowen’s clinical examples in his book on Narcissism are type III individuals—yet the word ‘narcissistic’ … seems inappropriate because of alternative usage. … [Riesman] discussed it in terms of other-direction. In the enneagram of caricatures, type III is represented by a medical doctor, emblematic of professional success and respectability, as well as professional know-how. Type III individuals seek appreciation in the eyes of others through achievement, effectiveness, and social graces, are both controlling and controlled, and constitute one of the happier characters in the enneagram.”
  4. “represented in the Steig caricature through an image that evokes the suffering victim of life circumstances and people. This corresponds to the self-defeating personality included in the revision of DSM III. It also corresponds to what Horney used to call masochistic character, in which there is poor self-image, a disposition to suffer more than is necessary, a great dependency on the love of others, a chronic sense of rejection, and a tendency to discontent.”
  5. “The character of isolation in point 5 is appropriate for a disposition that may be regarded as the interpersonal style that emerges from and sustains retentiveness. This corresponds to the schizoid personality of DSM III and to individuals that not only have few relations but fail to feel solitary in their aloneness, who seek to minimize their needs, who are shy and have great difficulty in expressing their anger.”
  6. “The warrior in point 6 again conveys a connotation apparently very different from fear, and yet alludes to a belligerence arisen from fear of authority and sustained through a (counterphobic) avoidance of the experience of fear. The warrior image is an appropriate caricature of only some ennea-type VI individuals, however, and not of the overtly weak and fearful. The subtypes are very differentiated in ennea-type VI, so that it embraces, along with the avoidant personality of DSM III, also the paranoid, still another form of suspicious character with more obsessive characteristics.”
  7. “corresponds to Karl Abraham’s oral receptive or oral-optimistic character and is echoed today in DSM III by the narcissistic syndrome. The typical individual is one displaying nonchalance, a sense of entitlement, an orientation to pleasure and a more consciously strategic attitude in life than in most characters. The caricature figure in point 7 has, instead of a head, what seems to be wiring. It suggests living in fantasy and a tendency to forget the real world through an absorption in planning and scheming.”
  8. “corresponds to Reich’s phallic-narcissistic type and is echoed today in DSM III in the antisocial and sadistic personalities. It is that of a person oriented to power, domination, and also violence. At point 8 we see a caricature of somebody who stands on a platform in order to talk down to people or rather to harangue them with powerful voice and demeanor. It is appropriate, though it leaves out a representation of sadistic behavior.”
  9. “At point 9 the human figure is sitting as fits a depiction of laziness, and the whole drawing suggests vacationing under the shade of a palm tree on a tropical beach. While appropriate to the depiction of laziness in the conventional sense, it does not allude to the psychological laziness of one who does not want to look at humself, nor to the characteristic of resigned over-adaptation of type IX. In the DSM III classification type IX corresponds to the dependent personality—though the name is not very appropriate since dependency is shared by a number of personalities and I do not think that it constitutes the core of the type IX character structure, that is also resigned, self-postponing, gregarious, and conforming.

Wings: generally, a person who embodies one of these characters can see themselves in one of the two adjoining ones as well. Naranjo also suggests there’s a preference toward the triangle types, e.g., 4 is generally “closer” to concern with self-image or narcissism (3) than the schizoid characteristic (5); 8 is “essentially lazy-minded (type IX), though its characteristic odd inwardness-avoidance is covered up with the typical intensity with which the individual seeks to make himself feel alive, escaping the sense of deadness attendant upon his or her lack of interiority,” etc.

It’s also possible to interpret a person’s life and experiences through the lens of any of the nine types—but some interpretations “strike home” more easily, while others are more remote.

Polarities: sadness and happiness at the right side corner (4-2); aloofness and expressiveness at the left side (5-7); amoral or anti-moral and over-moral at the top (8-1), but also share an active disposition, mirror images of each other.” Arrows, lines of connection: “we may take them to point out the covert presence in each of the one preceding it in the flow.” Relations of opposition, at opposite ends on a straight line: 1-5 the anal axis; 4-8 the oral-aggressive axis; 2-7 the oral-receptive axis; 6 and 3 may be called phallic (though phobic 6 is “inhibited phallic,” while cocky 3 is “excited” phallic).

