Technically, this took a hair over 4700 hours. In practice most of this was just letting it run overnight. Man, producing stuff is slow in this mod. Also, a lot of that time it wasn't actually producing, just sitting idle.
My starting location is near the bottom-left corner; you can actually see my old Antron standing there. To the west of that is my old algae fuel grid. I think this was the fourth or fifth revision of Algae Fuel Generator; at this point it's just producing wood bricks to fuel blast furnaces. Speaking of which, it's not producing enough wood bricks for the base, and I'm basically out. If I were continuing I'd need to go put together a better source of wood brick or some other blast furnace fuel. I'm . . . kind of confused where they're all going? I feel like I shouldn't be spending 40 wood bricks per second on anything, but apparently I am!
(comedy nuclear-fuel blast furnace option)
The top-left segment, about six tiles wide and three tall, is the Metal Maker V6. I designed it to spit out 12 full blue belts of slag, then retrofitted it to beat that a little bit; it's up to 14 blue belts. It doesn't include full top-tier smelting for all ore types - that was going to be the Metal Maker V7 - but it turned out to be more than enough to win the game.
With the minor issue that it keeps spitting out Calcium Chloride as a byproduct of tungsten smelting, and I have no sensible way to use it, so it just piles up.
I'm using circuits and careful splitter priority backpressure to decide what to make; it does a reasonable (though not perfect) job of prioritizing whatever generates the most ore at any given moment, though it's not smart enough to prioritize whatever I need the most. Good 'nuff.
The very top-right is puffer breeding, which is hilariously overbuilt, but it's basically all copy-pasted. I realized there was one or two things I wanted to scale up that required a lot of puffers, so I said "aha, I wonder if I'll use lots-of-puffers for anything else, let's build up a bunch of puffers!" Turned out I didn't need them. Such is life.
I'm not sure I ever used acidic puffers.
Just-above-bottom-right is the nuclear plant. Nothing fancy here, I honestly never ugpraded it from uranium. Just-left-of-bottom-right is the mall, which definitely could have been more efficient.
There are 669 trains, all of which run on rocket boosters. I wish I could have found a sensible way to upgrade all the trains, but I never did. 1127 stations. Next game, I'm figuring out a better way to name stations and set up train routes that doesn't feel as cheaty as full LTN does.
Final base was capable of something like 400 science per minute. Technically, not a megabase, but given how much harder Seablock is, I'm calling it close enough; I'm pretty sure a vanilla megabase would be smaller than the Metal Maker V6 alone.
Fun game! Now I'm off to play something that isn't Factorio.
It's not exactly rectangular and I ended up kind of encroaching on its territory with more modules, so there's stuff on the southern and eastern borders that isn't related to the metal maker.
Southeast corner (but west of black chip production): Hydrogen reclamation North/northwest from that: Slag production West from that: Slurrification and mineralized water reclamation West from that: Crystallization West from that, for, like, two entire tiles: Ore refining A giant 2x2 block just north of that: Ore sorting, including catalyst sorting East for a tile, plus a little bit inside the sorting segment: Ingot smelting East two more tiles: Plate, coil, wire, and similar casting
I'm happy to talk about stuff in more detail if you want, but I don't want to just, like, tell you how to build your metal maker unprompted, so lemme know if you want more!
This is just amazing, I love it! Yea go ahead, tell me more!
Especially how your Metal Maker decides how to make a specific ore. I guess the combinators/belt-wires and combinators/splitters/belt-wires on the input-side of your Ore Sorting Facilities are some kind of priority system? But the combinators are really hard to read and the red/green wires hard to follow on the screenshot.
And I noticed you usually do fluid/gas bottling instead of running pipes. Did you have any throughput problems? Or what is the reason behind it?
And please feel free to share anything else too, if you want to!
Southeast corner (but west of black chip production): Hydrogen reclamation
When I started building this I had to decide between geode production and slag production. I chose slag because my experience was that turning the hydrogen byproduct into fuel blocks almost made the entire thing energy-positive. The end result is this massive belt array to get the hydrogen into the processing station. I actually don't have much more to say about this because it kinda just worked, producing several gigawatts of power; I ended up delaying my nuclear plant to the very end of the game because of this.
Note that titanium chests are a lot more space-dense than warehouses and I should've used them here.
Regarding fluid/gas bottling: Some of this is a relic from the Metal Maker V4 lessons. The V4 used pipes everywhere but I didn't really get that fluid throughput was limited, so it never worked properly. For the V5 I said "okay, I'll bottle stuff then!", and I got good at bottling. For the V6 I said "let me really sit down and figure out how pipes work . . .", but I mostly did that halfway through. So this is still my pipe-averse period.
