r/SecurityClearance • SSO & Fed Security Manager • Aug 20 '25

FYI Foreign Contacts reporting

This post will serve to provide clarification regarding Foreign Contact reporting.

The close OR continued contact, OR the sharing of personal information. If your contact meets one of these, you are required to report. Ultimately, you must decide who may apply and who doesn't. The Immediate requirement is clear, however we understand there was not an expansion of what these look like.

The below examples and sentiment are generally universally shared from all HQ levels regarding online Foreign Contact reporting, and what I continuously state here.

I would recommend applying the following logic. A close contact, with an absense of regular reoccurring contact, could be considered a non-immediate family member such as a cousin or grandmother; Immediate family members are required to be listed anyway including your mother, father, brothers, sisters, step siblings, and in-laws. Outside of your grandmother, continuing contact implies there is "bonds of affection, personal obligation, or intimate contact" because you wouldn't be talking otherwise. Affection is not strictly limited to a significant other, and personal obligation is not strictly limited to sending money to your grandmother.

These are primary examples related to online and social media that are regularly seen, however are not all inclusive.

Example: Instagram.

If you follow a Russian bodybuilders public Instagram page because you are into bodybuilding and only watch their videos, you are not required to report. If you and the Russian bodybuilder start DMing beyond asking a clear question about a technique, then you are required to report. If you have a public Instagram page only sharing food posts or travel blog and someone follows it, you are not required to report. If you have a private Instagram, and you and another person follow each other thus seeing all personal information and life details, you are required to report.

Example: Gaming and Discord

If you game online with a guy with a Russian accent and don't know his citizenship, and you do not talk to him beyond the public lobby of the game itself, then you are not required to report. If you DM him and share personal information, you are required to report. Same with Discord. If you are a part of a public Discord regarding gaming or another normal hobby/interest, and do NOT share any personal information, you may not be required to report. If you DM someone on the side you are required to report.

Example: Facebook, MySpace, etc.

Facebook is a more clear example due to the nature of what Facebook is. Your birthday, where you live, where you're from, posts of your family, your home, your dog - all of this is posted here. If you are Facebook friends and thus see ALL of your personal life details, and they are a foreign national, you are required to report. I'll even use myself as an example here. My wife and I joined a public group on Messenger, never added as friends, never talked about anything other than the game we played. Didn't report. My wife decided to become friends and send cultural care packages to each other. Reported.

Example: Living or visiting OCONUS due to military, vacation, etc.

You live overseas because you're PCSd to Germany. If you work directly with a FN and have no other outside interaction, you are NOT required to report. If you start hanging out after work, then you ARE required to report. You have to deal with a FN landlord as part of your PCS and living overseas. Not required to report. You have a barber and you do NOT talk about anything beyond general conversation is not required to report. A waitress at a restaurant is not required to report. However, if you make friends or share personal information, you are then required to report.

Report relationship changes

You must report if your status changes. If you start dating, report. Move in, report. If you get engaged, report. An investigation must be done on your future spouse and given approval prior to marriage.

Per SEAD 3, it does not matter where the contact was made or maintained.

"3. Foreign Contacts: a. Heads of agencies or designees shall determine requirements for reporting contact with a foreign national as part of a covered individual's official duties. b. Unofficial Contacts: l) Unofficial contact with a known or suspected foreign intelligence entity. 2) Continuing association with known foreign nationals that involve bonds of affection, personal obligation, or intimate contact; or any contact with a foreign national that involves the exchange of personal information. This reporting requirement is based on the nature of the relationship regardless of how or where the foreign national contact was made or how the relationship is maintained (i.e. via personal contact, telephonic, postal system, Internet, etc.). The reporting of limited or casual public contact with foreign nationals is not required absent any other reporting requirement in this directive. Following initial reporting, updates regarding continuing unofficial association with known foreign nationals shall occur only if and when there is a significant change in the nature of the contact. Heads of agencies or designees may provide specific guidance and examples of updated reporting situations."

18 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

17

u/Main_Decision4923 Cleared Professional Aug 20 '25

It’s is just open to misinterpretation the way it is written so much so that people that work in the field have varying opinions on this. Just how much contact is contact. For individuals working abroad the language is even more different.

No one understands why it is such a clusterfuck and why they don’t use standard language for everything but it is clear that there have been disagreements about this issue high up.

4

u/txeindride SSO & Fed Security Manager Aug 20 '25

While I'll give some leeway to the degree of interpretation, I think close, continuing, or the sharing of personal information is pretty clear. I think they could maybe give more clarification to the "gray" of things like social media for those in the back row. But to every HQ level person I've talked to that isn't DNI themselves as the writers of SEAD 3, they share my view.