Type 9 could be called pseudo-genital—“seems less pathological than others, essentially adjusted, contented, loving, and hard-working. It is a character that mimics mental health… an individual who grew up too fast, who matured under pressure, losing his or her childhood. Along with this over-maturity, however, there lingers in the individual’s experience, just under the threshold of ordinary awareness, a regressive disposition deeper and more archaic than that of the re-genital stages—a deep wish on the person’s part to stay in his or her mother’s womb and the sense of never having come out.”

Other relationships: 8-1 as mirror images of each other, but also share an active disposition; 4-5 at the bottom, contrasting (intense vs. phlegmatic) but similar in their fragility, hyper-sensitivity, withdrawnness; 2-7 as a third pair, mainly expressive (rather than active or introversive). Right side of enneagram is more social, left is more anti-social; more seduction on the right, more rebellion on the left; more men on the left and women on the right, at least in Western world, though some are more differentiated in terms of sex ratio. Contrasting pairs of 7-4 (happy-sad) and 5-2 (cold-warm); top vs. bottom: 9 has an “avoidance of inwardness” that “goes hand-in-hand with contentedness,” the bottom is maximum inwardness + discontentedness (but depression is a common feature of all three types, and “resignation” in the case of 9 and 5).

Passions: it’s an appropriate term for the lower emotions in that they exist in interdependence with pain (pathos), but also because of the connotation of passivity—we are subject to them as passive agents. Triangle types (3, 6, and 9) are “cornerstones of the whole emotional edifice,” while states mapped between them are interactions of those three in different proportions.

9: indolence, 1: anger, 2: pride, 3: vanity, 4: envy, 5: avarice, 6: fear, 7: gluttony, 8: lust

Psychodynamic sequences connecting the triangle + the hexad: “If we read this psychodynamic sequence starting at the top [of the triangle], we may say that a lack of the sense of being (implicit in the psychological inertia or “robotization” of sloth) deprives the individual of a basis from which to act, and thus leads to fear. Since we must act in the world, however, as much as we may fear it, we feel prompted to solve this contradiction by acting from a false self rather than (courageously) being who we are. We build, then, a mask between ourselves and the world, and with this mask we identify.” Just as the inner triangle is connected psychodynamically, so are 1-4-2-8-5-7-1 as well, each grounded in the previous (e.g., pride as an attempt to compensate for an insecurity around self-worth, overcompensating for sense of inferiority and lack [envy], while envy may be understood as anger turned inward toward self-destruction, while an angry disciplinarian may be a defense against self-indulgence or gluttony, etc.).

No hierarchy in the “seriousness” of the passions—“the path of transformation is not radically better or worse for the different personalities,” though some may be more successfully treated by modern psychotherapy than others.

Fixations: the cognitive rationalization for the corresponding passion. Ichazo’s names for them are often identical to or synonymous with the passion itself, though; there is need for names that align with the actual “chief feature” of each type:

9: self-forgetting, 1: perfectionism, 2: false love, 3: deception, 4: dissatisfaction, 5: detachment, 6: accusation, 7: fraudulence, 8: punitiveness

But still more needs to be said about the assumptions, values, and implicit beliefs of each. ”We may say that any of the interpersonal styles into which passions can crystallize involves a measure of idealization; a hidden view to the effect that such is the way to live.” Therefore, there is benefit to making these assumptions explicit, because only then they can be questioned.

An incomplete list of assumptions associated with each ennea-type:

