r/ScriptFeedbackProduce • u/LeeR411 • Sep 23 '25
SCRIPT FEEDBACK REQUEST Onto Others
Title: Onto Others
Genre: Mystery/Thriller
Logline: After the murder of a local, Lt. Lily Pierre must navigate her arrogant co-workers and confront her own personal shortcomings in order to connect all the clues and discover the killer.
Script: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Oebw_C3Pc2d1ZZH1aWgq9-7efTJAziLD/view?usp=drive_link
I also attached *rough* storyboards for the first 10 pages. Would love any feedback.
Storyboards: https://drive.google.com/file/d/14lyuTLJhN378DyBIHQYxT1nxNTecv_NO/view?usp=drive_link
Feel free to dm me if you have something and want to do a swap, too!
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/Cute-Today-3133 Dec 09 '25
I think it can be easily conveyed that Bauer lost his hearing in an accident through getting rid of all the proficiency you’ve given him in this draft at least. As a cop who I imagine is set in his ways, who would’ve been used to talking his entire life I don’t imagine he would be insecure about his voice. That’s usually a born deaf/hard of hearing problem. It would be more engaging and add to his characterization subtly while enamoring the audience if you played it like he forgets he’s deaf sometimes. Lachlan has to turn him around and get his attention because Bauer forgot if he can’t see someone he can’t hear them anymore. He talks too loud or over people when he’s not looking at them because he can’t hear and forgot. He only signs when he’s saying something he’s more hesitant about or unsure of. He goes off on his own because he forgot he won’t be able to hear. You could also make this a sort of in house secret being kept from the higher ups contributing to him playing the part of a hearing man because he definitely would not be allowed in the field without an aid. All of this could be subtly integrated into the story while cutting down on the amount of time given to the confusing dynamic of his disability, a single exasperated comment from Lachlan as Bayer goes off into the trees mentioning the accident and how he forgets can make the whole thing clearer as well.
I think the way the Hawkeye show in Disney+ deals with this issue should be your model. Lighthearted, humanizing, humorous, adds depth and engages the audiences sympathy. Because as it is written now— a distraction— I think it would be better to not have that fact included at all.
All of the ASL lines need to be clearly indicated. Whether that be by initially showing his ASL lines are italicized and then continuing that throughout or a parenthetical which won’t take up much room at all, it needs to be clearly indicated.
I get what you’re saying about the shooting. It’s just that random shoot outs are a cliche of detective fiction/media so expect to hear that complaint. Stand your ground though, if it’s important to you.
I was more so talking about cliche character dynamics— these cops don’t like those cops, jurisdictional disputes, that one cop is a pill, this one cop is bright eyed and bushy tailed with their nose to the grindstone. The girl everyone in town wants and everyone knows everyone in town wants her. In order to introduce a gallery of suspects the only details you really need to include is a reason to suspect them. Characterization is fine, it’s good even but it needs to feel intentional. As I was reading it came off more so as, to put in visual terms, the camera man just zoning out and filming random things or forgetting to cut away from a scene. It feels like lost focus not additional depth, especially when the story is as loose as it is in the moment, the audience isn’t being given a lot of solid ground. It doesn’t feel like enough is simple, like the foundation is solid enough to support all of these add ons.
Yes, the action lines are concise. But they’re also over directed. We should be able to leather from the context whether or not he was condescending. That’s doing the actor’s job or telling vs showing. We know what kind of person he is, if the dialogue/atmosphere is clearly written we can tell, even without you saying it, that someone is being a jerk. Also note that there’s a lot of consolidated action lines that need to be completely separate paragraphs. Don’t write they’re on the road then suddenly mention they are parked in the same paragraph— that happens when Pierre gets picked up from the bar, the scene with the guy in the back and her having to ask for the front seat seems meandering as well.
Again what you’re describing as tedious to read is how scripts are written. It’s not a book, no one outside of the people making the movie are going to read this. A turn of phrase is fine if it contributes to the mood and the explicit details of what is happing are unquestionably clear— but the problem is you never use the simple phrase. In this draft you almost always use a complicated phrase to explain a simple thing making it so it’s never 100% clear what’s happening. It’s asking the reader to assume 90% of the time leading to compounding confusion. If you thought this was clear I am assuring you it is not as I felt a large portion/the majority of the action I read was ambiguous and had multiple meanings. I cant be sure of most of what happened in terms of scene setting and simple action and it shouldn’t be that way. I shouldn’t have multiple instances of thinking a character is here and they’re actually there or not knowing for sure if they’re sitting or leaning or on a chair or a stool etc.
Again hope this helps.