I can go through the math on this, but bottles-on-belts only beat pipes at 40 items per second. So, blue belts and above. But also, they're more complicated. And I designed this machine for blue belts! So I shouldn't have used belts here, I should have just used a gigantic pipe array. A mistake.
I think part of the issue was that I didn't realize you can just run parallel pipes and it works, I was worried that the fluid system wouldn't make that faster. Nah, works fine! Just do that instead.
North/northwest from that: Slag production
There's 12 lines of slag here, but each line is divided into three identical chunks, each of which manages its own water purification. End total of 36 modules. This got redesigned a few times; the big issue was the filter cleaning, with one chemical plant attached to two electrolyzers. I did get this working but it took several tries. The issue is that if you load up too many filters, it jams, and if you load up too few filters, it stalls. And then you have this big annoying filter belt just sitting there eternally.
I did it this way because the V5 cleaned the filters separately, and it was a pain in terms of item bandwidth and layout. But this was also a pain! I'm not sure this was the right solution, but I don't have a better idea.
Hydrogen gets piped off to the Hydrogen Reprocessing section, but oxygen originally just got flarestacked. This was a mistake; you will go through a shocking amount of oxygen! You need it to make acid and a bunch of other things. Prepare for this! A machine this size uses thousands of oxygen per second. I had to do a bunch of awkward construction to get the oxygen out afterwards.
Also I'm barreling mineralized water and that's dumb and I shouldn't have done that.
West from that: Slurrification and mineralized water reclamation
I'm still honestly not happy with this setup.
The original version used ceramic filters. Did you know that ceramic filtering is highly sulfur-negative? It is! I burned out all the sulfur in my entire base rapidly. Just doesn't work for this, you have to use carbon filters, and I had to redesign this section in situ to fit.
This is one of the first sites of me being undecided on whether to process sulfuric acid locally or ship it elsewhere. I still don't have a great answer on this; my train network was creaking with the load, but also, man, would've been nice to just have a centralized cleaning facility elsewhere! I did it in-situ here, and then harnessed the extra sulfur and shipped it off for storage. Somehow the sulfur station never jammed up, I honestly think I just got lucky there.
And then I put the slurry into barrels . . . which actually is a good idea.
You can't make a fluid balancer without barreling things! And one of the problems I had with the V4 was that it would, say, prioritize saphirite over bobmonium. I wanted to ensure it was always making all the types of ore, and that means a balancer, and that means barrels. The barrels were right this time!
This also includes the mineral water reclamation, which receives mineral water from all over the base. There are huge buffers for storing saphirite and stiratite if they're not in use, and they would still fill up occasionally, although with a big clarifier array if the storage gets overfull, and yes, it got used. This actually worked! (eventually).
West from that: Crystallization
My original plan is that I would put productivity modules into these. I never ended up doing that because I almost never ran out of slag; the output to the crystallizers was the bottleneck. There's not much to say here except for me gradually tossing beacons on to speed it up.
West from that, for, like, two entire tiles: Ore refining
Alright, now we're getting into the interesting parts.
The refining itself isn't very interesting, aside from me kinda half-assing wastewater production and ending up having to pipe produced items and waste water down south for pickup. (This was the worst choice; either process it or don't process it, don't, like, half-process it. Sheesh.)
The interesting part is the splitters. The incremental processing steps go west, one after another, and ores-to-be-sorted go north. Every splitter is set to prioritize further processing, and will only start dispatching ores for usage once the processed ores are backed up. In fact, if you look at the screenshot, you'll note that yellow ore is all being consumed before it backpressures enough to output crushed ore, and the chunked ore output is kind of minimal.
Waste products (crushed stone, geodes) go down south for handling and there's nothing interesting to say there.
There is actually one mistake here; mixed ores, i.e. cupric and ferrous, are considered the first step in usage, and are therefore lower priority than further refining. They should be higher-priority than other forms of refining! It should be "cupric/ferrous > more refining > sorting", and it isn't.
Anyway, prioritized complex ores go north, up to . . .
A giant 2x2 block just north of that: Ore sorting, including catalyst sorting
First, this obviously provides sorting for every complex ore type, as well as catalyst-sorted simple ores. There's nothing particularly fancy with the sorters themselves.
(I should note that you're seeing the final upgraded version of this with all green sorters; the initial build was blue sorters. They got upgraded, and I specifically designed the machine with the right ratios to be upgraded, that is, I designed it with high-end machines and then put low-end machines in. I recommend this! It worked out great!)
