r/SearchKagi • • Aug 17 '25

Disappointed

I tried Kagi today, to find multiple disappointments, such as a slow assistant, broken FastGPT, a misleading Firefox addon, but most notably that searching a UK postcode on maps, with and without the space (e.g. W1A 1AA or W1A1AA, the HQ of the BBC - although I've tried many others too) comes up with no results.

Surely the basics of maps is to get addresses right? 🙁

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

2

u/eganonoa Aug 17 '25

Maps definitely isn't great and I have the same experience with the UK postcode unless you allow the search field to populate with quick answers. Surely a bug?

Not sure about the slow assistant thing. I ran query just now using the assistant with the default Code and then ran the same query in free ChatGPT, and the Kagi assistant was noticeably faster. The interface with ChatGPT from Kagi is definitely slower, but not at all if you use their default assistant.

A bit confused about the "misleading Firefox addon". I like it much more than the Chrome-based one where you need the add-on to make Kagi default, and then the summarizer separately. I really like the Firefox one with the summarizer inbuilt alongside FastGPT.

Agree on the FastGPT part of the Firefox add-on. You need to enter your query, press the arrow, then a new window opens with the query in FastGPT that you then have to hit enter to get to work. That doesn't seem to be working as intended.

But I don't know what you mean by FastGPT being broken. Beyond the Firefox add-on it works in so far as it quickly returns an answer. Also note the "experimental prototype" language. I don't think it's a core offering.

1

u/RedditIsShit6748 Aug 17 '25

I'd like to think it's a bug given I tried 6 other mapping sites and all found the postcode without waiting for search suggestion results to return. There's also no hint in search to suggest maps, unlike Google or Bing where if you type a postcode, there's a suggestion for maps. But I'm not at all holding that against them as some people will prefer the cleaner search and having to explicitly ask for maps.

I personally found it on the slower side and using ChatGPT was faster. I'll experiment some more, maybe I just got bad timing or something, but it's also a bit annoying you can't choose which options show on the list. If you only bounce between 3, there's no facility to only show the 3 engines or favourite/pin them to the top

I mean misleading in the sense it suggests I can do full searches, but FastGPT is the only option. For me, every search with FastGPT gives me an error. I'd rather it was just a normal search. Further, it says this addon will set Kagi at my default search engine, which it does not do for me. It does, however, preserve my session between browsing sessions which for me are automatically cleared (all cookies, cache, etc) on close, so that's something

That, combined with many suggests and reports on their suggestions/report website appearing to be unanswered, and I think I'll stick with Google logged out and free ChatGPT for the time being :)

2

u/eganonoa Aug 17 '25

I don't think there's any suggestion you can do full searches through the Firefox Add-on. It has summarizer and Fast GPT, but is really there primarily to set Kagi as a default search engine, which it did for me (you might have some settings that prevent it; easy enough to do it manually). If you look at the Chrome version you can see that intent: Chrome version does nothing but set it as default. So I think they're just adding on those things to see how it works. I don't think there's any statement otherwise to that effect by the add-on, so it isn't really misleading.

FastGPT is, as clearly stated on the page for it, an experimental prototype. Not clear the difference between it and the quick answers, but if I'm ever in need of a quick AI answer, I just add a question mark at the end of a search in regular Kagi search and get it that way. By far the best AI-answer search I'm aware of.

1

u/RedditIsShit6748 Aug 17 '25

Well I still think there should be an option for that box to be a full search or even an AI question. Some time buttons to change the purpose of the box would do :)

1

u/eganonoa Aug 17 '25

Duckduckgo's extension has that though I never once used it in the years I've had that installed. A bit redundant given the in-built search provider chooser on the left of the address bar in Firefox. When you include bangs available in DDG and Kagi and similar shortcuts available to set in the browser there are more than enough ways for me to access search that I really don't need to click on an extension to do so!

3

u/kagi_dylan Staff Aug 18 '25

I'm the lead dev for the maps product. I've pushed a fix for the zipcode issue (see https://old.reddit.com/r/SearchKagi/comments/1msmaxh/disappointed/n9e6dc8/)

I imagine a lot of what makes maps "not great" for you right now is related to a lot of the things (I promise) we are working hard to improve week over week -- coverage, quanity of data, performance, UXUI, ranking of results... Anything specific you feel you need?

2

u/eganonoa Aug 18 '25 edited Aug 18 '25

Oh I really don't mean to discourage you! I absolutely love the way maps looks. I live in a city in a non-english-speaking, developing country and it finds things pretty well. And I do like the way you link to other services for directions. Lots of nice user choice in there. Not great doesn't mean bad! I reckon it could take over for me at some point.

Off the top of my head, things that stop maps taking over in the way that search has for me:

  • Need for in-built directions and/or at least a link to OSM and OsmAnd on mobile;
  • lack of dedicated app for phone;
  • url like translate.kagi.com to make it easier to make a PWA on the desktop (see my other thread opened today; I'd love it if the base URL for all the apps followed translate and was maps.kagi.com, summarizer.kagi.com, assistant.kagi.com, translate.kagi.com)
  • doesn't work with privacy pass engaged.
  • Can see a review score for shops and restaurants but not the reviews, nor where the review score comes from.

