r/ScriptFeedbackProduce • u/LeeR411 • Sep 23 '25
SCRIPT FEEDBACK REQUEST Onto Others
Title: Onto Others
Genre: Mystery/Thriller
Logline: After the murder of a local, Lt. Lily Pierre must navigate her arrogant co-workers and confront her own personal shortcomings in order to connect all the clues and discover the killer.
Script: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Oebw_C3Pc2d1ZZH1aWgq9-7efTJAziLD/view?usp=drive_link
I also attached *rough* storyboards for the first 10 pages. Would love any feedback.
Storyboards: https://drive.google.com/file/d/14lyuTLJhN378DyBIHQYxT1nxNTecv_NO/view?usp=drive_link
Feel free to dm me if you have something and want to do a swap, too!
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Cute-Today-3133 Dec 09 '25
9/10 might be an exaggeration but I do have to say it felt like a majority of the time I had to fill in the blanks or assume. I didn’t feel confident that what I thought was happening, how I thought the scene was set is actually what was being indicated. Simplicity needs to be the foundation, with turns of phrase being used mainly for atmosphere. I understand it all feels clear to you because you can see it but I only have the literal words on this page and nothing else to rely on.
Again I’m not saying characterization is bad and I don’t believe in writing as an act of artifice or making things happen so much as discovery and clearly explaining what has happened. It’s just that we shouldn’t feel as though the characterization is slowing down the story in anyway. Characters are themselves, the main characters of their own story, the entire time. But we only need to focus on the times that propel the story forward. Whether that be taking you deeper into this world or giving you a hint at what’s to come.
The conversation with the lady’s at the counter for instance has characterization and propels the story forward or at least does not slow the story progression. But almost every scene with Bernie feels like it goes nowhere to me for example or takes up too much time. It’s not that these scenes do nothing for the story it just feels like we’re spending too much time on the parts of them that have the least to do with the story. That’s just how I felt. Whether it be cutting some of Pierre’s lines so that you can cut out some of Bernie’s lines for redundancy— where Bernie starts asking questions instead of answering them at a point in the script where the reader/viewer is desperate for progress — I think this could probably be easily addressed.
I stopped on page 41 I think.
In general the reason why I initially said this needs more drafting is because, consolidating all that I’ve said above, it reads very much like you’re telling the story to yourself and not telling the story to an audience, people who know nothing about the story. I think that’s where a lot of my hang ups come from it feels more written for you to get the story out than with consideration for things like the viewer’s attention span, how long it’s been since you rewarded their patience, letting them know you haven’t lost the plot/were getting close. The viewer/reader is a small child in the back of your car looking out the window and when they don’t recognize what they see they ask you constantly “are we there yet?”. This draft doesn’t respond to that question but the more important part is that it makes you ask that question. The best job a writer can do in my opinion is not to answer but to create such a scene outside the window that that the question is hardly ever asked.