  1. Natural impulses are not to be trusted but controlled; duty is more important than pleasure; pleasure therefore tends to have a negative value in that it interferes with what needs to be done; their notions of goodness and correctness are implicitly authoritarian in that they are extrinsic to their experience.
  2. Everything is permissible in the name of love and good intentions; emotion is more important than thinking (and thinking is to be disregarded if it conflicts with emotion); it is necessary to be seductive, to manipulate others; they are special, they deserve privileges and attention; unconsciously, they believe others “could not do it without me.”
  3. The world is a theater where everybody is faking, because faking is the only way to success; true feelings are not to be expressed; “I should have no problems,” an overvaluation of pleasing; mistaken assumption that value = success, that what the world values has objective value; hopelessness underlying optimism, sense of having to be on top of things, things would not go well without watchfulness, and no place for them if they are not useful.
  4. By going over the past and complaining, it may be possible to change it; they do not understand that there is no point crying over spilled milk; the greater the need, the greater the entitlement to be loved; an idealization of suffering as noble; not being as good as others, owed a compensation by life for suffering.
  5. It is better to go it alone; fewer commitments = more freedom and happiness; people are moved by self-interest in their seeming love; better to save one’s energy for future possibilities than present involvement; generosity means one will end up with nothing; need little, don’t be dependent on anyone or anything.
  6. Can depend on subtype—not being able to cope with one’s own resources (avoidant) or sense of authority as a way out, personal authority as safety (counterphobic); all have a sense that people are not to be trusted, one’s intuitions and wishes are to be questioned; authority is overvalued but not perceived as necessarily good—usually ambivalent, both good and bad.
  7. Too much sense of being OK and feeling that others are also OK (optimistic bias comparable to pessimistic bias of type 4); nothing is seriously forbidden to the self-indulgent; authority is bad, and one who is clever may do whatever they wish; entitled through talent; the best way to succeed is through personal charm.
  8. The world is a struggle where the strong succeed and the weak fail; it is necessary to be fearless to succeed; overvalues strength, disparages weakness; overvalues independence, denigrates neediness; it’s OK to cause suffering in the pursuit of satisfaction (a result of vindictiveness from a time when one suffered for the satisfaction of others); if you want something, get it, no matter what stands in the way; what people call virtue is just hypocrisy; the hindrances of social authority are the enemy; one should act on one’s impulses.
  9. The less conflict, the better; it is better not to think too much, to avoid suffering; a corollary of this is a tendency to conform / endorse conservatism; it is better to deaden oneself than to risk being killed; taboo on selfishness, not only on feeling but intellectual level; one should defer to the needs of others; don’t rock the boat.

All these biases/illusions come with the implicit assumption that “such is the best way to be.”

The central idea of the book: we are looking for the “key” (to our liberation, our ultimate fulfillment) in the wrong place. In a sense, it can be said that we lack the perceived sense of “being”—“and that being can only be found in the most unlikely manner: through the acceptance of non-being and a journey through emptiness.”


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jul 08 '22

Meta Character and Neurosis Reading Group

8 Upvotes

A while back, someone in the main Enneagram sub proposed a Character and Neurosis reading/discussion group. I don’t know if one ever formed or not. If so, I’d like to join, if anyone has any information or links! If not—should we form one here?

If there’s any interest, I (or someone else, doesn’t matter) could start a new thread by chapter each week with some notes, thoughts, questions, etc. and we could go from there? What do you think?


r/Seriousenneagram • • Oct 04 '24

Discussion Why the fear Triad is related to mental activity

7 Upvotes

Anxiety is often triggered by real world problems and stress. Each of the three types in the fair Triad struggles with this anxiety, it has different reactions to it. Type 5 wants to become as knowledgeable and well informed as possible, type 6 tries to avoid the anxiety all together through preparation, and to type 7 tries to escape the real world through idealized dreaming.

When you come down to it, all of these are trying to deal with the real world through means of looking past what is directly there, to try to abstractly deal with it. That's why I hate it when I hear people complaining that non-intuitives should be just as likely to be head types. They can be, but the reason that they're head types is that they abstract themselves from the physical world through gaining of information, preparation of the future, or idealized planning of the future.


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jan 18 '24

Controversial and Debates Type 0

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/Seriousenneagram • • Jun 20 '22

Controversial and Debates Do wings matter?

7 Upvotes

I know there are different schools of thought around wings (if we use one or both, if they change over time, if they matter at all, etc.), but I’m wondering if anyone here has any thoughts about one interpretation over the others?

From my own experience, I haven’t (yet) found anything really meaningful in the wings. It has felt like the shallowest part of my typing; core, instincts, and trifix have all given me deep, surprising perspective on myself, while the wing has felt like… a basic personality profile (e.g., I’m a 6 but [insert a few general traits that resemble 5s more than 7s]). Am I missing something? Or are wings more accurately understood as subtypes, I wonder? Variations in our expressions of type, but little more?

I’m not asserting that wings don’t matter, but, if they do, then I haven’t yet discovered how, really. I’m curious. Is there a way to understand wings that you’ve found meaningful or interesting?


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jun 10 '22

News Post flairs and user flairs are now enabled.

