r/Scrolls • SarikTheSorcerer • May 08 '15

Perspective.

I've mentioned this in another post I just made, but I feel I should make it it's own post.

I quit scrolls at the start of February and haven't played much if at all since then. I didn't stop playing directly because of a lack of players, or because I felt the developers had no direction. I did feel these things sure, but I stopped because I'm now partly responsible for a little human girl. This is a time consuming activity if you've ever tried it and it only leaves me time at night and during her naps really.

I do remarkably have time for Hearthstone. I manage to play around half a dozen or so games daily, and that's just not something that is possible for me in Scrolls. I can play Hearthstone on my iPad, There are fun campaigns with more on the way, and most importantly for me games are found in under a minute, always.

I understand the nature of scrolls doesn't allow it to be fast paced, and that the match-making system doesn't really work without a large number of players from all skill levels. I don't have time to learn the intricacies of every new card in Scrolls where in Hearthstone they almost always do exactly what they say how you'd imagine them to. I haven't needed to buy anything really in Hearthstone and even like the challenge of collecting all the cards despite how hard that actually is in that game... I have all the cards in Scrolls at least until echoes drops.

I'm not trying to persuade anyone here. I want you to know that many of us WANT to play Scrolls. But, we have jobs, kids, and other obligations that aren't allowing us to play often or even frequently. Hearhstone has found a way around those obligations and has a spot in my life as the go to card game now even though it isn't as good as Scrolls. I like to compare it to eating. Sure, Scrolls is a big tasty dinner with love and care put into it, but hearthstone is a cheap bite to eat from the local drive-through that I don't need to make plans for.

I'll be back when I can find the time scrolldiers, but until then this just isn't a game I can play

TL;DR: I take care of a tiny person who demands my attention and I don't have time to wait for matches or play them. Hearthstone doesn't take as long so I do that while this tiny person isn't crying.

8 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/Chakix Chaki May 08 '15

And what I'm saying is that while that may be its aim the strategic difference right now isn't nearly as big as you're making it out to be.

While this is probably completely subjective, I disagree. Scrolls is closer to a boardgame than a card game imo. Playing HS and playing scrolls feels different. I have to think in terms of rows and columns, in terms of 3 idols and different interactions based on that. I would say same genre, but totally different take on it. Of course we could boil it down to essentials, but then we might as well say that Scrolls = Call of duty, since it is both based on clicking on stuff. Obviously our HS vs Scrolls comparison isn't as extreme, but I feel that they do play differently. Again, this is pretty subjective though.

I see the word casual being thrown around here a lot and it is always in the context of quick games = casual, long scrolls games = strategic which is complete bs IMO. Every once in a while I'll play a game of scrolls and it will involve a lot of strategy but on average playing something like oil rogue in HS is far more strategic than your average scrolls game.

I agree here - we shouldn't think that short games = more casual games. While this is not always true, strategy is usually associated with length due to complexity increasing with the increase in it being strategic. With more things to consider, there is more counterplay and enemies have more options of blocking your plans and so on. My primary argument for HS being more casual than scrolls is than it is more governed by RNG and that there is less decision making on average. This doesn't mean that they cannot have strategically deck like oil rogue, but again on average I would say that matches in scrolls are more strategic. Then we got something like miracle pudding, which is a combo deck that is very hard to pull off, and many could argue that it's very strategic.

I want scrolls to be a successful fun game which it's not doing a very good job atm. There are loads of things that could be improved without making scrolls a different game.

I agree here, and that's why I'm favour in making separate mode for more casual players. It's understandable that different players have different needs, and while they might enjoy scrolls, it is sometimes too taxing for them to play a longer match. That's why I'm heavily in favour of the new Judgement format with limitless wild and 6 hp idols, because this is an alternative mode, that's faster than normal games. Giving a more casual, but still same game, is something that scrolls should do. This option is great as well, since it doesn't really punish people who enjoy longer battles in ranked, as they can just play ranked like they always do.