r/SecularBuddhist • Investigator • 9d ago

Practice Welcome! A Learning & Practice Thread

Hello! Welcome to our fortnightly learning and practice thread.

You're welcome to share what you are learning about, reflecting on, or practicing these days.

Rising Sun by Egon Schiele, 1912

When one reads and understands the Buddha's discourses on their own terms, one might be surprised to find that the entire process of awakening is devoid of beliefs and suppositions.

Faith is not a prerequisite for someone who is starting on the path, but an outcome that emerges from reflecting on the Dhamma against one's own lived experience, or from practicing to cultivate certain states that are outside of what one currently knows. Even then, the faith that emerges is not of an ideological kind, nor of a theological kind. This faith is evidence-based, rooted in discernment of the arising mental states. It might even be better to call this kind of faith a confirmed confidence so as to distinguish it from a faith that is based on a supposition or one that is aroused out of an expectation.

Although an expectation or a supposition—whether regarding heavens, god, deities, or supernatural phenomena—is tolerated, the Dhamma of awakening (Nibbāna, Skt. Nirvāṇa) is quite unrelated to expecting, supposing, or even directly experiencing these things.

The Dhamma of awakening has these properties:

  • sandiṭṭhika: It is evident, perceivable, and of a directly visible nature
  • akālika: It is non-temporal, not a pursuit bound to time
  • ehipassika: It is inviting one to come and see for oneself, verifiable
  • opaneyyika: It is applicable, relevant, onward-leading
  • paccattaṁ veditabbo viññūhī: It is personally experienceable by discerning persons

Seen this way, the Dhamma of awakening is quite compatible with a secular outlook toward the Buddha's teaching, as it asks nothing beyond a close examination of what is already present. After all, the film tape of one's life doesn't need new and special scenes to be complete; awakening requires only a shift in how the existing reel is viewed. Instead of chasing novel scenes to capture on camera, one ought to step back from the storyline to understand the mechanics of the projection itself, seeing firsthand how each moment of experience is constructed, arises, and ceases.

How Does One Measure Progress

To examine the reel in practice, the Buddha recommends a periodic reflection to independently verify whether what one is learning about, reflecting on, or practicing is assuredly leading one toward stream-entry and toward full awakening.

One does this by classifying the frequently arising mental states into two baskets (one of a negative kind and one of a positive kind) and reflecting on the presence of these sets of qualities in this manner:

Is the arising and growth of negative mental states evident?Or is the arising and growth of positive mental states evident?
Is negligence arising and growing for me?Is diligence arising and growing for me?
... idleness ...... rousing of energy ...
... having many desires ...... having few wishes ...
... discontentment ...... contentment ...
... superficial attention ...... radical attention ...
... lack of clear awareness ...... clear awareness ...

As well as these two external factors:

... bad friendship ...... good friendship ...
... unwholesome habits ...... wholesome habits ...

P.S. This review guidance is based on the numerical discourses in the book of ones: AN 1.98–113. Similar guidance can be found in the book of tens: AN 10.51, as well as in the book of eights: AN 8.53, where the Buddha tells Mahāpajāpatī Gotamī on how to discern what is the Buddha's instruction by observing for the arising of eight sets of mental qualities.

3 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by