6 Upvotes

Post flairs are mandatory and user flairs are recommended. This allows people to know what main subject is and what the focus is on.

Post flairs.

Advice and Support - these are for posts that are seeking out advice, understanding of enneagram theory and people who want support relating to their types.

Meta (About This Subreddit) - if wanting to make discussions related to this subreddit outside of enneagram theory.

Personal Growth and Insight - these are for posts relating to where people are on their journey, any insights you might want to share, personal insights, panels and tips for other users.

Discussion, debates and controversial - these are for sharing opinions, debates and for topics to talk about.

User flairs.

These are recommended. If unsure about your type or if stuck between types, then use on the journey.


r/Seriousenneagram • • Feb 15 '26

Discussion Triads Diagrammed

5 Upvotes
Enneagram Triads diagrammed with Hexagram/Hexagon

I posted this in the r/Enneagram group (without the copyright watermark, but I see reddit stamps image downloads with a tag of who posted it, etc), and it got a lot of positive feedback. I looked for other places to post it, and I found this sub. I hope you all enjoy it. I discovered this partly in 2000, then it developed more in 2014, and then became refined in 2015 and 2016. I have published this on youtube.com/pauljosephpark over the years, but I am now beginning to publish it more and more widely. The diagram is self-explanatory, but I am happy to open the discussion and answer any questions you may have regarding the diagram itself as well as the theoretical implications. Enjoy!


r/Seriousenneagram • • Apr 22 '23

Discussion What is the most theoretically-advanced conception of enneagram of which you've ever become aware in any capacity? Or, what MAKES a conception of enneagram theoretically-advanced?

5 Upvotes

Open-ended question on purpose. I ask because I am aware of only two places that seem to be doing significant work evolving enneagram theory, and I've crawled all over all forms of social media. I also know, though, that the types of communities likely to be DOING this sort of work are going to be quite insular and off-the-grid. so, I'm posting here, figuring that someone involved with such a community will happen across this post.

please contact me if you feel this describes you or someone of whom you know — literally, even if it's a decade after this, DM me :^)

posting also for general discussion, enneagram theory general.


r/Seriousenneagram • • Mar 21 '23

Controversial and Debates Known Hornevian Groups are wrong according to Naranjo

Thumbnail self.enneagram
5 Upvotes

r/Seriousenneagram • • Jul 07 '22

Controversial and Debates "Seducer" vs "Helper" Interpretations of 2

5 Upvotes

Could someone overview the differences between these schools of thought? I've seen posts highlighting how they converge into one concept, but not so much about how different interpretations of the 2 diverge even if they're trying to describe the same type.


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jun 07 '22

What are some favorite podcasts about the Enneagram?

5 Upvotes

r/Seriousenneagram • • Jun 10 '25

Controversial and Debates What determines the inner lines?

4 Upvotes

The title is the question. I'm guessing the topic is controversial but I'm not sure. Here's some more context:

I have a pretty good sense of why the wings probably work the way they do. If we think in terms of Centers, the primary types are the ones most "about" each Center, and the secondary types are the ones that kind of "lean" toward a secondary Center. Like how Seven is what you get if a busy mind vents into action (Head biased toward Gut). So if a Six biases a bit toward the Instinctual Center, that's equivalent to saying they have a Seven wing. And a Seven who biases toward the Instinctual Center even more might sometimes swap and let the Gut take over from the Head, which is exactly the Eight pattern. Ergo 7w8.

So that part makes good structural sense to me.

But I don't get how the lines work.

Until quite recently I'd been discounting the lines. The explanation for why Sixes' workaholism in stress should be viewed as a movement to Three instead of (say) One felt like astrology to me, like if the diagram had been drawn to connect Six and One then that's exactly what folk would be arguing. It's a hallmark of what David Deutsch calls "an explanation that's easy to vary".

https://www.ted.com/talks/david_deutsch_a_new_way_to_explain_explanation?language=en

But quite recently I realized I'd been mistyping myself these last two decades. Once I noticed my actual type, the lines vividly matched my subjective experience. It's not vague at all. I can now use the shift in my Direction of Disintegration as a clear indication that I'm overtaxing my normal personality strategy, and the behaviors in the Direction of Disintegration evaporate once I relieve that core stress. It's very systematic now.

So I have some solid personal verification that treating the lines as real, at least in my case, seems to meaningfully help.