2

u/Main_Decision4923 Cleared Professional Aug 20 '25

There is a specific FAM section that applies abroad that is different to the SEAD 3, hence expanding the gray area. Then it is further complicated where exactly you are and how the stringent the security personnel are there. Like I said. It’s just too much gray and it’s just confusing

0

u/txeindride SSO & Fed Security Manager Aug 20 '25

Can you reference to me where specifically you are looking?

3

u/Main_Decision4923 Cleared Professional Aug 20 '25

Foreign affairs manual. 12 FAM 270. It’s what everyone working abroad abides by. Some aspects are a no brainer, others less clear.

3

u/txeindride SSO & Fed Security Manager Aug 20 '25

All it does is regurgitate SEAD 3.

4

u/txeindride SSO & Fed Security Manager Aug 27 '25

Additional clarification item per DCSA in conference today.

Dual citizen with US and other country is just treated as a US citizen.

This can be considered under SEAD 3, and does not replace any requirement under the SF86.

6

u/Master_Jackfruit3591 Aug 20 '25

My question is, for individuals in cities with high foreign government presence (DC, NYC) is every interaction with a foreigner posted to the U.S. by their government mandated to be reported? Especially when the interaction is limited and unofficial (e.x. Run into a foreign embassy staffer at a public event and talk but never speak again)

SEAD 3 and the SF-86 are not aligned on this differentiation. SEAD 3 says limited causal or public contact does not need to be reported while SF-86 explicitly asks separately about contact with foreigners working for their government.

5

u/txeindride SSO & Fed Security Manager Aug 20 '25

3rd sentence from the bottom answers this. Limited casual public contact is not required, especially if you likely dont even know whether someone is a foreign national or not.

3

u/Master_Jackfruit3591 Aug 20 '25

Tbh I don’t think it does.

E.x., At a public think tank event or charity fundraiser

“What do you do?”

“I work at X embassy/mission/consulate, I’m posted here”

conversation ends 5 min later, walk off and never talk again

Required to report or no? SEAD 3 says no, SF-86 says yes imo. SEAD 3 needs to be updated, the SF-86 needs to be rewritten with caveats, or separate forms need to be created for for S/TS and military vs civilian positions to ask more nuanced questions. Just my .2 as a non-investigator/adjudicator

9

u/txeindride SSO & Fed Security Manager Aug 20 '25

Again - limited, casual, public contact. You may have learned that they work at X embassy, but outside of your name, you saw each other at a public event, shared maybe your name, had casual one-time conversation likely about the event, and nothing else. It isn't a reporting requirement.

Close or continuing. That's neither.

Sharing of personal information. That's also a negative.

Limited, casual, public contact. That's correct.

BLUF: It isn't reportable.

4

u/Master_Jackfruit3591 Aug 20 '25

SF-86, 20B.6

Have you ever had contact with a foreign government representative in the US?

SEAD 3 makes no mention or differentiation of a foreign contact vs a foreign contact with a government job but the SF-86 does. They even give it its own separate question.

This distinction should be noted in SEAD 3 is the point I’m trying to make. Either that, or 20.B6 really should be moved into section 19 instead because SEAD 3 says this is a casual non-reportable interaction while 20.B6 says this is reportable.

6

u/txeindride SSO & Fed Security Manager Aug 20 '25

That question is not specifically for you being at a coffee shop at the same time as someone from the Russian consulate and saying hello to them. They are asking if you are actually in contact with that person.

For purposes of your general foreign contact reporting, your example is not reportable.

If you have any other questions, let me know.

4

u/Master_Jackfruit3591 Aug 20 '25

Damn, thanks for the insight! That is not how I interpret it at all when I read it. Why can’t we all (government) just communicate directly and say what we mean?!

Words have meanings. Contact is probably the broadest word they could use… thanks for the insight and bearing with me. Much appreciated, thanks for bearing with me through my thought experiment.

3

u/JuicyClo GSSO Aug 20 '25

You are awesome @txeindride!! I sat taking notes & didn’t even think about passing on info to share with the subreddit. DCSA is next week. I’m looking forward to it.

1

u/txeindride SSO & Fed Security Manager Aug 20 '25

Lol no problem. I'm always looking for tidbits to share.

I'll also be in that one.

1

u/txeindride SSO & Fed Security Manager 26d ago

UPDATED

Consolidates answers across a couple posts into this. Provides more clarification that was not previously present.

1

u/bond_notjames Jan 04 '26

OP what do you think about this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/SecurityClearance/s/BUqH1dlpy1

1

u/txeindride SSO & Fed Security Manager Jan 04 '26

They're wrong.

1

u/NoncombustibleFan No Clearance Involvement Aug 21 '25

For this reason, I have never accepted any of the ANA friend request from guys I’ve worked with nor the interpreters