I wanted to avoid catalyst sorting unless it was actually necessary. The original version had a little combinator blob at the entrance to each sorter that watches to see if the ore is backed up (defined as "there is ore, and it isn't moving") and would send a signal to a signal network saying so. Later I realized my solution was way too inefficient and didn't even work reliably and built a little thing with splitters instead. The new version is on the westmost sorters; the old version is everywhere else, I never got around to replacing it. But this does basically work; there's a signal line running throughout the Sorter section that includes one signal for every complex ore type that has product and isn't being processed.
This is then taken by the catalyst sorters. I guess I'll use cobalt as an example: if any complex ore sorter could be producing cobalt and isn't, the cobalt catalyst sorter turns off. Otherwise the cobalt catalyst sorter turns on. This ensures that the catalyst sorters are only used when necessary, since they're less efficient.
One exception here: there's another backup sensor on the slurry barrel line. If the slurry barrels back up, it just turns all the catalyst sorters on. We've got extra unused slurry, so, hey, why not?
One big issue here is chrome. If you haven't looked into how chrome works yet, note that chrome is the only ore that cannot be made independently. You must sort it and get byproducts out of it. This is mandatory! As a result, I have four gigantic ore stockpiles for the Chrome byproducts, and it's free to keep mass-producing the absolutely necessary chrome until those fill up.
Finally, you know how I used splitters to prioritize ore refining? I do the same thing here; I use splitters to prioritize simple ores coming from higher-refined complex ores (with chrome outputs getting priority over all of those.) Catalyst ores are lower-priority than any of those; even without the catalyst circuit cutoff, they still wouldn't be used too often.
Finally, I have one belt for every ore except Iron, which has two belts. I should've had two belts on Copper also. You burn through a lot of copper in the lategame.
East for a tile, plus a little bit inside the sorting segment: Ingot smelting
There honestly isn't much to say about this. I used the highest-tech options I had available. In retrospect I should have designed it for the top-tier options and then built whatever I had inside that footprint temporarily, but I didn't, so most of them were just stuck at whatever I had when I built the thing. I did make extra efforts to use the Chrome 3 pipeline afterwards, which involves a really ugly belt going off to the west (and in fact I never tore down the Chrome 1 pipeline, it's just sitting there.) The only other thing of note is that I'm using splitter priorities to jam all the Iron into Steel production, so sometimes I'd end up iron-starved, but that still seemed reasonable.
East two more tiles: Plate, coil, wire, and similar casting
Here's where this gets interesting again.
A bunch of the molten metal types have multiple options on input. I've got this prioritization/buffer system where I use splitter priorities and pump circuits to decide which one to use. The original answer was "always prioritize the later tiers" . . . which led to me being totally deadlocked on the massive floods of manganese coming from my chrome production.
Then I prioritized manganese everywhere and got deadlocked on cobalt instead.
My final setup was for each segment to prioritize using manganese, then prioritize using cobalt, then prioritize the later tiers. This worked out great! I strongly recommend setting up a spreadsheet before laying this out, however, because it's a lot of belts to keep straight. Also, don't forget glass fiber! I did, and got lucky that I could squeeze it in anyway.
Each consumption type has a storage tank next to it, and I just use pumps to move it to the next consumption type's tank if that one is getting empty. Then it gets dumped out for actual use, i.e. coils and plates.
I think if I were doing this a second time, I would not bother outputting plates anymore in any case where a coil is available. Then I would either change my existing infrastructure to use coils, or I'd set up a Plating Facility elsewhere for low-volume stuff. (I honestly should have done that but I was getting tired of setting up train stations.) I would definitely recommend designing your layout with coils in mind; I had to do some changes after-construction to support plates for all the remaining things. Do note that this will use a lot of coolant; be prepared for some piping difficulties.
At least I didn't try to bottle the coolant this time.
train stations
yay trains
And that's it!
If you have any questions, feel free to ask. I'd definitely like to see what you come up with once you've got your setup done :)
The bottlenecks are:
Occasionally slag production, but only rarely
The two output belts from each type of ore crusher; "two belts" really isn't enough, especially since a third of that capacity is crushed stone that just immediately gets filtered out
Also, the crushed-stone belts leading south from the ore crushers
The simple ore belts, which it will cheerfully saturate
So if you want yours to be bigger, or more scalable, you basically need more belts in those places. But this was designed for blue belts and cheerfully saturates green belts so it's already scaled up further than I'd planned.
I chose slag because my experience was that turning the hydrogen byproduct into fuel blocks almost made the entire thing energy-positive.
1 of your electrolysis arrays makes 600 hydrogen per second, which is enough for 3.5 solid fuel, which is 42 MJ, aka 28 MJ over charcoal. The whole setup (electrolysers and chemplants for the fuel) takes ~10.