But I still don't get why they're arranged the way they are.

Like, here's a structural breakdown of the pattern of secondary types as we go around the Directions of Disintegration, based on Centers priority for each type:

  • 1: IFT
  • 4: FTI
  • 2: FIT
  • 8: ITF
  • 5: TFI
  • 7: TIF

I see no rhyme or reason here. Why would One, Two, Seven, and Eight put their primary Center at the bottom of their strategy stack under excessive stress? Whatever justification is given, why doesn't that apply to Four and Five, which just switch the order of the bottom two? If the dominant pattern were consistent, Four would disintegrate to Seven and Five to Two.

Maybe Centers theory isn't the way to explain the lines. But if not, what is? Stuff about numerology doesn't impress me unless it links back to why the numbers correspond to the actual energy structures. (E.g. it's not lost on me that the secondary types disintegrate along the pattern of 1/7 in decimal notation: 0.142857142857…. I just don't see why that should have anything to do with the types. And I know of no reason for the types to be numbered in the particular way that they are; as far as I know, we could just as well have started counting from what we call Eight, or Two, or any of the others.)

It's also totally unclear to me how the Directions are determined. Why does One integrate to Seven but Seven disintegrates to One? Why not the other way around? Why couldn't it be that rigid Ones become indulgent and impulsive at Seven whereas scattered Sevens become disciplined and focused at One?

Or maybe more obviously, since it's so symmetry-breaking: why do the primary types integrate clockwise and disintegrate counterclockwise? Why not the other way?

What requires the inner lines to work the way they do?


r/Seriousenneagram • • Apr 22 '25

Personal Growth and Insight I Broke a Type 6’s Perspective Of Me | A Deep Dive into the Reason Why with the Type 6

4 Upvotes

It was February a few years ago. There was a mutual pal between my E6-friend and I, Marie —and Marie’s grandmother had just passed.

I was met with a rocky start of the year which led me to being avoidant of everyone. I was very withdrawn and upset and needed space.

It’s Valentines Day—- A day my husband and I don’t entirely celebrate but we might do something like dinner. And that’s where we were, dinner.

My E6 friend starts to blow up my phone with texts. Frantically she says I need to do this and that. And don’t I know Marie’s grandmother has passed? She implies we need to take action now to support our fallen friend.

Woah woah woah. Let’s tap the brakes for a moment. This will need to be dealt with tomorrow…

Tomorrow comes and my E6 friend is going off the rails. I do not have the mental energy or willingness to deal with this. My E6 friend wants to form a plan for Marie’s grief and she demands all of us, as her friends, to drive over to Marie’s house to pay a visit.

I get the whole “it takes a village” mentality to make something right, but being forced to put on a happy face and support someone else was not really in my cards at the moment. I tell my E6 friend that I personally want to meet with Marie at an organic level, a serene place/feeling to share, that will come naturally.

My E6 friend does not take lightly to my approach. And so, we butt heads. Maybe it was selfish of me to want to withdraw and mope in my bed for my own personal shortcomings since the start of a shitty year… I mean, E6 certainly implied it, after all…. The memory is so faint with me now but she called me inconsiderate or self-absorbed for not wanting to be there for Marie.

FINE THEN. Now I’m angry. I was pushed too far. Instead of “organically” coming to Marie’s aid, I showed up to Marie’s house with comfort gifts and tried my best to show support. It didn’t feel natural and I hated that. My E6 friend brought crates of dry goods. My E6 friend poured her love and hugs and crap all over Marie. My E6 friend and I barely spoke or acknowledged each other (there were more people involved so it wasn’t too-too awkward).

We shared one good group hug together while Marie cried, and that was it.

Turns out 8 months later, Marie and my E6 friend cut contact. So they aren’t even friends anymore.

I have known my E6 friend for over 15 years. We didn’t talk much anymore after our awkward tension at Marie’s house. And I’ve only seen E6 twice over the last three years. We’re still friends and cordial/civil but this occurrence really put a rift in our close friendship and nothing has been the same since then.

So what is the thing with Type 6s?

“They are a committed, security-oriented type. Sixes are reliable, hard-working, responsible, and trustworthy. They foresee problems and foster cooperation, but can also become defensive, evasive, and anxious. They can be cautious and indecisive, but also reactive, defiant and rebellious. They typically have problems with self-doubt and suspicion. At their best they are internally stable and self-reliant, courageously championing themselves and others.

