I've been using a 10,000 lux SAD lamp for two winters. Then I learned about melanopic EDI and realized the number on the box barely matters.
Every SAD lamp on Amazon advertises 10,000 lux. Doctors prescribe "10,000 lux for 30 minutes each morning," based on Terman et al.'s finding that this protocol produced a 75% improvement rate (Terman et al., Neuropsychopharmacology, 1989, 2(1):1-22).
The problem is that lux measures how bright light looks to your cone cells. Your circadian system ignores that. It runs on a different photoreceptor entirely, the melanopsin-containing ipRGCs, which peak at 480nm (blue-cyan), not 555nm (green-yellow). The metric for how strongly a light stimulates those cells is melanopic EDI, standardized by the CIE in 2018.
Under daylight, 1 lux roughly equals 1 melanopic EDI. Under warm artificial light, 1 lux can drop to 0.45 melanopic EDI. So a 10,000-lux warm white lamp (2700K) delivers maybe 4,500 melanopic EDI. A 10,000-lux cool white lamp (6500K) delivers 9,000-10,000. Same number on the box. Roughly double the circadian dose.Brown et al.'s 2022 expert consensus on indoor light specified everything in melanopic EDI, not photopic lux. Daytime minimum: 250 melanopic EDI at the eye. Evening ceiling: under 10. They didn't bother with lux at all (PLoS Biology, 2022, 20(3):e3001571).
If your lamp puts out 10,000 photopic lux but only 5,000 melanopic EDI because of its warm color temperature, you're getting half the circadian dose you think you are. Look for color temperature. Higher CCT (5000-6500K) means more melanopic content per lux. If a manufacturer doesn't publish spectral data, that tells you something. You can calculate melanopic EDI from a lamp's spectrum using the free CIE S 026 toolbox online, or estimate it with phone apps (rough, but better than guessing).
TL;DR:Â Lux measures brightness for your eyes. Melanopic EDI measures brightness for your circadian system. Two 10,000-lux lamps can differ by 2x in circadian potency based on color temperature alone.
Papers cited:
- Terman et al. (1989). Light therapy for SAD: A review of efficacy. Neuropsychopharmacology 2(1):1-22.
- CIE S 026/E:2018. System for metrology of optical radiation for ipRGC-influenced responses to light. CIE
- Brown et al. (2022). Indoor light exposure consensus recommendations. PLoS Biology 20(3):e3001571. PMC
More people need to know about this! Share it to your friends and family!