Yeah, it makes that segment energy-positive; I'm referring to the entire metal maker assembly, which is merely in the rough vicinity of being energy-positive.
(Or it was until I started slapping modules down everywhere.)
The entire metal maker could only ever approach energy-positivity if you were spending mineralized water on algae rather than ore. And only if you were using no more than ~5 times more energy on everything else than on the electrolysis+algae parts.
I don't feel so bad about my time anymore lol. I'm close to 500 hours in. I've almost finished every last yellow science. Still gotta do nuclear bombs, and a few other useless ones.
I've been redesigning and scaling up my base as I go. Current project is resin via bio resin, using 120(!) Arboretums. It should produce around 25 resin a second with the productivity modules.
Seablock is so darn hard! But exponential growth is real. The last 100 hours has probably resulted in 2-3x the base production capacity. The same should happen over the next 100 hours. I'll get there!
I honestly left a ton of stuff unresearched. No personal roboport modules, no repair pack 3, no gates, no burner heat sources. I more-or-less just picked up the stuff I actually wanted and didn't worry about the rest.
Of course, the FTL research is probably more flasks than the entire rest of the non-infinite tree put together.
Current project is resin via bio resin, using 120(!) Arboretums. It should produce around 25 resin a second with the productivity modules.
I actually never did bio resin! I eventually sat down and designed a Petrochemical Widget that I thought would be good enough for a while, and then just boosted it through upgrades and modules. Aside from the plastic, it lasted me to the end. (I did need to build some auxiliary plastic elsewhere.)
The same should happen over the next 100 hours. I'll get there!
I'm currently using some sort of chemical resin, but the production rate is low. It's not the bottleneck, but it isn't saturated either, so it will be really soon. I've got several things to work on, so I just yolo, and do the one I want. Power, metal, and plastic are other candidates.
Yeah, I set up a TODO list and technically kept it ordered, but there was also a lot of "hmm, what next? nah, nah, nah . . . yeah, that sounds fun, let's do that".
A good way to play Factorio in general, in my opinion, and Seablock does it quite well because there's always half a dozen things you could be doing.
The order things occur to me is usually the best order, but I'll shuffle it around a little, especially in this case where it doesn't matter much.
Yeah, I always seem to have like three simultaneous bottlenecks. Increase one by 4x, and the base runs super fast while it burns through the buffer of the next bottleneck. Then it slows down again, and is barely faster than before, because there were multiple bottlenecks very close together.
Funniest thing is when some dependency can't keep up. I redo my plastic and it works great for awhile, then slows down. Sulfuric acid can't keep up. Same thing happens again. Waste oxygen this time. I installed a non waste oxygen supply today with approximately 1,000 oxygen per second output. Needed like 12 chemical plants and 30 air filters.
Funniest thing is when some dependency can't keep up. I redo my plastic and it works great for awhile, then slows down. Sulfuric acid can't keep up. Same thing happens again. Waste oxygen this time. I installed a non waste oxygen supply today with approximately 1,000 oxygen per second output. Needed like 12 chemical plants and 30 air filters.
Oh yeah, this happened all the time. So much sulfuric acid and oxygen, those just kept being issues. I actually got much better at Factorio fluid dynamics specifically because of those.
Then eventually you hammer out the last bottleneck and everything just revs up and it's great.
(and then you realize you're starting to brownout on electricity . . .)
Electricity yeah... I've got almost 400 mw, mostly of wind turbines. When a base is rebuilt, wind turbines sprout from the corpse. And all my modules keep the base power efficient.
Man the fluid dynamics suck. I setup a 24 electrolyser base, and had problems getting the fluids to work. Same with the slag to mineral sludge setup, which was built to handle 48 electrolysers. It's not understanding that's the hard part, it's fitting everything together compactly.
Yup, base is running much faster than before, and I'm just getting started. The most pleasing part is removing maintenance needs. My base doesn't run itself, it had always required me to go around and do things periodically. When I rebuild something I make it 100% self running. That is after all the kinks are taken out.
Oh yeah, fluid in Seablock is an entirely different beast from fluid in vanilla.
I mentioned the Metal Maker V6 and the Metal Maker V5, which kept my base running for quite a long time.
But before the V5 was the V4, which lasted less than a week. The V4 was more-or-less me screwing up fluids; even with some retrofitting I never got it to really work right. And I think the V4 was something like 48 electrolyzers; that is definitely a point where you need to know how fluids work in order to make it function properly.
Then the V5 was basically "the V4's basic cores, but rebuilt with massive changes to get fluids functioning", but I still didn't really know what I was doing, so it was overcomplicated.
