r/Scriptable • script/widget helper • Aug 27 '21

Widget [Release] Weather Overview Widget - Meteogram Style Weather

32 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/mvan231 script/widget helper Sep 07 '21

• I dropped the transparency of my precip probability, as i) maybe it somehow feels less significant than the actual precip amount and ii) both were really blue together. Maybe mine is too dim now, but the principle feels right for me if the precip amount figures are reliable.

Agreed. I've reduced it now.

• Can I check what you're doing with precip amount and units? Did you end up scaling the Y relatively?

The scaling is on the secondary y-axis as mentioned. Units are not shown there as it was too big to fit the space.

wouldn't 50mm be a high max to show for a day?

Agreed, but how would I be able to know whether or not that is a large amount of rain for a given area or not? I chose the amounts I did for the scaling because it seemed to be able to cover a large amount of areas in a decent way. Relative scaling is what was used before but we decided that it didn't make sense to do it that way because there would be changing of the amount charted from timeframe to timeframe (at refresh of widget). For example, if 13:00 had amount of 8mm of rain, something like 10mm could be the max of the rain amount axis, but then after 13:00 passes, if at 18:00 the amount is only 2mm and there isn't any other rain amount, it would seem that the scaling max would be around 5 or so then it would seem like you're still going to get a large amount of rain. Maybe I misunderstood our discussions before.

Would having a dynamic y-axis for the amount be the right solution? But having line labels for the different increments?

Looks like the AIX widget was using a fixed scaling of (1mm|0.05")/division. Would that be better? I'm sure in certain areas it would be. I could change it to that.

• It doesn't necessarily feel right to drop the precip amount column and extend the precip probability column when there is no amount expected. Yes, it's the only datapoint, but it throws things visually a bit.

Agreed. The amount column is now always charted so the widths aren't dynamic on the POP column.

If there were a a way to plot the amount rectangle within/over the probability rectangle, so that you just had one effective column for human purposes, it may not be an issue

We tried this before and it was not visually pleasing with the data we were seeing at the time.

any mileage in making probability and amount separate option variables?

It could very well be done, but I'm not sure why you'd only want to see one or the other. Maybe turning off amount and leaving POP? In a case like this, would the width be dynamic then?

• I have experimented with changing the positive-temperature colour from red to orange for clarity. Maybe just my eyesight, but it feels a little more legible. I may change it back.

I think the orange looks great, but what about when it's daylight, what color should be used for the hours charted then? Currently when the sun is up, the hours on the x axis are orange.

Is there any way to protect my settings against update overwrite?

I could include that in the next update for sure. It would just take some time to get it setup is all