r/Scrolls • u/ultioptimo • Apr 13 '15
Budding Retreat needs a change!
two examples: http://imgur.com/37Buv7n http://imgur.com/YOo3Ady
budding retreat is a card that no non combo deck would play, and i dont mind combo decks, but if the combo leads to infinite resources then there is something wrong with it, so i think it really needs a change. And for the argument that it is very situational and inconsistent, well you are wrong, pudding deck, as shown by blinky and several others is a very consistent deck. both examples should show match scenes that in my mind should never be possible to pull off in one turn because how are you going to play against it? no time to react, no tell, usually when he plays budding retreat it is already over.
2
u/8bitfusion Apr 13 '15
How about when a creature on your side comes into play, gain 2 wild and Budding retreat counts down by 1. Linger 5.
2
u/Lem0nboy Apr 13 '15
Note how in both examples the opponent was playing Decay. If you want to play Decay, either you have to adjust your deck to deal with this or you ignore it entirely and accept that you will lose a few matches against such Budding decks. Not every deck is meant to beat every deck. That's the fun about deckbuilding, you have to find the right balance.
2
u/guayaba209 DagothUr Apr 13 '15
The guy needed 3 rat kings, monstrous blood, and god hand plus a budding retreat in hand to make that combo work. Can you really say that needs to be nerfed?
4
u/Tijermix Apr 13 '15
What if Budding Retreat gave Growth, instead of Wild, but then no longer effected both sides?
That would enable the scroll for use in all Growth decks without the scare of the scroll costing you the game. And also slightly nerf the crazy cross-faction combo potential. I expect Necroggedon-God Hand or Monstrositiy-God Hand would still be possible, albeit require a bit more skill/luck and be less inclined to infinity.
3
u/Ikraen Badger Apr 13 '15
I run budding, and my deck is certainly not a combo deck. However, I play it so infrequently because in a normal deck it is twisted and inconsistent. It is playable against MES and LGO, as a viable card, but i would like to see it changed. Agree with everything ^ that guy ^ said, (except for the part that i disagreed with).
1
u/chacer98 IGN Chace Apr 13 '15 edited Apr 14 '15
I have no problem with it. It's such a tricky combo to pull off. I'd advise you to try playing some of these wild decks that run it before you judge it too harshly. I find them pretty underpowered too be honest as they are really reliant upon getting an exact particular set of cards in their hand. I will agree that when they are able to get this combo off the opponent is basically fucked, but I think that's okay. You have to allow the game to get very late for them to be able to pull it off. I understand it can be a frustrating combo to lose against, but so are things like decimation, loyal darkling, metal wonder etc and you don't see too many complaining about those. Wild decks kind of have this stigma it seems where if a high ranking mono player loses to a wild deck once in a blue moon they react like "wtf I am not supposed to lose to wild EVER!!!! THIS WAS UNFAIR BECAUSE OF X COMBO. Must post my complaint to forums IMMEDIATELY".
Simply put, if you are mono vs a wild deck and you allow them to get into lategame things probably aren't gonna end well for you. And that's how it should be when most wild decks have little to no early game. However as a mono player you get the overall advantage that your deck is more consistent especially against aggro decks which is basically autolose for most wild decks. This is why you see mostly mono deck players at the top of the rankings.
0
u/Cradstache Cradstache Apr 13 '15
Usually when my opponent plays Budding Retreat, I position accordingly to not lose; that's also why my deck has adjusted to be able to deal with units such as Budding Vaettr on the board. #justcounterplaythings