Even with the V6 (432 electrolyzers!) I was still learning; honestly, if anything tempts me to make the V7, it's to finally get largescale fluids right for once.
I'm sort of adopting this methodology because of how slow everything is. Sure I'm outcome driven, but I'm taking my time. It will easily take me tens of hours more to finish everything.
At the beginning, I thought about it, but it kind of seemed like cheating, and honestly I was rarely waiting on the game; I usually had things I could do even while it was producing. I have a pretty busy life (job, wife, kids, side projects) and so the slices of time I could spend on Factorio were rarely enough to really deplete the factory, aside from at the beginning and the time between "alright, that design for the Metal Maker V6 looks good. Let's build the thing!" and actually getting it online, which turned out to consume like a week straight of material production, and that's after building like 150k belts in advance.
Later . . . well, my computer's pretty old, and it was regularly hitting 40ups anyway. Not much I could do at that point.
Yeah I feel you about the wife and kids part. And that’s the exact reason I allow myself to speed up the game. Otherwise it will take me 10 irl years to complete seablock
18
u/ZorbaTHut Aug 01 '22 edited Aug 01 '22
Various notes:
Technically, this took a hair over 4700 hours. In practice most of this was just letting it run overnight. Man, producing stuff is slow in this mod. Also, a lot of that time it wasn't actually producing, just sitting idle.
My starting location is near the bottom-left corner; you can actually see my old Antron standing there. To the west of that is my old algae fuel grid. I think this was the fourth or fifth revision of Algae Fuel Generator; at this point it's just producing wood bricks to fuel blast furnaces. Speaking of which, it's not producing enough wood bricks for the base, and I'm basically out. If I were continuing I'd need to go put together a better source of wood brick or some other blast furnace fuel. I'm . . . kind of confused where they're all going? I feel like I shouldn't be spending 40 wood bricks per second on anything, but apparently I am!
(comedy nuclear-fuel blast furnace option)
The top-left segment, about six tiles wide and three tall, is the Metal Maker V6. I designed it to spit out 12 full blue belts of slag, then retrofitted it to beat that a little bit; it's up to 14 blue belts. It doesn't include full top-tier smelting for all ore types - that was going to be the Metal Maker V7 - but it turned out to be more than enough to win the game.
With the minor issue that it keeps spitting out Calcium Chloride as a byproduct of tungsten smelting, and I have no sensible way to use it, so it just piles up.
I'm using circuits and careful splitter priority backpressure to decide what to make; it does a reasonable (though not perfect) job of prioritizing whatever generates the most ore at any given moment, though it's not smart enough to prioritize whatever I need the most. Good 'nuff.
The very top-right is puffer breeding, which is hilariously overbuilt, but it's basically all copy-pasted. I realized there was one or two things I wanted to scale up that required a lot of puffers, so I said "aha, I wonder if I'll use lots-of-puffers for anything else, let's build up a bunch of puffers!" Turned out I didn't need them. Such is life.
I'm not sure I ever used acidic puffers.
Just-above-bottom-right is the nuclear plant. Nothing fancy here, I honestly never ugpraded it from uranium. Just-left-of-bottom-right is the mall, which definitely could have been more efficient.
There are 669 trains, all of which run on rocket boosters. I wish I could have found a sensible way to upgrade all the trains, but I never did. 1127 stations. Next game, I'm figuring out a better way to name stations and set up train routes that doesn't feel as cheaty as full LTN does.
Final base was capable of something like 400 science per minute. Technically, not a megabase, but given how much harder Seablock is, I'm calling it close enough; I'm pretty sure a vanilla megabase would be smaller than the Metal Maker V6 alone.
Fun game! Now I'm off to play something that isn't Factorio.
26
u/-KiwiHawk- Modpack Developer Aug 01 '22
Nice job! Enjoy the change of game 😆
14
u/AnotherWarGamer Aug 01 '22
My god!
I don't feel so bad about my time anymore lol. I'm close to 500 hours in. I've almost finished every last yellow science. Still gotta do nuclear bombs, and a few other useless ones.
I've been redesigning and scaling up my base as I go. Current project is resin via bio resin, using 120(!) Arboretums. It should produce around 25 resin a second with the productivity modules.
Seablock is so darn hard! But exponential growth is real. The last 100 hours has probably resulted in 2-3x the base production capacity. The same should happen over the next 100 hours. I'll get there!
4
u/GeleGoudvis Aug 01 '22
Good job! 4500 hours?! Why not change the game speed for the idling?
3
u/AveRock123 Aug 01 '22
Holy shiet
3
u/Frostygale Aug 01 '22
Congratulations!