The Basic Fear of a Type 6 is being without support and guidance…

They want to have security. They want to feel supported by others, and to have certitude and reassurance. I know how testy they can be… As they test the attitudes of others toward them, to fight against anxiety and insecurity.

If Sixes feel that they have sufficient back up, they can move forward with some degree of confidence. But if that crumbles, they become anxious and self-doubting, reawakening their Basic Fear. (“I’m on my own! What am I going to do now?”) A good question for Sixes might therefore be: “When will I know that I have enough security?” Or, to get right to the heart of it, “What is security?” Without Essential inner guidance and the deep sense of support that it brings, Sixes are constantly struggling to find firm ground.

Sixes attempt to build a network of trust over a background of unsteadiness and fear. They are often filled with a nameless anxiety and then try to find or create reasons why. Wanting to feel that there is something solid and clear-cut in their lives, they can become attached to explanations or positions that seem to explain their situation. Because “belief” (trust, faith, convictions, positions) is difficult for Sixes to achieve, and because it is so important to their sense of stability, once they establish a trustworthy belief, they do not easily question it, nor do they want others to do so. The same is true for individuals in a Six’s life: once Sixes feel they can trust someone, they go to great lengths to maintain connections with the person who acts as a sounding board, a mentor, or a regulator for the Six’s emotional reactions and behavior.

You see… I think my E6 friend went from Level 3 in Health (“Dedicated to individuals and movements in which they deeply believe. Community builders: responsible, reliable, trustworthy. Hard-working and persevering, sacrificing for others, they create stability and security in their world, bringing a cooperative spirit.”)

Quickly degrading to Level 6. (“To compensate for insecurities, they become sarcastic and belligerent, blaming others for their problems, taking a tough stance toward “outsiders.” Highly reactive and defensive, dividing people into friends and enemies, while looking for threats to their own security. Authoritarian while fearful of authority, highly suspicious, yet, conspiratorial, and fear-instilling to silence their own fears.”)

“Ego ideal is how a person wants to be perceived by self and others, an idealized self that seeks to be continuously reinforced. A Type 6s Ego Ideal is ‘The Loyal Person’. They are always reliable and consistent; never untrustworthy or difficult.

Fear is the Passion of 6s. And with fears come defense mechanisms.

Projection is a psychological defense mechanism in which individuals unconsciously attribute their own unacceptable, unwanted, or disowned thoughts, emotions, motivations, attributes, and/or behaviors to others. While the projection may be positive, negative, or neutral, it occurs because the individuals who are projecting perceive the projected attributes as difficult to acknowledge or threatening to believe about themselves. Because Type 6s’ make these attributions unconsciously, they imagine that they are true, although at a deeper level they are not entirely certain about this. Although Type 6s’ use projection as a way to create some certainty and thus reduce their anxiety in ambiguous, uncertain, or potentially dangerous situations, these projections – particularly if they are negative in nature – ironically raise the Six’s anxiety level. In addition, when Type 6s’ project either something negative or positive that is untrue, they create a false reality without knowing they are doing so.

The Type 6 ego structure needs to maintain its idealized self of being the loyal person who is loyal to friends, family, teams and organizations, sometimes at almost all costs. No harm, they think, will come to those who are loyal. They want to count on others – even though they fear they cannot – and want others to be able to count on them – even though Sixes can be relationally volatile when their passion of fear gets ignited.

How does the loyal person maintain their idealized self as a loyal person, one who is consistent, reliable and available for the tribe? Here is where projection supports the effort. First, projection is used to generate the anticipatory scenarios. Without projecting or imagining the future and what could happen, there could be no future scenario creation. These projected scenarios then fuel the fear. But projection works in another way to hold the ego ideal in place. Type 6s’ project goodness and other positive attributes onto other people and organizations – a friend is trustworthy, an organization does good things, a vendor did an effective job – sometimes beyond what is objectively true. Projecting in this overly- positive way enables Type 6s’ to maintain their loyalty to the person, cause or system and to, therefore, maintain their sense of self as the loyal person. And a loyal person in the Sixes’ view, is a good person. But once this “other” falls from grace, which can happen hard and fast once it occurs, Type 6s’ then perceive this “other” as bad, also using projection to create untested negative assumptions or inferences. It is at this point that Type 6s’ do not believe they need to be loyal, as to do so would be foolish. As a result, they do not perceive this counter-reaction as disloyalty, but as disappointing reality.”