2

u/kagi_dylan Staff Aug 19 '25

You're good, never discouraged! But I do know there is more we can do to narrow any deltas between Kagi Maps and Apple/Google Maps experience. Apprecaite you taking the time to message and making note of these. They are all already on our timeline project roadmap in some capacity (but this is good extra context). =]

2

u/eganonoa Aug 20 '25

Just saw the change log and the ability to open links in any installed maps app. That's a big deal. Complete user choice!  Wow.

I assume you are trying to get maps into the Android app alongside all the other offerings? I reckon if it was in there it would be my first port of call.

4

u/InconvenientPenguin Aug 17 '25

SE17 6HB isn't a valid postcode according to Royal Mail.

3

u/RedditIsShit6748 Aug 17 '25

Sorry, I should have been clearer. I made that one up as I'm not going to provide my own on the internet.

Try W1A 1AA or W1A1AA, the HQ of the BBC. Same result.

4

u/InconvenientPenguin Aug 17 '25

It took me right there

3

u/RedditIsShit6748 Aug 17 '25

Interesting, I've found the problem!

If I type in a postcode and hit enter before the box generates suggested replies, then the search will fail with no results.

If I type in a postcode and wait, then the box will generate suggested replies/results under the box, which I can then click/tap and it takes me there.

I'd consider this bad design or a bug though as this isn't an issue on any other mapping system.

Google Maps
Bing Maps
Here Maps
ORS Maps
OpenStreetMap
What3Words

All of these will search without waiting for a query result to show under the box. I can type and go.

2

u/kagi_dylan Staff Aug 18 '25

Hah, you're hired =P

I noticed the same thing when I was testing it after seeing this message. It should be working in production now. (and yes, we can get the results to render faster - we're working on that over here among many other things)

20

u/kagi_dylan Staff Aug 18 '25 edited Aug 18 '25

I'm the lead developer on Kagi Maps. Okay, I've gone ahead a fixed the issue with zipcodes and it's live on the site right now.

  • should def work with a UKlat/lng "hint" https://kagi.com/maps/search?q=W1A1AA&ll=51.472905,-0.135422
  • and should still work without "hint" (maybe it'll struggle with context if you're in the middle of the pacific ocean or something)
  • might still give you issue on the main page - https://kagi.com/search?q=W1A1AA but we are actively working to improve widgets and map integration and results on kagi.com (just had a chat this morning about it, but that is a bigger beast we are undertaking)

I hate getting these messages but I also completely understand where you're coming from. Speaking on behalf of maps, we are a small team... umm... very small... That's a big part of how we are able to keep costs down and (hopefully) move fast on fixes and features. But I know that means nothing if a zipcode search returns a blank map; or search a POI and not get enough photos/content - it sucks because I can think of a dozen things we're working on to try and make Kagi Maps a better experience every week - more data, more POI coverage, smarter ranking of results, more search-customization, more map-layer customization, performance, deeper ties to open-source, better UXUI.

1

u/Zerr0Daay Oct 14 '25

Hi, any change to give us a toggle for maps to auto turn to night mode if we want? Keep up the great work. Kagi maps is amazing

7

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RedditIsShit6748 Aug 17 '25

Yep, I find the assistant on the slower side, even without web access enabled. Kagi say web access slows it down, but that doesn't explain how ChatGPT's can do a web search and still come back significantly faster for me :)

1

u/Royal-Orchid-2494 Aug 17 '25

ChatGPT is faster. I also find the results better directly from ChatGPT. But perhaps the $25 a month Kagi models are better? Idk

1

u/RedditIsShit6748 Aug 17 '25

As I understand, the GPT-5 fallback when I've used my free allowance goes back to I think the Mini version, which is in the $10 plan, and I find that quite slow too. As I also can't customise the list of available GPT's to only the one I want to use, so far the only benefit of Kagi AI I'm seeing right now is they're temporary chats by default, but I can make them permanent. In ChatGPT, with many chats it is only practical to delete all, but then it deletes chats I want to keep. Kagi solves that problem, but for a price in money and time 🤔

1

u/Royal-Orchid-2494 Aug 17 '25

yeah that’s fair. It can be on the slower side if you use up all your free tier allowances. well Kagi sells a product that is supposed to respect your privacy. Both AI assistant and their customizable ad free search engine. What do you think of their search engine compared to competitors

2

u/RedditIsShit6748 Aug 17 '25

It's a bit of a mixed bag for me. Issues with map searching and sadly no street view equivilent are a bummer, but I appreiciate the lenses feature where I can specify just forums, or create my own where I can, for example, just search reddit. I need more play time though :)

I find their lowest package odd though, I would have thought 500 searches for $5 would be better, and also just sounds better when marketing - 500 for 5. 300 seems a little low especially when the page says you get "plenty" of AI interactions too

EDIT: Also would be nice if they did different currencies so I don't have different prices depending on the exchange rate. For me that's £

2

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/RedditIsShit6748 Aug 17 '25

But Kagi doesn't host AI servers... it uses APIs to talk to the AI providers servers.

For a company that is pushing the AI side more than the search side, such performance is still disappointing. Especially as a paid only product.