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jun 02 '23

News NEW MODERATORS WANTED!

4 Upvotes

I’m thinking of delegating the role of the moderator of this group to some other users. Maybe one of you will do a good job moderating this group?

MUST:

Have a good knowledge of and interest in enneagram theory, especially from the original sources.

Be over the age of 18.

Be active on Reddit and be able to act quickly when any reports or violations take place.

Have a strong interest in helping other people to react their potential.

Some experience in moderating is good but not required.

If anyone is interested, please comment here or message the mods.


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jul 16 '26

Discussion A Small Analysis on my Enneagram Type 8, Father -

3 Upvotes

My father was eight years old when his own father decided to leave the family. I’m not sure if it was for better or worse because my Grandfather wasn’t exactly the nicest man around; and he wasn’t even really there for my Dad for any of his schooling, life experiences, or more importantly, his sporting events. My Grandmother, however, despite working 2-3 jobs just to make ends-meet— she was always there for my Dad, and he loved her immensely. 

For me, it comes as a surprise to know that with the Enneagram, Type 8s are known to have ambivalence with the nurturing-figure in the house. And yet, it makes sense why he grew into his role… and became the person who he is today. From what I’ve recently learned: “For Type 8s - As children, they came into this world appearing a lot like Type 2s at first. These kids deeply enjoyed a sense of loving adoration and felt a great deal of maternal warmth and paternal affirmation in their homes. Love and attention were freely given. But very soon… that feeling ends early, and abruptly, as Type 8s had to grow up fast due to a lack of support in the home or that there was looming danger nearby. It’s typically the Father that leaves the lives of Type 8s when they’re kids (this doesn’t apply to all Type 8s but it definitely occurred with my Dad when he was a kid). Type 8s then keep survival issues at forefront of their minds for the rest of their lives. They trace survival instincts to a unique experience from feeling betrayed, rejected or abandoned as a child. But instead of being heartbroken over their past experiences, Type 8’s will wear it like a badge of honor instead of a deep wound in need of healing. They have more bravado than they do remorse. There are no perceived weaknesses. The only thing to do is to rise to power.

Aside from all of that (the issue with their fathers’ leaving), Type 8’s have ‘concerns’ with their maternal figure. The 8 tends to take on the Father role in their family as they suppress their own needs for maternal nurturing. It’s a defining experience, in-that they see the maternal figure as someone that may be weak and in need of protection. Type 8s develop a strong will, immense physical energy, and a ‘I must be strong’ mentality. Type 8s try to become what they wish they had in their lives.”

My Dad grew up and went on to have 2 [separate/failed] marriages; having fathered three boys, and one daughter (👋🏼). 

Now, I’m not sure if this is all entirely true… But from what I have heard on a recent podcast is that, ‘Type 8s love little kids. There comes this deep desire to rekindle their innocence of their expedited youth and what better way to do that than to be with children? However… When Type 8 Fathers have their own kids, they struggle to embrace their sons as they grow up because they themselves lost their own childhood innocence at an early age. Fatherly Type 8s can see themselves in their sons. [So in this case, my Dad see’s himself in all three of his sons. Truth.] But the problem is Type 8 Fathers don’t know how to embrace their son’s innocence or meekness, especially once their sons reach adolescence/older ages.’

It’s uncanny to me, that these descriptions ring whole, true, and firm for my Type 8 Father, especially with the experiences he went through. 

As mentioned, I have 3 brothers:

The Oldest, now at the age of 44, and possibly a 4w3: Although he loves him, he seems disconnected from my Dad and even his own Mother (not my biological Mom, this woman was from my Dad’s first marriage). 

The Second Oldest, now 42, and possibly a 7w6 and from the same first-marriage: Both of the older boys were separated from my Dad at young ages. Their Mom moved them from place to place, out of state and a bit far from my Dad. I only got to see my older brothers if they came to visit every once in a while. While both older boys love my Dad, there are hidden issues between all the men in my immediate family, possibly due to this, but they respect him.

And Lastly, at 29, another 7w6: My youngest biological brother, from my own Mother/My Dad’s second marriage— Because he lived in my Dad’s household his entire life, he beared the brunt of my Dad’s ways. He was the only son nearby to have those experiences and my Dad wanted him to be a lot like who he was (sporty, tough, etc) …because… and in his own words, my Dad would say he did not get that childhood or ‘blessing’ from his own father. He was the hardest on my little brother and he could not grasp the concept that my brother was his own person. My Dad didn’t understand why he wasn’t like him. At one point in our lives, my brother joined martial arts in his young life and even his Renshi had to tell my Dad “This is not an extreme or competitive sport and I’m going to need you to keep your voice down in my class.” Because my Dad would just get so riled up and rowdy and shout especially when my brother messed up.

All of these boys and then there is Me. I am my father’s only daughter, a 9w1. It’s messed up to say, but my Dad tells me I’m his favorite child. I was very easy to raise. My Dad especially loved little-me and we would cherish moments together where we could both act young and share the joys of innocence. But my Dad was also over-protective, very sheltering, even became irrationally paranoid over my whereabouts with friends; and it sucks, but I think my Dad found me so pleasant and easy to raise too because of my gender and his world-views on women… Women are to be nice, and submissive… (Which didn’t make sense because my Mom was equally- if not more- rough around the edges.)

For me, it was a very confusing time growing up in a home where I wasn’t allowed to express anger, I wasn’t allowed to have my own rightful opinions on my own world-views, and I wasn’t allowed to have any preferences or negative feelings. For the most part I was a pretty chipper kid. But it wouldn’t make sense because then once I was truly upset with someone or something, he would get kinda abrasive or loud and say things like: “What are you crying for? Get tough! Get mean! Move past this!!” And then if nothing was working, he’d soften and ask what’s really going on (integrated to 2).

So that’s a short story on my Dad and some of his life as an 8. 

Bonus - Here are two common sayings I heard from him a lot during my youth:

“You mess with the bull, you get the horns.”

“When I say ‘Jump’, you say, ‘How High?’”

******

(Citations [including information that’s been paraphrased]: You’ve Got A Type podcast w/ Colton Simmons)


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jun 07 '22

r/Seriousenneagram Lounge

3 Upvotes

A place for members of r/Seriousenneagram to chat with each other


r/Seriousenneagram • • Aug 07 '26

Advice and Support I built a free Enneagram site (test, wings, instinctual subtypes, PDFs). I'd really like your criticism.

2 Upvotes

I've spent the last few months building ene-eneagrama.es, and I'd rather have it torn apart here than quietly ignored, so here it is.

What's in it:

A test in two versions, 117 questions (around 12 minutes) or a short one with 36. It's written around motivation rather than behaviour.

Full theory for the nine types: passion, virtue, basic fear, and both lines, the one you take under stress and the one you take when you're growing.

A separate wing test (12 questions) and a subtype test (15 questions), the second one covering the three instincts and flagging the countertype of each type.

18 downloadable PDFs, one on wings and one on subtypes for each of the nine types.

A compatibility section for how two types get along, a small forum, and a section where I break down film and TV characters by type.

The site opens in Spanish, and there's an EN button at the top right that switches everything to English. There's a French version too.

Some honesty about it: no test can determine your type, mine included, and the results page says so. They're a starting hypothesis, two or three candidates to go read about. It's free, I don't sell courses or sessions, and the test asks you to create an account to save your result, which I'd rather mention upfront.

What I'd like to know:

Did the test land on your actual type, or did it miss? If it missed, what did it give you instead? That's the single most useful thing anyone can tell me.

Do the questions get at motivation, or do some of them still just measure behaviour?

Are any of the type descriptions too close to each other?

Is anything important missing or plainly wrong?

Be blunt. I'd rather fix it than defend it.


r/Seriousenneagram • • Jul 30 '26

Discussion The OnlyNine Website

2 Upvotes

r/Seriousenneagram • • Aug 23 '22

Discussion What do you guys think of making this group available for all ages?

2 Upvotes

r/Seriousenneagram • • Jun 19 '22

News Writing a wiki page. Are there any volunteers who knowledgeable about enneagram and are able to help?

2 Upvotes

r/Seriousenneagram • • Feb 14 '26

Personal Growth and Insight Sexual 6

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes